By Jennifer Dubose

The AI Revolution: Rethinking Automation with Al Whatmough, Ep #13

In this episode of Lights Out, we’re joined by a true innovator in the manufacturing space, Al Whatmough, CEO of Toolpath. Al brings a wealth of experience from his time at Autodesk and his leadership at Toolpath, where he’s driving the next wave of automation in CNC machining. Together, we dive into the revolutionary role that AI is playing in reshaping manufacturing operations, offering fresh perspectives on how automation can enhance productivity and streamline processes on the shop floor.

Throughout the conversation, Al unpacks the exciting developments at Toolpath, including their acquisition of Chatter, a key technology that helps shops automate their operations more effectively. He shares his vision for the future of manufacturing, where AI doesn’t just automate processes but actively assists in decision-making, freeing up cognitive load for operators and improving workflow efficiency.

We also explore the challenges traditional shops face when integrating new technology and how bridging generational gaps in the workforce is crucial for embracing the full potential of automation.

This episode is a must-listen for manufacturing leaders looking to understand how AI and automation can create smarter, more agile operations. Al’s insights into the real-world applications of AI, along with his thoughtful reflections on industry trends, will inspire you to think differently about the tools you use and the systems you have in place.

You’ll want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:00) Chatting about our time at the MFG Meeting 2025
  • (3:06) Introducing Al Whatmough, CEO of Toolpath
  • (3:40) Bridging the generational divide in manufacturing
  • (6:20) Al’s journey from Autodesk to Toolpath and what they aim to achieve
  • (8:37) Building trust in AI and overcoming skepticism from more traditional shops
  • (11:11) The acquisition of Chatter and how it enhances Toolpath’s capabilities
  • (12:39) Why automation should focus on the mundane tasks to free up cognitive load
  • (13:38) The dangers of chasing complex problems rather than solving simple ones
  • (15:52) The importance of understanding customer needs and creating tailored solutions
  • (18:13) The intersection of AI and existing technologies in modern manufacturing
  • (21:24) Rethinking workflows with AI and improving the connection between tools
  • (26:57) Know what you’re good at and learn to do it well
  • (33:22) Reflections on the future of AI and automation in manufacturing

Connect with Al Whatmough

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] Nick Goellner: Mike, thank you so much for leading the yoga class at 10 a. m. yesterday. You were so transcendent.

[0:10] Mike Payne: I mean, I do what I can. Thank God for like Lululemon pants though, because they’re flexible, so you can really stretch in them.

Paul Van Metre: Yeah, and they don’t show through when you really stretch them wide.

[0:20] Narrator: Talent is scarce, experience even more so, driving up costs and sleepless nights. You may even think to yourself, can I do this? But this new era. Brings new technology and a different perspective on your operations. What you will hear will turn on a light bulb in your mind, so you can turn out the lights in your shop. Get ready to sleep soundly while your shop never stops. Get ready.

[0:50] For making chips, Lights Out.

[1:00] Nick Goellner: So welcome to this episode of Lights Out. Caleb is doing real work while we’re at a conference, having fun with our friends. And, uh, I brought two hosts that I affectionately refer to as the B team. So

[1:10] Mike Payne: good to be here as back. Oh,

Nick Goellner: Mike. Yeah. B B B means backup back.

Mike Payne: You, you pointed at me when you said Paul and then you went to your arm, went to him.

Well, this is an

[1:20] Nick Goellner: audio podcast and nobody knows that until I do not. And now everybody does. So I’ve had an incredible time here and I didn’t know what to expect cause I’ve never been to one of these, uh, The MFG 2025. It’s a

Mike Payne: great show. It is cool.

Nick Goellner: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Great networking. Smaller crowd, like you can have more conversations.

And when you say show,

[1:40] Nick Goellner: I think a lot of people probably think it’s a show like a trade show or whatever, but it’s a conference. Yeah. And it’s. Awesome. And it’s broader than like MT forecast, which I love, but there was, there was a great economist today who was very funny. But MT forecast is like nine of those sessions.

[2:00] It’s just all very technical. It’s like really good, you know, for planning out. and working on your budget and things like that. But it just becomes like a lot of economics where this is kind of like really all over the place and broad.

[2:20] Mike Payne: Yeah. So I, you know, historically I don’t do well at conferences. I can do, I’m fine at a trade show, but I don’t generally like sitting in a room listening to people speak, but I’ve.

I’ve enjoyed both days of really every speaker. I don’t, I don’t think any of them lost me. I mean, it was all good stuff.

[2:30] Nick Goellner: Yeah, for sure. And I like that we’re kind of all on the same resort. It’s like you’re on a vacation together with a bunch of people that you work with. Yeah.

[2:40] Paul Van Metre: I think the after, you know, as good as the speakers are, the times afterwards where you’re just networking, meeting new people.

Building new connections are so valuable.

[2:50] Nick Goellner: Watching me get emotional. I don’t even remember what we were talking about, but I was definitely tearing up at one point in front of a lot of people.

