By Jennifer Dubose
49. Think Like a Buyer: How to Maximize Your Shop’s Value Before You Sell
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Most shop owners never sell a business before the day they actually sell theirs. You build something for thirty years, then one phone call later you’re trying to figure out what it’s worth, what the buyer is really paying for, and why the number in your head doesn’t match the offer on the table. The fix is simple to say and hard to do: start thinking like a buyer long before you ever plan to sell.
In this episode I sat down with the deal team from CLA (Phil Hanke, Erin Mickels, and Brady Paschke), to walk through what actually moves the value of a manufacturing business. We’re in the middle of a massive wave of baby boomer owners heading for the exit, and a lot of them show up ready to be done today, with no runway and no plan. That’s rarely the best place to sell from.
We get into the math and the art behind it. Your shop trades on a multiple of adjusted EBITDA, but where you land in the range, anywhere from two times to six in precision machining, comes down to the stuff that doesn’t show up on a single line: how clean and consistent your books are, how concentrated your customers are, and how much the whole operation depends on you. If a buyer thinks they’re buying a job instead of a business, you get discounted.
Then there’s the part that wrecks more deals than price ever does: structure. Net proceeds, not the headline number, are what actually land in your account. We talk through purchase price allocation, working capital, earn-outs, and seller financing, and why you want those conversations on the table at the letter of intent stage, not six months into diligence.
And we don’t skip the human side. This is usually the largest and most emotional transaction of an owner’s life. We get into legacy, the arrival fallacy, and why knowing your why and your next chapter matters as much as the wire that hits your bank account. If you’re anywhere from one to fifteen years out from a transition, there’s something in here for you.
What’s Covered in this Episode
- (0:00) Meet the CLA crew: Phil Hanke, Erin, and Brady join Mike
- (3:34) Why now: a wave of boomer owners retiring with no succession plan
- (5:18) Readiness: a 3 to 5 year runway beats selling off a triggered event
- (6:40) What a buyer actually buys: your earnings, not your new machines
- (9:17) Cleaning up the financial house: add-backs, owner comp, related-party items
- (11:20) The owner-reliance question: can the business run without you?
- (13:40) Messy books get discounted; clean books are step one
- (14:52) “Am I buying a job or a business?” The buyer’s real worry
- (18:03) The range in precision machining: 2x to 6x, and what moves it
- (20:02) Why size matters and enterprise value basics
- (23:14) The three-year rule: What you can still move late in the game
- (25:51) How Factur helps suppliers build a consistent sales pipeline
- (27:00) Step two: personal financial planning, know what you need to net
- (30:45) A client story: net proceeds, not headline price, got the deal done
- (32:34) Where deals break: purchase price allocation and working capital
- (35:43) Earn-outs and seller financing: bridging a valuation gap
- (40:50) How to get started: reflect on internal vs. external options
- (43:21) Build your advisor team, starting with your most trusted pro
- (46:53) Let Navu answer the hard questions for you
- (48:07) The emotional side: selling your life’s work
- (53:36) Define your purpose before you sell
Resources Mentioned
- Build a consistent sales pipeline with targeted outreach and a free custom report from Factur
- Add AI chat to your website so buyers get accurate answers in real time with Navu
- Explore practical manufacturing insights from CLA on profitability, automation, growth, and more at CLAConnect.com/makingchips
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] One of the most valuable things you can do today to just start thinking, even if transition is not on your mind today, is just pause and think like a buyer and look at your business and try and look at it through a buyer’s lens and what would make a buyer more confident in the future of the business and what things would cause concern and maybe make a buyer a little bit nervous if they are digging under the hood and looking at your business. Welcome to Buy the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business, from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company. Let’s crunch some numbers. All right, I’m back with the CLA crew here and like some of my favorites, I haven’t talked to Aaron in a long time, I’m just meeting Brady, but Phil, you’re back. It’s been a few months since we’ve had you on the show. Glad to be back. Appreciate you bringing us back in. I know that we have an exciting topic for today, so happy to be here. Yeah, Phil, why don’t you just real briefly, why don’t you give listeners a little bit of reminder who you are and what you do at CLA? Sure. So, Phil Hanke, I’m a principal at CLA, I’ve been with CLA for about five years.
[1:31] Before that, I was in industry, so working with businesses, primarily manufacturers from a finance perspective. And now here at CLA, we help do outsourcing for small business. Many of your listeners kind of sit in that space, and so we service them with outsourced accounting. And you’ve talked with a lot of my listeners too, so. Yes, we have. And Erin, so Erin, it’s been about a year since I was up visiting you in Minneapolis, and you were my co-host for a couple of episodes where we had a similar conversation about kind of mergers acquisition, I guess more buy-sell more so than merger acquisition. But Erin, welcome back. It’s great to be back, Mike. It feels like it was just yesterday that we sat down and had a conversation and I was sharing with Brady, I said, Mike, Mike makes these sessions fun. Just the energy that you bring alongside of us. So glad to be back and maybe plan to go a little bit deeper in the world of, you know, planning considerations in the realm of transition, whether that’s internal, external, you know, we think of that in kind of two different angles and yeah, excited to, excited to be back. Yeah, well, I’m glad you’re back and, you know, I’ve had the, since a year ago, we’ve had an opportunity to work with, again, a few of the listeners on some of their own things and it’s, it’s been fun to work with you on, on that side of things too.
[2:54] And then we have a newbie, Brady. Welcome to the show. Thanks, Mike. I’m, I’m excited to be here. Similar to Erin, I, you know, at CLA, a principal on our deal services team and, and really focused on helping serve clients in the preparation, you know, deal preparation phase and financial preparation phase as they are looking for some type of transition plan and then helping, you know, work through that execution process. And so I think this conversation is incredibly relevant to a lot of, you know, manufacturing business owners that we speak with on a daily basis. And so I’m really excited to dive in and kind of engage with the audience that you have here. Well, yeah. So thanks for being here. And I think you’re right. I think it’s a very timely conversation. I don’t, I don’t have the stats in front of me, but I don’t think, I don’t think anybody can disagree that, you know, we’re at, we’re at a time and really the entire economy, but I know the manufacturing space just because of the ownership structure of most of manufacturing being so closely held, privately held businesses where we’ve got, you know, just, I mean, kind of unprecedented amounts of, you know, a baby boomer generation retiring and leaving the industry. And then, you know, in some cases you have the next generation coming in. In a lot of cases you don’t, right. Because baby boomers told all of our, all of us as Gen Xers and the millennials and so forth.
