By Jennifer Dubose

The Overlooked Expense: How Utility Assessments Can Unlock Hidden Savings, Ep #41

Most of the time on Buy the Numbers, we focus on revenue growth, margin improvement, cash flow strategy, or capital investments. But in this episode, we turn our attention to something many manufacturers rarely question: utility expenses.

Electricity. Gas. Water. Sewer. Waste.

For most of us, these bills show up, we pay them, and we move on. They’re viewed as fixed costs of doing business. But what if they’re not as fixed as we think?

In this episode, I’m joined by Lori Demeyer and Leticia Lawson from CliftonLarsonAllen to talk about utility assessments — what they are, how they work, and where manufacturers may be leaving real money on the table.

We discuss exemption certificates, rate classifications, time-of-use billing, meter configurations, and why businesses in certain states may have more opportunity than they realize. Most importantly, we walk through the process and risk profile so owners can decide if it’s worth exploring.

If you’ve ever assumed your utility bills are simply “the cost of doing business,” this conversation may change how you think about one of the most overlooked lines on your P&L.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:00) Nearly $1M in utility savings: what’s possible over multiple years
  • (1:10) Introducing Lori Demeyer and Leticia Lawson from CLA
  • (3:55) What a utility assessment actually is and how it works
  • (7:37) Manufacturing exemptions and how they apply to utilities
  • (9:59) Grow your top and bottom line with CliftonLarsonAllen (CLA)
  • (10:40) Common billing errors, expired exemptions, and missed documentation
  • (13:53) Rate classifications, multiple meters, and usage breakdowns
  • (18:18) Incentives, business riders, and time-of-use rate opportunities
  • (22:39) Get a free report of sales opportunities in your industry from facturmfg.com/chips
  • (23:45) Who should consider a utility review and ideal spend profiles
  • (26:36) State-by-state complexity and why California and the Northeast stand out
  • (31:39) What the review process looks like (30–45 days, minimal client lift)
  • (36:19) What happens if savings are identified and how implementation works
  • (38:41) Real-world savings examples: six-figure and seven-figure impact
  • (42:13) Why utility assessments are typically low-risk and contingency-based
  • (45:00) How ProShop can help you achieve on-time delivery

Resources & People Mentioned

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] Lori Demeyer: And between the three years that we were engaged with the client, it was about $960,000, between refunds and just, you know, rate change savings.

[0:10] Mike Payne: I mean, that’s all real money, right?

[0:12] Lori Demeyer: The great thing about that is, is when you do implement rate changes, those tend to stay in place for, you know, seven, maybe even up to 10 years before you might have to provide updated documentation to the utility provider. And then obviously, exemptions stay in place as your certificate continues to get renewed. And then again, if you’re using the meters in the same capacity, there’s no problem there, right?

Your percentage of exemption would remain the same.

[0:42] Narrator: Welcome to Buy the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business, from accounting and finance, to operations, and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.

Let’s crunch some numbers.

[1:10] Mike Payne: Ladies, welcome to Buy the Numbers.

[1:12] Lori Demeyer: Thank you for having us. We’re very excited.

[1:15] Mike Payne: We’ve got some guests from CLA. You’re all very familiar with CLA. They always bring us great topics and great financial and accounting advice.

So we’ve got kind of a new topic today, something we haven’t ever talked about, but we’re going to talk a little bit about utility assessments. So we’re going to be focused now on the expense side of your P&L, where lots of times we tend to be talking about either top line or cost of goods sold. But here we’re going to, I think we’re going to be digging mostly into things that’ll fall down in your SG&A that I think a lot of us feel like there’s not a lot we can do about those things, but maybe we’re going to learn a little bit differently today.

So I’ll let you guys introduce yourselves. Laurie, we can start with you.

[1:58] Lori Demeyer: Sure. Laurie DeMeyer. I’ve been with CLA for about eight, just over eight years now.

My background actually is about 20 years in the telecom industry, and we diversified a bit as coming to CLA. Also started working on utility assessments as well. It was a big ask for our clients from, you know, what can we do with this type of service?

Are there any savings opportunities? So we took that on and we complete assessments for utilities and have gotten great savings for clients.

[2:34] Mike Payne: Yeah. Good, good, good.

[2:35] Leticia Lawson: And I’m Leticia Lawson, and I’ve been with CLA for 10 plus years now. And similar to Laurie, I also have a extensive kind of telecom-related background. But as, you know, needs come up with clients, we always try to, you know, meet those needs by, you know, integrating some new type of assessments.

And so that’s what we’ve been doing quite a few years now with the utility reviews.

[3:04] Mike Payne: Yeah. Excellent. So to put this in context for me as a business owner, and I’ve spent most of my career, you know, as a business owner, and I’ve, you know, I’ve often, I can say I’ve never done what we’re going to talk about, but I have very, very often over the years, seems like, you know, I probably at least once a year, you know, you meet somebody that does these cost analysis and, you know, talks about being able to, it typically is related to utilities, it seems, you know, being able to do reviews that, you know, will produce some sort of savings.