Mike Payne: You were? I missed that.

Nick Goellner: Yeah. Last night we, we, we were just talking about like our families and.

Paul Van Metre: Yeah. Yeah. Your roots back in, in, in Austria and.

[3:00] Nick Goellner: And I get that way. Yeah, you know, I’m a big soft. We love that about you. Thank you. So, okay, let’s get to, uh, our guest. He’s not a stranger to making chips. He, this is his first time on Lights Out and this, this gentleman is transcendent. That’s the word. That is the word. So, no, but, uh, welcome to the show, Al Whatmoe.

[3:30] Oh, the CEO of toolpath, the man, a great friend of ours. So why did I say that? I was kind of just texting back and forth and joking, but get into what you noticed, you know, in that big conference room area. And you just text me like, wow, this is what I noticed. Get into that a little bit.

[3:40] Al Whatmough: You are so good at just pulling it like instantly, just pulling that into the deep conversation.

Yeah, let’s go. We do

Nick Goellner: big, we do big talk, not small talk.

[3:50] Al Whatmough: Yeah. You guys were starting to talk about hanging out with friends and. I agree, we were hanging out last night with friends and, uh, with you guys sitting around, and then I was, I was walking back to my room, I kind of realized, like, this whole group of people, there’s many people here that I know as, as friends, but there’s an entire other community that are also friends, like, earlier in the week, I was in Atlanta with John Saunders and listening to a podcast from, from Dylan with, with Intolerance.

And there’s like a whole community of, I might call them Insta machinists.

Nick Goellner (2): Yeah.

[4:20] Al Whatmough: Paul, we were talking about CJ, who’s probably one of those people that blends both sides, but kind of thinking of these two communities and almost two generations with a missing manufacturing generation in the middle of it and starting to kind of think, how do you, how do you bring those groups together or do you?

[4:40] Nick Goellner: Yeah. Well, okay. So the missing generation, I would say. I totally agree with what you’re saying. There’s, there is a gap and it’s like right where I’m at. So I’m, I’m like 37.

Paul Van Metre: So I’m in the older group now. I don’t, I don’t, hold on, come on, man.

[4:50] I don’t even know

[5:00] Nick Goellner: how old you are, Paul. Okay. 51. Mike’s like 73. No, but like, there’s nobody who’s right at like the 40 ish age. We’re

Al Whatmough: unique on that. You’re 42 and

[5:10] Nick Goellner: you’re 37. Yeah. So like. Everyone in shops I feel like is in their, you know, fifties or sixties or their like twenties and thirties. That’s what I see.

[5:20] Al Whatmough: My guess is your experience is the same, but when I was in high school, I almost had to like fight to take machining classes. Cause they kind of say, well, if you’re not on a track for university, it was Canada, then you shouldn’t be going to the shop classes. And like generally. Kind of loosely blame high school guidance counselors from a generation.

[5:40] Mike Payne: We actually had metalworking, woodworking, drafting, auto shop in my high school. But I think my wife who graduated from the same high school two years later, I think it was gone by the time she graduated and it had gone to the local tech schools. You’ll say it removed it out of the, you know, on campus to while I was in high

Nick Goellner: school.

[6:00] The shop class died, like, in the four years that I was

[6:10] Al Whatmough: there. It was fading while I was there, and I actually went back and taught high school in the high school I went to, but it sort of faded in a middle period, too, in Canada, anyway.

[6:20] Nick Goellner: So with, uh, with Lighthouse being focused on technology and automation and some of our listeners, I’m sure haven’t heard the episode we did before get into like your story a little bit, you know coming from Autodesk and then to Toolpath and basically what does your solution do?

[6:30] Al Whatmough: What does our solution do? Oh, man. I’m not a smart one In general, we’re applying AI to to solve the solve a portion of an automation problem to CNC machining AI is kind of broadly used. It’s just a new set of tools to solve the solve the problem in a different way I think the to me the the most exciting thing that we’re doing is changing the way you think about interacting with software We kind of jokingly say may must and mustn’t but you have to build we have to build a system that allows Louser shop to say what may you decide on your own?

[7:10] What must you do and what can’t you do? And it’s, it’s a flip of the way you interact with software today. If you think of engineering software, the user makes a decision, the software is a calculator and gives an answer. And to me with, with AI and all the tools that are available, a need is for a I’ll call it a parametric system.

[7:30] So that’s what was good at parametric CAD cam. You can define your intent, but it’s at a higher level and the S the system’s making decisions and we need to find a way for the. The user to control what the AI may do, what it must do, and what it must not do.

[7:40] Nick Goellner: Okay. That’s like a really good way to, you’re good at that.

Like, you’re like, Oh, how do I describe what I do? And then you just nail it.

[7:50] Al Whatmough: It’s kind of funny. Like, um, we just talked about teaching, but you’d think the last decade and a half now. Okay. So we’re old to, uh, that I spent in software for manufacturing. You’d think it was my time as a machinist that was more valuable.

