By Jennifer Dubose
How to Turn Around a Struggling Shop, Ep #6
Every shop owner eventually walks into a mess. Maybe you just took over a struggling facility, maybe you stepped into a new role, or maybe the business you’ve run for years just needs a refresh. In this episode, Paul Barnes and I dig into the question we both get asked a lot. When a manufacturing business is on its knees, where do you actually start?
The instinct is usually to buy new machines or clean house and bring in new people. We make the case for almost the opposite. Most of the time you don’t have a capability problem, you have a visibility problem, and the first job is to stop the bleeding and create stability before you try to improve anything. Paul describes it as fixing the plane while it’s still flying, because the business can’t grind to a halt while you sort it out.
From there we walk through the framework we both lean on. Use a survival filter to triage safety, people, quality, delivery, and cost. Attack job readiness and bottlenecks first, because an hour lost at the bottleneck is an hour lost for the whole shop. Stabilize the schedule, build a system to plan the work, and get your metrics out of the office and onto the floor where the team can actually see them.
Then we get into the people side, which is where most turnarounds really live. We talk about the blame culture that creeps in when a business is hurting, how to make it safe for people to tell you what’s broken, and when coaching crosses over into a culture decision you can’t avoid. Paul shares Harry Harbour’s four Ps for reading your team, and I share a couple of stories about keeping good people and letting the wrong attitude go.
We close with what not to fix first, because the fastest way to make an unstable shop worse is to kick off five projects at once. Pick one thing this week, get it right, and build from there. Profits follow stability, and stability gets built one process at a time.
What’s Covered in this Episode
- (0:00) The five Ps: proper preparation prevents poor performance
- (1:14) Walking into a shop that needs fixing, and why you don’t start with new machines or people
- (3:27) It’s a visibility problem: make a grocery list and use the action priority matrix to chase quick wins
- (6:10) Stop the bleeding with the SPQDC survival filter: safety, people, quality, delivery, cost
- (8:30) Why cutting cost first usually makes an unstable shop worse
- (10:09) Job readiness and bottlenecks: one lost hour costs the whole shop
- (12:03) Walk the floor, find the WIP, and line-level from the saw to shipping
- (14:07) IMTS: the largest manufacturing trade show in North America
- (15:00) Is planning the central bottleneck in a machine shop?
- (18:05) Build a system, even if it starts as a shared Excel sheet
- (18:59) Staying flexible when a job goes sideways: the broken-tap story and pallet-changer lights-out runs
- (22:36) Stabilize the schedule, then build standard work the floor will actually follow
- (25:26) Coaching with questions to earn real operator buy-in
- (29:42) Visual management: get the metrics out of the office and onto the floor
- (31:53) How posting scrap numbers changed operator behavior
- (35:42) DN Solutions: high-end machining with the SMX and DVF 5-axis lineup
- (36:50) When to address people and making it safe to surface bad news without fear
- (39:27) The 6am story: moving a strong worker instead of losing them
- (41:30) When coaching isn’t enough: the talented but toxic machinist
- (42:26) Harry Harbour’s four Ps: players, prisoners, passengers, protesters
- (45:23) Factur: building a steady pipeline of sales opportunities
- (46:28) What not to fix first: don’t clean house and rehire
- (48:29) Tackle one thing at a time to avoid creating more chaos
- (50:40) Profits follow stability: pick one thing to fix this week
Resources Mentioned
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] That makes me think about a high school baseball coach that I had. And to this day, I still remember it. He had the five Ps and it’s proper preparation prevents poor performance.
[0:09] And while that’s totally accurate when it comes to athletics, it’s also true in business, because if you’re properly prepared, your performance will be improved. We can take that when it comes to machining, when it comes to assembly operations, any manufacturing operations, every single part of job, just as an individual, if you’re the planner in a facility, if you are properly prepared to do your job, then you’re going to prevent poor performance. So make sure that you’re properly prepared.
[0:38] Five Ps. Welcome to the Manufacturing Blueprint. This is the show where manufacturing leaders, shop owners, and operators come to sharpen their thinking, strengthen their teams, and improve the way work gets done.
[0:55] From leadership and culture to systems, strategy, and execution, we break down the blueprint used to build high-performing manufacturing organizations. No fluff, just straight talk and real conversations, real lessons and real results. Here’s your host, Jason Davis.
[1:14] Hey guys, welcome back to the Manufacturing Blueprint podcast. I’m Jason Davis and my good friend, Paul Barnes. Paul, how are you, buddy? I’m good.
[1:25] I’ve been traveling. From a traveling standpoint, I really enjoy traveling for work, but I really like doing it by myself. So, but the reason why I think is I get into an airport and like, I just take that time or on an airplane and I shut everything else off and I can like work on things that I don’t have time to work on normally, and I actually was one of the things that I was thinking about while we were traveling was if you walk into a new facility, there’s going to be a lot of things that you got to learn.
[1:58] A lot of things you got to pick up on, but I think you really got to probably identify some areas that you’d want to start to making some adjustments in and maybe some areas that you wouldn’t want to. Like, I think the first thing I would want to do is not go buy new machines. Obviously we think a lot of times, Hey, if we want to be more efficient, get new equipment, but I don’t think you can just rush in and do that.
