By Jennifer Dubose
QDISC Explained: A 5-KPI System for Smarter, More Profitable Manufacturing, Ep #34
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
KPIs can feel like a buzzword—every manufacturer knows they should be tracking them, but few feel confident about where to start or what actually matters. In this episode of Buy the Numbers, Mike Payne sits down once again with Jon Hughes of CLA to unpack the real purpose of KPIs, why they’re so misunderstood, and how data-driven decision-making can completely change the way a shop performs.
Mike and Jon dive into the QDISC framework—Quality, Delivery, Inventory, Safety, and Cost—and explore how these five buckets give manufacturers a clear, stable foundation for visibility. But they don’t stop at what to track. They go deeper into how to understand the story behind the metrics, how to trend progress over time, and how to set targets that actually mean something for your business and your customers.
Whether it’s measuring scrap and rework, calculating utilization, tightening cost control, or maintaining high on-time delivery, the two leaders discuss how the right KPIs help owners move from reactive firefighting to proactive leadership. They also break down the softer side of metrics: employee engagement, customer satisfaction, and the “why” behind the numbers that every team member needs to understand.
Most importantly, Mike and Jon show that KPIs don’t have to be complicated. In fact, the power comes from keeping them simple, actionable, relevant, and directly tied to your goals. If you’re ready to elevate your operation by measuring what actually matters, this episode gives you the roadmap to get there.
You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…
- (1:16) Introducing Jon Hughes and why KPIs matter
- (2:34) Why business owners struggle to start tracking KPIs
- (3:51) Learn how to grow your top and bottom line with CLA
- (5:46) How data reduces pressure and improves decision-making
- (7:41) KPIs as a living system that changes with your business
- (8:57) The QDISC framework: Quality, Delivery, Inventory, Safety, Cost
- (10:47) Safety metrics and examples of what to measure
- (12:15) Quality metrics: scrap, rework, escapes, and root-cause analysis
- (14:51) How to set meaningful KPI targets and benchmark well
- (16:55) Benchmarking challenges and looking at your own historical data
- (18:09) Trending metrics using percentages versus absolute values
- (19:44) Using yield and scrap data to price jobs correctly
- (22:48) Delivery and inventory KPIs, including OTD and cycle counting
- (24:26) Cost and capacity KPIs: utilization as a profitability lever
- (25:16) How ProShop ERP can help you achieve on-time delivery
- (26:15) Mike’s simple utilization KPI: billed vs. paid hours
- (30:28) Pricing strategy and understanding capacity
- (31:30) Tracking safety using workers’ comp modifier as a high-level metric
- (33:18) Why less is more when selecting KPIs
- (34:32) Financial review vs. weekly KPI review
- (36:26) Integrating KPIs into 13-week cash flow
- (37:39) Digging deeper only when KPIs show leakage
- (40:13) Measuring soft KPIs like customer concerns and employee satisfaction
- (42:48) Using employee surveys and tracking trends over time
- (44:00) KPIs as directional tools for improvement
- (45:12) Teaching employees how their actions affect KPIs
- (47:23) Using KPIs in all-hands meetings and bonus plans
- (49:16) Why we created Hire MFG Leaders (and why you should use it)
- (49:45) Final thoughts, how to connect with Jon, and closing
Resources & People Mentioned
- Learn how to grow your top and bottom line with CLA
- The KPIs to Help Manufacturers Improve Company Performance
- Your 6-Step Guide to Achieving Over 95% On-Time Delivery with Minimal Effort
- Cash Flow Power Moves: Pricing, Terms & Tools That Protect Your Business
- Why we created Hire MFG Leaders (and why you should use it)
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] Mike Payne: You order one part from me, I’m gonna set up and I’m gonna run it and I’m gonna lose it in the last op or something, and then I’m gonna have to start over and I’m gonna have to start over. Well, now we know it’s 30%, right? So run three of them from the get-go and just price that in.
[0:17] Jon Hughes: Price it in, yep.
[0:18] Mike Payne: When we brought this up to the customer that we had to change the pricing because of this high scrap rate, they acknowledged that we’re right and the reason they started outsourcing is because they had a higher scrap rate than that. They were making 10 to get two, but they understood that this is a hard part to make and we’re okay with that. So the more you get that data, then you can make those data-driven decisions that I’ve gotta charge X amount for this part to get a good one.
[0:45] Narrator: ♪ Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey ♪ Welcome to Buy the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business, from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.
Let’s crunch some numbers.
[1:16] Mike Payne: John, welcome back to Buy the Numbers.
[1:19] Jon Hughes: Hey, Mike, great to see you again, sir.
[1:21] Mike Payne: I think you now probably have officially have the award for the most frequent guest on Buy the Numbers.
[1:28] Jon Hughes: I’m gonna go back to my fifth grade class and grab that coveted copy of the Guinness Book of World Records. We had one for the entire class and see if I’m in there.
[1:38] Mike Payne: Yeah, exactly. Well, I couldn’t think of somebody better to talk about this. I wanna talk about KPIs today.
And for the listeners, we’ve done this a lot. I’m a big believer in data-driven decisions and KPIs help you do that. And we’ve done a handful of shows on KPIs and people always seem to get a lot out of these.