[8:10] The year and a half as a teacher, I think has been far more valuable to think about how do you articulate something in a way that’s understandable, whether it’s articulate to the user base, how to understand what the smart developers did or articulate to the smart developers, what it is the machinists need.

[8:20] It’s largely the. Skill that I enjoy the most anyway. So you have to transcend both groups? Translate. Let’s use translate. Transcend seems too weird. I just, I just keep saying

[8:30] Nick Goellner: it because I know every time I do, you’re like, why do you say it? I know we’re

Al Whatmough: friends now because you only tease your friends.

[8:40] Nick Goellner: But okay, so a lot of people would hear what Toolpath does and be like, yeah, right.

[8:50] You know, prove it. How does it work? Right? And I think when we talk about these kind of two groups of people a lot of the people with more Established shops that have been doing it a certain way for a long period of time are gonna be like, yeah You know all these youngsters think AI is gonna solve everything and you and it won’t do this or it It’s almost like they’re like looking for the flaw in it to be like see Is that, is that what you see with some, some users or, I guess people who aren’t users, cause they might be hesitant to give it a shot.

[9:20] Al Whatmough: That’s, I mean, that’s what we have to do is build trust. Right. Uh, you mentioned the youngsters. This did actually hit me the other day. My youngest is. 10 and she’s getting close to being the generation that’s not gonna understand a world that didn’t have AI. Sure There’s like we’re kind of in the bridge of the world right understands it didn’t understand having computers But I think in many ways I think it’s been overhyped but it’s it’s really just a new a new set of decision making computers can make that you kind of can interact with in a In a new way to understand your intent.

Mm hmm. That makes

Nick Goellner: sense.

Speaker 4: Yeah

[9:50] Nick Goellner: So with your ten year old living in a certain paradigm And never seeing the other side of it. She’s going to think a certain way. It’s very

Mike Payne: natural.

[10:00] Nick Goellner: And we’ve got a whole generation of people who grew up in a different paradigm and they seen pre computer machining all the way through to like what we have today.

[10:10] And some, some of those folks are hesitant to try the latest tech because they remember when, like, for example, uh, when. additive was booming and everyone said like, Oh, we won’t have machining anymore. And like, people just like blew it up way too far and suddenly they’re like, no, like let’s be cautious with this stuff.

[10:30] Al Whatmough: When you say cautious, it is something that’s interesting for me that like manufacturing is the industry that figured out how to. Do automation. And yet in a lot of ways we’re the furthest behind on a lot of things. Like I remember when I was at Autodesk, it’d be working in pier nine, walking a USB key to the machine to get G code on it while self driving cars are driving past.

[10:50] How did this happen as our industry? Yeah. And then you were talking about like expectations about a Prusa printer a little while ago and I was trying to get it plugged in. And my son says, Hey dad, like everything’s wireless now, but that, and then tie that to. Toolpath, we just acquired Chatter, and there are still a lot of hurdles and roadblocks to just get a wire connected to a CNC machine, which is kind of insane to think about.

[11:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah. So tell us a little bit about like what Chatter is, why you acquired it, what it does in connection to the core functionality of Toolpath.

[11:20] Al Whatmough: At a fundamental level, it’s pretty simple. If you think of Toolpath as a brain, Chatter is the eyes and the ears, the nervous system. I have like this deep belief that the speed of innovation is only controlled by the speed of communication.

[11:30] There was a time that was somebody carrying a letter on a horse, but the faster you can communicate and iterate, the faster you can, you can move forward. Carl Bass is one of our, one of my mentors on the board. He was involved in graphics cards early and said they, the dramatic improvements there happen when they close the loop between the software and the hardware.

[11:50] Uh, to me, chatter’s, chatter’s the same thing. How do we create a two way conversation and not just a, a one way yelling match of cam software at a CNC machine? It needs to be, it needs to be a conversation. And from that’ll be a whole stack of innovations. I’m sure of it. Wow.

[12:10] Speaker 5: Yeah. And that, uh, you know, to push programs in, but then to get information back out, I know I’ve, I’ve talked to, to, uh, Pete, you know, I remember talking to Pete a few years ago.

[12:20] You know, and, uh, and I know CJ, a customer of ours, uses it, and he’s like, I rely on, on Chatter to get me, like, a text at 9pm that something is up, and I can go fix it for a couple minutes, and then get, you know, the whole rest of the night of runtime.

[12:30] Al Whatmough: And, like, those are the things you don’t think about.

[12:40] Like, when CJ says that, he’s got I’m so proud of that guy, but he’s got like a row of Willamette’s that just run, run parts like 96 hours straight. But in automation, what our job is is to automate the mundane tasks so you can free your cognitive load up to solve something else. So you might think, well, it’s pretty easy to look at the machine and see if it’s running.