[3:41] Lori Demeyer: Right. Absolutely.

[3:42] Mike Payne: Like I said, I’ve never personally done it. So I’m super anxious to hear about this because I do know a lot of other business owners that have done things and have had great things to say about the process. So let’s kind of define it out of the beginning.

So like, what is a utility assessment? What does that look like, you know, just at the highest level?

[4:02] Lori Demeyer: A utility assessment is really as simple as it sounds. And you’re really focusing on invoices for this type of assessment. So you would review any electric, electrical invoices, waste, water, those two sort of get overlooked as well, gas and sewage.

So, you know, depending on which of those that you are utilizing an abundance of utility usage on, you do want to verify those. So typically invoices are reviewed in detail. You’re reviewing to make sure that the rates that the utility provider has on your invoice is accurate based upon any of your eligibility for a specific rate.

So a lot of folks, what they don’t know is like wireless plans or any other type of rates, utility providers do have different rates and you’re not just, you know, confined to typically a standard rate depending again on the type of business that you’re doing. And these rates are specific for your meters. So you can have several meters in a facility where one can be used for office space and that will most likely be on your standard type of electric rates.

But depending on what other meters are, you know, tied to machinery, things like that, there are different categories. So end users and business owners typically are not really fully aware of what those options potentially could be, what they qualify for. Another thing you want to also ensure is that exemptions are in place.

So if you are eligible for any tax exemptions, be it sales tax or a state or county taxes, whether it’s a full exemption or a percentage of that, you also want to make sure that that is accurate on an invoice. So those are the things that we, you know, and other companies that conduct utility assessments will typically look for right out of the gate.

[5:57] Mike Payne: So you raised a couple of questions there. So as I said, when I framed up the question, you know, I think a lot of us just assume, I mean, we get our bill from the electric company, we pay it, you know, a bunch of CNC machines don’t do me any good if I don’t have electricity, right? So we just, we pay it.

We don’t ask questions. I probably haven’t looked at one.

[6:17] Lori Demeyer: The same as we do in our personal lives, right? You just pay the bill and it’s a need. So you pay it.

[6:24] Mike Payne: Yeah. I mean, I don’t know the last time I looked at an electric bill. I know it gets really expensive in the summer and it’s not bad in the winter.

That’s all I know. But you know, like you brought up multiple meters. I don’t know if I even have multiple meters.

I’m already thinking, okay, well, when we’re done with this call, I’m going to go look. Because I know when this building was put to use as hill manufacturing, I guess, 15, 17 years ago now, all the infrastructure was built out amazingly. I mean, we have tremendous electrical infrastructure and in addition to compressed air, it was done really, really well.

So it wouldn’t shock me if I go out there and it was built to be, you know, for opportunity to be super efficient. And we’re not taking advantage of that.

[7:15] Lori Demeyer: And you might have just one meter that’s shared, right? So that’s a different ballgame where you now have to identify how is that meter being used? What percentage is this function for?

What percentage is for manufacturing? So, you know, some companies can have one, some can have three, some can have 15. It just really depends on how that’s all built out.

[7:37] Mike Payne: Something else you said that I’ve never considered, you talked about, you know, maybe we have a sales tax exemption or something. So we do, for example, in the state of Oklahoma, we have our manufacturer’s sales tax exemption. Would that generally roll over to my electric?

[7:52] Lori Demeyer: Sure. Yes. So if you typically have that exemption, that will follow through on your utility invoices.

Again, it is dependent, right?

[8:00] Mike Payne: There is some criteria.

[8:02] Lori Demeyer: Yeah. So you have to identify, you know, always going back to the what percentage of that meter is being used for any usage tied to manufacturing, you know, or, you know, and it’s not just the machinery, it could be refrigeration, you know, whatever that might look like. And so it really is dependent on that percentage.

And typically, if you’re over 50 of usage, there are some discount that would be eligible.

[8:32] Mike Payne: Yeah, I would, again, I haven’t looked at a bill in forever, but I can’t remember that we ever filed an exemption. So I’m going to guess that if I go look, I’m probably paying.

[8:43] Lori Demeyer: And that is easy to see on an invoice. All the other things you want to look at, you know, you sort of have to have a little bit more of specialized knowledge to say, okay, am I being billed correctly? Is the meter rate proper?

How are we calculating this? But the exemptions, you can tell right off the bat, whether you see sales tax or any type of county or state taxes.

[9:04] Mike Payne: And so I would assume when there are any, you know, of course, so far we’ve only, I’ve given electric examples, but you mentioned trash and probably water and I mean, water, sewer, I guess everything, right? Telecom, all of this applies to, I mean, I guess most of what we will talk about today kind of applies across the board to all those types of things.

[9:25] Lori Demeyer: For mostly utility, from a telecom perspective, it’s a little bit different, but from an exemption perspective, you would see maybe that advantage on the utility invoices.

