By Jennifer Dubose
Lights Out Isn’t the Future—It’s Already Here, 513
Automation and lights-out manufacturing are often framed as the future of machining, but for many shops that future is already here.
In this episode of MakingChips, we sit down with longtime industry leader Keith Grano to talk about what lights-out machining actually looks like in practice. Drawing on years of experience working with manufacturers, Keith explains how automation, machine monitoring, and disciplined processes allow shops to run more efficiently and extend production beyond the traditional workday.
Lights-out machining isn’t about replacing people. It’s about using technology to make better use of the time, talent, and equipment already inside a shop. When done well, it increases capacity, improves consistency, and helps manufacturers grow even when skilled labor is limited.
Keith walks through the practical considerations behind unattended production, including machine reliability, process stability, tooling strategy, and the systems required to keep parts running when no one is standing at the control. Along the way, we explore why many shops struggle to implement automation and why incremental steps often work better than trying to jump straight into fully autonomous production.
This conversation also connects to a theme we’ve been exploring across our Generation CNC series: the next generation of manufacturing leaders is entering an industry where automation and digital systems are becoming foundational capabilities. Understanding how lights-out machining works, and when it makes sense, will shape how the next generation builds and scales their shops.
Segments
- (1:28) Introducing Keith Grano and his background in manufacturing automation
- (3:06) What “lights-out machining” actually means in a modern shop
- (7:23) Why automation is about maximizing equipment and people, not replacing labor
- (12:09) The operational discipline required to run machines unattended
- (14:52) How ProShop ERP can help you achieve on-time delivery
- (20:11) Why process stability matters more than the machine itself
- (25:08) Tooling strategy, monitoring, and the systems that support unattended production
- (29:38) If you want the speed of AI without the risk, go to PaperlessParts.com
- (30:53) The mindset you need to have to implement lights-out machining
- (33:13) Where do you start with lights out automation?
- (40:08) How to adjust your mindset to allow for automation
- (46:33) How machine monitoring and data change decision-making on the shop floor
- (51:27) Why we created Hire MFG Leaders (and why you should use it)
- (51:58) The most affordable way to automate a five-axis setup
- (58:54) How state, local, and federal grants can help cover purchases
- (1:00:47) How to determine what to charge for a machine’s time
Resources mentioned on this episode
- Visit proshoperp.com/95 to get a free guide to achieve on-time delivery
- If you want the speed of AI without the risk, go to PaperlessParts.com
- Why we created Hire MFG Leaders (and why you should use it)
- ROI Calculator
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] Mike, what’s up, Nick? Hey, have you seen the numbers lately? Which numbers? Like our download numbers and how they’re spiking like crazy. I haven’t looked. Well, let me show you. I think it’s because of the lights and I got to show you what I got. It’s because of the lights. I got more. I got, I got these. Hang on, let me put my headphones back on. I got rope lights. See? Ropes. I got more spotlights. I’m telling you, I think it’s the lights. But don’t you host a show called Lights Out? Oh, shoot. I didn’t think about that. Hang on, for those, for those watching on video, the lights are out. Oh, just with the switch of a button. Well, hey, speaking of lights out, we’re going to talk about lights out today, right? Yeah. Yeah. My favorite topic too. Exactly. And we got a guest. We have a wonderful guest, a good friend of both of ours. USA Hockey going with the USA Titans today. Yeah, yeah.
[1:17] What do you guys think about that? I thought it was incredible. Insane. So Keith Grano, for those who are just listening, Keith Grano, the, what are you? The chief sales officer for Titans of C&C. Chief sales officer for Titans of C&C. Been doing this way too long, but I love it more than anything. So that’s why I’m way too long is okay. So we were, we were talking, so everyone we’re interviewing this year, Keith is a like under 30 year old entrepreneur in this space, in this manufacturing space. And the kid we had on, like the last episode we recorded was making a joke about what all the old machine tool guys say to him when he’s at IMTS. And Mike, you remember what he said? He’s like, he’s like, they’re all like, yeah, um, I would have done it. I would have started my own shop, but they have this like laundry list of excuses. And he’s like, and I don’t want to be an old guy selling machine tools at IMTS. And I was like, Hey, me and Keith take offense to that. Okay. That is great. But he’s probably spot on because right. We all know this, that this industry, it just perpetuates, you know, the ability to not change. If you just, you can’t, you can’t literally sit there and tell a guy you could talk to your blue in the face about how much better things. Oh, we’ve got it figured out.
[2:34] This is dialed in. We don’t need to change it all the time. All the time. It’s crazy. You know, Keith, the other thing we’ve heard, Keith, the other thing we’ve heard from all these young entrepreneurs we’ve talked to so far, when we talk to them about, you know, inspiration and education though, um, I mean, in all fairness to every one of them’s mentioned titans of CNC, you know, the content. Yeah. I mean, what you guys are doing from that regard of like inspiring, you know, an entire generation is pretty, pretty darn incredible. Well, you know, I will say this, you know, people have asked me, you know, why’d you leave Selway? You know, God, you had it dialed in out there. And, and, and part of that, you know, reason to leave and move to Texas was literally, I love this industry more than anything. Love it. Love, love, love it. And to bring the awareness to that younger generation is kind of like what I felt I had to give back to the industry. And it’s been so good, right? Yeah. The people, we all know this, you guys know it. We’re on that same. The people are the best people on the planet. There’s not a better group of, of people that I’ve ever been, come across in my, in my life. And in 32 years, I can honestly say on one hand, less than one hand met a people that I wouldn’t want to do business with.
[3:51] Less than one hand. And I’ve been into thousands of machine shops, sold thousands of machines, and that’s saying something. So it speaks to, yes, having the ability to help Titan, if that is even possible. Cause he had a great platform before I got here, but just continue to spread that awareness. And I talk to people, Mike, every day, I was a carpenter. I was an IT guy. I was an electrician. I was, you know, I, we had a family farm and I went through Titan’s building blocks. Now I have three machines, four machines. This great guy, Nick Preece, he’s out in Colorado. Uh, he’s one of the young entrepreneurs. He’s one of the ones we just talked to. Yeah. He’s one of the episodes and he’s one of the guys who talked about you guys. He is awesome. Such a great guy, such a great guy. And, uh, he and I touched base when I first got on board here and he was one of those guys that told me, you know, about the platform and how he really listened to Titan on the business side of things, how to, you know, maybe alleviate walking into some of these pitfalls and what have you, and how Titan almost lost everything, but got it all back. And, uh, I just talked to him last Thursday on my way home from Austin. And, uh. That might be when we talked to him. He went from 4,000 to 14,000 square feet. What a stud. That’s so cool how it’s such a big world and such a small world all at once. It’s so great.
