By Jennifer Dubose

From First Questions to First Deals: Navigating Machine Shop Acquisitions, Ep #28

When you’re buying a machine shop for the first time, it’s easy to feel like you’re lost in the dark. I’ve been through more than 150 transactions in my career, but I still remember what it was like sitting across from my first seller—wondering if I was asking the right questions or if I was missing something important. That’s why I love conversations like this one.

In this episode of Buy the Numbers, I sit down with Jeff Lee, Operations Manager at Hayer Engineering in Singapore. Jeff reached out after listening to some of our episodes on acquisitions, and the quality of his questions made me realize they weren’t just for him—these are the same questions countless first-time buyers wrestle with but rarely get answered.

Jeff shares his story of joining his family’s 30-year-old oil & gas machining business, beginning the search for potential acquisitions in the region, and running into the roadblocks that every buyer faces: how to evaluate opportunities, when to buy assets versus equity, and what really happens when you integrate a new shop.

As we work through his list, I pull from my own playbook—what I look for in a shop, how I handle customer concentration, and why ‘people’ issues almost always end up being the biggest surprises. Whether you’re on your first acquisition or your fiftieth, I think you’ll find this conversation valuable, practical, and maybe even a little reassuring.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:43) Jeff Lee’s background and path to Hayer Engineering
  • (3:00) Why pursuing deals can feel lonely and stressful
  • (5:13) The characteristics I look for in a shop
  • (7:47) Verdant Commercial Capital makes the process smooth & easy
  • (8:25) What my acquisition strategy looks like: diversification and capabilities
  • (11:08) Asset vs. equity deals and what transfers
  • (14:13) Handling customer concentration risks
  • (16:00) Declining revenue: neglect or market forces?
  • (19:25) CapEx spending and owner age as indicators
  • (21:18) Implementing a tech stack post-acquisition
  • (23:53) Level up your workholding with SMW Autoblok
  • (24:34) Onboarding employees and infrastructure quickly
  • (27:01) Centralization vs. decentralization decisions
  • (30:17) Managing customer relationships across shops
  • (31:23) How people issues as the biggest surprises
  • (33:58) Valuation approach and doubling value
  • (39:54) Leveraging your strengths in due diligence
  • (43:49) The future of machining: consolidation and automation
  • (49:51) Grow your top and bottom line with CLA

Resources & People Mentioned

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] Mike Payne: When we build out our systems, our processes, and our people, because of the options that we’ve chosen to go with, like a pro shop or you know, whatever, a lot of those things could be done from a beach in Mexico.

Narrator: Welcome to buy the numbers. Each week we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or juststarting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to re in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.

Let’s crunch some numbers.

Mike Payne: Jeff, welcome to buy the numbers. Thanks Mike. Very excited to be here. I’ll give a little bit of a, a precursor to this and I want you to introduce yourself, but you’ve listened to buy the numbers and making chips and Machine Shop Mastery. I think you’ve listened to a lot of our shows and probably a lot of other shows.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[1:00] Mike Payne: And, uh, you had reached out with questions like, I always encourage people to do really the quality of your questions were great. And when I read through ’em all, I thought, you know what, this might just be a better episode. ’cause if, if you have those questions, then I bet a lot of other people do.

So thanks for hopping on here with me and to do this. ’cause I think it’ll probably be helpful to a lot of people out there listening.

Jeff Lee: Absolutely. And it specifically, it was Machine Shot Mastery episodes 24 and 80. Okay. Where you spoke about acquisitions. Yeah. And that’s where I just started writing down a whole lot of questions.

I think it was at the end of episode 80 you said if if you have any follow up questions, just reach out. And then I reached out half expecting you wouldn’t come back. And then you came back and your very response very helpful. So that got me even more excited.

Mike Payne: And I have to apologize ’cause I know it took a couple weeks for us to get to this point, but, but you caught me I think.

I think when you first reached out, I was traveling and then. Yeah, it’s just been kind of crazy, but mm-hmm. But I’m glad we finally got on this. So why don’t you tell the listeners a little bit about who you are and kind of where you’re at and why you had a bunch of questions.

[2:00] Jeff Lee: Yeah, absolutely. So I’m currently the operations manager at Hair Engineering.

So hair engineering is a machine shop based in Singapore. So we do oil and gas, specifically down hole tools. And it was started by my father-in-law about 30 years ago. And I got involved quite recently, about two years back. Originally I’m from the us but long story, met my current wife in the US and then moved to Singapore and then got involved in this business.