[9:36] Mike Payne: Okay. So again, I’m probably like most business owners and I just assume that my electric company or my waste company or, you know, like our water and sewers through our city, you know, which I guess probably most are, but, you know, I’m, I guess I just fly blind, right? And I just assume they’re doing things correctly and above board.

Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation, maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business ready to sell? At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more.

Every day, CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings. Like one manufacturer that boosted capacity and revenues by 15 to 20%. Visit claconnect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line. I mean, where did the errors come from? Like it sounds like could some be maybe be my fault if I haven’t filed exemptions or.

[10:47] Lori Demeyer: The utility provider won’t necessarily know what your exemption status is until you tell them that, right? So you have to provide the certificates to them. You also have to provide obviously any proof that follows through with that to them.

So that is the responsibility of the business owner. And, you know, like you said, if you’ve set your account up years ago and you’re on X, Y, Z plans, but maybe your business has changed a bit and how it produces things or the amount of usage that it has.

[11:26] Leticia Lawson: Especially new equipment that are that’s installed or new new meters that get installed. And sometimes those meters aren’t properly classified as well. So the exemption, yeah, you have to really pay quite a bit of attention to that.

[11:42] Lori Demeyer: Yeah. So I think it’s just, I mean, it’s just, it could be human error or just, you know, failed to update or, you know, whatever that could be. It’s not that anybody, I don’t think the utility providers are, you know, doing anything on purpose so that you’re not getting your discounts.

It’s just if they don’t know certain things.

[12:01] Leticia Lawson: Yeah. Right. Exemptions have a limited timeline too.

So sometimes they want you to update that exemption paperwork. So exemptions can kind of fall off and they’re not necessarily going to tell you that it fell off. So we’ve seen it where maybe it fell off two years ago, but you didn’t know that and you didn’t update the paperwork.

So that’s another example of something simple that could happen.

[12:25] Mike Payne: Again, I can’t sit here and tell you, I look at my utility bills on a regular basis, but, but I know when I do see them, they’re a little insane.

[12:33] Leticia Lawson: Yes. There’s a lot of numbers.

[12:35] Mike Payne: Yeah.

[12:36] Leticia Lawson: I know. Yeah. So, you know, there’s a lot of data there and sometimes it, it’s, it’s not your area to be, you know, an expert or to be knowledgeable.

Right. So that’s why it is important to have that kind of utility review relatively often. So you can have someone else take a look at it and see where, you know, there might be some, you know, some things to be reviewed.

[13:03] Mike Payne: Yeah. And, you know, as I’m sitting here thinking about it too, if I did have some crazy high bill and I said, Hey, let me see this. I don’t understand.

I would almost guarantee you the way my mind would work. And I think probably a lot of my, my peers in the industry would, I mean, once I get to the line where there’s fees and taxes, that’s where I’m going to figure, well, I don’t have, I mean, there’s nothing I can do about that. Right.

But now, if I mean the right out of the gate, the first thing I’m hearing from you is that might actually be your low hanging fruit. If you have some exemptions and, and, and most of, I think most of our listeners are probably going to have their manufacturing exemption in their state because we’re all manufacturers. So that’s, that’s interesting.

Yeah. I never even thought about that aspect. So, so where, where are the most common, like, like, where do you see those like cost drivers when you start picking apart utilities?

Like, what are those common things that just pop up almost every time as, you know, missed or skipped or whatever?

[14:13] Lori Demeyer: Really, to me, there’s the two main ones that we’ve been discussing, but I would say the one that really stands out the most could be the exemptions, just because as Leticia mentioned, you know, again, as a business owner, you’re like, well, I submitted this and we’re, you know, they have the documentation, we’re good to go. And then you don’t think three to five years later that you’re renewing a certificate that you have to send that back in. You’re just assuming it’s a one and a done.

[14:44] Mike Payne: They’d ask me if they need an update.

[14:46] Lori Demeyer: Typically they won’t send you an email or, and say, Hey, it’s time. We need your certificate.

[14:50] Mike Payne: We got money to save you.

[14:51] Lori Demeyer: You know, they’ll just go ahead and it’ll just start invoicing. And we see that often that everyone’s like, Oh my God, but we’ve had, we were exempt. Here are our certificates.

Now, the good thing about that is you can get a refund. So that’s the positive on it. But that, as Leticia mentioned, it’s, you know, you want these reviews done frequent, excuse me, frequently, because you do want to ensure that, you know, five years doesn’t go by and they’re like, we’re only going to give you a three year refund because that was your error or whatever that might be.

Right. So, you know, that’s where you can do it, you know, at least every two years, you’re within that window where if something fell off, you can go ahead and, and, you know, provide their certificate. And then there could be some due diligence on your end.

Sometimes the utility provider will get that all processed and immediately give you a refund. That’s when you jump for joy. There’s no, no work on your end, but in some cases they’re like, okay, now you can go and, you know, get your refund from the state or, you know, or we need all this documentation and proof.

So it can go either way.