[5:11] Like I think he might’ve been the guy who, no, he wasn’t. Uh, he wasn’t the guy who said that about like, I don’t want to be one of these guys coulda, woulda, shoulda, and started my own shop. But yeah, it was just so cool. I’ll bring up one of our guests. And he’s what? 21. Is that right? He’s under 30. All everyone we’ve been talking to Nick, I think, uh, not 21, but I’ll say maybe mid, mid twenties. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe it’s pretty incredible. Very incredible. I got another one. I should have you guys reach out to, uh, Todd Newhouse. Great friend of mine, Selway machine tool legend works the Pacific Northwest introduced me to this young kid. I’m not, uh, remember his name right now, but 23 years old, just bought his first man and said, I need to be able to run this thing with nobody in front of it for money to be successful. I’m missing the name too, but I think we talked to him. You’re kidding me. Great kid. I had a good time. It’s not Michael King. Is it? No, no, no. Okay. That’s who I was thinking. But we did talk to him and he’s got him. He’s got a, I want to say, well, what’s the small mats are a five axis that we’re putting three 30, 30. Yeah. He’s got one of those and he’s going to put one of those pallet systems that we make on there. So that’s. Oh, very good. That’s another good one.
[6:26] I will tell you this. So boombastic, as we all know, was crazy, right? We had what? Over 1500 people in two days walk through this place. And I think that showed so well, but my God, I have probably walked. Since November, probably 30 other customers, you know, demos walking them through give that thing shows so beautifully. Well, what? 12 inch cube, right? 40 pallets can go on to any five axis machine or any machine in general, but we feel like five axis, mostly five axis. Yeah, there’s been some interest with verticals, but. But to that point, we, we specifically, I think when you guys really hit on that, it was for the five axis platform, right? Well, maybe it’s a good lead into what we’re talking about, because I feel like that’s where. You know, Matt Surra excels. I’ve sold Matt Surra for 30 plus years. Love their product. Love the family. Katsu is amazing. Yuto is going to be an incredible CEO when that time comes. And, and to that point, when you get to tools and pallets, meaning, you know, everybody’s got a five axis, but then when you start to really get to that point where you’re like, oh my God, we can take this. And now we want to expand on that. Everybody’s generally got to go third party. Whereas Matt Surra, they put everything under their own roof, own pallet changers. You know, the tools go from, you know, 330 to 530 tools, uh, you know, from 10 pallets to 40 to 60.
[7:53] So they, they just, it’s hard when you get to that realm of understanding where you have to go with lights out. They’re hard to beat. They’re hard to beat. You’ve entered that world with the world. And what’s so crazy is, uh, I just, because of what you said, I assumed with Matt Surra, there wouldn’t be an opportunity with the workflow. And then you introduced me to Billy, right. And Billy was like, actually, there’s a window here where like that MX series before you jump up to the man. And there’s that gap. And so now like, we’re talking about what to put on the Matt Surra for IMTS, which is cool. Yeah. Nick, you’re spot on because right. They make the MX with a 10 pallet, but then the next option is 32. So, and, and it’s like what, 500 grand more to jump from that step to that step. And that barrier is a lot to overcome for maybe like a young entrepreneur, like some of the people we’ve been interviewing and they’re, they want to run lights out. They want to stay ahead of their machine. I talk about that all the time, work ahead of your machine. And just to kind of frame that for everybody, what I mean by that, what we mean by that, when we say that is your machine’s running a job and you’re loading two, three, four, five jobs ahead, making sure you have pallets ready with programs, with work holding, with the tools required. That’s right.
[9:09] And so like, you’re always ahead of your machine, your machine never stops and you’re, you’re working ahead of it. And then you get good at doing that with one machine. Now, maybe you’re able to run two or three or four machines. That’s right. And now you’re really stretching yourself and you’re taking labor out of the equation. And that’s how some of our, our best partners and some of my best friends who run shops in Switzerland, of all places, the most expensive real estate in the world for commercial real estate, but they can compete on a global scale because they all run that way. They all have that culture. Well, and I think that’s where, you know, a lot of the shops have to figure out what they want. Like, you know, it’s interesting, Texas in particular. So I’ve been going out a lot here recently. I think I’ve seen every shop now in Austin, Marble Falls, Cedar Park, Leander. There’s been some great, you know, shops, great people, of course, like I mentioned earlier, but you go to Austin and then a good little radius around Austin is a lot of shops. And, you know, there is, you know, some automation out there, but a lot of guys, it’s, I don’t know what it is. It’s, it’s, they got to understand that, you know, one of these systems, one of these, even a 10 pallet, but, you know, go into a MX or a workflow or a man, you know, it probably takes the place of three verticals. Yeah.
[10:27] You know, it completely does. And, and think about three verticals. You got to have three guys in front of them, or maybe for a really good shot, maybe you got one guy standing in front of those three, but you got to have other guys to, you know, man, the other verticals. When you start to get into this idea of lights out and five axis with multi pallets and tools, man, those things eat. That’s what they do. That’s what they’re meant to do. And, uh, you set them up correctly. And like Matt, sir, right. They’ve got 72, 35 V 72, 42 V 72 52. That’s 72 is for 72 unmanned hours, which is a weekend shift of no one standing in front of that machine. Now that’s what, that’s how they name it. Huh? I love that. That is so cool. Nick, what was the, when you were in Tulsa, um, we were at Scott’s place. What was the model number of his? He was using, those were Akuma’s right? Yeah. The one, uh, Scott’s shortest that was getting loaded with, uh, with that fast system. Yeah. Yeah. What was the model number of the fastest though? Oh, what is it? 86, 20, 8,620 minutes in a, in a year. Yeah. Or 8,760 is on their logo. Yeah. Yeah. That’s it. And I love that. Like the number, the meaning for the number, that’s how many hours in a year or something like that. Yeah.
[11:42] So that’s right. What did I say? Minutes. Yeah. Hours in a year. Yeah. We knew what you meant. Yeah. And that’s, and that’s what you do. Fastoms is wonderful for that. Right. I mean, you could, you have a fricking, you know, FMS system in a box. Yeah. So Keith, I mean, you’re right. Great lead in. So let’s, let’s talk about, you know, that you, you, you brought up, there’s the old, there’s kind of the old school mentality. I’m going to have one to two people running these three machines, you know, whatever. I mean, if you’re, I think traditionally, if you’re really well-performing, you might have two running three, right. Correct. You know, versus this mentality. And a lot of these young entrepreneurs we’ve talked about, you know, what they want to build is something that, you know, they’re a lot more interested in their time freedom. Right. They want, they want to build something that just runs and, and they have time to enjoy their lives. And what do you see when you do tour around, you know, and of course throughout your 30 career, what does that shift look like for a shop? That’s like positioned well to do that versus one that’s, you know, may never get there. Yeah. You know, it’s a great question because that’s what I kind of figure. Like I look at, at, at the, at the Dallas, you know, area being very similar to what I saw in Northern Nevada in the early two thousands, you know, there are a lot of three axis verticals and I always used to say, right. And maybe the, the, the progression has gotten a little bit, it’s changed a little bit from those days, but you’d go from maybe a six or seven guy had six or seven verticals from you.
[13:14] Okay. It was now time for a horizontal, you know, then, then he went from a horizontal to a multi-palette line, like a linear palette line. And then he went from that to a five axis. Well, today that horizontal, if you go back to like, say 2005, I’d sell 20 horizontals for every one at five axis. Today it’s 25 axis for every one of horizontal. So when you start to look at that progression to your question, Mike, I think that’s what it is when that guy’s at that point, you got to start somewhere. So everyone’s going to start with, Hey, give me a few verticals. Let me get some equipment on the floor. We all know this, this industry is not cheap to start and get into, but when you get to that point of going, okay, I’m sick of touching the part. I’m sick of setting this up multiple different times down the line or over multiple spindles. I, you just got to your point. You got to find a way around that. And that way could be a standalone five axis to start, but that’s not going to give you lights out. That’s going to give you the ability to, Hey, complete the part in one with workholding. Like you have knit right under the Hennig brand. We’ve got, you know, some really great brands that you guys use for workholding, where we can get multiple pieces on one workholding set. That’s great. But when you have palettes, now we’re talking tools.