And I think one of the interesting things about KPIs are that there’s no right answer. You can measure whatever is important to you. And so I think it’s really important to hear different perspectives on gathering KPIs, measuring KPIs and how to lead with data-driven decisions.
So anyway, so John, thank you for, I know you guys, I know CLA is, you work with a lot of your clients on putting these systems in place, whether they’re financial metrics or performance metrics. So yeah, I appreciate you joining today to talk about some of this.
[2:34] Jon Hughes: Yeah, Mike, I appreciate the opportunity to be here. And certainly in my day-to-day life where I’m helping companies that are looking to improve their accounting function, and that’s typically having a month-end closed process and reporting. And as I’m talking to these business owners, everyone is looking for KPIs.
And I think it’s a buzzword and there’s a general consensus that this is important to running a business. And like you said, Mike, having data to make decisions on the business. But what I often hear from these owners is, one, they’re not sure where to start, what’s important to measure, how often they should be measuring things, or even what the format is.
How do they go about starting to track KPIs? It’s a topic that we get a lot of questions on. I think there’s a lot of interest here on business owners and just how do you go about setting up a system to track and what’s important to measure and how do you do it?
[3:51] Mike Payne: Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation, maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business ready to sell? At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more.
Every day, CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings, like one manufacturer that boosted capacity in revenues by 15 to 20%. Visit claconnect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line. And everybody’s KPIs can be drastically different, right?
Because we all have different business goals. Maybe there’s things we’re tracking, of course, to our profitability and our performance, but maybe culture and all sorts of different things. And having those targets that you want to be at, give you a direction.
I mean, one of the things I always, a personal opinion on KPIs too and data-driven decisions in general, is I think it’s often important to not just let the numbers make decisions for you, but I think it’s important to know the effect of your decisions on your KPIs, right? I know I’m going to make this decision that is not supported by the math necessarily, but by having good KPIs, by monitoring them, by tracking that, you then at least know what you’re giving up, right? Like maybe you’re willing to give up that little bit of ROI to make this different decision.
Maybe you’re, because it’s going to help your culture or whatever that case might be. It’s kind of a personal opinion. I know some people, it’s by the number.
Well, that’s the name of the show. But it’s just the math gives them the answer and I don’t think that’s always right, but I do like to have the measures in place to know what the math is telling me, right? So I’m not just going blind.
[5:46] Jon Hughes: Yeah, Mike, can I say when you have the data to inform decisions, I think in a lot of ways, we’re all coming to work and trying to do our best every day and in a lot of ways, having that data can relieve stress. When you think about being in the shop, we’re under constant pressure to do things more efficiently, to find ways to cut costs, reduce turnaround time, deliver a quality product. So there’s a lot of pressure on us as leaders and owners in the shop.
So by having that data available to help with the decisions, to your point, we know we’re objectively making decisions on the business and there may be some trade-offs to the decisions that we’re making, but at least we’re informed. And I’ve often said calling balls and strikes, but it’s really using the data to help us know, hey, is this something that was going to keep us on track or if we make this decision, is this going to send us in the wrong direction? And my overall opinion here on KPIs is really, it’s starting with understanding what’s most important to the business.
I like to know the long-term goals and for some companies that could be, we’ve got a, Mike, some companies might have a five-year plan, right? We know where we’re going to be and we’ve got some clear directions. Some companies might have a three-year plan.
A lot of companies are probably thinking about next year, but maybe not to or beyond that. But I think kind of starting where you’re at and understanding first, what are the goals here? And then that’s going to help to inform, okay, what do we need to measure?
What’s important to measure to help us towards those goals?
[7:41] Mike Payne: Yeah, and I think that’s such a great point. The KPIs, they really should be like a living, breathing document in some regard, right? So at different stages of your company, different things are going to be important to you.
So from a startup phase to a, I’m preparing to sell, look at that as a 20, 30-year span, whatever that might be. What you care about is going to change dramatically, right? I mean, early on it might be cash flow and later it’s EBITDA, right?
I mean, just from a financial perspective.
[8:12] Jon Hughes: Absolutely, and when you look at maybe the differences between the businesses that have good, say, good data, and I’d say the KPIs, but maybe even beyond that, just good accounting data versus the companies that don’t, I think that the difference really is in the visibility of kind of knowing where we’re at versus being able to make proactive decisions versus, hey, we’re driving a little bit blind here, something happens, and now we’re going to be reactive to that, or we don’t really have a clear understanding of how the business is performing in different areas.
[8:56] Mike Payne: You’ve shared with me some of your CLA material on KPIs, and you guys have core set of KPIs that you look at. You want to talk about those?
[9:05] Jon Hughes: Yeah, absolutely. The timing on this is great, Mike, for a couple of reasons. One is because we recently put out an article here on KPIs for manufacturing companies, but also just the time of year coming up to year end and thinking about what do we want to track here for 26.
So we recently did an article that was with one of our consultants, Mike Estes, and then in conjunction with a company, Phoenix Lighting, and their CEO, and really looked at what are these KPIs that make sense for most manufacturing companies to look at. There’s kind of a core set of KPIs that we recommend companies start with. And now, again, these are going to be different for every business, and I think it gets back to the alignment with the goals, but some of these are maybe foundational types of KPIs that we look at.