[13:00] But if it’s constantly in the back of my mind is a machine running as a machine running as a machine running, it’s, it’s consuming. Bandwidth or CJ say like he can go enjoy dinner with his family and know that he’ll get a text message The machine’s not doing something so you can kind of free his mind up.

[13:10] I think it’s the autopilot I love the autopilot analogy to that automated stick and rudder skills and it Might’ve been the easiest thing the pilot did. Well, they tried to navigate with the stuff on their, on their lap. But as soon as that got automated, they could really start thinking more about navigation.

[13:30] And I think it is a mistake that happens a lot with automation is you try and solve the hard problems instead of solving the easy problem. So the humans freed up. So that’s, yeah, that’s the thing CJ will talk about a lot. I just love getting text messages to know I need to go pay attention to the machine again.

[13:40] Nick Goellner: Do you think going after the hard problems is. Part of what holds a company like yours back from more adoption is they go after the craziest use case instead of the most simple use case. And I don’t know if my question is clear, but I think when you try to solve the biggest, scariest problem that maybe not a lot of people have to really show off the ultimate capabilities of your solution.

Instead of just being like, hey, look what this can do. And then from there they learn how to take it to the next level.

[14:10] Al Whatmough: I might as well just say it. If others copy me, that’s a good thing. Anyway, it’s, it’s what makes this industry fun for me. Uh, it’s the biggest opportunity. I think in general, people in manufacturing are problem solvers.

[14:20] So we go chase them.

Mike Payne: Sure.

[14:30] Al Whatmough: I don’t want to say it made it easy, but it did actually make it pretty easy for me when we were building fusion. 70 percent of machining done is two and a half axis. If you went to IMTS, you’d think that 70 percent of machining done was impellers. But it’s not, um, the whole, the whole market chased impellers and we just made the stuff that should be easy, easy.

[14:50] People laughed at us 10 years ago and said, you could only run a Haas, you’ll never run a Mazak. And now we run, well it’s not we anymore, I’m not there now, they run Mazaks now. But I do think that

Nick Goellner: just so the audience knows, you used to be like head of product for Autodesk or something like that. What was your,

Al Whatmough: yeah, I got the, I got a chance to be monkey in the middle there.

[15:00] So the same thing, product manager at Autodesk. Product manager in a big company is kind of, you don’t have any direct reports. I ended up having direct reports just cause I had a product management team, but you live in the middle of translation of explaining to the marketing and sales teams what the teams did, hearing from the customers and explaining that to developers, explaining to developers down.

[15:20] But yes, I wouldn’t say I lead, but I was, I was the translator in the middle of

[15:30] Nick Goellner: it. Such a perfect example of like, uh, Oh, if you go to IMTS, everything we machine is blisks and impellers and things that take like simultaneous five axis machining. And Mike, you and I just had a conversation the other day about like, you should get five axis mills, not because you have that five axis work, but just because you want to do everything in like one or two ops.

[15:40] Right, right, right. The point I was making before, you know, if you go to like the extreme of what it can do, you miss like, in a lot of ways, like the best use cases for whatever the technology is.

Al Whatmough: I got to be careful too, because it’s like. You need to go at each extremes. My bias is going to the extremes at the bottom.

[16:00] So like when we were, we had the Dell Cam group merge with us when it was a fusion, fusion. So I got a first hand seat of, with cam software, there’s two ways of going about it. We were unique being the only ones, but one way of saying, say, I can solve any problem, not anybody can use the solution. So you’d say.

[16:20] PowerMill is best in class five axis machining for that. It’s a high touch product at a high cost can solve any problem and you’ll throw people at it to solve it. Um, fusion was the opposite. So anybody can use it, but it won’t do anything. Right. And then you, and then you work the work, the problem up from there with, with tool path or approach will be the same as make a broad solution that anybody can use and expand capability.

[16:50] Another path to solving this problem could be. Solve it from the top down and solve a singular hard problem. I think that the terrifying spot is the, the middle band where you’re neither trying to take something low touch for a high number of people or solve a specific point solution. But I think our industry is naturally biased to high touch point solutions.

[17:10] Nick Goellner: Really insightful spectrum you just created in, in our, in our minds here of like that. What do you call it? High touch. Not, not everybody can use it versus everybody can use it, but very low. The

[17:20] Al Whatmough: experience has to match, right? If you go and buy a Maserati, you expect for somebody to. Give you the car in white gloves.

[17:30] You pay a lot of money. You’re probably back at the dealership quite a bit. If you buy a Corolla, you’re going to leave and drive it home and hope you don’t come back for 10 years. So it’s like, sure. It applies to any product. I think in our particular industry, though, it’s, it’s more common to focus on the, the problems, and I think that’s.

[17:50] I’m going to go down another tangent. There’s two types of sales. There’s, there’s hunters and gatherers. There’s like, I’m going to go hunt for the stuff that’s a fit for me, or I’m going to fulfill. If you’re taking a fulfillment type approach, then you’re more likely to say, here’s the hard problem. Now I’ll go solve that problem versus the other approach.