[14:30] Now we’re talking. You are set up for success because right? Spindle utilization is number one. You’ve got to have those darn spindles turning and it spindle utilization equals the amount of parts you get out at the end of the day. What do you think of when I say OTD? Well, in making chips, we’ve got lots of acronyms to deal with, but OTD is on-time delivery. On-time delivery is part of Hill’s mission. Deliver quality parts on time. Every time when I was shopping for an ERP system, I was looking for something that would ensure that we do that on a regular basis. Delivering jobs on time was something we struggled with, and I know that most shops struggle with. I think I saw recently that 70% of shops struggled with delivering parts on time. So the best decision I made in that, enter ProShop. Did you know that many of ProShop’s customers quickly experienced 95% or better on-time delivery rates with their customers? And now ProShop has a guide to help all shops, whether you’re using ProShop or not. Visit ProShopERP.com slash 95. Again, that’s ProShopERP slash 95 to get your copy today. I’m glad you’ve talked about tools, and I’m glad you talked about workholding too. And the first thing I want to mention that you kind of alluded to is you don’t need like simultaneous turbine blisks to get a 5-axis mill.
[15:55] And we see that so much with a lot of these young entrepreneurs too, right, Mike? A higher proportion of the younger entrepreneurs are thinking with this, let’s just get a 5-axis mill and do everything in one, maybe two ops than what you see out there with more established shops. But yeah, you’ve got a pallet. Let’s say it’s a 300-millimeter pallet, just like what we were talking about earlier. And you could do maybe a part like the size of your hand or whatever. Red bulk. Yeah. Throw a little pyramid on there and do three of them. That’s right. And then add 20, 30, 40 pallets. That’s right. Now what are you doing? Now what’s your overall cycle time per pallet increases, the amount of pallets you can run unattended increases, but tools still factor into it. You’ve got 40 pallets and you’re running a different mix of jobs. You’ve got 40 tools. It doesn’t really matter because you can’t do it. That’s right. So you need the tools too. So everything has to work together. That’s when you start. Yeah. If you’ve got high mix, low volume, which is a great fit. And I love that. I love that you said, you know, um, the, the pallet size, when you start to look at like, you know, going from like a little 12 inch cube and what part most guys not only can fit those parts on any of those pallets, whether it’s the workflow or some other sort of automation, but 95%, well, maybe not 95, 90% of the people are all doing three plus two. There’s no simultaneous five going all, and maybe that’s what people are afraid of. Like, oh, I don’t have five axis work.
[17:26] Yes, you do. Three plus two work is all that 95% of the people do on a, on a five axis. Yeah. I mean, I think I can speak to that. I mean, you know, here we’re a 50 year old company, right? Keith, you came up here and, you know, we were looking at stuff like, I don’t really have any five axis work. Right. And, and you showed me, I do. Yep. We’ve, we bought a five axis from you. We’ve, you know, now had it for what, five, six months, maybe something like that. Yep. And yeah, I mean, it stays plenty busy and we don’t have any, what I think traditionally would be considered five axis parts. Well, we have some, but I mean, that’s not what’s keeping it busy all day, every day. Right. It’s, it’s the stuff that was going to be four mil ops. That’s right. And now is one or whatever. And, um, I think, I think you’re right. I think that’s that old mindset of, well, that’s, yeah, we don’t have that. Right. Like we don’t need that. Um, yeah, I used to always say, and it’s, it’s still a true statement today. Um, eight years into owning Hill, we’ve only no quoted one part that required five axis. There you go. Right. So eight years, one part. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, yeah, nothing very seldom do we see something that requires it. Yeah.
[18:43] But in six months we’ve found, I mean, a countless number of parts that benefit from it. That’s right. Right. So look at engineers are designing around it. You know, we all understand the popularity of five axis. One of my great friends, you guys know him, Sven Klott at, uh, at Vineburn. I sold him his first five axis machine. He bought 10 more after that. And he said, I’ll never buy another vertical again. There’s no reason I could run the five axis, like a three axis if I need to, but it’s there to complete a part when I want to. So when you start to look at those things about having that mentality, you look at a standard three axis vertical these days. And tech take brands, XYZ, a 30 inch, 40 inch vertical. You’re gonna spend $125, 135, $40,000 on a three axis vertical loaded up probing chip mirror, high pressure, coolant, heading, chipping mirror, and high pressure coolant on everything. Right. Put those. If you want it to work, right. If you don’t want to be down. Correct. Put headache on everything. And, and then you look at a five axis. So you’re, let’s just say, let’s just say the median for a 40 inch vertical is 150 grand. So for double that three, 300 grand, you know, in some cases, in, in most cases, you’re going to find that not with automation, but a five axis is going to be achievable. And now, again, you’re getting that spindle in the cut much longer. You’re getting, you’re not having to touch the part and you just get a point where things come off the machine complete.
[20:09] You’re like, why would I ever do it the other way? And so that’s what he thought. And 11, five axis machines later, he just, he stuck to his word. He never bought another three axis vertical. So you led right into the next question I was going to ask you. So I have five horizontals. Yeah. And that was, you know, that was definitely, you know, historically where we went and we could handle, you know, maybe two to three ops at a time, whatever, um, do, do the same math on a, on a horizontal. Yeah. I mean, what’s, how, what am I looking at today on a, on a horizontal, a horizontal and then an equivalent five axis? Yeah, exactly. And again, depending on if you’re talking about a standalone unit, right. No pallet to start, you know, you could go from three to 500,000 on a standalone five axis, and you can go from, you know, five to 700,000 on a, on a horizontal. This was the greatest, uh, um, I thought, you know, kind of breakdown of a five axis versus a horizontal back in the day when it was really starting to make that, that, that change over from the horizontal to five axis. This was probably just after the recession. And Danny Selway, a great guy, great salesman. He had a shop in the Bay area.
[21:28] And this guy was looking at a two machine Mori cell horizontal, 24 pallet, two, two spindles on 24 pallets. And Danny went in with a ma’am 35 V. So at five axis, 350 millimeter vertical with 32 pallets and 330 tools. And Danny said, he says, look at the cost and the cost that then for the five axis versus the horizontal, the Delta was about 250 grand in Mori’s favor. But then Danny said, well, think about every buffer station. This still holds true. Nick, you’ll know this. Every buffer station on that horizontal is going to cost you 10 grand. So now you’ve got 10 times 24. So you’ve got to fill that up. That’s 240 grand just to get your tombstone set up on that horizontal. There’s your difference because your work holding for a five axis, whether you used a single, uh, you know, Raptor vice at that time, back in the day, or today you’re using a Lang or a Triag or a fifth axis part, whatever that means it’s half, it’s a, it’s a fraction of the cost on a horizontal. So it brings the cost difference into almost an even playing field. And you get way more out of the five axis. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, for a company that our work holding brands, flagship product is the tombstone and we see this shift and, you know, we’re still selling tombstones. Horizontals have their place, of course, but like we’re seeing the tombstones go from like, you know, rectangular shapes to more of these prismatic shapes because they’re adjusting to the shift in how the machines are being built with more, you know, five axis milling technology being popular. And I mean, we’ve, we’ve talked to some entrepreneurs who have three machines and their third machine after they have a standard mill and a standard lathe is a five axis mill.