So we came up with an acronym here for this, QDISC. So we’ve got safety, quality, delivery, inventory, and cost as kind of the five buckets here of KPIs that we would look at. Now, when we put those into a kind of a prioritized order, well, we started, you know, QDISC, we started with quality, but I think for most organizations, you’re going to start with safety.
So that makes for a nice acronym, but I think we rearranged that, so.
[10:44] Mike Payne: Yeah, I don’t know how you’d spell it starting with an S.
[10:47] Jon Hughes: It’s going to be tough. I guess with an acronym, it has to sound like a word, right? It has to be different, so, yeah.
So yeah, so, you know, certainly safety starting with, you know, measuring what’s most important. You know, we all want our team to go home from work in the same condition that they arrived, so. And when you think about, you know, safety and maybe some of the metrics that you might look at there, of course there’s accidents or reportable incidents.
You know, that’s a pretty common KPI, and we all want to have that long period of time since there’s been an incident, and I think most shops track that in one way or another kind of visibly on the floor. We might look at things like lost time or near misses, so those are kind of, when we think about things that we look at for safety, you know, I’ve seen shops where, you know, they’ve tracked kind of see something, say something types of initiatives and really just looking to get one, I think kind of a unison of the team or kind of collaboration that, hey, we’re, you know, we’re in this together, we’re all, you know, working towards this goal here of safety, and, you know, certainly to create accountability as well when we look at these KPIs. So we’ve got safety on the list. We’ve got, of course, quality.
So when we think about my quality metrics and interested what you might track at the shop, I mean, certainly things like first pass yield or scrap rate.
[12:28] Mike Payne: So quality’s really high on our KPI list. We probably track it too many different ways, but yeah, first pass yield, scrap and rework as a percentage of dollars and as a percentage of parts, right? Because that can be drastically different.
We dig even a little bit deeper into, so of the exceptions, you know, leading causes, you know, those types of things. We dig in pretty deep on that side and that stems from, you know, not hitting our overall quality metrics. And so escapes, we also, you know, we track escapes differently from caught internally too, right?
So, you know, escapes, we want less than a half a percent internal. We usually run somewhere around 1.3, 1.4%. The less escapes we have, the more we catch internally, right? So it’s kind of a, it’s funny how those two numbers almost go in opposite direction.
Sure. But I’ll always take a higher internal rate, lower escapes.
[13:26] Speaker 5: Yeah.
[13:26] Mike Payne: I don’t ever get upset about that. But then we, then like I said, we dig in pretty deep into why. Yeah.
Right? And so we track a lot of numbers in the Y range also.
[13:37] Jon Hughes: I think Mike, that’s a big point there, is the Y. Cause we’re gonna, we have this data that we’re tracking. We’re looking at the numbers, maybe looking at the trends, but then, you know, what are we going to do with this information?
And it’s that, it’s that Y, right? It’s that digging in to understand the root cause there. And then like, what are the decisions that we’re going to make as a result?
[13:59] Mike Payne: Yeah. Why are 70% of my graph and rework set up error? You know, whatever the case might be.
I mean, I’m just making stuff up now, but yeah, so now that tells me I’ve got a flaw in my setup, instructions or process or something, right? So I can dig in and try to improve that.
[14:15] Jon Hughes: I would say, Mike, I’ve seen on the quality side, certainly a lot of shops may have some long-term, long-term contracts, particularly if they’re doing government work. And in my experience, certainly the importance of tracking the right metrics on those jobs, those long-term projects from the start is absolutely mission critical. And certainly have seen, you know, some companies struggle with on the quality side, not having the right tracking from the start.
[14:51] Mike Payne: Yeah. And the, you know, let’s pause here and talk a little bit too about, so we have our, we’re tracking certain things related to quality. We have our targets.
We track towards those. Here’s one of the questions that always comes up. It’s like, well, how do I know what my target is, right?
Like what’s okay? Am I okay at 1.3% internal scrap and rework? I am.
Am I okay at, you know, how did I establish we want to be under a half a percent escapes? And is that good, right? I mean, that some people might think that’s terrible.
Some people might think that’s incredible.
[15:25] Speaker 5: Yep.
[15:25] Mike Payne: So in my case, how did we establish those numbers as it relates to quality, the escapes under a half a percent, that’s the highest expectation of any of my customers.
[15:39] Speaker 5: Okay. Right.
[15:39] Mike Payne: So my customer that expects us to be the best expects us to be 99.5% of the parts we send them are right there. They understand stuff happens and they’re going to get a bad part or, but the tightest restriction I have to still score well with them is 99.5. So that’s just our standard. It’s not our standard with that customer.
That’s just our standard.
[16:00] Speaker 5: Yep.
[16:01] Mike Payne: Right. As it relates to internal, how did I establish that target of, so our target is actually 1.2. And that is actually, as people listen to buy the numbers and making chips from the top shops, modern machine shop, top shop survey, the top shops are generally in that range where it’s one, the 1.25 percentage, something like that. We want to be the best.
We want to be a top shop. That’s what we said is acceptable. It’s one thing to track it, but you got to know why are you picking the target you’re picking, right?
And in our case, that’s those two examples.
[16:37] Jon Hughes: Mike, I think the way you approach that and sort of looking at, right, here’s the standard that we have to meet for, you know, our toughest customer. And that’s going to be the benchmark here. We know that sort of the minimum and right.