[18:10] You need to deeply understand the customer’s need, create the solution, and then go hunt for the match.

[18:20] Mike Payne: Okay. I mean, it’s, it’s, I guess it’s, it’s, it’s not that much different from just the evolution of like how robotics has been accepted into the industry, right? So, I mean, I, I remember even like in 2018 at IMTS when you would see robotics, it was doing like this really cool stuff.

[18:30] And now I think everybody’s kind of gone to the dull, dirty, and dangerous, right? Like, I mean, that’s, that’s probably not about everybody, but that’s probably where the The broadest adoption is like, let me just, let me do the easy stuff with the robot to free up bandwidth of my more skilled labor.

Al Whatmough: It is.

[18:50] And it isn’t though, right? Cause the, the high touch point solution is the easier sale because it’s pretty binary. I need it or I don’t. Right. The solving the mundane task, you have to help the person understand. Sure. That if, if you free them up from that, that it’s, it’s freeing and they get to do more. So it’s, it’s not the immediate need.

[19:10] As a shop owner, you’re saying, well, what’s my biggest bottleneck? And you’re, you’re likely focused on what the biggest challenge is and looking for a solution to solve that challenge. The reality is if I can solve the thing you do easily now, 90 percent of the time, you can free your current people up to go solve the challenge.

But it’s a lot easier to focus on the problem than go look for a solution to that problem.

[19:30] Speaker 5: And that middle band you talked about, I think is actually pretty large. It’s very large and

Al Whatmough: very, kind of very Dangerous to be in for any business. Yeah,

[19:40] Nick Goellner: I think this connects to like your world to Paul with E. R. P.

[19:50] Systems. You’ve got these crazy, expensive, can do absolutely everything, these oracles and S. A. P. S. And then you’ve got some like really, really scaled back. This, this is just the basics. Would you say you’re kind of like niche specialized in that middle band for a certain industry?

[20:00] Speaker 5: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, that’s kind of how I

Nick Goellner: see it.

[20:10] Speaker 5: Yeah, we’re not for, you know, 10, 000 person multi site in, you know, multinational corporations, but we’re also not serving a distributor that has a very simple process. There’s no sophistication to it. They’re just buying one thing, sticking on the shelf for a little while, and then selling to someone else later.

[20:20] You know, we’re working with job shops that have lots of Regulatory requirements and flow downs and complex processes they try to manage and that’s the majority of the job shop world

[20:30] Al Whatmough: Yeah, you can feel free to tell them if I got the wrong interpretation But I think that you’re not QuickBooks you’re helping somebody solve a technical problem So around your product you’ve added The appropriate supports and services to help that customer be successful and it is a little higher touch because it is a complicated problem It’s not something you could just hand somebody because you I think half of what you got to do is educate the shop on how to run so that they can run their shop efficiently.

Speaker 5: Absolutely. It’s

Al Whatmough: a huge part of how, how he rolls.

[21:00] Speaker 5: Yeah. I mean, that’s, that’s largely why I started my podcast. I wanted to share the successes and the tactics of successful shops. You know, with the rest of the industry, because most manufacturers are started by a technician that isn’t super great at actually running the business.

[21:20] And so hearing firsthand from others that have done it for years and have done it well, and are totally willing to just be an open book and share what’s worked for them is going to help rise all boats.

[21:30] Nick Goellner: So connective tissue, we were talking about this, we were talking about this connective tissue and. I felt kind of bad because we had all these super legit, like, speakers, the head of North America for NVIDIA and there was another AI consultant and everything was so interesting and I’m sitting next to Okay, so there’s a slide and it says, like, how can AI be used?

[21:50] And it’s like, it can assist in the CAM process for, you know, CNC machines. And I’m sitting next to Al, who’s got a business that does that, and I’m like, oh, that’s kind of surreal. And then we ended up Just sitting there talking, like chatting the whole time, like, like two students who weren’t paying attention.

[22:10] But it’s because we were paying attention and then we just were so interested in and what they were talking about and you were, you were like saying, here’s where I see it’s, it going and you were talking a lot about connected tissue. So, you know how, how All of these things kind of intersect and what ends up connecting them.

[22:20] I don’t even remember what I said. Yeah, but it was something to that effect. Like, cause all of these applications are super interesting. And then you were like, yeah, but the one who has like the platform or

[22:30] Al Whatmough: that is a fair point. And so there’s, I’m not, I’m not going to take away from any of the presentations, but they like one of them in particular, I think when we got talking it.

[22:40] I might have actually called it the dangerous middle to be honest, um, because they’re very generically talking about the capabilities of what this particular solution would solve in manufacturing. It wasn’t the level so deep that software providers would have extracted a lot of value from it. And I think it might’ve been a little too high for some shop owners to extract value from it.