[2:20] And I don’t think you start with people necessarily either. If you were going to step into a manufacturing facility, maybe somewhere that’s struggling, you’re starting a new role or you’re just, you’re just in a current role and you realize, Hey, we just need a refresh, I mean, every once in a while you need that, you know, what would be the things that you want to take a look at first if you’re trying to fix that manufacturing facility? The only way I can describe it is like trying to fix the plane while it’s still flying, right? We’re working, we work a lot for the aviation industry and when you’ve got a business and it’s running and it’s under pressure, right? Which it is because we wouldn’t be there solving problems if there wasn’t problems and you can’t afford, you can’t afford just to grind the business till a halt, so you have to try and be able to target the right things first and make the biggest impact in the shorter frame of time frame as possible and create some stability, right? Create some stability so you can work on some improvements, but yeah, it’s hard to know where to start and what to work on first and create that priority. Because you probably don’t have a capability problem.
[3:27] I mean, you’re, you’re in that business for a reason and you’ve been able to be in that business and probably have some success in that business, so I don’t think it’s necessarily a capability problem, but maybe a visibility problem, right? There’s something inside that organization that isn’t being seen, something inside that organization that’s being overlooked, something inside that organization that may at one time been running and operating properly, but has for whatever reason, over time, you know, you lose it. I think one of the craziest things I think that I have learned over the years is the importance of recording information, right? Like when I think about things on a daily basis, I write them down a lot of times because I can’t tell you how many times I’ve thought of stuff I want to do. I mean, we’ve all been in that situation.
[4:21] It’s like, Hey, why don’t we make a grocery list, right? We make a grocery list so we remember the things that we want and we need when we get to the grocery store. But a lot of times in business, like I think we’ll just like think about the things we want to do in the future or we want to get done later, but we don’t actually record them. So I think that’s really important is you’re going to go through that business to start with and make yourself a grocery list, make a list of all the things you want to do and all the things you want to attack, and then you’ve got to come back and decide, okay, which one of these do we want to go to first, right? Grab that low hanging fruit, start to knock some of those things off, and then you can go from there.
[4:58] So maybe stop the bleeding a little bit. You made me think of the action, action priority matrix. You heard of that? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[5:07] Action priority matrix. You’re looking for what’s got your quick, quick wins with low effort, high impact. Right.
[5:14] And then you’ve got your important tasks, which is high impact with high effort, or you’ve got other tasks versus low impact, low effort, or then like you’ve really heavy stuff, which is like the ungrateful tasks, which is like low impact and really, really big effort. And they are the things you don’t bother with. So yeah, it’s good as you walk around and you start to encounter problems, you’re thinking, well, what’s the quick wins, what’s the easy wins, the low effort, high impact things that we can just first to kind of create some ease of pressure in the business.
[5:46] What’s the important things that need to be done that takes a little bit of work, get people working on those. But those big tasks that maybe you want to do, you’re right, you might go in and you might see a machine and it’s, and it’s old, it might be unreliable, but you know, it’s going to take a long time to get replaced. It’s going to take a long time and money.
[6:02] It’s maybe not the time just to focus on those kinds of things, but yeah. Yeah. Being able to prioritize those things and create some kind of plan around them is good.
[6:10] Yeah. Well, even thinking about just the financial side of things, like if you’re, if you’re evaluating that business and you walk in, you know, one of the, I mean, I think you just start to look at waste too, you know, if you’re, you got to stop the bleeding at some point. Um, and before you’re improved, before you improve anything, I think you got to really take a look like what’s our scrap rate look like, you know, what are our expenses look like? What’s our overtime rates look like? Are we missing deliveries? I mean, these are, you know, these are things that are obviously going to be good indicators for us to then take a little bit deeper dive.
[6:46] We talked in one of the previous shows about some of our metrics and so on. We talked about metrics and we talked about, I think we talked about SPQDC, right, which is some of our metric heading that we talk about. Yeah.
[6:58] We talked about, I mean, I kind of nicknamed that the survival filter, right? It’s what do you need to know to survive? And if you’re going into any kind of critical business, you need to think about those things. First one is safety, right? What’s safety critical? Is there anything in this business right now that could hurt someone or result in some kind of legal shutdown or something that’s going to really hurt your business, that’s got to always be your number one priority, that’s non-negotiable. We need to fix it.
[7:27] Rightify it. Now you’re, hopefully you’re not going to have too many of those, but you must consider it first. So people, right? Have you got the right people to do what needs done today? Have you got the right skills? Is the right people in the right places? Have you got the attendance to do what you need today? These are quite things that we can just check in the morning and make sure that we’re good.
[7:46] And then, you know, you’re set up then for the rest of the day that you can really target and zoom in on, on your bottlenecks, uh, quality, high priority. Again, right. You need to know urgently, are you doing what you need to do? Are you shipping defects? Are you paying twice for the same product? Is it killing your reputation? I often find that if you can fix your, your top three re reoccurring defects first, that’s probably 90% of what you need to worry about, especially in the early door, so look for your reoccurring.
[8:18] Delivery that comes, that’s only a medium risk one, right? When you’ve contained the rest, then what, what are you missing your deadlines and where’s your bottlenecks? And that’s generally where you’ll be able to get your time to spend. And then cost, you said earlier cost, cost is probably the low priority for me though, because ironically focusing on cutting costs generally makes things worse, especially when your business is unstable. So I don’t, wouldn’t worry about cutting costs, but focusing on the flow and the quality and when you’d make those improvements, then the costs and the business will naturally drop as the waste eliminated.
[8:53] Well, I think there is another aspect of that cost though. Um, a lot of times when, when you hear cost cutting, you think of like just your workforce reduction, but in my mind, that is not what I would be considering, but I think cost from my, my standpoint is going to be, are we doing a good job on our raw materials? Are we negotiating those raw materials properly? What are our service vendors charging us? What should they be charging us and have we worked with them? What are we paying for tools? Do we have thousands or tens of thousands of dollars of tools on our floor that we don’t need at the moment that we could change our buying habits? Same thing for raw material. How much inventory do we have on the floor? So I think reducing those costs can really quickly make an impact to your cashflow, uh, which is, which is going to really change that short term, uh, flexibility of the business.