We can improve from there. We get a lot of questions on kind of what’s available for benchmarking. Information.
And, you know, I think there certainly are sources like the top shops survey and there you have some very kind of specific questions and metrics in that survey. And you probably have some good reliable data there that you can use. I know on the financial side, the one thing I would say, and this is, you know, from my experience here over the years is yes, there are kind of financial benchmarks out there, but there’s also a lot of differences, particularly when we’re talking about smaller shops in how the numbers are being reported.
So a lot of times with those financial benchmarks, you’re comparing apples to oranges. Sure. So I think that, you know, for a lot of times for companies looking at their kind of past history can be a good starting point as well.
We’ve kind of know where we’ve been. We know that we want to improve the business. We’re going to pick some areas to focus on and then look for some incremental improvement.
[18:09] Mike Payne: Yeah. Are we making changes that, I mean, we may be way off of some top shops target that may or may not be relevant to us. Right.
But are we trending in the right direction? And that’s what KPIs can do such a good job of, especially when you look at percentage of something. If you just looked at the dollar value of your rework and you had a really low month to hit your target on a pure dollar value standpoint, you could be like, Oh, we’re doing a great job.
It was also our slowest month and as a percentage, it was three times the month before. So I always try to boil KPIs down to make them very relevant. It doesn’t matter what the inputs were, right?
It’s a percentage of something. It’s a ratio, whatever. So that I can really trend how I’m doing regardless of all the other variables.
[18:56] Jon Hughes: Yeah. That makes a lot of sense. And I think it’s just, you know, it’s certainly, it’s understanding the metrics and really making sure that we understand what we’re measuring and what the results say, because we could go from not having any KPIs to setting up KPIs we don’t understand.
And then, then we’re making the wrong decisions. Yeah. And I liked the percentage because it’s almost like you could have a basketball player has scored 30 points last night, but he took 40 shots and they say, well, that’s not great.
So yeah, a lot of times the, you know, having those percentages to kind of normalize the numbers, but I think it’s really understanding what we’re measuring and what those results actually mean for the business.
[19:44] Mike Payne: Well, and I know we haven’t even gotten off quality, but let’s take that a step further. Cause I’m just thinking about how we, you know, how we implement some of this KPIs into our overall process. So by tracking quality well, and knowing what our percentage of scrap is, we’re also able to price that in when we’re bidding new jobs.
Right. So if we expect that we’re going to have 1.3 parts percent scrap or rework, then we know that to make a hundred parts, we’ve got to make a hundred and one. Right.
So I need enough material. Like I’m going to start that order with a hundred and one and really, if I’m doing it really correctly, I’m going to probably start with a hundred and two, right? Because 1.3 is going to be two parts and we do that. And we price that in. So if someone orders a hundred parts or asks us to quote a hundred parts, we price it. Like we’ve got to run a hundred and two.
Well, now my scrap and rework is paid for, right? It’s part of my cost of this job. If I end up with a hundred and two parts, great.
You know, generally the customer will take those two extra parts or maybe they go into inventory, whatever the case might be. But I’ve priced that in. The other thing that’s done for us is it also identified parts that we can achieve that low of a rate.
There is one part we have in our shop that we know we’re going to have a 30% scrap rate on. It’s just, and we have tried to improve that for four years. Like as far as we know, it can’t be improved.
There’s a tolerance stack up to the part that you’re just going to miss a couple of them. Well, used to, we didn’t know that. So you order one part from me, I’m going to set up and I’m going to run it and I’m going to lose it in the last off or something.
And then I’m going to have to start over and I’m going to have to start over. Well, now we know it’s 30%, right? So run three of them from the get-go and just price that in.
[21:32] Jon Hughes: Price it in, yep.
[21:33] Mike Payne: And you might end up with two. You’re probably not going to end up with three, but you will end up with one. And your costs are lower.
You’ve priced the part appropriately. And this actually, this one part, when we brought this up to the customer that we had to change the pricing because of this high scrap rate, they acknowledged that we’re right. And the reason they started outsourcing is because they had a higher scrap rate than that.
[21:58] Jon Hughes: Okay, yep. So you made an improvement, yeah.
[22:00] Mike Payne: Yeah, so this was not a shock to anybody. They were making 10 to get two, right? And they understood that this is a hard part to make and we’re okay with that.
So the more you get that data, then you can make those data-driven decisions that I’ve got to charge X amount for this part to get a good one.
[22:19] Jon Hughes: Yeah, and these are all interrelated, right? Looking across the different engines in the shop. And yeah, you’re right.
And also going back to just the, what do we benchmark against? Well, in our shop, we’ve got a part here where there’s a high variability on the yield. So that’s going to be different than other shops, right?
[22:38] Speaker 7: Sure.
[22:39] Jon Hughes: So yeah, so we’ve talked about safety and quality. So in that kind of core five in the Q disk, we also have the delivery. So certainly I think the big one that companies look at is the on-time delivery.
We might also look at things like our suppliers’ delivery rates as well. We could look at things like downtime within the shop. We might track production downtime, which is going to tie into our ability to deliver on time.
Right. So we also have inventory, which is a big one there within the top five. So we’re looking at things like, I think most of the audience here, I’m assuming that we’re generally making to order.
Most of it. So there’s going to be some overrun, but we’re generally not maintaining kind of a large finished goods. Volume, right?