And as I started learning about the business, we started seeing, uh, opportunities to potentially acquire other machine shops in Singapore and in the region. And this has been, we’ve been exploring for about a year now. It’s been a lot of trial and error where we just speak to people that we know in the industry through our network, read things online, watch YouTube videos, listen to podcasts like yours.

[3:00] Yeah. And try to piece things together. And we’ve evaluated about five or six machine shops, but we haven’t acquired anything yet. And I think this is fantastic, the, the content that you and your team are putting out because it’s really encouraging. ’cause I think a lot of people also feel this. It can be quite lonely when you’re going through Yeah.

These, uh, evaluating these machine shops and a lot of time you’re questioning yourself, not really sure you’re kind of learning on the fly. So I’m really glad we got to connect and some of these questions I wrote down. We go through them and then hopefully other people also get a lot of value out of it.

Mike Payne: Yeah. Well, and you make such a good point there where, you know, it can kind of feel lonely and, and you know, one thing, I’ve talked about it before on some shows and, and, and anytime I’m helping someone buy or sell, this topic always comes up and I think this, maybe this will make you feel better, but also, you know, anybody listening that thinks acquisition is in their growth plans.

Mm-hmm. I, I’ve closed, I guess over 150 transactions throughout my career. Which means you’ve not closed a whole bunch more and you’ve evaluated 10, 15, 20 times that amount. Right. So, and you haven’t.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[4:00] Mike Payne: Right. This is, this is your first go at doing some acquisitions. Exactly. You know, a lot of people have a feeling either as a buyer or a seller, they’re like, oh my gosh, I’m so stupid.

Like, I can’t do this. I’m not smart enough to do this. I don’t know what I’m doing. That’s a very natural feeling, like you should feel that way. Right. I mean. Because like the point I always make to people, if you look across the world, if you’re super lucky in your life, you might do this one time. Hmm.

Right. Well, you’re, you can’t be an expert at something doing it one time very often. Right. Yeah. So, you know, I’ve done it lots of times and wouldn’t consider myself an expert at it, but I’ve just had a lot of experience at it.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: And, uh, so yeah, no, I, I, I understand where you’re coming from, where you’re just kind of sitting this like lost, like, I don’t know what’s next.

Yeah. But that’s natural and it shouldn’t let you not do it. Right. Like, you know, seek out resources like you’re doing and, and, uh, you know, hopefully what we talked about today will be helpful. So let’s get into some of your questions. Like, let’s, let’s just see what we can do to answer ’em.

[5:00] Jeff Lee: Yeah, so I roughly broke it down.

So my questions, I think you can break it down into roughly four areas. So one is evaluation, transactions, integration, and then additional acquisitions. So I think we can just start off with the evaluation part. So in the beginning. The first question I had was, what are the certain characteristics you look for or what are the things you avoid?

When you look at machine shops.

Mike Payne: Yeah. So let me preface this with the answer to probably every one of your questions. I need to preface with, you know, I have my ways of doing things and my strategies and opinions and someone else is gonna be different, right? So I’m gonna answer what I look at and I’ll, and, and where I can, I’ll try to give some guidance around other options.

[6:00] So I have a very specific target type of machine shop that I’m looking for. Mm-hmm. I have a good infrastructure of a machine shop. You’ve got one that’s been in business for a long time, so I have, you know what I call like my secret sauce, right? I’ve got my tech stack. I mean, essentially I’ve got my people, my processes, and my systems.

Mm-hmm. I’m looking for ones that my people processes and systems bring value to, right? So I don’t want to go buy a perfect shop. I want to buy a shop that is good and has a good legacy business, but that if I put my people, processes and systems on top of that. Will be better. Does that make sense? Yeah.

And then beyond that, I am, I’m looking for does it give me industry diversification? Does it give me customer diversification? Does it give me new capabilities? I mean, it’s naturally gonna gimme new capacity, right? Unless they’re already complete capacity. But the best example I can give you on, on maybe new capability, the, the shop I just bought a few months ago.

I would venture to say that my existing shop, we probably would no quote about 80% of the work they do.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[7:00] Mike Payne: And, and they would probably no quote 60% of the work we do.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: So it’s kind of weird and it’s wild. I mean, we have a lot of the same machines. We have the same types of equipment, but just the type of work we would not take in my existing shop.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: And we’ve no bid a lot of that work over the years. Well. Bolting on that capability. Now I know I don’t have to No quote that work anymore. I can run it there. And we’ve already seen that happen quite a bit in the last couple months. We’ve had jobs come in to quote, now turned into pos because we’re like, oh, we can run these over at QMI instead of hill.

So those are kind of my things. I look for a shop that I can bring value to beyond just buying, ideally gives me something that I don’t already have, right? Mm-hmm. So again. Whether that’s a customer, an industry capability, something like that. Hey guys, it’s Mike. Are you thinking about upgrading some old equipment or expanding your business?