[9:49] You’re spot on with those things you need to look at and looking at your, I think one of the ones that you mentioned was your bottlenecks and for our facility, that’s a huge point because that becomes just a waste point, a stopping point. So when you’ve got that, that bottlenecks and so you got to make sure that you fix that for me, one of the main problems there is just the job readiness. So when you’ve got a job, when, when jobs are not ready to go to a machine, then you’re probably dealing with things like missing tools, or you don’t have a system for your programs, or you don’t have proven programs, your materials not staged properly at the right time.
[10:32] Uh, maybe there’s unclear, uh, there’s not true clarity in your, in your drawings or your engineering data. Um, and so I think, you know, just making sure that you get, making sure that you do all of that prep work before the job is going to a machine is what’s going to make the difference. So in your facility, it’s a little bit different, right? I mean, you’re not necessarily dealing with machines.
[10:54] You’re a little more human side, but you, you got to make sure you’re kitted prior to that operator trying to start their next, their next job. The bottlenecks can appear anywhere. And it’s very hard to say hypothetically where your bottlenecks going to be.
[11:10] But usually there’s one area, one specific either department or one process that causes 80% of the delays. And it’s just important to find where that is. And then just spend time working on it.
[11:26] I mean, that’s where you need to find your solutions. Yeah. Generally an hour lost at a bottleneck is an hour lost for the entire factory, right? Where if the bottleneck jams up, if that process that’s already your bottleneck feels, well, the whole factory then is, is losing time.
[11:42] So the flip side of that, I mean, an hour saved, if you’re working on something that’s not your bottleneck and you see of an hour, well, it’s a waste of time because your factory is only running as fast as your slowest process, right? Yeah, that’s right. So it’s important that you don’t invest any time working on efficiency anywhere, anywhere else, except for your bottleneck. Yeah.
[12:02] So my advice is just spend the time walking the floor, look where you’re. Yeah. Look where your most whip is, right? Where’s your work in progress? Where’s the whip piling up? And then that’s your primary target either for repair, optimization, for some lean focus to drive some improvements.
[12:22] Yeah. Cause you’re looking at tack time, especially in your business, you’re looking at tack time, or you’re looking at line leveling so that you’re, you know, as, as that process goes through. And that would be a little different than a machine shop, but in, but the concepts are still, the concepts should still be the same in that we want to make sure that we’re leveling, we’re line leveling across the entire facility, which goes from the saw to the machine, to inspection, um, to outside processing, shipping, receiving those things.
[12:53] Because I definitely, you know, in our years of experience, we’ve gone moments where maybe the saw was the bottleneck and you’ve got machines waiting on the raw material to get prepared and it’s, it’s a mad scramble there, or maybe you’ve got, uh, at times, maybe your, your quality is the holdup because you’ve set up a machine, now you’re waiting on quality to give the sign off, but you’re not prepared in the quality department, so the machine is sitting idle for two or three hours when it should have been 30 minutes, or maybe the setup didn’t go in the one hour that it needed to go in, it took three hours because the individual didn’t have the right tools there, they didn’t have the right, um, uh, the right fixtures, the right jaws, or they weren’t prepared prior to. And so I think that’s the other part. That’s not just a, that’s, that’s something that’s going to make people more efficient.
[13:46] You can make you more profitable because, you know, if you add three hours of work at the saw, or waiting, and you add three hours at the machine and you add three hours in quality, that customer’s not paying for those extra nine hours. Those, those, that nine hours is coming out of the company’s pocket, right? What is up Metalworking Nation, Making Chips family. It is an even year, which means IMTS is coming.
[14:14] September 14th through 19th at McCormick Place in beautiful Chicago. It is the largest manufacturing trade show in North America, bringing together thousands of manufacturers, OEMs, and solution providers every two years to explore how new technologies are being applied to real shop floors. So whether you’re planning future capital investments, benchmarking operations, or simply trying to cut through the noise around emerging technologies, IMTS is designed to help manufacturers make better, more informed decisions.
[14:41] Whether you’ve been going for years or this might be your first time, put it on your calendar right now, schedule your time away from the shop. It’s good to get out and see new things. It’s going to be a big party.
[14:53] I hope to see you there. Go to IMTS.com and register today. Have you any specific, seen any particular bottleneck specific to the machine shops? Like I know in the business I work in, I’ve been working through a lot of issues recently caused by planning, right? And planning being so central function, I think to most businesses and a weak plan can cause havoc through the shop floor for us because we release work orders, we put out material, we realize some of the material isn’t, hasn’t come in on time, you’ve got whip on the floor.
[15:31] And before you know it, we’re, we’re, we’re trying to do that because the material is not here. We end up making work because we’re trying to keep people busy, but then you can’t complete anything and you start partially doing work, partially completing work, but you can’t finish it. And then you try to move on to something else.
[15:48] And I see it quite often that we build up a stockpile of whip and all of a sudden our, our production gets really fat with material, right? We become heavy. Our infantry numbers be high. Our processes become slow and the, and the business gets bogged down just with pure whip.
[16:06] Do you guys see any of that in the machine shops or? Yeah, we definitely have the same type of situations happen. Um, but it’s obviously a little bit different. It kind of goes back to the things I just touched on where the planning aspect is so critical because if we get a new, new project or a new, a new items that we’re going to work on.
[16:26] It’s important that we not only let the engineering team know so that they can work on the engineering, creating programmings, fixtures, those types of things, but we also, the quality team has to know because they’ve got to make sure we’ve got any gauges or special gauges. Cause sometimes you might need a special gauge that might be eight weeks away. So you can’t wait until the, the parts on the floor.