So we’re really looking at kind of raw materials, things like cycle counting, the raw materials, making sure that we’ve got accurate quantities in the system, how often we’re turning that inventory. I’ve seen, again, and this may apply to some of the audience, but sometimes with those government contracts, there’s, we end up having inventory that’s held. So in those cases, we may have some finished goods that we need to track more closely, and that could be important to the shop.
And then rounding out the top five, we have cost. And for cost, right, it’s really related to these other categories. One thing that we see as an opportunity for a lot of shops is just really elevating their understanding of how they’re utilizing capacity within the shop.
So maybe looking at KPIs around utilization. In our experience that, you know, often the biggest lever that shops can pull here when we’re thinking about improving profitability is just how do we utilize the additional, the existing capacity that we have within the shop, equipment, and people. So we generally recommend that as kind of an important metric for shops, particularly when you have, you know, when you’re in a high fixed costs, lots of equipment type of environment.
[25:17] Mike Payne: Hey, everybody. What do you think of when I say OTD? Well, in making chips, we’ve got lots of acronyms to deal with, but OTD is on-time delivery.
On-time delivery is part of Hill’s mission. Deliver quality parts on time, every time. When I was shopping for an ERP system, I was looking for something that would ensure that we do that on a regular basis.
Delivering jobs on time was something we struggled with, and I know that most shops struggle with. I think I saw recently that 70% of shops struggle with delivering parts on time. So the best decision I made in that, enter ProShop.
Did you know that many of ProShop’s customers quickly experienced 95% or better on-time delivery rates with their customers? And now, ProShop has a guide to help all shops, whether you’re using ProShop or not. Visit ProShopERP.com slash 95. Again, that’s ProShopERP slash 95 to get your copy today. So let’s touch on that one, because to me, once you start getting into efficiency, utilization, and those types of things, there’s just so many ways you can track it, right? I mean, like, I think in most cases, if I really wanted to, I could always make the numbers look good, just depending on how I calculate it, right?
So I’ve actually tried to slim mine down and make it as simple as possible so there is no bias towards this or that. But what are some of the ways, like, that you would say, like, if I wanna track, you know, overall efficiency, utilization, so forth? I mean, do you have, like, kind of a best practice look at that?
And actually, what I can do is I can tell you the highest level I look at it before I dig any deeper. So, you know, we have a shop rate we wanna hit as a shop. We bid based off of that, we try to perform based off of that.
So one of the simplest things I look at, and this is so simple, but I’ll look at labor hours for a time period, right? Whether I’m looking at a week, a month, a quarter, whatever it might be, times my shop rate, and I get a number. I paid for 5,000 hours in this time period at, call it $90 an hour, you know, something like that.
Whatever blended rate I’m looking for as a shop. So I have, there’s $450,000 there in that time period. What did I actually hit?
Did I hit over that, under that? Right? So that gives me a very high level look at, just from a labor hour standpoint, and look at spendability and look at anything else.
But at the end of the day, we’re generally selling, I think most of us in this business are selling labor hours.
[27:49] Jon Hughes: So Mike, if you wanted to know kind of where you’re at mid-month, that’s a good leading indicator.
[27:55] Mike Payne: Right.
[27:56] Jon Hughes: For you, so the hours. How many labor hours do you have at that point?
[27:59] Mike Payne: Yeah, so I just look at it, what percentage of hours that I paid for at my shop rate, and then how much have I actually shipped? Like, I want that to be .85, .9, or better, right? Some months it’s 1.4, right?
Some months it’s .6, right? So it’s a very high level, simplistic view at what I just call utilization, right? Like, are we billing for the time that we’re spending?
Yeah. And then from there, I can dig down into 100 more KPIs.
[28:30] Jon Hughes: Yeah, well I love that one, because you’ve kind of got the utilization, but you’re also kind of playing there on the billing and the cash flow as well, right? Because it’s, what have we recorded for labor hours, and what have we turned around and billed? How do we ultimately get paid for this time?
So it’s, are we utilized, and then how quickly are we getting those products out the door and invoice and collect? It’s interesting because we might look at things by work center, and looking at utilization by work center. I found in practice that information’s really helpful when we’re doing quoting meetings, or looking at bidding on jobs, and really considering, is this a part of the shop where we have excess capacity?
And then you start to look at, well, what does it really cost us to run this job? It’s the materials, right? We already have the people, we already have the equipment.
So that can be a way where we can find some opportunities to improve the bottom line. I think when we’re talking about anything related to pricing, there’s always strategy involved there, and you wanna be true to how you’re pricing strategy. But if we have the capacity, I think the general point is just, hey, we may wanna be a little bit more aggressive to take on certain types of work.
When you look at just the overall, the cost structure within a shop, if we’re getting into any type of accrual accounting, you can end up with complexities there that lead to the wrong decisions. And when you start to think about how we’re allocating labor and overhead, and those things are certainly important, and we need to have an understanding of that when we’re quoting work. But to get back to that discussion on capacity, we also have to be kind of recognizing where we’re underutilized within the shop, and we don’t wanna let that cost accounting lead us to the wrong decisions.