[4:15] Don’t come to do this, go to college, like become a doctor, an engineer, lawyer, whatever. So there’s this, you know, kind of massive gap, but I know every time I see numbers about, you know, the, the amount of businesses that we’re going to be losing, whether it’s monthly, annually, whatever for the next 10 years, it’s quite shocking. And I know just in my own like acquisition pursuits, you know, in most cases I show up, talk to some shop owner and, you know, they haven’t prepped, they haven’t done anything. They’re just ready to be done today. Like, you know, something happened in the last, or several things probably occurred in the last year or whatever, that’s just said, okay, I’m done, I’m out, let’s sell this thing. And not necessarily the best place to sell from. So we, you know, that, I think that’s what we want to talk about today is like, how can you plan that out a little bit more so that you’re really going to monetize your life’s work to the extent that you should. So Brady, kind of starting with you, what are you seeing in that regard? I mean, you’re working with these people every day, like from a preparedness standpoint, I mean, how many are coming to you fully ready with a 5, 7, 10 year plan or versus, hey, I’m ready to go right now. I’m ready to sell or somebody called me and I want to sell to them.
[5:36] Yeah. The more common answer to that is businesses have some type of event, as you mentioned, and, you know, that triggers a decision point that they’re ready to, you know, look at some type of exit plan and go fast, possibly. Where we can provide a lot more value and where there’s a lot more opportunity to work with the business owners is when they do have that plan and that runway of three to five years, let’s say, to help, you know, kind of look through a buyer’s lens and look at their business a little bit differently than they would have looked at or operated their business, you know, historically. And so, you know, really as a business owner, you know, I often say, you know, one of the most valuable things you can do today to just, you know, start thinking, even if transition is not on your mind today is, you know, just pause and think like a buyer and look at your business and try and look at it through a buyer’s lens and, you know, what would make a buyer more confident in kind of the future of the business and what, you know, things would cause concern and, you know, maybe make a buyer a little bit nervous if they are, you know, digging under the hood and looking at your business. And that’s such great advice from the, you know, right off the bat, you know, looking at it as a buyer, right? Because I mean, especially in, again, in this industry, you know, there’s an art and a science to evaluation, right? But, but the smaller the company is, it’s more art, you know, you can, I can tell you what a public company is worth in about three seconds, right? Like it’s, it’s, it’s, you can go look at their stock price, you know, and, and in our world, it’s worth what someone’s willing to pay for it, right? So you got to go look and, and look at it from their perspective and say, okay, well, what are they buying? And I think that’s a big misconception right out of the gate. What are they buying? You know, I, I think a lot of, a lot of times people think, oh, I’ve got great machines.
[7:24] I’ve got the, you know, I have these physical assets that are great. I just, I just replaced all my machines. Everything’s less than five years old. I can tell you as a buyer, I don’t really care, right? I mean, it’s an element of it, but I’m buying your earnings, right? So, so let’s, let’s start with that. So what, what is a buyer looking at? And, you know, if I’m gonna look at this through the eyes of the buyer, what’s, what’s good to great to maybe not viable? Yeah. And that’s an interesting question too, because, uh, two different buyers could look at the exact same business completely differently, depending on what their risk tolerances are and, and what their intentions are going forward. But generally speaking, I mean, you know, they want to have confidence in the future earnings of the business. The best way that they often, you know, can kind of dig under the hood there is to look at past performance and use that as somewhat of a predictor going forward. They’re going to look at the customer mix to understand, are there any customer concentrations there? You know, what is the strength of the management team and how involved is the owner on a daily basis within that business? Well, definitely, you know, directly correlate to the value that they, they assign. And usually businesses within certain industries are, are valued within a range or a multiple of, you know, adjusted EBITDA that’s commonly used. And, you know, there are certain non-quantifiable characteristics that we’re often having conversations with business owners to help them understand, you know, where they would fall within that valuation range based on market comparables in the private markets. That is, you know, when a business owner comes to us and says, hey, you know, a certain event, I’m thinking about a transition.
[9:04] The first question they ask is, what is my business worth? Helping educate them through the factors that will contribute to that is something that we’re diving in really deep and, you know, helping them look at it from a buyer’s lens there. I think it’s really important, Brady, you hit that really well. I think it’s really important and sometimes overlooked that as you think about value and enterprise value, that they’re considering and evaluating really the qualitative and quantitative considerations, right? Because both of those absolutely go hand in hand. You know, if I think about the number side of the house, you’re right. I mean, it’s, it’s the math behind the suggested EBITDA concept times some sort of EBITDA multiplier, right? So, I mean, it’s a low hanging fruit there says, okay, what can you do to just frame up the financial house a little bit differently to even arrive at the right adjusted EBITDA number that’s going to kind of pass a sniff test? Do we have, you know, non-business expenses running through the business that need to get cleaned up? Have we considered kind of owner compensation or other related party transactions that could be, you know, needle movers as you think about either this adjusted EBITDA or seller discretionary earnings kind of concept? How clean are your books, right? I mean, do you have monthly consistent, you know, record keeping, timely record keeping? You know, I think maybe an unpopular opinion a little bit of what we would say, and I think Brady and Phil would agree with me and probably you too, Mike, is consistency over true full blown gap based financial statements is oftentimes the golden ticket, right? I mean, especially for smaller, you know, businesses where, you know, the cost benefit of getting you to a fully gap compliant set of numbers is just not your reality, right? You don’t need, you know, an audit or review, you know, annual set of financials. But just the consistency in your record keeping is critically important, right? Like just changes in management estimates, whether that’s, you know, inventory valuation, inventory reserves, AR, same concept, right? Like, are you just capturing things in a consistent way is going to carry a lot of weight.