[23:03] And then their next thought is the ones that we think are thinking the right way is maybe I don’t need another five axis mill for another 350 grand ish. Maybe I should just automate the one I already have. That’s right. And I’ll get three times the productivity because instead of it running one shift while I’m there watching it and babysitting it, it’s running at least 20 hours a day. That’s right. Because of that automation, the automation maybe costs half of what the machine costs. Yep. So now we’re doing some by the numbers math with Mike Payne and figuring out exactly how smart we are. And you’re alleviating the need for another employee, right? Then that, then you’re not bringing on another body because that, that workflow or that automation pallet system is going to handle what that body can fill. So that one guy is still going to be able to run that to your point. Like you said, early staying ahead of the machine and just making sure you’re, you’re filling it up to enough to have that thing eat all day. And that’s really the key with the, with the pallet system is just making sure you’ve got the jobs and the correct jobs in there to keep that spindle running. And that’s 99% of it. And again, right, this isn’t the end all, cause that’s not manufacturing at all. Manufacturing has a lot of different ways you could skin the cat, but an horizontal to your point still has a place because, you know, again, maybe not everything’s got an angled hole.
[24:22] Not everything’s, you know, you can set up for 10 of these and five of those and 10 of those, but it is, you know, also something you can get at from a number of different sides as well. Opt one on two sides of the tombstone, opt two on the other two sides of the tombstone. Every time you’re transferring those pallets, you’re getting complete parts. So. See that, see that’s exact. I love that he brought that up because like, if you think about real, what you’re buying is like real estate or work. And if you can put a tombstone in there and do all of the different ops and different phases on the different phases of the tombstone, it’s kind of in a way, a lot like running everything in one up on a five axis. But if you want the equivalent work envelope on a five axis mill, as you have with a horizontal, you better have a, yeah, you better have a lot of money. And you’re spot on the higher, you know, you can go from a five axis at a little 300 millimeter five axis up to, you know, a one meter and above. And when you start to get into that same pallet size that you would require that on a horizontal, the cost then jumps exponentially. Yeah. You’re spot on. Good point, Nick. So back to Sven for a second, because you talked to Paul and, or Sven talked to Paul and did a whole episode on his story. But I want to, I want to give Keith the credit he deserves here on connecting the dots between Sven and my team and my family, Tilo, his partner, who’s a huge part of the story because like, that’s why the workflow exists.
[25:48] That’s why we’re talking about the workflow is because of you really, Keith. I mean, from your perspective, tell the story of like how you saw you played Cupid and you were the matchmaker between us. Well, you know, again, Sven, God bless him, him and Garrett senior and junior at Weinberg and Carson City, Nevada. Wonderful people. Called on him forever. I mean, I’ve been in this 32 years. I probably called on Sven for yeah, 30 of those 32 years and Garrett and senior and junior are two of my best friends. Love them. But when Sven had me, this was probably, he was, I would say he was about six or seven, five axis deep when he said, I need to get something going automation wise. And I had a product for him at the time that, that was, you know, kind of one of those third party automation pallet systems that were really one of the only few out there. I mean, yes, you got a row, you got, you know, there’s, there’s people out there that play in that arena, but they didn’t fit the size or they were too big or too expensive or too problematic. And so I quoted him this, this automated pallet system and he thought, oh my God, that’s ridiculous.
[27:03] And, and, and I need tools and okay. So how am I going to get around this? Well, Sven said, Keith, no, I’m going to pass. And I went in six months later, do a shop. I’ve seen him. Of course I would see him in between then. But then he showed me the Palman, which he created from scratch to combat what I quoted him. And he basically, I come in and see this pallet system that he has running on one of his UMCs. And I’m like, you have got to be kidding me. You just came, make this from scratch. And I said, this is gorgeous. So long story short, then version two came even better. And then by the time you stepped into the arena, I had left where I was at before. And, and Sven and I always kept in contact. We still do to this day. I love him. And yeah, and said, Nick, you need to take a look at this guy. Because we were like on our way into automation and we were more of a partner to a different brand. And it was more like, I really wish Hennig had this product. That’s what it was like. I didn’t want to be a partner, a reseller or whatever. I wanted our own thing. And we’re machine designers, but you’re talking about like six months to figure it out. And it, it wasn’t a hundred percent done, but it was unloading the machine. That’s right. So it was perfect. And of course, Sven had some help here. He was still running his shop.
[28:20] He had Tilo to help him get there. Yeah. But that’s what Germans do, right? Like, oh, wouldn’t you design it this way? Yeah, we would design it that way. Well, why don’t you do it? And then they just go and they go and they go and they go. And the next thing you know, like all of his machines have his homemade automation system, software included. They found Joey, this young guy who’s in school for computer science. So like, hey, you’re going to design the software. He comes in and yeah, fast forward to today. Like what a cool story. It is, it is a shop with this culture that we’re trying to describe on this episode. Everyone’s keeping more than one machine running all the time. And yeah, just three guys put it all together. And then you made the match and we made the joint venture happen. And now Hennig Automation exists. So yeah, just so grateful for you doing that. Oh, thank you. No, and you know, that’s part of it. We just had a customer here earlier this morning. You know, we always say, even if I don’t sell you something or even if we don’t do, but use me as a tool for a resource. I have done this long enough. No, I don’t know everything, but I’ve seen enough and put enough people together. Guys will call me up. Hey, Keith, you know anybody that’s hiring and I’d get guys jobs at places and they’re still there today. And I love it. I love this industry more than you guys can even imagine. I just, I, it hit me at a young age of 23. I didn’t know what a machine tool was.
[29:41] And here we are today talking about 5-axis automation, lights out machining and work holding and pallets and tools and manufacturing from ground up. It just, it’s the best. There’s nothing better. So Keith is a tool. I mean, he’s a great tool. The rumors are true. You heard it from him. Yeah, correct. Exactly. Did I say that? Hey, everybody, you know, everyone’s pushing AI into quoting right now. And look, AI can be powerful, but in manufacturing, it can also be risky. If you don’t know where your RFQs are going, who can access them or how your data is being handled, that’s a serious problem. And that’s where we talk about secure AI. And that’s where paperless parts stands out. Paperless parts is built specifically for manufacturers. Their CMMC compliant platform uses secure AI to take the busy work off of your estimators, organizing RFQ packages, surfacing key details and centralizing your entire quoting workflow so your team can focus on actually estimating. And when they say secure, they mean it. They maintain rigorous security standards, including a FedRAMP, moderate equivalent security posture, verified by a third party assessment organization. It’s built for shops preparing for CMMC level two. If you want the speed of AI without the risk, go to paperlessparts.com. That’s paperlessparts.com. Quoting made simple, profitable and powerful. So Keith, to pull that into this, you know, what is the lights out culture? When you look at, so Sven’s a great example, and I’m sure you know many others.