[16:49] And also they need to put together their inspection plans that’s going to be used on our travelers, our data that’s going to be used on the travelers. And then also if there’s any CMM programs that need to be written, that needs to be done up front. Because what will happen if your planning is not proper and you’ve not done the work to be prepared.
[17:08] The work order’s made, part gets sold, part goes to the machine, setup’s done. We record all the data we need to, we pass it off to quality for inspection. And it’s like, Oh yeah, well, we need to, we’re going to get to that.
[17:25] Well, what happens with that operator? Now we’re, we are scrambling to go find, you know, it’s spending extra resources to go take that setup guy and have him stop what he’s doing and go shift gears and do something else. And that machine is just sitting still. Right.
[17:39] So that is completely wasteful. While what needed to happen is all of that work in the background, that planning has to be done. So when he gets his first off ready to be inspected, it can be inspected and brought right back to him.
[17:53] Make any changes we need to make, start that production run and then go ahead and get finished. Because if you’re not prepared, I mean, yeah, sure. You can lose 30 minutes, an hour.
[18:05] I mean, I have seen us lose days because we weren’t prepared for something. And so that’s where, you know, you’ve got to work to build a system that’s going to help you manage that. Now, whether that’s going to be like a complete ERP system or maybe you’re just using, I mean, you know, when we started, it was Excel, like we created an Excel spreadsheet.
[18:30] So you can throw in some conditional formatting, you share it across a couple of people and that way engineering has it, purchasing has it, quality has it, shipping has it. So everybody knows, Hey, these are the jobs that are coming up. These are the jobs that we need to be working on.
[18:47] And that they can be prepared. So we’re not behind the eight ball whenever it, whenever the time comes and the job gets there. And in your industry, Jason, I’m going to ask you difficult questions.
[18:57] All right. In your industry, if something goes wrong in one of those processes, how easy do you find adjusting your plan? Is it easy that you can just pull out that product target for a day, two days, if you need to spend engineering time or something on it before picking it up again and continuing? Do you have other jobs that you can just drop in or how easy is that to do in your industry? Yeah, for, for us, it’s, it’s not too bad if we, if we have that visibility and we make that decision. So we’ve got over 30 pieces of CNC equipment and a lot of those, we wouldn’t just have one particular machine that can run that one part.
[19:37] Normally there’s going to be multiple machines that can run that part. So if it were a situation that we were not prepared, could we pull that off and do the next job in line? Absolutely. And, you know, sometimes that happens.
[19:52] I mean, we’ve, we’ve run into situation before, um, late last year, we were preparing to run a job. We had three taps, we bought three taps just in preparation. And, you know, first cycle through the tap breaks on the first one.
[20:06] So we make adjustments, second cycle, the tap breaks. The third and final tap, here we are, we’re like, you know, 30 minutes in and we get like four parts in the tap break. So, you know, in less than an hour, we broke all the tools that we planned for.
[20:19] So now you’re just kind of, you’re kind of down. You got to wait at least, maybe we could squeak out and find someone somewhere close that has them. Maybe it’s the next day.
[20:29] Sometimes these are specialty tools and it might be a couple of days. And so in that situation, yeah, you’d want to pull that job and come back to it. That is totally possible.
[20:37] At the same point in time, that also does kind of wreck your schedule potentially a little bit. So, but there are points that you can’t, you can’t plan for that, right? I mean, you can do, you know, there, there are some things that you just can’t plan for. But I will say one of the things I love about some of our equipment having pallet changers on them, right? So a perfect example, we have a five axis CNC mill with a eight pool pallet changer.
[21:03] So basically we can have as much as eight jobs set up at one time. That gives us a lot of flexibility in the sense that traditionally what we’ll do is we’ll run new jobs. We’ll draw on difficult jobs on first shift where we’ve got engineering, more engineering support, and we’ve got more quality support.
[21:22] And then we will take proven jobs and on second shift, we’ll run proven jobs that are much easier to do. And then overnight shift or the overnight, like four hours when we’re not here, we can actually have parts set up. So we’re actually being able to manufacture parts completely lights out.
[21:40] Now, the other part where that’s really, really helpful is let’s say on first shift, we set up a job and we are going to send it to quality. Well, while it goes to quality, you know, we’re going to be waiting for a few minutes, so instead of that machine sitting, we can flip the switch and we can run a 30 minute cycle on a different part number altogether. So that job, that work order is there.
[22:04] It’s open. We can log into that, flip it over, run that. And yeah, we might only get one or two parts at the moment, but if you do that every single day, you know, you start to have five, 10, 25, 30 and what we found, we’ve got one part number that’s very consistent for us and we almost don’t have to run that job on the floor by itself.
[22:25] We can run pieces of it all along. And it ends up being enough for a full job. So it saves us a ton of time.
[22:34] Good, insightful. Back to what we’re talking about there, right? We’re talking about how do we go in, fix this business that’s on its knees. And I think my takeaway there is that we have to stabilize that schedule, right? Stop changing the production plan every hour when we can create some kind of stability.
[22:53] Sometimes even a bad plan that’s followed is better than chaos that’s changing consistently, but planning and creating some stability for you, for your, for your shop’s good, right? Yeah. So, so with that, I mean, that makes me think of like standard work, right? So you’re, you’re creating a standard. I mean, how do you guys, how do you guys handle like creating that standard? Like who creates it? How do you document it? How do you like push that down to the next person or train that person? What are, what are some of the keys that you guys work with in that? Yeah.