[11:20] And then maybe just the other comment I would share on, you know, the non-number side of the house, if you will, and Brady touched on this a little bit, but those oftentimes are that it’s the differentiator that might get you from the low end of that EBITDA multiple to the high end of that EBITDA multiple, right? How involved is the owner in the day-to-day operations of the business? Do they have a succession or a transition plan? Do they have a team that can run more of the day-to-day, right? Or is this business really more solely, you know, based on the success of that owner to be grinding in the business, you know, 60 plus hours a week? I don’t, right? I mean, you sometimes forget the reality of that, of, okay, but the more, you know, Joe as the owner can step out of the business, likely that more of that business is going to be worth. Yeah, a thousand percent. And you think about maybe just hitting on a couple other things, right? The growth trajectory of the business. Are they in growth mode or not? You know, there absolutely are some, you know, market plan considerations. Brady hit on the customer, you know, piece, you know, do we have any IP, you know, what’s our mix, right? From like a revenue stream standpoint. So, you know, throwing a lot of considerations, but I think, Mike, to your point, we think about valuation.
[12:37] It absolutely is more of an art than it is a science. Both of those factors in this equation are key. Well, and you, you touched several times on, you know, like good, clean financials, which, you know, now we’re going to, we’re going to go right back into Phil’s lap, right? That’s where someone like a Phil is going to support you to have that. And I can tell you as a buyer, you know, having bought six shops in the last eight years and not bought a lot more, right, sometimes the, you know, the cleanliness of the financials and the, and the, I don’t know if trustworthiness is the right number or the right word, but, you know, I mean, just the confidence in them, right? I mean, I’ve gotten them handwritten. I’ve, I’ve gotten like printouts from accounting packages with like notes in the margins, like, well, this doesn’t include this cash transaction I did, you know, things like that all the way to audited financials, right? And I think to your point, Erin, I, I don’t necessarily need the fully audited financials either, but I do need something in the middle that I have confidence in that says, okay, this is, this is the company. So Phil, you have any input on that there? Yeah, just, just a few thoughts. And this kind of, it ties into both Brady and Erin’s point on one about the cleanliness of the books and some of it is as we get into like the art of it, like Brady and Erin talk about, okay, are you on the low end of a multiple or the high end, you know, clean books, it, when you think about buying a business, Brady commented about, you know, an owner initially taking a look of, take it from the lens of a buyer and you think of like your financials and what they look like, you know, if a buyer is confident in what they’re buying, they’re likely going to pay at a higher end, right? You’re not going to pay, you know, if, if the books are a mess or appear to be inconsistent, how do you trust them? You’re likely going to discount it. So, you know, from my perspective, you know, the clients that, that I service and we see is that is like, that’s, you know, I’ll call it one-on-one, right? That’s step number one in the journey of making sure that you’re at a point where it makes sense to get to a sale, which kind of leads into obviously the primary topic here, which is, you know, Brady and Erin regarding readiness for a sale. Yeah.
[14:52] Yeah. Yeah. And, and maybe going on to that, you know, this is very timely. Yesterday I had a conversation with a potential buyer of a project that I’m working on and the, he, it was a very candid conversation in that he was very confident in the numbers that he was looking at, but at the end of the day, you know, he, he mentioned to me, I’m concerned here that I’m buying a job and not a business. So it was some of those non-quantitative factors that he was really starting to dive into in the diligence process to understand, you know, the owner reliance or the business’s reliance on the owner to operate going forward. And, you know, what the relationships that they have with certain vendors and customer relationships and, you know, the transferability of that. And so I think the confidence in the numbers was kind of the, you know, the first hurdle to go through. But then, you know, as he’s diving deeper into thinking about, you know, what multiple or valuation to assign to this business and what, you know, this buyer is willing to pay, he’s really starting to, you know, peel the layers of the onion back and dive into some of those, um, non-quantitative factors that don’t necessarily show up immediately in the financials. And I think that’s where this runway is critical, right? Brady, that you mentioned just having some time.
[16:08] And I, again, I think in a perfect world, sure. You, you’ve, you’ve maybe done some planning or maybe thought through some of these elements in a three to five year window, but I think the reality is if you came at this with, you know, a proactive plan of attack, even 12 years out of actually wanting to execute on a transaction, I think you would be buying yourself some time to support many things. But I think that point, Brady, that you just mentioned on decentralizing this business owner and having time to do that is, is a critical, you know, it forces the hand a little bit to say, okay, do we have people in the organization that, you know, is it one, is it five? I don’t know. Right. But do we have people within the company who can, you know, upskill and take bits and pieces of, you know, an additional role responsibility, or is it an, you know, is it an outside person, right? I think just from a buyer perspective, appreciating that if that owner is, is wearing every hat in that organization, and there’s really the lifeline of that business, and now they’re wanting to, you know, they’re wanting to potentially step away in, in the near future, right? Just the level of risk that that creates for, I’m going to say most buyers. I mean, we could get into some conversation around the types of buyers that could be at the table too, as we think about private equity, financial, or strategic, and you know, maybe a different flavor that that would create.
[17:41] But the reality is, is that the more, you know, in the world of transition planning, the more this business owner could step away and let the team or otherwise kind of start to take the reins is going to be fruitful. So let me put a few things in perspective there for the audience. So, so I’ve, as I just said, I’ve bought six shops in eight years. One of them, the first shop, Hill, she had been preparing to sell, I don’t know about preparing, but she definitely was ready for about a three-year window. Okay. So there was, there were steps that she would take, she was taking. I wouldn’t say she was taking all the steps she should have, but it was definitely heading in the right direction. The other five, it was literally like a phone call. I’m done. I’m out. I’m ready to go. Now let’s talk about, let’s talk about that valuation range. You know, in the, you know, manufacturing can, can vary quite a bit, but, you know, specifically in precision machining, you know, outside of some of the things that you just mentioned, Erin, with it, you know, maybe being PE or strategics or, you know, something like that, you know, a supply chain rollup, if you just look at the typical type transaction, I mean, you can see as low as two, two times earnings up to maybe six. And the difference is in all the things that we’re talking about, right? So it’s, it’s all the, it’s, it’s that owner reliance. It’s the management team.