[31:24] What do you think the mindset of a shop that will pursue and see that in their future versus the, this is the way we’ve always done it. We’re not changing things. Where does that mindset differentiate for you? I think the mindset is how big the customer wants to get, you know, because think about it, if a guy is going to invest in a, you know, $900,000 multi-palette, large tool change, five axis, you know, he’s going to have some work. So that’s number one. Number two is, you know, there’s a lot of guys that are out there that, you know, they’re happy, six, eight, 10 machines, and they’re okay. And maybe, you know, at some point those six to eight to 10 machines will equal, you know, a five axis or two in the shop that will help make things easier, but maybe they don’t want, you know, 60, 80, a hundred employees. So I think it’s more of the mentality of the growth that that customer wants to experience. Now, you know this, Mike, right? Sometimes your customers make you grow. You can’t really get outside of that when you’re talking to a customer that all of a sudden his products going through the roof, or it’s a large defense contractor or semiconductor company or medical company that all of a sudden is just blowing the doors off of everything.
[32:40] And you kind of have to decide, I have an opportunity to grow with these guys. So I guess in the end, you know, when you, when you have that mix of parts that are really, really at a point where you’re, you’re touching it so often, or you’re having to set it up so many different times and you get, can continually get those repetitive parts in that same fashion, you, you got to make the jump. If you don’t make the jump, you’re losing money. I think that’s the one thing I noticed when I came, not when I came to Titans, when I first started selling in Titan, he had a weird, different mentality that was how, and not that nobody thinks about this, but he was always about what the profit that spindle could make in an eight hour shift. Then, okay, I want two shifts. I want three shifts. As long as that spindle’s running, I’m making money. And he just held to that. He just was dead set on running those machines as long as they can run 24 seven. It’d be good. Follow up question to that. Um, and you know, you and I have been talking over the past week about some of my CapEx. Yeah. You know, thoughts and plans and expectations may over the next year or two. But, uh, one thing you said to me last week, uh, when we were talking about some of it is we just need to get you a little bit more automation and, um, you know, so, so here I am, I’m an established company.
[33:58] I’ve been, I mean, this is our 50th year, right? We’ve got 65 spindles. I mean, I’m not going to replace them all. Right. I mean, that would be cost prohibitive and unnecessary. Um, we’ve, we’ve made strides over the last eight years towards automation. We, we have goals of more and more automation, but where would you start? I mean, like, so for people like me, we were in business, we have an existing amount, you know, we haven’t, we have some, some level of existing work. Yeah. Um, you know, maybe some consistent, some not, where, where, where should those shops mindset be? Well, and you in particular, right, we’ve talked about this, you’re like 70, 30 turn to mill, you know, work. So, you know, I went through your shop after, you know, picking the five, you know, a B axis, you know, some guys, you know, you, you look at the five axis on the mill side of things. Well, the mill turn on the, on the turning side is just as important, right? That’s kind of your automated, uh, option for turning is having a full B axis spindle with a tool changer. You know, you can load those things up with bar feeds. You can set everything in motion to get things done in one. Cause you have a full milling spindle, two spindles on main and sub, and then a lower turret to help facilitate additional tools. Plus, you know, 40 to 120 tools in the cabinet. So for that question, you know, I think it is one of those things that as you start to see that automation process, you started it, you, you went to the five axis that was new for you guys.
[35:32] Yeah. And I think that the difference that a lot of people have to figure too, in that when they go into five axis, what is that learning curve? Well, 20 years ago, it was a lot more than it is today. You know, with AM workholding and tooling, we’re able to see that learning curve get flattened quite. I mean, side note, I mean, we were terrified of the learning curve, right? And it honestly wasn’t that bad. And we, we even made some missteps along the way and, and, um, you know, sit in the day. I don’t think anything scares us five months later. That’s right. And I think that’s an important thing to remember because as much as you can say, okay, what is that automation that I want? I always feel like if the works there and you can say, Hey, let me jump into it. Some of the, some of the options out there go from a four pallet, you know, five axis machine to a 10 pallet to a 30 pallet to your 40 pallet workflows, you know, so there there’s a level that you could step into. And then all that starts with a standalone, right? Just a standalone five to maybe put your toe in that water and feel like, okay, I’m, I gotta figure this out a little bit, maybe get a little comfortable with this before I jump into full automation. But you’re, you are automated because you’re taking parts from three, four, five ops down to one, maybe two, right. If you’ve got to have a prep op or a finish off.
[36:50] So when you start to look at it in that regard, yeah, it is worth at least entering into the five axis world, maybe even without automation. But if you’ve got a nice part mix that are repeatable, low quantity parts that come across the, the, the, the email every, every month, Hey, leave those things set up. It’s a quick, quick and easy, you know, tear down if it’s not because of the work holding these days. So it’s manageable to go ahead and change those out. Unlike the horizontals. Yeah. And you just said something, you said it earlier that I think is a myth that again, a lot of shops like, like mine that, you know, maybe have been in business for a long time. I think in Nick, both of you guys can speak to this, the, maybe the myth of, I feel like I see it every day. Oh, well, we don’t have the right mix of things to automate because we only run small quantities. And Nick, I know this is a favorite subject of yours. So you might want to take the lead on that. But Keith, do you know Brian Kippen, our buddy from CAD models? I mean, he’s the myth buster for that. Hundred percent. So he has an average lot size of five and where, where I totally agree with the, like your first article, you want to be there and take care of it, prove it out. And then as soon as you’re done, if you have four more run those later.
[38:08] So basically spend your, spend your first shift proving out and getting first article and proving your process. And then if you have, if you did that, you know, on 10 jobs and you got to run a quantity of three for all of those, you’ve got 30 pallets running over the weekend. You’re good. He’s the best. And he’s right. And those are guys, you know, too, right. I know from the early days when, when, you know, all of us at Sellway with Bill Sellway leading the charge kind of entered us into this world, right? I mean, we sold a ton of Matt Surah on the West coast and Sellway still does a wonderful job with that product line on the West coast. That’s what they’re known for. And you, you start, you, you go down that path and you, you, our customers help us get educated, right? We have the product, but they’re the ones using it every day. So when they start getting ingrained as to like a Brian Kippen does and understands the ins and outs of what that machine and that spindle can give them to give us that feedback, then we just get to go, you know, use that as a testimonial and say, God, this is how it is done. And that’s why I talk about, I mean, you brought up Triag, but I talk about Triag, not so much about how much I love the workholding, although it’s pretty cool. It’s about, I love the way that the owner runs his company.
[39:24] Yeah. So when you go there, let’s talk about the people that Lights Out Culture employs. My brothers were just over there a few weeks after I was, and he’s, he goes up to the machine and the guy’s cleaning the machine. And we’re looking at like, who does what over at that company? He’s like, oh, are you in maintenance? He’s like, no, it’s Friday. On Friday, we maintain our machines. So great. So we, so every single person who works there on the shop floor is a programmer, a setup person, a maintenance person, a machinist. And they bring in their apprentices and they level up their skills until they’re all of the above. And that’s how they have a company that can, you know, supply the entire world with their workholding products out of a small shop in Switzerland, because the machines never stop. That’s right. The efficiency or the value or the utilization of the employee when the machine never stops. Right. Matches the machine when, you know what I’m saying? Because like you got one person running three or four machines all the time, taking care of the machine, maintaining the machine. And so that’s the culture that like you see, Mike, when we, when we interview these young entrepreneurs who they’re the only guy or they got one other person and they, they fix everything. Yeah. They see it different for sure. Like the one kid who was sitting there with the first time he had a service call and he didn’t go do something else. He’s, he just hovered around the guy and asked him a million questions because he’s the maintenance guy at his company.