[23:25] So generally, um, our industrial engineering team or our engineering team will, will work on our operating procedures, right? And that’ll document our process flow. Um, and what, what it entails from A to Z after that, right? Quite, quite often whenever the engineers do that, it works fine in planning, but doesn’t always work in reality. And I guess at that point, then you’re, you’re taking the feedback from the shop floor, right? Those production operators are doing the work day to day and that we then just drive our problem solving through that.
[23:59] But it’s highly reliant as well on management. Sometimes people will do what their standard operating procedure says as they should. Sometimes when we stand back and look at it and when we do our Gemba, when we do our fresh eyes, you actually look at it and you say, you know, that doesn’t really make sense.
[24:16] We should maybe be looking at doing it in a, in a different order and we’ll review that. But within the aviation industry, it’s also very, we have to be very careful that we do that in a controlled manner, in a very disciplined manner about when, how we make changes. So, uh, we always make sure that that’s reviewed with the quality and the engineering teams.
[24:33] But quite often, I always say that we should never, as a management level, we should never tell someone how to do their job because generally that technician that’s doing that knows how to do it far better than I will ever as a production manager, business owner. Right. Yeah.
[24:52] The guy that’s on that machine every day is going to know that machine inside out. It knows everything it’s going to do, when it’s going to do it, every sign that it makes, and sometimes we can be a little bit disrespectful for our production operators. They do it a certain way because they know that that’s the best way to do it.
[25:10] And sometimes we need to just listen to them and take the learning out of that. You don’t feel like you always know the best way? Cause sometimes I feel like that. I’m like, no, of course I know what to do.
[25:22] Uh, no, but, but you’re right. You’re a hundred percent right. It is important.
[25:25] But I think I have found for me, I usually what will happen and how I operate in those situations is I’ve already developed the way that I want it to be done in my head. Now, a lot of times I will not tell them that, but I will ask like strategic questions to get them thinking right. And if they do it the way that I want, then great.
[25:49] And if they do it a different way, but I deem it acceptable, then great. But sometimes it’s in left field and you kind of have to like coach them a little bit to get them kind of going in the right direction. And, and have they ever surprised you and you’ve went away and said, Oh yeah, that’s a good way to do it.
[26:06] Yeah, absolutely. Totally. That happens.
[26:09] I’m, I’m not suggesting that often. Yep. That’s the way I knew you were going to do it.
[26:14] Yeah, no, no, no, I’ll tell them. I mean, I definitely don’t think that I always have the right decision, but I think as a leader in a, in an organization, you need a plan, right? And you probably are developing that plan pretty quickly in your head, kind of getting an idea of what direction you want to go, what makes a better leader is being able to take the advice or take the direction from somebody else. But I also, what thinks, what I think makes, helps make a good leader is when you’re able to take your ideas and vision, and if you can get that operator to develop their own way of doing it the way you want it done, that’s a win for everybody.
[26:59] And you pour and you leave that with them. Like that’s, that’s one of the things I’ve done. I will have, I do this in meetings.
[27:06] I do this on the floor. I’ll ask questions. And again, if I’m going in and I’m asking questions, like, what is it? Where, where are our bottlenecks? Where are our problems? What, why did this not work? I’ve probably already thought through what my thoughts are and I will write them down and I will keep them folded up, hidden.
[27:24] I’m not going to walk in and be like, this is where we’re wrong. I want them to get there themselves. And that’s getting the buy-in from those individuals because I don’t need to be right, I don’t need the accolades of saying that I know this or I know that.
[27:40] That doesn’t matter. That’s really important for the buy-in in my opinion. So if you can get the employees to come up with solutions, come up with ideas that are their own, and they happen to be what you’re in, what you want, that’s a way better solution than you telling them what they need to go do.
[27:56] Yeah. It’s good for the employees development, right? Personal development. It’s good for them about their morale and how they feel about their work, that they’re valued, that their thoughts and opinions matter, that they have influence and can change the business and have an impact on the business.
[28:12] So it’s really important that we allow the employees the freedom to do that. Yeah. Still while you’re monitoring and control, because especially if we’re talking about a business here that’s in a, in a critical place, it’s in a critical place for a reason, and we have to make sure that the direction, you reminded me of a boss I once had, and there was three or four of us working on a project for him.
[28:35] We must’ve worked maybe for a week, two weeks. And we come up with this solution and he came down one afternoon and we presented what we’re going to do. He says, yeah, good, but it’s not what I want.
[28:49] And we were all just like, oh, we had been working on this for days. And we’re like, well, what do you want? He says, I don’t know, but I’ll know whenever you show me. And he left again.
[29:02] I know we were all just like, oh, and at that point we just went home. Right. It was the end of the day and we went home really deflated.
[29:08] And sometimes maybe you may think that was really just like harsh and discouraging, but, and it was, and perhaps maybe he could handle it better, but I knew exactly what he meant, the solution and what we were working towards is good, but you know, when you get your process right, right. We’re talking about visual management, standard management, and he knew by this process and he knew that whenever he looked at that process, he needed to see key criteria that was telling him whether it was good or bad. Right.
[29:41] And if we’re talking about turning around a failing business somewhere that’s really struggling, your metrics and your visual management, again, that’s another key point that we need to talk about on that. How do you have those visuals within your processes that tell you that you’re on track, you’re off track anyway, away from that topic, really critical. Um, the last time I went into a new department to take it over, or normally what I do is I find the biggest whiteboard I can, I’ll stick it to the wall or put it on a push cart and bring it in.
[30:12] Right. And you just want to get up your metrics. What are we doing? What is it per hour? Where are we at? What’s our exit rate? Right.