[19:21] It’s, you have systems and processes in place that are going to continue. It’s the, you know, customer concentration, industry concentration. It’s all those types of things. And I can tell you in, you know, in my experience, you know, if you’re not prepared, you’re going to probably be lucky to get a three, somewhere around a three X multiple, if, if you’re slightly prepared, maybe a four and to get much above a four, like all that stuff needs to be pretty well dialed in. Is that similar to what you guys see? I think that’s exactly right. I would say probably right in that sweet spot, Mike, is probably what we see, you know, the most of. I think maybe just one comment I would share is that size of the business definitely is going to drive that range, right? And I think sometimes that’s maybe confusing to folks as to why that might be the case, but I think at the end of the day, you know, with size comes the ability to scale, I think differently, you know, if you’re, and it’s hard to put numbers at it, right? But I would say generally speaking, what we see in our, our little bubble here is in manufacturing specifically, there there’s something to be said about this two and a half to $3 million EBITDA number and that kind of changes the playing field from like a multiple perspective in part because it it’s, it’s opening the horizons of your buyer universe, right? So I think naturally you’re, you’re going to have in theory, right. Just more interested parties when you get to like that size and scale. I think Mike, a lot of the folks who are perhaps listening today fall below that threshold and what I would say is, you know, it’s still very appropriate for, for a half a million dollar EBITDA business to be measured on this concept.
[21:10] Right. EBITDA times a multiple and, you know, when we think about just enterprise value, like what does that mean? Okay. Well, EBITDA times a multiple is really, I’m going to say base price. Generally speaking, it comes along with this cash-free debt-free concept, right? I mean, seller’s going to keep their cash also keep their, you know, use that cash in theory to pay down any remaining debts, but it also comes with a working capital element and we can get into that, you know, the expectation of delivering a normalized level of working capital to the buyer and that’s another area of art. Right. So just making sure that the components of how that price is going to be, you know, calculated and kind of built, built from there. Yeah. The yeah. So again, if we, you know, if we kind of put it in the real world examples I’ve lived, for example, so I’ve had a buyer show up in my office or a seller show up in my office and say, I’m done, I’m out. I want you to buy my shop all the way, you know, and then the opposite end of that is, is someone that was ready for a few years. Now the, the total opposite of that is like myself, right? So I’m 53, I figure I have 10, maybe 15 years, somewhere in that window left. And then I want to like be on a private jet going to fly fish.
[22:32] Good for you. And golf all the time. That sounds amazing. The so I have a lot of work to do to get there, but so like if I break that down for myself, right, I’ve got five to say seven years of continuing to operate and grow and scale and all those types of things I’ve got to, you know, and then I’ve got another three to five years of now preparing the business to sell. That’s going to involve a lot of the things that we, that we’re talking about. And then I’m going to be in this last couple of year window where I need to be prepared if I want to maximize my valuation. So I like, I have time to think about that, plan for that and take a lot of steps. If I’m inside of a, well, let’s, let’s also establish the fact that no one’s ever bought a business that didn’t ask for three years of financials, right? So, so if you’re inside of three years, there’s not a lot you can change about your past performance. Right. Like I have, I have 10 years to, to get to that three-year window for me. Right. So I have lots of times to, to, to maximize revenue, maximize EBITDA. Um, if I’m inside of three years of wanting to sell, uh, my financials kind of are what they are. Now I can get them cleaned up. I can, I can get with Phil and I can get good, solid financials and, um, have confidence in those.
[23:54] But the biggest thing I can affect in that last few years is going to be my multiple. Right. I mean, I can take steps that solidify, that take me from a two to a four to a five. Right. I can have the right systems processes and people in place that give a buyer confidence that they can pick up where I’ve, I’m leaving it and do just as well, if not better. Right. So I think the, I can’t emphasize honestly, the runway, like you talk about your runway. And as you talk through that, is your approach right in the 10 years you’re talking to specifically for yourself. Is that 10 year runway or even eight, nine is going to look a lot different tactically from a business perspective to where you’re going to be looking and targeting at the back half as you’re looking to exit. So like strategy changes immensely. Brady might have something to share on that as well, but I just, that’s something that I think we can’t emphasize enough of the importance of the planning side. And I think a lot of this planning is going to impact, you know, we’ve been focused on this conversation on an external sale and transition, but a lot of these, you know, things that business owners can do to plan and prepare for some type of transition in the future is going to be relevant for internal transitions or generational transfers as well.
[25:14] And ultimately the, the same thing a buyer looks at and would assign a premium to is really as a business owner, creating optionality for you when you do look for that transition. And so, you know, there may be listeners today that, you know, that are similar to you, Mike, where they’re, you know, 10 or 15 years out from any type of potential transition, but thinking about some of these things creates that flexibility and optionality. So when that time comes, they can make that decision on their own terms versus, you know, being forced into a situation due to some type of, you know, uncontrollable event or, or something that happens in their lives. Yeah. Great point. In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental, it’s engineered. But a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent follow-up, and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle. Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities. That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers. Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations, and sets qualified meetings.
[26:33] So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do. Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R mfg.com slash chips. Can’t help but take a step back and try to put myself in the seat of just some of the listeners, Mike and team, and just say, okay, we, we, we spend a lot of time talking about planning and, you know, getting ahead of it and giving yourself some runway and give yourself some time. I think a really important, you know, even if I, even if I said kind of a two step plan, right, keep it simple because I think this journey can become complex very fast, just depending on, you know, the dynamics, right? Everybody’s journey is unique, but if we boil it down and say, okay, yes, you know, the financial piece of this puzzle is important, quote unquote, clean up your books, right, work with an accountant to make that happen, it’s the first piece of information oftentimes it’s going to be asked, right, to even see if there’s a discussion to be had or not. So from a readiness perspective, right? Like have that. Yeah, it’s, it’s the first step every time. Yeah.