[40:47] That’s right. You know, the, the, you know, as, as the shop owner in this conversation, you know, and fully believing everything you guys say and you know, the, the struggle I’ve faced. So we’ve had, you know, machine tending robot on the lathe two and a half years now. Yeah. Yeah. It’s a great setup. It is a great setup. And every once in a while I, I walk, I do, you know, I’m walking through the shop floor and I see that the, you know, we had to retrofit a door opener for it to work because we put it on an older lathe. Yep. And if we decide to run that lathe because we need the capability to lay, but we’re not going to automate, we have to disconnect that door opener. Yeah. And I look up there and I see it disconnected and I, and, and I just, I kind of shake my head, but Nick, to your point, you know, we, we prove out the one part and then we’re going to run four or five, six, seven, whatever more. Right. But because it’s such a short run, we don’t, we don’t run the robot. We just, ah, we’re just going to run it real quick. And then we’ll hook the door opener back up. We’ll run, you know, we’ll automate the next job. Any, anything that you, either of you have seen out in the market to help someone like me, like translate that mindset to the floor to say, okay, well, you proved out the first part, just go ahead and put the other four on the table to, to be automated.
[42:19] Cause that’s, that’s probably the biggest struggle I have internally as a shop owner is just that mindset. They, they think if we’re not running, you know, a hundred or 200 or whatever, that it’s not worth the time. Yeah. But I think what you have to, I think the easiest thing to instill in that regard is understand that once you do set that up, you have something else you can do now. There’s always something else to do. Go maintain a machine or something. Right, right. So the mentality has to be, okay, I’m going to get this ready and I’m going to get this rolling. First article’s complete, right? So like Nick said earlier, process is proven. Everything’s ready to go. I’m going to set that up and I’m going to go run this, or I’m going to go help Mike with this, or I’m going to go help Brent with this. You’ve got that mentality that he’s got to let that just do his own thing once it’s rolling and just let him go. We always say that, right? Automation isn’t there to take jobs. It’s there to make people that much better at other- Yeah, it should upskill you and make you worth more, right? 100%. Think about it. You’re a numbers guy. I mean, so if you have a programmer, machinist, maintenance person who can run three or four machines at once versus if you had five employees, you’d rather pay the one guy a lot I’d rather pay that person three times what they make. If you’re listening and you’re that person, upskilling, go work for a shop that thinks the way Mike thinks.
[43:44] Exactly. And if you’re a shop owner, level up your employees and make sure that you compensate accordingly or else they’ll leave and they’ll go look for Mike. And Nick, I think that’s an important point, right? I do think shop owners have to take the mindset of, you know, I’m now asking this person to, you know, one, learn a new skill of the automation. Two, I mean, yes, I’ve invested in the automation. You learned the automation. You can now keep this three machine cell running because of your skills and my equipment. That’s right. I can’t pay you. I can’t pay you like you’re one person. That’s right. Right. And that’s something I think owners need to understand and do because I have heard from my own floor, the comment of, well, why? I mean, if he wants me to run two machines, he needs to pay me twice as much. Yeah, right, right. I mean, maybe it doesn’t scale exactly like that. It doesn’t scale exactly, but it does need to, you know, I think the floor does need to see the incentive that they have been upskilled, right? Or they’ve upskilled themselves or, you know, however you want to look at that. And there’s value in it for them also. So we had Ryan Bankel on. He’s the time freedom guy who kept coining that term on our episode.
[45:05] And he has a big sign and a sticker on the machines that says, if you can run this job lights out, you must run this job lights out. And then he had an employee who was learning a new CAD CAM system, and they put next to his machine a workstation so he could go through the tides of CNC videos or whatever training module he was using. And so there’s your answer, Mike. So like, and some of this comes down to like the machine monitoring metrics and how you measure like day to day shop performance. But yeah, to get that mindset, if you can run it lights out, you have to run it lights out and then show me what else you’re doing with your time. And so, you know, catching up on a YouTube video, opening and closing a door and reloading a part. And we got a lot of those too. I mean, so do we. I mean, we all do, right? Yeah, exactly. And that’s where I think it’s up to, right? The neat thing about this industry, you’re never not going to know it all. You’re going to, it’s all you learn every day. So if they do want to learn a new skill or they do want to learn something else, and there’s something for them to do. There’s no doubt. I was, I was lucky enough back in, it was 06, I got to go to Fanning, the factory in Japan and 1.4 million square feet of which like a million was manufacturing, you know, they make the robot drill, they make the wire EDMs, all the robots, but it was 1 million square feet of machine tools run by about 50 guys on the floor. And it was basically everything making the, you know, automation make, and this was back in 06, automation making, making all their parts.
[46:42] And it was so cool to see because that wasn’t anyone’s world yet. You know, we were just getting into that with horizontal machining centers at that time. And, and, and lights out was now a thing. And, and, you know, the five S’s and, you know, all the, all this stuff you learn. 5S’s, six sigmas and seven something else. Correct. And they were implementing it, of course, way before us over here. And you saw it full tilt. And I’m like, Holy smokes. It was eye-opening at that point. And guys, like you said, that were, they were, they’re changing tools. That was their biggest thing is they had to change cutting tools. Well, and, and, and think about what that does too. And I, you know, I think a lot of us are working towards this. I know we are, but that answers a couple of other problems that, that we’re all faced with too. Right. So we’re all faced with the same labor shortage skills gap, whatever you want to call it. Our friend out what Mo calls it, the, the productivity gap. Right. And that’s really what we’re trying to fill. Like if I can make somebody more productive, I can get, I might not need another person. That’s right. Um, and, and then the, um, we’re also increase, you know, we’re also facing an increasingly, well, I mean, but for, I guess for generations now, we’ve been facing this, uh, like a global competition, um, from a price standpoint. Right.
[48:07] And then, and then right now we’re in this, this reshore re-industrialization market where we need to do more for less to compete with overseas. Yeah. Well, everything we’re talking about does both of those. Right. Exactly. Covers my, covers my shortage in people. And it, if somebody, if I can make somebody twice as productive because I give them the right automation. Yep. Um, You’re kind of taking labor out of it. I’m, I’m taking the labor price and, and, you know, now if they’re Not out of it, but reducing it. Right. If it’s, if they’re $30 an hour, but I get 20 hours out of that, I get, yeah, say 20 hours out of them setting up this thing to run for 20 hours. Right. You stretch that eight hours you paid them into 20. Exactly. That’s right. And so now I’m more competitive against not only my local market, but global. And maybe I just reduced my work and, you know, I’m not looking at reduce my head count. Yeah. I’m, I’m looking to, you know, fill my capacity. That’s right. Right. And, and my capacity, maybe use your 20 hours. So you could go by hours or you could go by space. So real estate, labor. Yeah. Revenue per square foot or whatever.