[16:05] Mike Payne: Is it, is it two to three year window, generally pretty acceptable on a look back and a refile?

[16:10] Lori Demeyer: I would say two.

[16:12] Mike Payne: Yeah.

[16:12] Lori Demeyer: I would say two or, or to look. Yeah. So for sure, verify things are in order.

[16:18] Mike Payne: What, you know, so I mean, obviously like the sales tax exemption thing could apply across all your utilities. You know, I, I know I’ve heard people talk about, you know, an audit, you know, found like overpayments and, you know, maybe, maybe this is to your point, if you have multiple meters and I mean, is it, is it realistic? Like, again, we’ll stay on electrical that, um, well I use my house, for example, I have, I have two water meters at my house and I’ve got one for the house and I’ve got one for my irrigation system, my irrigation system.

I pay for the water that I’m using, but it doesn’t charge me sewer. Right. I mean, is, is that the type of situation that I could be in like with my electric, with my other stuff too, that maybe for my shop floor, I’m paying X number of cents per kilowatt and my office, I’m paying another or something like that.

I mean, they’re.

[17:17] Lori Demeyer: Mm-hmm. And that goes back to, you might see different rates because again, it’s all dependent on your meter usage and the rates that you can be eligible for. So again, if it’s standard office, standard lights for the lunch room, it’s going to be your standard electric rates.

It’s when you get into them being tied to something dealing with the manufacturing process that there’s different levels, right? So again, depends on the percentage used of the meter. If it’s a hundred percent of that meter is going towards a functionality, you know, or 80% will determine what plans or discounts that you can have for that.

But there’s several different rates. And I think that applies, that can apply to maybe all of the utilities from a rate perspective. Every state is different.

Every utility provider is different. So that’s key, you know, especially if you’re in multiple states, you want to make sure you’re reviewing each and every state and provider for their own specific offers, I guess I would say.

[18:18] Mike Payne: So how, in your experience then, because this, it seems like lots of times when I’ve heard people talk to me about, oh, we can do this cost review thing with you. You know, one of the outcomes maybe sometimes is we’ll go negotiate better rates for you also. Is that something that I, like I and a lot of people should be looking at?

Like I’ve never asked. I just pay what they pay.

[18:43] Lori Demeyer: Right. So I don’t know, you can’t really negotiate the rates. You know, you can’t say, hey, you know, I don’t want to pay $20.

Give me 15, you know, type of thing. But there’s different, just classifications of, correct. Yeah.

So they’re not going to say, you know, most of our customers get 20 cents and, you know, we’re going to give you 18. But that said, when you look at it outside of a rate perspective, providers do often, you know, have maybe what we would call incentives or business riders that can be offered as well. Right.

So, you know, some of those might be if you’re a new business, you know, they’ll offer a business rider on your utility that you might get a discount if you’re, you know, going to be offering X amount of jobs. They might have, you know, different programs where if you commit to using your higher usage at off peak times, you’ll get even more discounted rates or you get X amount, you know, on a quarterly basis, things like that.

[19:52] Leticia Lawson: Or they can call, they can call a rate, for instance, or an event. If you’re on a, if you’re enrolled in a certain type of program that you’re getting a certain level of, you know, reduction in your, your rate, but they can also call that incident. Right.

Like when they have peak demand, like, you know, could be during a snowstorm and they’re just seeing their utilities or, right. Or something that, that, so then what they’ll do is they’ll call and they, they are very specific within those requirements. I can do, you know, so many events per year.

So they’ll kind of tell you that in advance. So you can kind of calculate, okay, based on, you know, this many, you know, incidents a year, you could have saved if you were in this program, you know, X dollars, or you’re better off not being on that program because of the type of, you know, services or manufacturing that you’re doing, you don’t want to be able to, you know, reduce or don’t want, or can’t reduce, you know, your usage, that sort of thing.

So.

[20:51] Mike Payne: So the, the question that popped up when you guys were answering that, you talked about, I think you both mentioned, you know, some off peak usage, right? So, I, you know, there’s lots of manufacturing facilities around the country that operate 24 hours a day, same equipment on the same meter, right. 24 hours a day.

But is there, is there, have you ever seen, is there opportunity to say, hey, half of our usage is off peak and half isn’t? So like we get charged two different rates based on the time, or there’s a blended rate that’s a little bit cheaper or anything like that. I mean, is that an, is that a type of savings that’s available?

[21:29] Lori Demeyer: Well, yeah. And that’s where it’s the time of use. So that, yeah.

So depending, you know, and.

[21:35] Mike Payne: So they will, they’ll dig down that deep if you.

[21:37] Lori Demeyer: Correct. Correct. Because there are off peak rates, there are on peak rates, and things like that.

So when you’re looking at all those numbers on that invoice, you will see all of that, you know, outlined, or you might, you know, depending on the type of invoice, you might have to go into a utility portal to see that.

[21:55] Mike Payne: Yeah. Wow. Okay.