[27:50] And I would say step number two, you know, maybe branching away from, from a business readiness consideration is really shifting to say, you know, from a personal and from a financial planning perspective, what do you need? Yeah. Because I think a lot of times business owners actually find themselves going into the execution side of this transaction and may not have clarity on what that is. It’s such an important element of, you know, peace of mind as you think about establishing that financial planning process and, you know, do you almost do that first to say, okay, here’s what I need to feel comfortable as I move into this next chapter of my life and then kind of work your way back and say, okay, well, you know, if, if what I need and what my business is worth, there’s a gap. Without question, you’re going to need some time to, to problem solve, right? And, and what lovers do we need to start pulling or thinking about to make that reality successful? Well, and it’s, you know, it’s an excellent point too, and that probably gets overlooked more often than it should, you know, much like you just talk about, John Hughes was with me out in California a month ago and we were just talking about growth in general, right? And, you know, so, so many of us, we, we, we’re going to grow our business. Well, what the hell does that mean? You know, that can mean a lot of things. And, you know, my take is you need to grow the value of your business, right? So you got to know what, again, you got to know what buyers are buying.
[29:24] Um, and, but sometimes we just do that by default, right? Like we just, Oh, I got to grow. I got to grow revenue. Well, do you need to grow revenue or do you need to grow EBITDA? And again, different, different stages of this can dictate that, but, but yeah, knowing what you need and like what your purpose for these things is, is big, right? Like, you know, for me again, I’ll put, I’ll, I’ll put it back on me as a future seller, you know, I could sell today and probably achieve my personal financial needs, right? Like I’ll, I’d be fine, you know? So my why now is in most cases really for my team, right? Like I want to create opportunities for them. I want to, I want to build the business that, that they want, that, that will drive their futures, right? So you still have to have a why. And so I could go on cruise control now and I’m okay, but I still have, I still have this other thing I want to achieve, right? Yeah. When you’re looking at what does that next phase look like? I mean, does this transaction handle it or do you need to build something that will? Right. Are you wanting to, you want to build a library in your name? You got to grow your value a whole lot. You want to, you know, have a, have a peaceful retirement and leave a little bit for your kids. You may already be there, right? Aaron and I worked with a client, uh, over the last couple of years that really, you know, hit this situation home.
[30:51] We started with kind of that personal financial planning to understand what he needed in terms of kind of his go forward lifestyle. He was in the process of a transition of the business and, uh, to kind of a management team and, uh, through that process it unearthed that that wasn’t necessarily what was best for the business or himself personally. And so, you know, it made the difficult decision to pivot and, you know, look towards the external sale route. And as we were working through that process and he was negotiating terms with, you know, potential buyer. You know, we went through kind of that analysis to understand you’ve got this top line, you know, enterprise value. Um, but what does that directly relate into net proceeds after the sale, after you remove, you know, things like debt and taxes and, and those types of things. And what we found out was the structure that the buyer was presenting did not meet the needs that his personal financial plan needed. And so that allowed him to have some negotiating leverage to go back to the buyer and, you know, propose a different structure that met his needs to get a deal done and ultimately over the finish line. And so without having that kind of holistic view, you know, he never would have been in that position to make that educated decision so that he can now, I mean, similar to you, Mike, he’s out fishing and hunting every day going forward and really enjoying life.
[32:14] He needed to know what his personal financial plan looked like and how the business asset contributes contributed to that for this next chapter of his life. And you just said something that’s critically important that I think a lot of people lose sight of too is what was the net proceeds, right? I mean, that, that structure is all about the net proceeds. I cannot tell you how many sellers I’ve seen for whatever reason, they just have some price in their head. They don’t know why, you know, because somebody sold their company for 2 million, they need to sell there for two and a half or whatever, but they just pick a number and like, that’s their number. And there’s, you know, there can be ego tied up in that. There can be maybe some sort of financial need. And, you know, you know, like I’ve told a lot of sellers over the years, whether I was potentially buying from them or consulting with them. If your company’s worth 2 million and you need three, I can pay you that, but you’re just going to deliver me like a million and a half in working capital instead of a half a million in working capital, right? Like it’s that structure makes all the difference in the world. You know, I think a lot of people lose sight of that. The, and then, you know, like I always feel like there’s kind of two areas that deals break down. It’s in sales price allocation. And then even more specifically in working capital, right? Like that’s, that’s where the deals I see break.
[33:35] If you are deep in the throes of selling your business and there’s one thing you’re going to pay attention to, I would say, I would say it’s that sales price allocation because it affects your net, right? That’s, and that’s where you need this crew looking at this with you and your taxes and your personal finances and so forth to really guide you in the right direction because I’ve, I’ve unfortunately too seen many people get hurt there and not understanding it and net, net, you know, they just get killed in the deal. I think that’s right. It’s the unknowns, right? And what I would always say is those two things, Mike, the allocation schedule from a tax perspective and the working capital kind of mechanism. It is not too early to have those be key discussion items, even like at the LOI stage, right? Absolutely. Before you sign on the dotted line of that letter of intent, have some clarity of, you know, what does the proposed, what is the proposed structure? What does the proposed structure mean from a net proceed perspective? And then kind of layering in all of the other elements, it’s not just price. It’s, you know, like I said, the working capital framework, the indebtedness items or considerations, the purchase price allocation schedule.
[34:54] I mean, we’ve seen, um, we have seen letters, letters of intent that actually include those, that level of detail at that stage, because it, if it’s protecting the seller, right. I mean, they, they don’t want to jump in and then start incurring, you know, additional costs and certainly time and energy to like go through the ringer of the due diligence process without that level of clarity. So I think sometimes, you know, as a buyer, there might be frustration of like, oh, we can just figure that out later and what we would always advise is. No. Well, it’s where the deals break, right? So if it’s going to break, let’s break at the LOI stage, not six months in. That’s right. The, uh, and after everybody’s incurred a bunch of costs and so forth. Some of the other terms that we see that impact is, you know, how much of that purchase price, that top line purchase price is getting deferred in the form of an earn out or seller financed and what type of risk, you know, could you be taking as a seller that you no longer have control or decision-making power of the business, um, but it, it directly impacts what you may take home as well. And so understanding how that plays into kind of your personal financial plan. And, you know, looking at that from a risk-based approach, um, can be critical as well. Yeah. I mean, you have to put that in a little bit of perspective.