[49:25] Revenue is more appropriate. Now you’re stretching that out over 20 hours instead of eight too, so. Right. That’s what still kills me. How some of these people will get these long pallet systems, you know, the linear pallet systems rather than going vertical, because, you know, the vertical aspect of real estate. And like you said, it is, it is expensive. Obviously in some areas way more expensive than others, but you know, you know, the vertical pallet systems are so much more advantageous. And then I always used to say to guys to think about this, right. If you’ve got three machines on, let’s say a 45 pallet line and that line goes down, now you’ve got three spindles down, but if you have three, 15 pallet, you know, vertical stopper horizontals, and one goes down, you still got two running. So, you know, there, there’s a different mentality around what you just said these days in terms of how you are setting up that automation. I think pallet tech or pallet linear pallet systems, man, there is better options for, for putting three machines on one line. I think these days as well. Couldn’t agree more. Honestly, as a shop, we’ve got two machines connected with 25 big, you’ve seen our big horizontal set up and yeah, like what if they were, what if there were three or four machines with four or five pallets each, because you really only need as much to get you to the next shift. That’s right.
[50:49] I don’t need, you know, 120 hours of lights out with nobody touching it. I need enough to go to bed and come back the next day, you know, or get the next guy shifted. Weekend is the longest you should really think. Yeah. Weekend shift would be the longest, right? Yeah. Like I had a great shop up in Auburn, California, Armstrong, uh, manufacturing engineering. They, they were a lot of hosses in the early days. And then they, they put a Hitachi Siki two machine, 24 pallet line in. That was their first drive into automation. And then that got to the point where Hitachi Wright went out of business and so they couldn’t get parts. And so I sold them a, uh, Matt Sura, eight H plus 300, 15 pallet vertical stocker, great size machine. And that kind of opened the door. Then they bought a four Oh five Matt Sura with 12 pallets. Then they bought a ma’am 35 V, then they bought a cube X and another man, then another key. And they just saw now they’re adding on another 20,000 square feet to this facility. And you know what the crazy thing is, even with everything they had before their profits and their profitability went through the roof, when they went to the five axis automation, it allowed them to continue to build and add towards more and more of those spindles and exit the hosses that I’d sold them in the early days. And then add onto this next, uh, facility that they’re putting at the, at the back of their building. It’s incredible.
[52:10] Again, to your point, you get that spindle running those hours, consistent consistently, and maybe it is, you know, 20 hours a day. And now all of a sudden you don’t have material standing in front of that, that machine. When you leave at night, that material is in the machine. Yeah. Hey, it’s Paul from making chips. If you’ve been burned by recruiters who don’t understand manufacturing, you are not alone. That’s exactly why we created hire MFG leaders. We’re not just recruiters. We’re current and former shop owners, and we know what it takes to lead in this industry. Whether you’re hiring your next operations leader, sales manager, or production supervisor, we’ll help you find someone who actually fits. Learn more at makingchips.com slash hire Keith. I got an idea as we close, like the last little chapter of this episode, since we got Mike cornered, why don’t we walk him through like the most affordable way between you and me to get him going with a fully automated five axis setup. Let’s go. He’s already got the five axis platform, right? So yeah, but let’s just say he does it right. Just for the sake of the audience. Let’s say you don’t rewind. Rewind. He needs a five axis mill with an automated pallet system because he heard this episode and he wants to do all this. He needs the right options. And then Mike, what I want you to be thinking about is like how you would finance it, how you would get the grants, and what kind of cash flow you would need to make it worthwhile. Okay.
[53:32] All right, Keith, start. You got verticals, right? You’re struggling. You’re touching the part. You’re scrapping parts because we all know every time we touch it, there’s room for error in touching that part and setting it up again and again. And so you’re just struggling with all these issues that you’re going, Jesus, there’s got to be a better way. And your local salesman comes in and says, I think it’s time for you to get a five axis. And that’s the first kind of step into that direction, right? Getting that part off three machines and putting it on one, not touching it. Some of the features out there are set up where you can prep and finish off of the same off the same work holding. So you can literally set your prep off, run the part, then set your finish off all in one little space. So that’s the idea around getting all those setups done. And then when you get to that point, you’re like, Hey, I’ve had very good success. And my learning curve hasn’t been that much. I got to add some automation to this. I got through the first step. You know, it is the workflow. It is something along the lines of a multiple palette. And the neat thing I love, Nick, you guys did this, right? The workflow of what comes with 20 pallets to start, right? Yeah, it can. The same unit can hold up to 40, but we don’t start people with 40 in case they’re not ready for it. Well, it’s hard to get just 40 pallets. They can build up to that order pallets later. I love that aspect of it, but that’s the ideal way to do it.
[54:50] And even 20, honestly, like compared to what’s out there, that’s pretty much equal to a lot of the more expensive, highest end options that you can get out there. So, yeah, I mean, it’s a good starting point. You may take those first 20 pallets and you may set up eight jobs to start. Let me get the ball rolling. You know, again, you’re going to buy workholding. So each pallet has their own workholding. Whether or not you want to make your own workholding. I had a customer in Sacramento. Great, great customer. I sold him a lot of masters, sold him a lot of automation. They made their own workholding. Sven makes all his own workholding. He makes all of his own. But we don’t like that because we’d rather sell him a workholding. Right, right. It takes time. It’s way too much time. Focus on making parts. I’ll make your workholding. That’s right. Mike, let’s do 80-20 here on your mill parts. Yeah. OK, don’t worry about it. If you think it’s a traditional 5-axis, blisky, weird contour deal, just your milling parts. Would 80% of them fit in a shoebox? Yeah, probably close. Maybe, yeah, 60-70. I mean, we run some little bit larger stuff. Some big parts in there. You’ve got some verticals anyway, if they’re too big for your 5-axis. OK, so with that in mind, Keith, what kind of machine would be a right 5-axis mill from you guys? In that shoebox size, yeah, you’ve got, you know, of course, the Matsura is a great option for standalone.
[56:17] But YCM, Emco, brands X, Y, or Z that have that nice 20-inch envelope, right, that’s a good sweet sauce. But 500-millimeter to 650-millimeter option, you know, you could start at 300-millimeter if your stuff was pretty small. If you’re in the medical industry and you’re quoting, you know, medical parts are great because they, you could talk about nesting those things up on some workholding. Those triac little multi, what is it? It used to be called the Sputnik, but then Russia did some stuff, so now we’ve got to call it the Space Grip. There you go. It looks like a little, like, satellite that’d be floating around in space. Eight clamping stations. Eight clamping stations. So you have that, and again, loading up how many ever pallets you want to start with is just a great, great, you know, start into that world. So as you look at that… So within that price range, you know, kind of like, what are his options depending on how, you know, crazy he wants to go with the… Like from that standalone to a multi-pallet, is that what you’re saying? Yeah, well, let’s quote him a pallet system for the sake of this episode. Yeah, so, you know, yeah, if you look at a… With the machine. With the machine. Yeah, machine with 10 pallets and 120 tools, yeah, you’re going to be right around 600K. Okay. You know, and then, you know, tool that up, you know, maybe another 50 to tool it up.