[23:00] So it was a little bit in the middle. When I think about a lot of the providers though that have built these. AI engines. It’s to me, it’s a component technology that you might use in pro shop or we might use in, uh, toolpath. Uh, what, what’s needed is now to say, okay, we’ve got these, these new sets of tools.

[23:20] How do we tie them together into workflows? I think what we saw from some of those presentations is them workflows, but there’s an entire opportunity now to say, what is the The connective tissue or the workflow that uses these various tools right now, AI is the new tool. It might be like the new five axis machine that you got in your shop.

[23:50] You throw every part at, and then eventually you realize, well, barf at lathe is probably better for 60 percent of this stuff. AI is just another tool. Uh, and we’re probably throwing everything we can at it right now, but eventually software companies, might be ours, might be another one, figures out where pragmatically that new tool fits into a workflow.

Yeah. So that, that to me is the opportunity is the communication across tools that have been developed for 20 or 30 years. Plus the new ones. How can we rethink workflows?

[24:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah. I, and I see, I definitely see that too. I mean, just thinking about the past 10 guests we’ve had on there’s. ERP Paul, who’s not even a guest anymore, he’s, he’s a partner, but there’s, uh, the Paperless Parts guys who have some, like, AI driven tech, there’s what, what you’re doing with Toolpath, Chatter, there’s Adaptive Controls, and Tooling Optimization.

[24:40] Okay, so like all these different tools, and then they all have, like, an AI driven element to them, and then they all need to figure out how to work together for a company, and how do they all connect? You know, how do I, how do I make sure that, like It’s not like I’m learning 20 different things that feel disjointed and then it actually works for my business.

That’s what I got out of what you were saying. Like, how do we make sure that they all kind of work together and connect?

[25:00] Al Whatmough: I mean, that’s that’s largely the opportunity I see for Toolpath anyway, is how do we? Starting in the corner we’ve started in, but Solving a very simple problem. Should I do this work or not?

[25:10] Mm hmm But that’s my approach something that you can do broadly How do we use that as an opportunity to to rethink the way this chain fits together because up until now? It’s not been a chain for manufacturing. There’s a set of tools and make a decision if you should should take on a job So you quote it, you write something down on a sticky note or type it somewhere.

[25:30] And then the programmer says that dummy had no idea what he was doing. And they program it, how they’re going to program it. And they send it to the shop floor. And the operator said that dummy has no idea what they’re doing. And the feed override goes down to 50%. And then the manager runs by and runs it up to 120%, but like none of that, none of that kind of circles back through.

[25:50] It’s all very disconnected. I think some of the stuff with AI allows will allow us to create interfaces that set intent in a different way. So you can kind of more broadly, like when you’re flying a plane, you’re now saying this is my destination, you’re not making every decision about. Sticking or I don’t know if I’m making sense or not, but

[26:10] Nick Goellner: you are so you’re gonna try to be the connective tissue That’s that’s the path forward for you.

[26:20] Al Whatmough: We’re gonna try I it’s a fundamental enough time that I Personally believe that one of the large incumbent players will struggle to do this because there’s too many various departments And you’ve got to rethink how does data interact with interface, interact with the tools, and those are often many different departments across large, large organizations.

[26:40] So I think it’ll be hard for a very large software organization to solve the, the people problem of getting everybody to get aligned. I think at the same time, it’s be difficult for a very small software organization to But if you can get the right group of people together in a well funded medium sized organization, then it’s possible.

Nick Goellner: Yeah. Yeah. Interesting.

[27:00] Mike Payne: Well, and then when you look at the market, I would assume it’s going to, one of the problems that we’ll have to clear is the right solution for my shop is not the right solution for another shop for another shop. Right. So I think, you know, when I’m hearing, when you talk about the, the speed of communication between like all these different systems and processes and types of machines and types of ERP systems and types of machine monitoring and all that.

Maybe that’s, that’s where there can be clear advantages, or no?

[27:30] Al Whatmough: I guess I should be careful how I say this, but ultimately it should be the same solution. How you use the solution is going to be different. In technology, generally speaking, there’s a winner and nobody else. Because as the snowball rolls, it gets, it gets pretty Pretty big.

[27:50] Sure. And interestingly, my personal deep conviction is the company that solves a simple thing easily is the one that ultimately becomes the winner. Three examples that always stand out to me. When Google had I’m feeling lucky search, Yahoo had. Blogs and who knows what else they’re long since gone. And now you google to find anything.

[28:20] Sure. When Facebook had a thumbs up Myspace had way more and now Facebook kind of owns Connecting social media when you could buy anything on eBay Amazon sold books and now you can buy a car hoist on Amazon. Okay, so I think it’s it If you can control your growth properly and solve the core technical problem, then it’s, it’s a path, but it’s a, it’s also a big hurdle.

[28:40] Sure. But if we’ve done our job right, we’ve done it. We’ve built a solution that the way you use the tool is unique to you and the way somebody else uses, it’s unique to them, but there’s a shared set of. Technology that serves it. Yeah, that makes sense.