[36:16] I mean, I’ve, I’ve been involved in many, many deals that. I mean, you could have, you could have a million dollars less in purchase price that the seller nets more than if they paid a million dollars more. I mean, it’s, it’s all in structure and allocation. Mike, maybe I’m just going to jump in here. Something that Brady had brought up is, um, regarding structure and what we see a lot or in this is called, I’ll call it the backend after a transaction. Um, when it goes from small business to a new small business owner is there’s, you know, seller notes and as Brady talks about that, that risk profile is when you really think through what that means is that you are essentially taking on an individual’s willingness to pay you, um, which looks a lot different than a bank or, you know, from a, just a risk profile, it just naturally is going to look and feel differently. A hundred percent. Yeah. The, you know, but, but I, you know, I’ve, I’ve dealt with a lot of sellers, um, over the years that, I mean, yes, you’re taking on additional risk, but on the same hand, they want three to five years of income, right? Cause they’ve had income their whole life and it scares them to get one big check and then not have income, right? So it’s, again, it’s all comes down to really what fits your personal goals, right? If you, if you want to receive that check every month and, and you have confidence in that person, then that, that might be the right structure.
[37:56] If, if you don’t, it would be a terrible idea. And sometimes those mechanisms, you know, I think we’ve kind of framed it as, you know, they’re not necessarily seller-friendly, but in some cases, those, you know, structure that’s type of structure can be seller-friendly really articulates to the buyer that you have confidence in kind of the forward looking projections of the business and you’re willing to share in that risk and ultimately kind of use that as a bridge in terms, if there’s a valuation gap, you know, buyer thinks the business is worth X and, you know, you as the seller think it’s worth Y because you see the vision going forward. And some of these, you know, structured elements can help bridge that gap and buyer would say, Hey, I’m willing to pay you that if, you know, you can perform on that going forward. Yeah. So again, through the, through the eyes of a buyer, which I currently am, if there’s a valuation gap, that’s usually where I’ll put it back to seller financing. It’s like, look, I’m only paying this cause this is what I can do. If you want to take on some of this risk, I think we can work that out and, and, you know, offer that as a, as a format or as a structure. And it’s a, and it is, that is a good way to handle some, some gaps there. Or if there’s real gaps, I mean, you know, one of the shops I bought, we did there really wasn’t much earnings to value the company on.
[39:16] We made a, basically an asset offer with an earn out. If we were able to achieve certain things and we did, and we paid them that. And there’s a lot of structured things you can go there. And you know what, what this is making me all think, cause I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the listeners are sitting here thinking this, the importance of this podcast and the importance of what you guys do for a living every day is, I don’t know how many times I’ve ever sat with a buyer or a buyer or a seller. Really a first time buyer and almost every seller at some point in this process doesn’t go, God, I feel so stupid. Like I thought I was really good at business, but I don’t understand any of this. And you don’t, because if you’re really, really lucky in your life, you’re already in a small percentage of people that ever even have the opportunity to have this discussion. And if you’re really lucky, you’ll do it once in your life. If you’re really, really lucky, you might do it two or three times versus we’re sitting here talking in amongst us. We’ve done hundreds of these, right? So, so we’re rattling off things that I guarantee you listeners are going, I don’t know what they’re talking about. This doesn’t make any sense. Which again, comes back to the importance of like what we’re talking about, but also like getting with people such as yourselves that can guide you through this, because it can be, I’ve seen some bad deals go.
[40:37] And on the buyer and seller side, I mean, let’s, let’s not give all the credit to the sellers here. I mean, buyers can get hosed over pretty quick too, but it is really important to have a team. So that said, if let’s say I’m sitting here, I’m a couple of years out. I’ve been thinking about it. Let’s go through your guys’s advice. Like, okay, this is resonating. I’m ready. I know I need to be doing something. I’m anywhere from one to three to five years out from, from wanting to do something here. How do I get started? Call CLA. I’m just kidding. I mean, I would concur with that statement. I think question number one is reflecting maybe as a family or as a management team or as an owner on first, what options do I believe, what options do I believe I have if I’m planning and thinking through transition, you know, on the end, when we refer to the word internal transition, that really would be transferring of ownership to management family or, you know, some other maybe related party type transaction is, you know, do we have the right people that would even seek or have a desire for ownership? Do we have people on the team who have the skills and capability to, you know, wear an owner hat? And, and I think oftentimes what we find is the answer to that question is, is probably not. We don’t have kids who are interested in, you know, joining the business and learning the ropes and, you know, taking over, we might not have a management team or a individual who has the desire and honestly, I think a point to touch on too would be kind of the wherewithal or the ability from a financial perspective to really step in. Right.
[42:30] And so there’s some considerations there of like, well, could the business support? Right. I mean, that’s, that’s a, that’s a bigger question, but, you know, if internal isn’t, doesn’t create some options, then I think external, you know, thinking through that, I think it starts there. Right. And I would say jumping in outside of that, of just some more self-reflection on, you know, maybe the business, personal and financial readiness considerations, that’s really where an advisor is going to be incredibly impactful to support. And so I know we CLA and Brady, probably you and I more so have a lot of opinion on like, okay, who should that advisor team include? You know, do I need a business broker? Do I need somebody to support like a go-to-market strategy if we do go down the external path? Right. But then you kind of start building out who’s your team. And I would say, start with the most trusted business professional that you have, you know, whether that’s your attorney or Mike Payne or your banker, your whoever, start with them. And I think they’re going to have at least some initial thoughts of, you know, how to round out your team and just kind of build from there. But I mean, look, at the end of the day, it starts with giving that some initial thought and probably putting some action behind, you know, making that call and really start to engage in those conversations.