So are they already doing some of that anyway? So like if I’m using off peak, are they already discounting it or do I, is that something I would have to initiate?

[22:04] Lori Demeyer: Typically you would see some differing rates, but then where you would, you know, obviously get better rates is if you are sort of changing, if you can change some of that consumption, you know, so then that’s something where, you know, some companies would, you know, review and analyze the data and say, if you can take a hundred hours during this time, you know, and maybe that’s something that can be done and move it to here, you know, that would be able to save some additional.

[22:41] Speaker 4: In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental, it’s engineered. But a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent followup, and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle.

Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities. That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers.

Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations, and sets qualified meetings. So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do.

Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R M-F-G dot com slash chips.

[23:45] Mike Payne: Sounds like there’s lots of potential opportunities to look at this. So let’s help a listener understand like if this is worth their time to dig into. So what’s kind of that best fit profile?

Whether that’s size of company, type of operation, whatever. What do you see in the manufacturing space that should make someone go, oh, okay, that’s me?

[24:15] Lori Demeyer: Yeah. So I would recommend anybody do it just because you always want to verify that you are being invoiced accurately.

[24:24] Speaker 6: Okay.

[24:25] Lori Demeyer: Truly from a savings perspective, what we have seen when we look for maybe the most impactful savings because there are clients who they’re like, oh, you know, that’s fine. We don’t need to save 10 grand, but 10 grand might be a lot to somebody else.

[24:42] Mike Payne: Sure.

[24:43] Lori Demeyer: Is about at the million dollar annual spend is where you would typically see most opportunity for maybe errors or mismatches, whatever that might be. And then you would get impactful cost savings from that. Obviously less, you can have 500,000 annual spend, 100,000.

[25:06] Mike Payne: It’s just going to be a smaller benefit.

[25:07] Lori Demeyer: Right. Yeah. Correct.

It would be a smaller benefit, but at the end of the day, these assessments typically upfront should always be complimentary. And most are if you don’t find any savings, the client has no out-of-pocket expense. And if there is savings and implemented for a client, you’re sharing a portion of that.

So at the end of the day, in my opinion, these types of assessments, and it should be any type of assessment you do, it’s really risk-free for a client because you’re either not paying anything because you were just giving valuable feedback that everything looks good, which I think is still, again, very valuable, or you’re paying out a portion of what you were originally paying, but at the end of the day, you’re saving.

And then that’s just the fee that the companies would take from that perspective.

[26:03] Mike Payne: So whether it was you guys or anybody else that maybe one of the listeners is talking to, in a contingency type pricing model, your advice would be, take a look.

[26:17] Lori Demeyer: It doesn’t hurt. And it should not. That would be my first word of advice.

If you’re looking to do this, make sure that their initial review, there is not a cost for you to do that because there should not be.

[26:32] Mike Payne: So you talked about some spend characteristics, but are there any consistencies, again, in the manufacturing space that you’ve seen that also would make someone go, oh, well, that looks like me?

[26:46] Lori Demeyer: If you’re in California, I would highly recommend it. Okay. One of the most complex regulations in the country, they’re in California.

So I would say location is something that you want to be aware of. Again, great states, California, if you have locations in the Northeast, those tend to also have some complexity, some higher rates. Georgia, Florida are great states.

I would say we’ve seen in Texas, it’s a little bit harder to maybe get things implemented. That’s one of the states that we see require, for the most part, what we call a utility use study. And again, most providers may require that as well, but typically Texas is the one that does that.

So a utility use study is really when another company might come out and just document your meter usage, how it’s all being utilized. And there’s calculations and formulas and all that fun stuff, and it’s very detailed. Sometimes your operations manager will do that, and that might be part of the process to get your exemption status as well.

But Texas, you typically have to have it done by a third party from what our experience is. So there is a cost associated with that. And sometimes when clients are seeing…

[28:21] Leticia Lawson: So sometimes we’ve seen clients where there was a fair amount of savings, but the cost of doing the actual third party use study was so high that it really kind of negated some of the savings that they would have had.

[28:35] Lori Demeyer: And long-term, I think it’ll work out where the savings are there, but some business owners are looking at, oh, in the first two, three years, I’m breaking even. We’re not going to do that right now type of thing.

[28:47] Mike Payne: And I can understand that. I mean, I can tell you, like I kind of started the show, I’ve been asked about this probably most of my career, once or twice a year or something like that. And I mean, again, I’m just speaking honestly.

Usually my response is, that actually sounds really interesting, but it’s not on my priority list right now.

[29:13] Leticia Lawson: Well, it’s out-of-pocket expense as well, which is different.

[29:17] Mike Payne: Yeah. And if it’s a three-year payback, it’s probably just something I’m not going to personally spend time on right now. Because there’s other things I can do that I’m going to get a quick payback.

But in a contingency environment, maybe I’m in a market that doesn’t have all these other requirements.

[29:35] Lori Demeyer: Right. And that’s what it is. Again, it’s risk-free, in my opinion, to start the process.