Speaker 5: With enough configurability to make it really useful to almost anyone.

That

[29:00] Al Whatmough: is one of the things where something like AI does get interesting because it, it allows for more dynamic configurability, I think.

[29:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah, so a theme that I’m pulling out of this conversation is like solve a simple core problem and expand from there versus solving like a radically complex problem and being like, of course, I could do the simple stuff to

Al Whatmough: focus, focus, focus, focus.

Nick Goellner: I’m super good at that guy.

[29:20] Al Whatmough: Focus is my middle name. Stay out of the dangerous middle. I’m not trying to say that it’s wrong to solve a hard problem very well. Maseratis is a great brand, but it’s different than the F 150 brand. It’s just know what your, what your focus is and be the very best at it. My belief, and what I love doing, is solving broad problems that might be simple and, and growing from there.

[29:50] Others are better at focused on, on finite problems. What gets dangerous, and I saw it inside of, inside of Autodesk is when I guess I can say that when some of our team were jealous of the great five axis toolpaths that the Dell, the PowerMill team had, and then some of the Dell, the PowerMill team said, Oh, we can do easy too.

It gets dangerous when you try and do what somebody else is good at.

Nick Goellner: Yeah.

Al Whatmough: Know what you’re good at and do it well.

[30:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah. Different is always better than better. Exactly. You know, that’s one of my favorite quotes is like, figure out what you are and be great at that thing. And there’s going to be overlap, of course, but just kind of be the best Nick focus.

Goldman. You can be. And

Al Whatmough: I’m going to pick on high school guidance counselors

[30:30] Nick Goellner: somewhere. There’s a high school guidance counselor. That’s just like, screw you. Al just kidding. Actually

Al Whatmough: my high school guidance counselor also got me to do a co op in a machine shop. So my high school guidance counselor is great in our generation.

[30:40] There’s that whole be all you can be thing. And I think that led to a belief that Effectively as your Peter principle, get promoted to the peak of your incompetence. So be all you can be shouldn’t mean like push yourself to do the thing that’s the closest to your, your peak. I probably would have flunked out of engineering school.

[31:00] Instead I became a, a good machinist and thrive far better in that situation. And if I fully believed in the believe all you could be, I probably would have like struggled in engineering school instead of thrive as a machinist.

[31:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah. All right. That’s interesting. So yeah, just bring them down a peg and just be like, you know, Billy, you can’t be anything you want to be.

[31:20] Cause you’re really not that good at a lot of stuff, but you’re good at this one

Al Whatmough: thing. So you should do it. Find yourself in a position of strength. And then grow from there. That’s a way

[31:30] Nick Goellner: better way to say it.

Al Whatmough: You guys are old enough to play the game of risk, right? Oh, sure. Oh, I love it.

Nick Goellner: Yeah.

Al Whatmough: Risk is the only thing you need for business strategy.

[31:40] Right, right. If, if I can be the first one to get little purple, Australia, New Zealand, then I’ll win every time because you can control your frontline. You can be in a position of strength and you can grow from there. You naively think, Oh, I should land in this big thing and, and then everybody’s attacking you because nobody wants you to get that big.

So it’s, I think it is a pretty critical thing to any strategy.

[32:00] Nick Goellner: You know, risk has like a really good online ranking system and you can play people online and I know I

Al Whatmough: played way too much on my tablet and how to delete

Nick Goellner: it. It’s really freaking hard.

[32:10] Al Whatmough: Like people are really good at it, but you can see human behavior that applies the same to business.

Absolutely. The same way.

[32:20] Nick Goellner: No, it’s funny. We were, there was a long thread. I don’t know if you guys were in it, Mike or Paul, but like that guy who was talking about monopoly in business. And I jumped in and was like, do you know what I’m talking about? Did you read that? And I was like, I always try to get the light blue monopoly first.

[32:30] So like, cause it’s right away, usually after the first or second time around. Those properties are all

Al Whatmough: purple stuff. You don’t make enough money. You want to be like right at the end of the lane.

[32:40] Nick Goellner: Yeah, exactly. So first or second time around, like someone owns them all. So I just trade and get that first monopoly hotel it up.

[32:50] And then I get, then I get a hit and now I’ve got cash for the whole game. And I mean, it’s just like Australia and risk. And in business, it’s just like what your, your whole premise of this conversation is, you know, solve that core problem, kill it, make sure it’s you’re winning and then grow from there.

[33:00] Don’t take Asia when you can take Australia in risk. And if people don’t know risk, they’re like, what the hell are they talking about? It’s not that much

[33:10] Mike Payne: different than, you know, Paul, I know I’ve heard you over the years talk about, you know, the riches and the niches, right? It’s exactly the same thing. I mean, just find your space, fully develop it out.

Yeah. It’d be really excellent at it.