[43:51] That’s my perspective. Yeah. Phil, you have a perspective on that? Yeah. I just, you know, I agree a hundred percent with everything Erin said, you know, regarding your key players to be involved when you’re considering it. When I talk with business owners, most of the time it’s sole proprietors, right? There’s a few, maybe close employees who might be able to provide some perspective, but rarely, usually it’s a, it’s a one man shop, right? Or one woman shop that kind of makes all the calls. And I think in my, the conversations I’ve had with them, as they’ve considered down this path is there’s, there’s pride in that I built this. I did this. I know I’ve, I’ve grown this from where it was to where it is today. And I think getting over that mental barrier of it’s okay to acknowledge that this is not my space of expertise. I need to find my, you know, my, my core team to help me get through this next journey and path forward. That’s okay. You know, I think at the end of the day is it is okay as a business owner to acknowledge that. Yeah. And I think maybe to add on that Phil is it can be very lonely at the top as a, as a sole owned business owner. And this is something that is oftentimes, you know, highly confidential in that you don’t have a close group of people that you can talk to about this.
[45:16] And so really leaning on that trusted advisor to engage in that, you know, confidential conversation that really is, you know, potentially contributing to the largest liquidity event of your life. That’s where this team of trusted advisors really comes in and can help you through that process as they’ve seen and worked with business owners through processes like this, when, you know, you’re only going to do it one time, you know, if you’re lucky maybe more, but you know, typically only one time in your life. I’ll just echo what, what you guys all said. I mean, in my experience, you know, having that, you know, whether it’s your attorney, your CPA, your banker, your, your, your close, you know, maybe, maybe you have a, maybe you have a group of peer business owners that, that you spend time with. It’s, I mean, it’s an important discussion to start there. You know, and I can tell you, I mean, I’ll go on my personal little rant. I’m not a fan of brokers. Uh, most deals I’ve had go bad. There was a broker involved. Not to say there’s, I mean, I’ve seen good ones, good deals too, but I can tell you like as a buyer and an investor, like I, like my deal flow, my incoming deal flow when I hear about deals is typically coming more from lawyers, CPAs, and bankers. So, you know, my banker knows I’m in acquisition mode. He knows somebody else is looking to sell, says, Mike, you might want to talk to this person.
[46:39] You know, and I think lots of times the best deals never make it to a broker, right, because of, because of this trusted advisor status. So, you know, I think those are great resources to explore. Hey folks, listen up. You know, that manufacturing buyers don’t ask simple questions. They’re asking about product compatibility, materials, specs, lead times, application fit, and they want answers before they even talk to sales. That’s where Navoo comes in. Navoo adds AI chat to your website, trained on your own content. So visitors can get reliable, accurate answers in real time. It helps buyers find the right product, understand the right application, and take the next step without forcing your team to answer the same questions over and over. And setup is simple. Navoo works with your existing website. It connects with tools like HubSpot, Salesforce, and Slack, and gives you visibility into what visitors are actually asking. See what your website has to say at navoo.co slash makingchips. That’s N-A-V-U dot C-O slash makingchips. You guys all kind of touched on something though that, you know, maybe as we start to kind of wrap up here, let’s put some perspective on too, in addition to this being the largest liquidation event of your life and, and, you know, you’re monetizing your life’s work in many cases.
[48:22] It’s, it’s also going to possibly be one of the most emotional things you do in your life, right? I mean, it’s, you built this, you, you poured your life, your blood, your sweat, your tears. You, you missed time with your family. You skipped vacations. You, you gave your everything to this business. You know, you lost countless hours of sleep and everything else. Any advice on preparing for the emotional side of this? Mike, I’m going to put a little shameless plug on a future episode that you have with Heather regarding essentially transition where she will go into great detail regarding that emotional side of things. So I don’t have anything else. So if you cut this out, I’m fine with it. But I think Yeah, that, no, that, that it’s, it’s good to preview that because this is an important part of the process. It’s I, I know, I know many sellers that there’s the money and then there’s the legacy. I’ve been in the middle of many, many transactions on the buy side and the sell side that the highest bidder was not who got the deal. It was who could carry this on in a way that I’m going to be proud of it 20 years from now. I’ll just maybe share one story, but Phil, I think that is a really good segue into, you know, the next part of maybe this series and just taking a little bit of a deeper dive into kind of the, the personal readiness of this journey and really not only, you know, some kind of decentralization topics and ideas, but the impact on identity and, you know, how to navigate that. I would say time oftentimes, you know, heals some of that. Right.
[49:57] So I think just coupling against a lot of those comments we’ve shared with you all here today. I mean, just giving yourself some time and grace in that sense is critically important. I think, I think second, just wanted to share a story in that we supported a business owner and Mike, he was actually the individual who was on our panel last year. He just shared, he externally exited the business, sold to, in this case, a private equity group. He had some option as to how long he stuck around in the post-close environment. And he shared that the main reason why he stuck around longer than his initial thinking was to manage his way through the personal and emotional side of this journey. And it was just really impactful for him to hear, you know, for him to, to share that story and just the realization of that, right. I mean, it was high energy, fast paced, you know, not only in him and his partners kind of building the empire, but exiting the empire and working through really, you know, all the execution arms. And then when he got on the other side of it, I mean, what a, what a victory type feeling at first. And then as you know, that the days, weeks, months progressed, just having a lot more time, right. To just self reflect and say, what is the next step? What is my identity? You know, my identity was so tied up in this business that I, you know, he needed that time, you know, two, two plus years to really grab hold of and kind of create that next thing or thing, you know, that we’re going to help him give him a sense of a purpose. Yeah, there’s, you know, there’s two things there because I’ve talked to many sellers, you know, a year later, two years later, five years later, whatever, that that have kind of gone through that emotion.