I would say though with utilities, if you are getting refunds on exemptions, that can take a few months. You’re not going to have that quick turnaround. There’s a lot of documentation that needs to be sent, whether it’s to the provider or to the state.

Sometimes they can take six months to review or deny for whatever reason. You might get somebody who’s super picky and wants a copy of every single invoice, and you might not be able to do that. So there could be some of those instances where that savings can take up to nine months for you to actually see.

If you are updating any meter rates, that typically gets in a little bit quicker within a few billing cycles. We tend to see that start from that perspective. But it can be something where it does take time.

What I would say is if you have utility portals and access to that where you can pull historical data, that makes life a lot easier for whoever is doing the assessment. Otherwise, there might be a need for the business owner to dig back into files. Hopefully, they’re electronic, that they’re saved somewhere that they can get those in a leap file and send them to you.

And you might do an assessment where you say, okay, at first, just give me a couple invoices. You get a normal bill, a high bill, a low bill that you’ve had in the past 12 months, and then you see something and you’re like, is that a trend? Is that just a one-month thing?

How do we know? So you sometimes do need to have more detail in a longer time frame to review to really truly understand is this something that you would benefit from, especially if it’s a rate perspective. Does it make sense to change it or is this just a one-time thing?

[31:38] Mike Payne: Okay, I’m convinced. Let’s say I’ve heard enough that I need to look at this. Let’s start to explain what that process looks like.

I’ve called you guys up. I’ve said, let’s do it. What’s next?

[31:52] Leticia Lawson: Well, generally like what Lori just referred to, we receive invoices of the various utilities. Again, we’ve talked about the electric, gas, water, everything that you would potentially have. It’s really nice to have this in a digital format versus a scanned format, but we take both.

That’s why having access to the portal is important. That’s really just the first step is getting those over to us. Generally, we start looking at those.

Now, the assessment takes a little bit of time. It takes a little bit longer than a typical telecom type of assessment. So we’re usually going to be looking at that anywhere from 30 to 45 days.

Generally, what we’ll see is we’ll come back at that point and we might ask, as Lori mentioned, or within that time frame, hey, we see something, but we need more data. We need usage reports that are that downloadable Excel format, or we want a history of an entire year’s worth of data. It may only be on specific meters because we see something that’s spiking.

So we’ll see those things. So when we get those, we take a look at them. We’ll ask for the additional feedback, and that’s when we’ll start looking at, okay, these are the things that we see.

Sometimes we’re going to come back within that 30, 45 days timeline, and we’ll start with great news. Everything’s great. We like to think of that as like going to the doctor.

You don’t want to go to the doctor and say, hey, you’ve got problems. You need to fix this medication, all that stuff. You want to be, you’ve got to help.

[33:38] Mike Payne: Which, by the way, has not happened to me in a long time.

[33:42] Leticia Lawson: We call that the health check, where we’re like, everything’s great. This is the good news. Your exemptions are, if you were eligible, your tariff rates are convenient.

Or we might even have some sort of observation that we will provide to you, as you may be eligible for the special enrollment, but this is the caveat to it. They might be able to call an incidence. It sounds like you might need to have the ability to say, no, that doesn’t make sense for my business.

So we provide some feedback on that as well. Especially if there’s not enough savings there to kind of move forward with anything, but we want you to be aware of some things. So it’s getting a little bit of a free advice, if you will.

And then the third thing is generally, which was what we’re more hoping for, is saying, yeah, there’s some things that we really feel like that we can potentially do for you. And this is what it looks like from a monetary perspective. And oftentimes that monetary perspective could be a range, because we still yet to do need to do more digging.

And it’s dependent again on the vendor. Some vendors are going to be easier to work with, or they’re going to do more things. Or again, like some things might be state oriented if it comes with tax exemptions, because some vendors will give you some of the exemption money back if that was the case.

And then some will need you to go back to the actual state. And then that process is a little bit different. So there’s a variety of different things that we will take a look at.

So oftentimes we’ll give you the range of these are the savings that we might see on a monthly perspective. And then sometimes there’ll be the savings that are like a one time. So we’ve made a correction, let’s say on a on the exemption status, that is normally going to be a one time thing that you’re going to see back.

So you might get this money back. And it’s that’s the last time you’re going to see it because they’re going to refund that monies and that sort of thing, versus having more of a monthly kind of a reduction between what you were paying and what the savings would look like as as we implement as well.

[35:55] Lori Demeyer: I think it would be the same though, you know, for anybody, it just really you just start off and you provide the invoices. Yeah, because you have to, you know, have those reviews. So, you know, whatever you have, you know, I would say send over that snapshot.

And then, you know, the company will go ahead and review that and then come back with the findings. So to me, it’s that simple.

[36:18] Mike Payne: We’ve done that. We’ve gotten there. But you come back and you say, we’ve identified savings.

Now, what does that workload look like for like, I mean, what do you handle versus what the company handle in talking with the utilities?