[57:35] Sure. And then you… But that’s tooled up, ready to go, workholding, software, everything you will need, lights out. That’s a 10-pallet, 120 tool. Then if you go, you know, to a 40-pallet on, like, what would you spend on that, Emco, about 400-ish? Yeah. Right? Then you add a workflow, which is what, one… 184 is our list price? Yeah. You can, like, jab Keith for a better discount, but that’s between you and him. So that’s the neat thing is, if you’re a guy out there and you’ve got a standalone brand XYZ, right? You guys are brand agnostic, Nick. I mean, you can put that damn thing on anything. But brands XY or Z, 200 grand, you’re adding something to the field to your Emco that you could get automation tomorrow on, instead of, you know, starting with another machine and a fully automated pallet system. Right. Sure. So what’s the most affordable 5-axis that you have with that shoebox envelope that you have available? I would say probably YCM. Yeah. That plus the 184 would cost Mike what? Yeah. That plus the 184, yeah, probably right around that 500 mark. I was going to say, I think you’ve quoted that to me. It was right around 500. So if you take that and then maybe you want to add the work holding into your financing with a cert or something like that, which you should definitely do.
[58:58] Now, Mike, like based on now, here’s where you shine and me and Keith learn from you because you know exactly how to cash flow this thing and what you’re going to have to pay to finance it and all that. Give us an idea kind of like what it would take for a shop in that position, not necessarily Hill, to start to see the light at the end of the tunnel. Yeah. I mean, roughly if you finance that, like if, yeah. So if you were to finance that whole thing, you had no down or anything like that, you buy the tooling cert, you know, let’s say you tack on a $50,000 tooling cert to get some work holding and some tooling and so forth, you know, a five to 550 finance on a piece of equipment, you’re probably looking in the eight to $9,000 a month range, I would have to guess. Good barometer is always $20 per thousand spent. So you’d be right about $10,000 on that. Okay. Yep. Maybe I get better terms than Keith. Yeah, correct. Good call. Very good call. They see me coming a mile away, hit this guy up. Yeah. So then, you know, Nick, you mentioned earlier like the grant piece. I mean, anytime I’m going to take on a project like that, I’m going to explore state, local, federal grants that are available. Just based on your past history, how much of it do you think you’d actually pay for? I mean, you know, realistically, depending on the grant, honestly, I mean, it wouldn’t be abnormal to see a 50% grant on that now.
[1:00:26] On the whole deal? On the whole deal. Now, a lot of that’s going to depend on how the grant’s paid back, right? So like the grant I would, my go-to grant on that in the state of Oklahoma would actually be in a refund of state payroll taxes. And in the same amount of time, I wouldn’t, you know, let’s say it’s for a year, right? I wouldn’t have state payroll taxes in the neighborhood of 250. It might be half that. So I wouldn’t necessarily in that grant get half of it paid for, but they would match me up to half of my spend. So depending on my payroll taxes, I maybe get 25% of it paid for, 30% of it paid for, something like that. That’s fantastic. But there’s a lot of other grants too, right? So there’s, and every state’s different, every, you know, so again, you can look at state, federal, local. There’s a lot of university grants, stuff like that. And lots of times you can even stack those, right? So you might be able to get a training grant from a local workforce development grant that, you know, maybe you’re going to have to spend, you know, $25,000 to get your people trained on the automation. Something like that. And that could potentially be completely paid for through a state, you know, a local trade school or something like that.
[1:01:50] So yeah, I mean, I certainly always explore grant opportunities on any CapEx I’m doing. The opportunities there for it, every one of them is so different though. You just have to explore how it works for you. Yeah. So now let’s talk about what you can charge for a good machine rate. I know it ranges. Is it regulated industry? I mean, what are the tolerances? What’s the customer, you know, all that kind of stuff. But just give me some ballpark rates for what you could charge for that machine’s time. Me? Yeah, you or, I mean, just anybody, like just a range, you know, like someone who’s, you know, what’s a typical machine rate for a 5-axis mill like that? I mean, I can tell you what, what, how we’re doing it. And I think this is a, I think this is a safe way for shops to, we, we quote it. So I made that investment, right? I bought that 5-axis. I bought that automation. I need a return on that investment. So we generally quote it like we’re not automating it, like we’re not 5-axis, you know, so, so if, if it’s going to take me four ops to run it in a non-automated, non-5-axis environment, we’re going to quote it that way. The gain that we get from running it in one op or two ops versus four or five, that’s my ROI because I’m the one that bought it.
[1:03:18] Right. Now, if I got into a super competitive situation where to be, to even get an opportunity at the job, I need to quote it that my labor rate is a third of what it would be. Then I can, and I will, but no, I mean, the way we price our stuff for two reasons. One, it’s my investment. My customer didn’t make that investment. I did, right. I want the return. And the other thing too, is because I’m not fully automated, I may not always be able to run it automated. Sure. Right. So I need that job to be priced in such a way that if I can’t run it through automation or I can’t run it across the 5-axis because of capacity, I’m still profitable. So we look at it from a labor, I mean, I’ve done the math and essentially if we can automate, if we can run 5-axis, we’re saving about 60% time in the job in both of those scenarios. So we’re running about a third of the labor as we would if we don’t run it that way. You know, if we just run it traditionally. But, you know, I mean, I priced the job in such a way that that’s my ROI.
[1:04:35] That’s right. Good call. Yeah. Yeah. So good, man. And like, I guess the point is, you know, without perfect math, that would you have to cover a month, like nine to 10 grand? Yeah. Like that should be… It’s not a huge hurdle. That should be a walk in the park if you’re running even one extra shift. If you’re running half of the automation you could run, you are crushing it. Absolutely. And shout out to Crystal, my marketing director. She built this incredible ROI calculator. Yeah. And you guys are spot on. That is the monthly, you know, outlay for a machine. It should not be the factor. You will absolutely… If you’ve got the work for it and you’re looking to be just become more efficient, you’ll see the profits go through the roof. Just taking it from those verticals to the five axis. I love that’s the way you do it, Mike. That is so smart because you’re right. Maybe that you’re quoting it, but that machine might not… That spindle might not be open that day. So, hey, I’m not going to lose. I still hold it this way. But if it is, that’s a great, great way to look at it. Yeah. That’s your gain. That’s your ROI. Well, I made the investment. And I was just going to say your investment to the customer. Just if you want to see exactly how to calculate all of this, this is a Mike Payne approved ROI calculator.
[1:05:50] We ran it. We ran it across him. I don’t think it factors grants or anything like that in there. Hennigworldwide.com slash ROI dash calculator. You can find it on our resource. And it is good. I would tell listeners to go use it if you’re considering any of this. I did go through it. It’s really, really good. And if you’re like me and you suck at math, you could just take our word for it. If you use even a fraction of what you really just invested in, you’re good. Yeah, right, right, right. Darn it. So, Keith, man, thank you so much for joining us and helping us talk about what a lights out culture really looks like. Everything from the tools that people are using, the machine tools, the technology, the people and how they think and even how they invest. Yeah. And Mike, yeah, man. It’s always great when we can use your company as kind of the case example. So yeah. After we hang up here, me and Keith will send you over a formal proposal. And I appreciate that. I appreciate that. We’ll get that right back, Nick. A hundred percent. All right. Well, we’ll close it out here. And what we always say is, look, if you can automate your machines, you’re not making chips. You’re not making chips. You ain’t making money. Bam.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect With MakingChips