[30:20] What’s our attack time? And quite often our visuals within our factories, our plans and when our execution plans, what we’re trying to do, sometimes we don’t really give clarity to the shop floor and sometimes our technicians don’t know exactly what the goal is, right? What’s our target for the week, for the month? Are we on track, off track? And sometimes it’s good just to create that clarity and give the team a solid plan and monitor that plan and let the team see that that plan is being monitored. Because then it also allows you to start benchmarking your improvements. When we start working on those bottlenecks, how can we measure whether we’re getting better or worse? Right.
[31:01] Cause you don’t, you don’t want to say, I mean, it’s the old thing. How do you eat an elephant, right? A bite at a time, but it’s, you’re not going to turn around your business in a day. You can’t revolutionize it overnight.
[31:14] So again, it’s important that you can start creating early metrics. And I know me and you talked this morning or your last night, my this morning about being data-driven and we need to talk about that sometime. But yeah, the more data you have, the better decisions you can make, the more visibility you’ve got, right? Rather than being opinions or just what you can physically see, you need to listen to what the business is telling you.
[31:41] And we need to start tracking metrics to understand the true health of the business. Yeah, I agree a hundred percent. And I think we’ll, we can, we can do a whole episode on data and how that’s going to help drive your business.
[31:53] But just to make a short point on that, you’re a hundred percent right. And it’s a situation where when you track things on your floor and your people are aware, they become more careful. If you’re not measuring it, you know, and you’re not monitoring and then it’s, then you’re just not going to care.
[32:13] It’s just saying that you don’t care about it. And so, you know, I remember several years back when we went and we started, you know, we, we, being a smaller machine shop, you know, you have those moments where you’re kind of doing things as best you can, and then you can make an adjustment and you’re just getting better over time. I mean, it’s nothing, you know, nobody’s going to step into the game no matter where you’re at and be perfect.
[32:37] There’s always going to be holes. There’s always going to be problems. And you’re basically just choosing to fix certain things as you go.
[32:43] And that’s just how it’s going to be. Um, when we made the changes, started tracking our scrap. So we started tracking our internal scrap, what was getting scrapped prior to getting to our final inspection.
[32:55] And then we were also tracking what was being caught in our final inspection. The numbers were like, it wasn’t, I don’t remember what they were. It wasn’t really, really crazy, but it was enough that it was like, okay, that’s more than I thought it was going to be.
[33:10] But as soon as we started posting that and people saw that, cause even the operators were like, whoa, I didn’t realize it was like that because, you know, one here, two there, 10 there, like those things kind of start to add up. But once we started posting it, you could see that trend just started going down because people were aware and they want to do a good job. Yeah.
[33:33] And I’ll emphasize Jason, the visibility of where you have that. Um, I’ve seen a number of businesses and their leadership team, management teams, they sit in their offices with their metrics, looking at their metrics. I believe there’s far more power in having those metrics actually out on the shop floor where the work’s happening.
[33:55] Agreed. And, and even the time that I spend looking at those metrics should be on the shop floor where people see me looking at those metrics because then they understand that I care about those metrics. They see me checking the metrics.
[34:08] If I’m sitting in an office and I’m checking the metrics and no one else can see them, then it may as well not exist. Right. And there’s a little bit of a psychology impact there because they can see the metrics, they see you looking at the metrics, they know you care about the metrics and then they can check it.
[34:24] Cause if you’re standing there staring at it or talking about it, people want to know, right, what is it he’s looking at? What’s good or what’s bad? Why is he concerned? Right. And it’s that engagement. And if you can, sometimes we need to close the gap between where management is and where the shop floor is.
[34:39] Maybe it’s not so bad in your shop, but I know sometimes in big corporations, we can, the shop floor technician can feel distant from the, from the owner, from the director, management team. And it’s important. We talked before about the visibility of being on the floor with your people and the metrics need to be right there in the center of operations where everyone can access them, everyone can see it.
[35:01] And then at the start of shift, everyone should have a rundown. What was our health from yesterday? What went right? What went wrong? What did we hit? What did we miss? What’s the reasons? What’s the learnings and what’s the plan for today? Yeah. And if we’re all together in that as well, it creates a good atmosphere with the team.
[35:18] Yeah. So I think, I mean, if we kind of recap that, you know, the number one thing we kind of think is we walk into that new business or a struggling business, we want to stop the bleeding, you want to fix the job readiness, you want to stabilize the process, and then that brought us to leadership and communication, which I think is exactly where we’re at, you know, wrapping that up. You can’t spell high-end without DN.
[35:42] If you’re serious about taking your shop to the next level, it might be time to stop thinking in terms of good enough and start thinking in terms of capability, flexibility, and my favorite, automation. DN Solutions is helping manufacturers move into true high-end machining with their SMX multitasking series. The DVF 5-axis machines and advanced automation solutions designed for shops that want to run smarter, faster, and more competitively.
[36:10] The SMX platform gives you the ability to combine multiple operations into one setup, reducing handling, improving accuracy, and helping you get complex parts out the door faster. Their DVF 5-axis lineup delivers the precision, rigidity, and confidence manufacturers need for today’s demanding aerospace, medical, and high-performance applications. And when you pair those machines with automation, you’re not just buying equipment, you’re building a more scalable business.
[36:37] High-end parts, high-end capability, high-end thinking, because you can’t spell high-end without DN. Learn more at dnsolutions.com. So the next question I have is then for us is like the people, like at what point do we start to address the people, right? Cause there’s going to be some point where that culture is going to have to be adjusted and, you know, so we’ve, we’ve taken care of our systems, we’ve taken care of our expectations. We’ve set that so that everybody knows exactly what our expectations are.