[51:52] And probably the most common analogy I’ve, I’ve heard from them is, well, I can only play so much golf, right? Like I don’t, like I don’t know what to do now, but I can tell you, you know, from my own personal experience, you know, I was a founder in a company that, that exited that within, oh gosh, 12, definitely 24 months, I was ashamed of, and, and that’s not a good feeling either, right? So, so there’s a lot to be said for, I mean, you know, we, we talk a lot about buyer due diligence, but I think seller due diligence is just as important, you know, that, you know, and trusts, I mean, obviously if there’s seller financing and stuff like that involved, you, you’ve got to do a lot of that, but, but you have to really understand who you’re selling to and, and, and if you care or not, I mean, you may not care if you’re proud of the company a couple of years later or not, but if you are, I mean, if you think you will be, you know, there’s, again, it’s art, right? You may be willing to take a different offer from someone that, you know, can carry this forward and you’re proud of it than if you just want to get the maximum value you can get and you don’t care what happens to the company. Yeah. I want to double click on a few things you hit on there, Mike, in that, you know, there’s oftentimes, you know, two major considerations when you’re, you know, let’s say a seller interviewing a buyer and it’s, you know, value price and it’s legacy.
[53:15] And oftentimes we work with a lot of, you know, clients who run a brokered process and it is not the highest bidder that they end up selling to. It is kind of someone who they trust and, and can see that vision and, you know, will support their employees, the people who helped them get to where they are because they want to reward them going forward. And I think having that vision of, you know, what you want your legacy to be, but then also seeing into the future and what your purpose is in that next chapter is important because there’s this concept of the arrival fallacy where, you know, you get this giant wire into your bank account and you expect it, you know, you work 30, 40, you know, 20, 30, 40 years to get there. You expect this, you know, emotional high that you did it, you made it, but you see that you look at those numbers and all of a sudden you don’t feel any different. It’s kind of, you know, what’s next. You got to wake up, you’re going to eat breakfast, you know, you’re going to do the same thing that you do every day. And so what is your purpose, you know, moving forward and having that vision and clearly defined before you enter this process will make that a lot easier. And also that transition post-close into that next chapter, a lot more fulfilling and easier. Yeah, well, and, you know, I’m glad that we’ve, I’m glad, Phil, I’m glad you kind of previewed.
[54:37] We’re going to have an episode coming up kind of on this topic because I think it’s critically important as part of this process is to really understand that whole side of things. Because Brady, as you just pointed out, I mean, yeah, okay, I got this great big wire that came in, you know, I closed, I went out and, you know, took my family to dinner, celebrated, but what’s going to happen to my people? What’s going to happen to my customers? What’s going to happen, you know, to all these people I care about that I’ve built around? And then what’s going to happen to me? And chances are, if you did have a nice, successful close that resulted in a big wire to your bank account, you probably already had a bunch of money in your bank account. Yeah, you’ve got more now, but like there’s got to be, I think all of us as business owners, we need more than just that, right? Like there’s something else driving us all. So, yeah, digging into that in the next step of this process will be a ton of fun because I think it’s, I think it’s more important really than a lot of the other stuff. So, okay, so wrapping up here, I think I heard we need to plan, we need to plan as early as we can, right? I mean, obviously there can be life events that make it relevant tomorrow, but the more thought and planning that you’ve done can help maximize that value. You need to think about what are those next steps. So if I’m sitting in back here and I’m trying to figure this out and this hits some nerves with me, just real briefly, why don’t you, once you guys tell people the best way to get ahold of you, we’ll put, we’ll put some of that in the show notes too, but Erin, maybe start with you. Like how can people reach out to you if they have questions or anything? Yeah. I mean, I am an open book.
[56:11] I mean, email, give myself a call. I am, I’m more than willing to take a, take a phone call and maybe direct right in a, in the most simplistic way, you know, what are, what is the next step or what are the next couple of steps that, that folks should be thinking about just depending on, you know, their, their facts and circumstances that may be on the table. What I always like to say in, in, you know, the nature of, of all of this is, A, it’s a lot, right? There’s a lot to unpack and there’s a lot of different things that I think we’re throwing at, at folks in a very short period of time, but I think start small. Again, what is that one thing that you can really even take away from this conversation that does resonate, that could maybe create some action behind, you know, where you’re at and where you’re headed and, and maybe it is the, the personal reflection piece of this or, you know, picking up the phone and putting some action behind, like as you think about your, your peers, your family, your friends, you know, who is that one person that you could kind of confide in, right? More of a trusted advisor that may be able to provide, you know, if nothing else, right? Get some confidence or excitement or energy to do something, right, you know, to pick up the phone and start somewhere. And in all of your cases too, of course, all my listeners know, I’m, I’m always available to talk, happy to answer questions, happy to help guide through this, happy to make connections to this team. This team, I, I will tell you just what I love about this team is I’ve yet to have a hesitation recommending anybody talk to them.
[57:42] So reach out to me. I can connect you to, with everybody. They’ve, they’ve taken great care of everybody that I’ve, that I’ve pushed that direction. I, you know, thank you guys for that. Cause that means a lot to me just knowing I’ve got you guys to, to point people to and that there’ll be well taken care of. Yeah. So Phil, you got any closing remarks? Yeah, I think, you know, just in easy non-intrusive way, right? Like LinkedIn, we’re all on LinkedIn. So if you’re interested in seeing the content that we’re pushing out have an interest in that also claconnect.com. We have a ton of resources out there, webinars. There’s more information out there than probably you want to digest, but it’s there. So other than connecting with us directly, you know, feel free to go on our website. We got lots of information out there as well. Yeah. You guys do a great job of pushing out a lot of really, really relevant content around all sorts of finance and accounting issues for sure. Well, thank you guys for being here. I really appreciate it. And I think this is a, this is an important conversation and, and I hope people are listening to it, you know, listeners again, reach out to me, reach out to any of them individually, connect with CLA online. They, again, they, they really do put out great content. If, if you’re not even thinking about selling, but you’re, you’re in the throes of operating, there’s great content out there about taking advantage of tax credits and grants.
[59:03] And I mean, I’m just trying to think of some of the things I’ve seen you put out this week. So all super relevant, worth paying attention to. I try to catch it and share it as well, but you guys put out so much, I know I don’t catch it all. So again, thank you guys. I look forward to next time.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect with the CLA Team
- Connect with Phil Hanke on LinkedIn
- Connect with Erin Mickels on LinkedIn
- Connect with Brady Paschke on LinkedIn
- Reach the full team and browse their resources at claconnect.com