[36:32] Lori Demeyer: Right. So I can speak to, you know, how CLA works. I would have to assume a majority of the other companies are the same.

You know, what we would do is process, you know, prepare the documentation that’s needed, you know, for the client, do continued research. We would identify what is required, get that filled out. You know, typically we would have some sort of letter of authorization that would allow us to speak to the provider on the client’s behalf as well, you know, for informational purposes, just to make sure we’re gathering all of the documentation that’s needed.

So hopefully all the client needs to do is just sign some documents and we submit everything, be it to the provider or to the state. And then, you know, in some cases, like I said, if there’s no portal access, that would be really the only heavy lifting that the client may have is if we are doing a refund and going back three years, we need three years worth of invoices, you know, to complete some documentation. So you always try to make it as, you know, painless as possible for the client and take on as much as you physically can of the process.

[37:49] Mike Payne: So there’ll be, I mean, at the very least, there’s going to be authorization, like the company’s got to make some authorizations for you guys to negotiate and then potentially hopping on a phone call or signing something or doing whatever.

[38:03] Lori Demeyer: Right. Yeah. Yeah.

They would have to, if, you know, if we need updated certificates, exemption certificates, they would have to provide that. In the cases that a utility use study is required, you know, we can help, you know, get that taken care of. But there’s also clients who just have that, you know, they just do it for whatever reason, whether it’s part of an audit process, an exemption process, they just do it for good measure to have that on their books.

They, you know, and if it’s a recent one within a year or two, the utility provider might accept that. So, you know, we would request that documentation as well.

[38:40] Mike Payne: Right. So let’s put it in perspective for, you know, as we kind of put a bow on that piece. I mean, it sounds like the process is relatively painless or should be very, very low to no risk.

And if you’re working with the right people, like the way you guys do it, right. Let’s, let’s talk a little bit about like, I mean, what, what are typical outcomes that you guys see? I mean, and we can base that on like percentages, right?

So obviously everybody spends going to be different, but I mean, is there opportunity for 1% savings, a hundred, you know, 70% savings? I mean, what, what, those are two extremes, obviously.

[39:25] Lori Demeyer: I never thought of that about like percentages. I mean, I have dollar amounts.

[39:28] Mike Payne: Well, dollar amounts is fine.

[39:30] Lori Demeyer: So for example, we, we had a manufacturing client that was nationwide and we focused on a few States, California being one of them. We had Florida, Georgia, I want to say Colorado, and one or two other States, maybe Missouri. And between, you know, the, the three years that we were engaged with the client, it was about $960,000 between refunds and just, you know, rate change savings.

So the great thing about that is, is when you do implement rate changes you know, those tend to stay in place for, you know, seven, maybe even up to 10 years before you might have to provide updated documentation to the utility provider. And then obviously exemptions stay in place as your certificate continues to get renewed. And then again, if you’re using the meters in the same capacity, there’s no problem there, right?

Your percentage of exemption would remain the same. So, you know, for years you would continue to get that savings, right? And again, you always want to look every two years just to make sure there aren’t any new tariffs or, you know, regulations or new incentives that that provider has that would, you can be a benefit to.

We’ve done another one we’re in the process of right now. It’s about a hundred and change, a hundred thousand and change a year. We’re waiting on a refund process.

We don’t know if it’s going to be approved.

[40:54] Mike Payne: Did you say a hundred per year?

[40:56] Lori Demeyer: Per year.

[40:57] Mike Payne: Yeah.

[40:57] Lori Demeyer: Yeah. So that, yeah, that one’s going to be per year. The other one was about 960 for the three years.

We’ve also, you know, outside of manufacturing, you know, if you have colleagues in other industries, agribusiness is great. Food processing is great. We did agribusiness in California where it was just meter re-rates because they were not on the correct ag rates for, you know, the particular meters and how they were being used.

And we saved, I want to say about 400. No, that one was about 400, 420,000 over that three year time period as well. So again, things that the client continues to save, you know, years after we’re no longer engaged with them.

[41:42] Mike Payne: Yeah. I mean, that’s, I mean, that’s all real money, right?

[41:46] Lori Demeyer: Correct. Yeah. And again, it goes back to, even if you’re saving 10 grand a year, that’s 10 grand a year that you can invest somewhere else within your business.

[41:55] Mike Payne: So yeah.

[41:57] Lori Demeyer: By that new piece of equipment.

[42:01] Mike Payne: Right. So, okay. So I, I mean, I can’t poke any holes in your story, which I wasn’t trying to, but I, the, so, so what, let’s, let’s, you know, as we kind of put a wrap on it, I guess the call to action there for somebody that a lot of this makes sense to, what, just call you guys?

[42:26] Lori Demeyer: They can call us. Absolutely. You know, we, we have contact information, but CLA’s website, you can get to, you know, outsourcing and services and we’re under telecom advisory, but there, you know, again, reach out to who, you know, ask colleagues, you know, who’ve you, you know, have you done this?

What, what was your experience? You know, I think it’s just, it really is just getting it done because it’s very easy and risk-free.