[37:13] Um, and most of the time it’s probably the processes. It’s probably not the people, but there is going to be a point where there’s going to be people that have to be, is it retraining? Is it, you know, coaching? I know you, I know you’ve always been a very big advocate and you’ve been a very, very good person from a coaching standpoint. I’ve noticed that as the business struggles.
[37:36] Right. The blame culture starts to come out, right? Nobody wants to take responsibility for what goes wrong. Yeah.
[37:42] And quite often, whenever I go into challenging situations, it’s not my fault, right, it’s his fault and there’s a struggling company usually has the blame culture and people hide mistakes and they hide mistakes, why to stay out of trouble. Right. They hide things to stay out of the limelight.
[37:59] They deflect, they will hide from work. They will go to the toilet for an extremely long period of time. Right.
[38:05] They will take time off work. They will take time off work on stress. It may be stress, but it also can be just related to just the dread of going to work because of either the pressure, not being in control and how that makes them feel.
[38:21] Um, and that’s really hard, but the first thing to do, or what I would try to do is try to make it safe for people to talk on about point out what’s broken. Right. Without the fear of retribution, because sometimes people are afraid to give you bad news.
[38:37] And I’m also in a, in a country where the culture is that they don’t like to give you bad news. Right. People will talk around an issue and talk about anything except the bad news, because they don’t want to be the bearer of bad news in case you associate the bad news with them.
[38:54] And that can be hard, but trying to build those friendships and make people feel open and honest, because I would rather know of a bad situation so that we can help deal with it rather than people hiding and staying away from, but the blame culture, the blame culture can be toxic. Yeah, totally. You know, I think you’re right.
[39:12] And I think, I think the coaching, the coaching aspect is probably, you know, that next step. So you set, you set those expectations and now it’s, let’s, let’s create a plan to help you, you know, get to where you need to get to. And it might be something simple.
[39:26] Like, I mean, I’ve, I’ve had experience with somebody who the shift starts at 6 a.m. and they just can’t make it to work at 6 a.m. They’re just not a morning person. That’s life sometimes for people, but they were really, really good at their job and I didn’t want to lose them, but I couldn’t continue to have them coming in at 6 45 every day, because what does that do to the morale of the rest of the So the solution for them was they went to second shift and it was perfect because they had time to get up and could get, you know, get themselves going because some people just aren’t morning people, you know, I’m glad you were sympathetic. I’m glad you’re sympathetic.
[40:04] I don’t know if I would have put them on the second shift. The, uh, yeah, the executioner in you would have come out. Well, let’s put it like this.
[40:12] If everyone’s getting paid the same money, if I’m expected to have 50 people working on a production line and one just comes in 15 minutes late, well, my line can only go as fast as the slowest person. Right. And if that’s, that can end up costing me a lot of money.
[40:27] So in time keeping is important and I’m not saying we shouldn’t be sympathetic. Right. We’re not up-throating and that ruthless, but we also are responsible for the standards of the business.
[40:39] And if our standards are low, trust me, our workers and our workforce standard will be even lower. Yeah. Right.
[40:47] And the higher my standard is, well, their standard is still going to be lower, but it’s going to be higher than it would be if I already had a low standard. So yeah, my expectation should be to a really high standard and then it’s. Yeah, it is.
[41:00] And in that one situation, I mean, it was just their personality and the way it worked out, but they were a hard worker when once they were here, they were great. It was just, they needed a little shift and it worked out for the best. But we certainly have also been in situations where, you know, no matter how many times you coach someone, no matter how many times you give them some clear expectations, no matter how many times you work with them on, okay, this is the process and it still can’t come, come through, then there are times that you have to make adjustments, you have to make changes and sometimes, you know, a few years ago, we went through a phase where it was like, you know, even though I had a machinist that was exceptional, he was here every single day, he was on time, he was here every day, he did great work, but his attitude was absolutely terrible and it just drags other people down.
[41:50] And we had the conversations and he eventually, we had to make the decision as an organization that we’re not going to allow that to be part of the culture. We have to make that culture change. And, and I think you will hear that for a lot of top end facilities and top end companies is going to be what that culture is.
[42:09] And I know that’s one of the things that we have to really fight at times because you can’t allow that culture to drift. You’ve got to have standards. You’ve got to have culture of just unity.
[42:19] And if you’re not able to do that, then that’s going to really make your organization have difficulties at times. Uh, the guy that used to do some coaching and training and, uh, he was called Harry Harbour, I have to give him the credit for this because I love it. And if he’s ever listened to this, I don’t want them to think that I’m stealing his material.
[42:38] He is a training consultant and he teaches a lot of this stuff, but he talked about the four P’s. So I’m giving Harry the credit for this. He talked about the players, right? Those people that’s on your team, they’re your starting 11, right? They’re the guys that you’re, you depend on.
[42:52] They’re the ones that if you’re in crisis, they’re the ones you call on first. You don’t need to worry about them. They’re always on your team.
[42:59] Then he talks about the prisoners. There’s those people that don’t want to be there, right? Four P’s, players, prisoners. And sometimes you just need to let those prisoners go, right? Those prisoners don’t want to be there.
[43:09] They grumble. Nothing’s good. There’s misery.
[43:14] You’re not paying them enough. They don’t want to work there. Then you’ve got your, um, protesters and you’ve got your passengers, right? Your passengers, they’re the people that’s there to pick up the paycheck.
[43:29] Yeah. And Harry would tell you that, how do you get those passengers engaged? How do you get more out of those? How do you maximize the potential of those passengers and turn them into players? The protesters, I always thought was an intriguing one. Harry used to say that protesters can be good and they can be bad.