That’s a challenge that we see sometimes when companies are doing accrual accounting that plays into this as well. But I love that metric that you led with there, Mike, because I think a lot of times it’s looking at the leading indicators in the shop, and it could even be something like, I’ve seen shops look at unplanned call-outs, as that can be a significant indicator for them as to what is production gonna look like here for the month, ultimately, what are we gonna be able to kind of bill and collect here? And I think anytime you get those leading indicators, it just helps you to make a decision.
Like, do we have an issue here with attendance or something that leadership needs to address?
[31:30] Mike Payne: That’s such a good lead way into, I mean, I think everything we talked about in the Q-disk model makes perfect sense. And I did actually wanna go back to one thing on the safety. I think that’s a hard one for a lot of people to track, right?
Like there’s days since last incident, there’s those types of things. And I know in our environment, I think there’s a lot of near misses that certainly go unreported, right? Like no one’s walking around and go, almost cut my finger, right?
But there’s a first aid closet that I can hear open and close too. So I know people are grabbing Band-Aids from time to time, right? But one of the things I’ve done in that regard, and this is more of an annual check and it’s really big picture, but I’ll even just kind of track my, oh, whatever they call it, my modifier on my worker’s comp, right?
And where I stand against kind of the industry norm. And I know because of tracking that, I know that we do a pretty good job. I don’t remember the exact numbers off the top of my head right now, but we’ve even had worker’s comp audits purely because our number, our modifier is so low for the industry.
And they’re like, this can’t be right. And then they come in and they audit and they’re like, no, it’s right. So I know we’re performing well there, right?
So it’s something I track, but because I know we’re performing well, it’s not something I’ve gone deeper on, right? Versus some of these other things, they expose a problem and I need to dig deeper. So using that as an example, and where we’ve talked about quality or costs and so forth.
So if I’ve established this kind of high-level Q-disk model, and again, maybe those are driven by customer expectations and internal expectations, where now can I start to kind of dig deeper into like, so costs, for example, right? I mean, there’s, I think we probably all do or should track our cost of goods sold, maybe a little bit different from our SG&A. But I mean, I have some light item expectations on my SG&A, right?
I mean, it’s just, there are things that are not gonna be more than a percentage of revenue or whatever that case might be. So how do you recommend people, if they get a good Q-disk established, like where do you then start digging in deeper?
[33:52] Jon Hughes: I might say I’d start with kind of the concept that less is more. We don’t want to over-complicate things. So it’s really deciding on what are the, what matters most.
In the article here, we suggest four or five kind of KPIs as a focus. In practice, I’ve seen clients effectively use maybe up to 10 KPIs that they’re tracking. And I would separate the, there’s the KPIs and some of these are financial measurements.
Some of them are non-financial. And I’d separate that a little bit just from kind of the basic financial statement review. Because I think that there are some practices here and we could look at things like having an annual budget, which can be important, right?
Having an expectation for the year and then measuring our actual results against that. So when we’re looking at things like the SG&A expenses, we have a expectation for the year. It might be based on starting with last year, but it could be that there’s also some initiatives that you planned for the year and areas that you can improve the business.
So we kind of have that financial review and that’s important. And that’s kind of looking at the company as a whole, our overall financial results. And then we start to look at, okay, here are these other measurements, these KPIs that we want to track.
And we can start with our five categories there, the Q disk and there may be some other areas of the business that you want to measure as well. But kind of starting with that framework of, okay, we don’t want to overcomplicate this because if we track too many things, we lose focus on what’s important. And I would say another important point here too is the timing of how often do we want to look at things.
So I had mentioned unplanned call outs. I mean, that may be something that we want to look at on a weekly basis or in your kind of metric there of what we have for labor booked versus what we build. These are things that we want to look at more frequently than that kind of monthly financial statement view.
[36:26] Mike Payne: Well, it’s kind of interesting, just again, I’m interested in your opinion on this. So you and I have talked a lot and the most recent episode you were on with me, we talked about 13 week cashflow. So some of the things I talked about, like even that super high level efficiency thing, right?
Or utilization. So I put this on my 13 week cashflow actually goes, one of the inputs for me is labor hours that week. And at the bottom of my 13 week cashflow, I have some of these KPIs that I track.
So how much did I ship this week and how much labor hours did I pay, right? And it gives me that, okay, you were at 87%. Okay, I’m not worried, right?
Like we did good. To me, I always look at KPIs as like this big pyramid, right? Like ultimately I want to be profitable, right?
Like at the top of the list, I need to be profitable. I don’t want to be profitable, I need to be profitable. So there’s things that goes into that, right?
So when you’re talking about budgeting and forecasting and are we hitting our revenue targets, are we hitting our cost targets, so forth. So that branches off to a couple of your financial metrics that you need to do. And then I think when you start seeing problems, or maybe not even problems, but just leakage at each level, that’s gonna branch off to, okay, well, if I’m seeing leakage and gross margin, then I need to dig a little bit deeper into cost of goods sold.
So from there, what do I need to look at? Well, maybe I need to be looking at my labor hours, and maybe I need to be looking at our material purchases, our inventory, those types of things, or supplies, right? Like, am I spending too much on tooling, which is now gonna give me a new metric.
Well, how do I know if I’m spending too much on tooling? Maybe I’ve got to dig in and go, okay, are we buying effectively? Are we utilizing all the best methods?