[33:20] Nick Goellner: Yeah, that’s awesome. Okay, so before we close, there was a lot of really cool kind of use cases, you know, it wasn’t all ethereal AI is awesome. It was like, this is what’s going to happen in factories. And this is on the horizon. And I’m going to ask us all to pick like, kind of our Wow, that’s cool.

[33:40] Or like, I see that having a big impact or kind of what was your biggest takeaway from some of what you saw in that first day at at the MFG? Think about it for a little bit. I’ll say what When I, when I looked at you, Mike, and I was like, Whoa, it was when the NVIDIA guy showed, like, they basically prompted the chat or whatever it was.

[34:00] And then it like built a three dimensional factory. Oh,

Speaker 5: right. That was mine for sure. It was like,

[34:10] Nick Goellner: what? And then they were like moving stuff around and then it evolved into like basically this digital twin where they’re kind of like. Plant they’re basically doing the industrial engineering of the facility and then they’re like, okay So we’ve already done a lot of this testing that would have been really hard really expensive The logistics would have been crazy to do physically and learn physically, but you can learn really quick digitally and then apply it I was like that that is bad.

[34:30] Mike Payne: Yeah, there were I mean some of those big picture, you know Digital factory things that they were showing was certainly was not in my mind I think maybe what I was probably not the most surprised about but the most encouraged about kind of breaking some of that down to realize I could probably go back to my shop next week and develop some agents that, and Paul and I, I asked Paul a few questions during some of the presentations.

[35:00] Like, so can I, you know, using the pro shop API, you know, start to conversationally interact with. Maybe my multiple systems, right? So where I can, I could have an agent that looks into pro shop, looks into dynamics at my history of machine monitoring, you know, kind of all in one conversational approach and say, Hey, you know, tell me about every time we’ve run this part and what is my history of.

[35:30] scrap with those or broken tools or my cycle times and, and, and maybe even at some point, you know, go then go use, uh, I don’t know what the right word is, but the, the, the greater public knowledge base, like, okay, if I’m breaking a drill all the time, what are the things I should. I, like, that’s, that’s here now.

Some of the stuff we saw was really cool. And I guess it’s probably here now too. It’s not practical, like it’s not anything relevant to make

[35:50] Nick Goellner: like an, an agent that’s a tooling consultant or an agent that’s a maintenance consultant or something. I

Mike Payne: definitely, I had a better grasp that like those things, you know, they’re possible.

[36:00] I think I have a better grasp that there. But they’re also doable, like it’s, it’s reachable and it’s something that like we could deploy sooner rather than later.

[36:10] Nick Goellner: Yeah, for sure. Al, what was your biggest takeaway? Or were you just not paying attention at all?

[36:20] Al Whatmough: Hey, uh, the biggest takeaway, I’m glad you didn’t say AI because my biggest takeaway was the last presentation.

I thought the last presenter talking through the, the risks and the opportunity on CMMC.

Nick Goellner (2): Yeah.

[36:30] Al Whatmough: That was probably the one that left me thinking like. Man, if I was a small shop owner right now, I’d be overwhelmed. Mm-hmm . It’s a big price tag and industry of people that serve small shops, we gotta figure out how we make that better for them.

Yeah. So that’s, that’s what hit me the most.

[36:40] Nick Goellner: And hey, if, if you’re listening on Lights Out right now, that that presenter we just interviewed, Paul brought him in Jacob Horn from, what’s it called? Summit? Summit Seven. Summit Seven. I’m glad you remembered. I was gonna try and name drop them. Yeah. And it was incredible.

[37:00] So we talked to him for about. It was over an hour. It was a really good episode, but yeah, just, I guess my takeaway from that was there’s a certain, um, there’s a small section of shops that have been doing it right from the beginning and they got, they got through all of the hoops that you need to get through and they’re totally compliant and they have just a massive competitive edge now because they did it.

[37:20] Sure. But there’s a. Massive group of people who have a lot of work to do. And it’s a lot of that’s going to be pretty bottlenecked.

[37:30] Al Whatmough: I guess that’s a comfort too, though. Anybody that thinks they’re alone and nobody else is, is like them. It’s not true. It’s like their peers are mostly in the same situation too.

So it’s an opportunity for everybody to step forward. Yeah.

[37:40] Mike Payne: We, I mean, what we talked about on the podcast yesterday, the, what do you say there was 80, 000 there projected maybe 80, 000 suppliers that need to be compliant. And there’s currently about a hundred.

Al Whatmough: That’s a massive

[37:50] Mike Payne: opportunity for a big gap to fill.

Yeah. Every change is an opportunity. So really you’re alone. If you are compliant, you should feel alone. There’s 99 other people.

[38:00] Nick Goellner: It’s wild. Well, Hey, um, it was awesome bringing you on and we have podcasts where the conversations all the time, and occasionally we have a microphone and we’re recording. Yeah.

[38:10] With that, we got to. Turn the lights out on this episode. So someone clapped twice.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.


Connect With Lights Out

Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.