[43:48] They can be positive and negative. You have these people who complain and will complain about things, but what’s their motivation? Are they complaining because they actually want the business to improve and are frustrated with things that they can’t get help to change? What we need to do is empower those people. Empower them to go and implement the change.
[44:05] And those people can be really, really good because they are the ones that have got a vision on how to improve and to fix your business, but there may be just need support. Yeah. And then you’ve got your negative protesters.
[44:17] You just have the people there who are just complaining. They’re the ones that you need to deal with in a different manner. But there’s lots and lots of ways to, to think about your team.
[44:25] But one of the best ways, the best ways to spend our time is just to invest in our team, right? Because if we have a good team and people’s far more effective than just me performing well. So it’s important to maximize our team. That makes me think about a high school baseball coach that I had.
[44:43] And to this day, I still remember it. He had the five Ps and it’s proper preparation prevents poor performance. And while that’s totally accurate when it comes to athletics, it’s also true in business because if you’re properly prepared, your performance will be improved.
[44:59] We can take that when it comes to machining, when it comes to assembly operations, any manufacturing operations, every single part of job, just as an individual, if you’re the planner in a facility, if you are properly prepared to do your job, then you’re going to prevent poor performance. So make sure that you’re properly prepared. Five Ps.
[45:22] In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental, it’s engineered. But a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent follow-up, and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle.
[45:38] Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities. That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers.
[45:56] Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations, and sets qualified meetings. So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do.
[46:16] Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R M-F-G dot com slash chips. All right.
[46:28] So next step, what is it that we probably don’t want to fix right away? Like, obviously these are things that we’re going to want to look at down the road, but what would be maybe some common mistakes that we don’t want to fix first? I know, uh, as we talk about people, we don’t want to just walk in and clean house and hire new people, because that’s going to completely ruin, you know, that’s going to ruin a lot of things, especially, I mean, your, your morale and your culture are going to suffer. You can build up from your morale and culture from where you are, but if you’d completely start over, like, you know, you’re, you’re really going to be resetting yourself, I think. And you’re also going to probably lose some of your experience.
[47:05] You’re going to, you know, lose some of your knowledge that you, you really need to get that and get it converted into processes that are stable. And I think, you know, you probably think like machines, you probably don’t want to go in and buy machines immediately. Again, that’s down the road.
[47:20] Those are, those are things that you’re going to want to look at, but right away you probably would want to avoid buying the machines. I know another thing that, that has, this one I’m on the fence with, right? So I think there’s a, there’s a piece of it. One side of it, I would say if your organization is not properly using a software system, I would say that would be a critical step in getting to the next level, because just like we talked about, it’s your data, you’ve got, you can then start making data-driven decisions.
[47:49] We’ll talk about that on another episode, but how crazy your visualization is when you have data versus not having data. But the other aspect of that is if you come in and you just jump into a new software, what is that going to do to the team? Like, you know, are you going to totally bog everybody down trying to learn and convert to a new software system when we’re not really prepared? So I think that’s a critical step, but maybe just not to do that first. Have you ever dealt with any of those situations? We’ve implemented new MRP systems transferring between SAP or going from GDE to SAP and so on.
[48:27] But I think, I think to your point, it’s about creating stability, right? Whatever you’re going to change and whatever you want to fix, well, tackle one thing at a time and try not to create too much volatility, because sometimes the temptation is to go in and, and kick off different projects in different departments and what you, what you may struggle to do is create more waves and sometimes it’s good just to be able to focus on one or two of your high priorities at a time and try and create some stability first within the business and then really create your strategy then about what you need to tackle next and create that priority matrix. Again, looking at what’s the high impact with the low effort first to get your biggest wins as quickly as you can. Yeah.
[49:12] Cause I think, I think the thing is if you’re buying machines, if you’re changing software systems, uh, and even hiring placements or chasing more work, you’re creating some chaos that’s already in, you’re already in a unstable point. Those things are just going to add more chaos and you’ve got to really work to, to stabilize your current process. And then you can start to add these other things.
[49:38] They’re all really important parts of the business and important parts of the growth. But it just has to come at a later date. We’re going to, we’re going to stop the bleeding.
[49:46] We’re going to fix the job readiness. We’re going to stabilize the process. We’re going to work with leadership on our leadership communication.
[49:56] We’ve covered our people. We’ve covered what not to fix. You know, that’s kind of finalizes our whole framework there.
[50:03] We, we just make sure you’ve got that vision. You’ve got that clarity. You’re getting things very clear across all aspects of the business.
[50:11] Stabilizing all your processes, having your jobs prepared, ready on time, making sure not only leadership in the business is aligned with you, but also I think it’s important as a leader to, to be involved on the floor processes to as much as you can and get involved in knowing the people and developing those people. So that, that’ll kind of help you turn that chaos that you’re stepping into or chaos that you’re already involved in into consistency. And that’s the first thing that you want to do.
[50:40] Following that the profits follow stability. So that’s a really important part for us. So make sure that you walk the floor, make sure that you ask questions about the job.
[50:51] Make sure that you pick something, one thing to focus on, get it right. Move to the next process, pick one system that you want to stabilize. So do that this week, this week in your business, take a look at what’s going on.
[51:05] Take a look at something that you’re not feeling like is performing to the top level and dig into it, figure out, okay, what is it that I can change? What is it that we can change as an organization that’s going to make us and give us a more stable process? Just pick one thing, be the focus on that. And then you can just start to build, start to build, start to build. That’s the blueprint that we want to build one piece at a time.
[51:30] Guys, thanks for joining us again for Paul Barnes. I’m Jason Davis. Thanks for joining us on the Manufacturing Blueprint Podcast.
[51:43] I’m Jason Davis.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.