And to me, it’s just, they all build off of, like I don’t create KPIs for the sake of creating KPIs. I create them for the sake of driving the goal above it. Where is my scrap and rework coming from?
If it’s on target, I’m not digging in as deep for the why that we talked about earlier, right? If I’m hitting those targets, I’m not digging to that next level. If I’m not hitting those targets, well, why are we having setup errors?
Why are we having tool breakage? You know, whatever the case might be. And yeah, so I mean, in my mind, that’s how I’ve done my systems over the years is just starting at that highest level and then just starting to dig down, dig down.
[38:59] Jon Hughes: It’s framing it with that, what are the big picture goals? And then from being in the shop, what are the areas that you need to focus? You’re right, if we’re knocking it out of the park in an area, then maybe that’s where we don’t need to put our attention there, right?
We need to maintain it’s, what are the other parts of the business that we can improve? To your point of ultimately, it’s about we need to be profitable, right? We need to be profitable.
We need to grow to create opportunities for our people, right, to create opportunities as shop owners or leaders. You know, some of these things kind of, you know, I had mentioned the financial review and then you had mentioned the cashflow, which I love that you’ve got on there. You got pretty slick there.
You’re kind of forecasting the, right, what the cash has been based on the labor, which I love. But even, it might be that cashflow is important, but our KPI could be as simple as we could have cash collections for the week. We kind of know what we need to collect here to stay on track with that 13 week plan, so let’s just look at it weekly and hopefully drive some, maybe drive some actions or how we’re handling our collections, practices, and we’re looking to drive some improvements.
[40:13] Mike Payne: Yeah, now in the article that you’ve referenced, which we’ll make sure to link to that in the show notes, you know, I read a couple of things I hadn’t seen before and it brings up, I think, a good topic, some of these softer KPIs, right? Like how in the heck do you measure that? And you had two in there.
One was customer delight and one was employee engagement, I think is what they said. I want to hear a little bit about that because I think there are a lot of soft metrics that we want to measure, but we don’t know how, right? Like how do you measure customer delight, right?
Like that’s, or employee engagement. So I’m just curious, maybe some of the examples that you’ve seen of that and or other kind of soft numbers and how to measure those.
[40:53] Jon Hughes: Mike, in that article there’s, so I’d mentioned it’s Mike Estes from CLA in connection with Phoenix Lighting and they talk about one of the metrics at Phoenix Lighting, which I think maybe referencing there’s a customer concerns per million.
[41:10] Speaker 8: Yeah.
[41:11] Jon Hughes: Metric where they’re looking at everything customer related, right? It could be an issue with the part, but it could be an issue with the purchase order or invoice wasn’t sent to the right, whatever the case may be, they’re going to measure any customer concern related to that order. So they’re tracking that on a kind of per million basis.
So it might be, we’ve got 50 incidents out of a million orders or coming up with the baseline there I think is the key. And then looking to improve that. You have the employee satisfaction or customer employee delight, I don’t know.
[41:51] Speaker 8: Yeah.
[41:52] Jon Hughes: Employee satisfaction, yeah. Yeah, I mean, you see things like certain companies will certainly look at things like turnover, right? But that’s after the fact type of an indicator.
But I’ve seen companies look at things like personal training programs. So having a requirement that everybody within the organization’s getting some continuous development and making sure that employees are on track with that. Some companies might look to do some kind of a employee satisfaction type of survey.
So we could look to kind of take a kind of measurement that way with a survey. But yeah, I think when you get into some of the softer topics, you just have to be a little bit more creative than how do we, understanding what we want to measure but being creative maybe in how we approach that.
[42:48] Mike Payne: Yeah, and I’m glad you brought that up about like the employee survey. So, we use ProShop ERP. It actually has a built-in employee survey function.
One of the things, and we do it once or twice a year probably something like that. So it’s kind of a canned survey that goes out to employees about all sorts of working condition things. Opportunity for improvement, opportunity for growth and how’s my pay and how’s my benefits.
And one of the things that’s always been frustrating for me since we started doing it is relatively low participation. We probably average half the people fill out the survey. And early on, it was super frustrating for me.
But after we had done it five or six times I realized it kind of didn’t matter because again, we were getting a trend, right? So our composite score of those surveys was either going up or down every time we did it, right? Yes, there’s people that chose not to do it.
That’s fine. We don’t have that input. I guess I could force it.
I’ve never chosen to force it. But I think it maybe goes a little bit back to what we were talking about earlier though is lots of times it doesn’t matter if everybody participates or not you’re still seeing trends, right? So whether it’s quality data, safety data or employee satisfaction data, you are seeing trends.
[44:00] Jon Hughes: Absolutely, yeah. And I think that’s an important point is we know where we are now, right? We’re starting here and then what are the trends?
Are we making incremental improvement to the business, right? Are we making progress on that goal of profitability or improving the bottom line or whatever the kind of the big picture goals are? Where are we now?
Where do we want to go? And using the KPIs and data to make decisions to help us get there. I would just add, it’s definitely this is a process of iteration.
So, if somebody is new to using KPIs I’d encourage you to start and you’re gonna track certain things and then you’re gonna say, hey, I don’t know that this is important and that’s okay. And you can go and say, I’m gonna track something else instead. And that’s the way the process is gonna go here to really get down to what’s important to measure in the business.