[42:57] Mike Payne: I mean, I guess here’s another question you’re thinking about. So first of all, this isn’t something that every CPA, like my existing CPA probably doesn’t offer this, but they might know somebody.

[43:07] Lori Demeyer: Correct. Yes.

[43:09] Mike Payne: But in your guys’ case, I mean, you know, specifically talk about CLA. I mean, you guys are a national operation. You’re able to do, I mean, so you’re national, except you’re not in Oklahoma, because I wish you were, but the, but I mean, you can help me here, right?

[43:26] Lori Demeyer: Correct. Yes. We help clients nationwide.

It does not matter where you’re located or where your facilities are located in the domestic US. So again, a utility assessment, we focus domestically.

[43:36] Mike Payne: Right. Yeah. So, so anybody could reach out to you guys if they don’t have a local contact or anything like that.

[43:43] Lori Demeyer: Correct.

[43:44] Mike Payne: Or don’t find one. So what’s the best way, best place to reach or best way to reach out to you guys individually?

[43:50] Lori Demeyer: I say email or phone. We can go old school and, and, and pick up the phone or send an email.

[43:57] Mike Payne: Well, and listeners, as, as I always tell you, if, if you, if you do try to reach out and you don’t reach them, we’ll, we’ll make sure to get their contact info in, in the show notes, but reach out to me too. And I, I’m happy to forward an email or, or, or make a phone call introduction, whatever we can. Anything else that we need to cover on this?

I think it’s great.

[44:20] Lori Demeyer: No, I mean, I think we went through all the major points. You know, I would say again, you know, costs are increasing everywhere. And, you know, if you have an opportunity just to see if you can save a little bit of money, a lot of money, or just know this isn’t the area you should be focusing on for cost savings, go ahead and do it.

Because again, it, it should be complimentary on the front end. And, and, you know, just a little bit of documentation that’s needed from an invoicing perspective to review. And you know, you’ll be able to know if there’s opportunity or not.

[45:02] Mike Payne: Hey everybody. What do you think of when I say OTD? Well, in making chips, we’ve got lots of acronyms to deal with, but OTD is on-time delivery.

On-time delivery is part of Hill’s mission. Deliver quality parts on time, every time. When I was shopping for an ERP system, I was looking for something that would ensure that we do that on a regular basis.

Delivering jobs on time was something we struggled with, and I know that most shops struggle with. I think I saw recently that 70% of shops struggle with delivering parts on time. So the best decision I made in that, enter ProShop.

Did you know that many of ProShop’s customers quickly experience 95% or better on-time delivery rates with their customers? And now ProShop has a guide to help all shops, whether you’re using ProShop or not. Visit ProShopERP.com slash 95. Again, that’s ProShopERP slash 95 to get your copy today. You know, again, I’m a small business owner. I’m busy.

You know, I’m no different than everybody else, you know, working 12, 14, 16 hours a day, right? To make my dreams come true. And this is certainly not something that I’m checking every month.

It’s not something I’m checking every year. It’s just a necessity of life that I have to pay to be in business. So it’s awesome to hear, you know, here’s an independent resource.

Doesn’t cost me anything. Just look at it. Tell me if we have anything to worry about.

And then maybe it is a priority, right? I mean, you might identify that, hey, you do need to you do need to spend a few hours of your time over the next month helping us figure this out. Because we can, you know, we save you a hundred thousand dollars.

That’s worth my time.

[46:49] Leticia Lawson: Correct.

[46:50] Mike Payne: For sure.

[46:50] Leticia Lawson: Well, we’ve had clients mentioned to us that it’s a no brainer and that is their exact words.

[46:56] Mike Payne: It feels like it. Yeah. No, I mean, everything you’ve said, I mean, it absolutely feels like, why wouldn’t I do this?

Honestly. I mean, there’s no, I’m not, I’m not taking any of the risk. You guys are really right.

I mean, you’re.

[47:09] Lori Demeyer: Correct. Yeah. Cause it’s our time and we don’t find anything that, you know, that was our time.

But again, from our perspective, if we provide value to a client, you know, that’s worthwhile to us.

[47:20] Mike Payne: Yeah. That’s awesome. Thank you both so much.

[47:22] Lori Demeyer: This is good. Thank you.

[47:23] Mike Payne: I’m going to, I’m certainly going to hope the listeners have come off of this feeling like one, they learned that they need to check it out. And two, it’s worth their time to, to reach out to you guys, or if they do know somebody locally and start the process.

[47:38] Leticia Lawson: So perfect.

[47:39] Mike Payne: Yeah. Thank you so much.

[47:41] Leticia Lawson: All right. Well, thank you for having us on listeners.

[47:44] Mike Payne: Again, reach out to them, reach out to me. If you can’t get ahold of them as always, thank you for listening and we’ll catch you next time.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.


Connect with Lori and Leticia

Connect With Buy the Numbers

Subscribe to Buy the Numbers

on Apple + Spotify

Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.