And when you figure that out, then it’s gonna change, right? Because the goals of the business are gonna change or the environment that you’re operating is gonna change.
[45:12] Mike Payne: Yeah, and I think that’s such as we wrap up, I think that’s a great way to encourage people to get started is, let’s keep it simple, right? And don’t track too much stuff that no one can keep up with everything you’re tracking. The other lesson that I’ve learned over the years that I was not doing a good job at Hill and I think we’re a lot better now than we were, but still not perfect is, make sure to really communicate to everyone on your team how they can affect the KPI, right?
So your shop floor guy maybe does not need to understand how you’re tracking a KPI related to purchasing, right? Or something like that. But they do need to understand how they affect that simple efficiency calculation I described earlier, right?
Like, hey, we’re tracking, we’re trying to be 85% or better. That means that every hour of your day needs to be built towards making, out of every hour, 85% of it, which is 51 minutes or something, I can’t remember what the number is. Needs to be productive, right?
Spindle needs to be turning, putting parts on a pallet, whatever their job is. And because for the longest time, I was tracking all these KPIs and I would grow frustrated that this isn’t happening, this isn’t happening. And I had told someone why, what they’re doing.
I told them what I’m asking them to do is important because in some ways it gives me the data I need to make good decisions. But I never explained to them why it was important and why that decision they can make this way or the other is gonna affect that number. So I’ve really tried, I’d say over the last year and a half, to really align everybody’s individual roles and let them understand how they affect our overall KPIs.
And that alone, I’d say I saw a pretty good improvement. Just every single person understanding how they affect whatever numbers they affect. Some numbers they don’t affect.
They don’t need to know about those. They don’t need to worry about them. But the ones that they can affect, the more they understand it, the more they performed in a way that affected the KPIs positively.
[47:23] Jon Hughes: I love that, Mike. And I think on that why, I mean, the individual communication’s really important. Certainly any all hands types meetings, these are, right, this is great opportunity to share kind of what it is that we’re measuring, why they’re important and how we’re doing.
I’ve always found that this type of information’s really well received in all hands meetings. Right, we wanna know, everybody wants to know how we’re doing. Some companies will even tie some of these metrics maybe into bonus plans and things like that to create that sense that we’re kind of, we’re working together collaboratively on these goals.
[48:05] Mike Payne: Yeah, and I think that’s a critically important piece. I actually have kind of undone that internally right now with the goal of reestablishing some very direct KPIs to a bonus plan. Ours were a little too complicated.
[48:20] Speaker 7: Yeah.
[48:21] Mike Payne: So I kind of unwound it. Again, part of it was they didn’t understand the KPIs, they didn’t understand how they affect the KPIs. So they just, we based it on some big numbers that rolled up that people didn’t understand how them making a decision one way or the other affected that top number, right?
So trying, I’ve actually, I’m kind of redoing mine now to break that down a little bit more so that it’s not six calculations removed from their daily operations.
[48:48] Speaker 5: Yeah, right, yeah.
[48:49] Mike Payne: They know what I did today affects my numbers this way, you know, type thing. But yeah, I mean, I think the more you can tie compensation to early bonus plans or anything to some of these KPIs, I think you just get triple the effect of the positive results of it for sure.
[49:06] Jon Hughes: Yeah, amen, I love keeping it simple. And yet your point has to be things that the team has the ability to impact.
[49:13] Mike Payne: And know how to impact, right?
[49:15] Speaker 4: Yeah. Hey, it’s Paul from Making Chips. If you’ve been burned by recruiters who don’t understand manufacturing, you are not alone.
That’s exactly why we created Hire MFG Leaders. We’re not just recruiters, we’re current and former shop owners, and we know what it takes to lead in this industry. Whether you’re hiring your next operations leader, sales manager, or production supervisor, we’ll help you find someone who actually fits.
Learn more at makingchips.com slash hire.
[49:45] Mike Payne: Well, John, this was good. I appreciate you jumping on and talking about some of this. We’ll definitely tie the article that we’ve been referencing to the show notes here so that listeners can go look at that.
As I’ve told listeners many times when CLA is involved, like you should just go follow their stuff anyway. They put out so much great content for manufacturers, whether it’s about KPIs or taxes or whatever the case might be, inventory management. I mean, all sorts of great articles all the time.
So I would definitely encourage you just to go follow their stuff. Of course, a lot of you have heard from John before, but John, go ahead and tell people how they can find you if they’ve got some questions on this.
[50:26] Jon Hughes: Yeah, absolutely, Mike, appreciate that. And I’m happy to help with any questions here on KPIs. As I mentioned, it’s a process of iteration and I’m happy to help support you on your journey.
You can find me at, it’s John, J-O-N, three letters. My parents knew I wasn’t smart enough to spell a four-letter word. So it’s john.hughes at claconnect.com.
And again, happy to help with any questions.
[50:53] Mike Payne: Yeah, and if you don’t track him down there, just holler at me and I’m happy to connect you guys as well. So yeah, with that, thank you everybody for listening. And John, thanks again for being on the show.
[51:03] Jon Hughes: Thanks, Mike, thanks for having me. Always a pleasure. BEAPLE CREDITS
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect with Jon Hughes
- CliftonLarsonAllen (CLA)
- Connect on LinkedIn
Connect With Buy the Numbers
Subscribe to Buy the Numbers