[8:00] You need to talk to my friends at Verdant Commercial Capital. When we needed some new equipment, they made the financing process fast, smooth, and actually very enjoyable. What impressed me the most was how well they understood our industry. Verdant offers, flexible terms, quick approval, and they were just great to work with.

If you want a true partner in your corner, check out Verdant Commercial Capital. Go to verdant cc.com/numbers V-E-R-D-A-N-T cc.com/numbers, or find them on LinkedIn.

Jeff Lee: Like when you’re evaluating these shops, do you have a specific, because now that you have a portfolio of shops, are you looking more on like.

The vertical or horizontal. So what I mean by that is do you really go after shops diversifying away into different industries and different customers, or do you acquire, shop and say, okay, here’s some additional capabilities like wire cut, EDM, heat treatment, coding, which I can bolt on? Or is it just kind of, you take it as it comes, as you evaluate different shops, you just see what’s good, what works, and then go from there?

[9:00] Mike Payne: Really, in my mind, you address two of the things that I’m looking for. So in one of the ways you’re addressing that capability, right? So does this expand my capabilities? Does it have wired EEDM? Does it have a coatings of something like that? And then my industry diversification. When I bought Hill, we were 90 something percent, oil and gas we’re now 60.

Because we’ve, we have focused on growing other industries. We love oil and gas. I’m, I mean, you know how good it is when it’s good. Yeah. The problem is, is it’s not good when it’s not. Right. So, so yeah, we’re absolutely looking for indus industry diversification. Now, I will tell you, like here, regionally to me, it’s hard to get outside of oil and gas.

So even where maybe I make an acquisition that’s still mostly in that oil and gas space, now I’m looking for the customer diversification.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm. Right.

Mike Payne: Is it the same customers I already have? Because if it is and that shop goes outta business, I’m gonna get a portion of that work anyway. Mm-hmm. Right.

[10:00] Or is it a brand new customer? So, so the last two acquisitions I’ve made, each of ’em biggest customer was still in oil and gas space. They were massive customers here regionally. But neither one of ’em had I had any success getting into prior to buying that shop.

Speaker 3: Hmm. And

Mike Payne: then, and they’re massive organizations, but in both cases.

We’ve been able to take what they were doing and because of our increased capabilities and capacity, in most part, double the revenue coming out of those, those customers that prior, we couldn’t even get a phone call returned.

Jeff Lee: Yeah.

Mike Payne: So it’s, it’s kind of staged, right? Yeah. I’m looking for industry diversification.

I’m looking for capabilities. If I don’t get both, what am I getting?

Speaker 3: Hmm.

Jeff Lee: That seems like a big plus point when you’re evaluating these machine shops is can you get your foot in the door with some of these customers? ’cause I mean, you know, just as well as I do to get just knocking on the door, it can take years, right?

[11:00] To get in the door, get their trust, you get audited, you get on their A VL. Yeah. It can take years. If you even get to that point. Right.

Mike Payne: So like just, yeah. It can take years to get to RFQ. Yeah. Right. And then Lord knows how long it’ll take to actually get a po.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. This is another question I had, ’cause you mentioned that for a lot of shops you prefer buying the assets rather than the stock or the equity.

Mike Payne: Correct.

Jeff Lee: But I’m wondering because if you buy the assets, if that shop was on a customer a VL or they were audited or they have certain licensing like ISO or uh, what have you. Does that not transfer over? So if you get the, as just the assets, would you not be, aren’t you leaving that behind and you’re at a disadvantage?

[12:00] Mike Payne: So it, the answer will be, it depends. Mm-hmm. So far out of all the deals we’ve done in this space, we’ve had one customer that, that we couldn’t move over. So, okay. So let’s, let’s break that up. So we’ve always been able to transfer the ISO certs. That has never been an issue, basically. And I think one time we had to do like a recertification type thing, but it wasn’t it, it was, it wasn’t even like a full audit.

It was just kind of a we wanna come in and make sure you didn’t change the way they’re doing things.

Speaker 3: Mm.

Mike Payne: Or at least didn’t change ’em for the worst. Mm-hmm. That’s not been a big deal. I have done one asset transaction or one equity transaction of a machine shop, and that was because we talked to the primary customer.

They were actually also a customer of mine already, and their preference was to keep that vendor number separate.

Speaker 3: Hmm.

Mike Payne: So in that one instance, we did do an equity transaction, so that, I mean, I, I now have two vendor numbers with that customer, so they order from each separately, and there’s a whole lot, that’s a whole, probably a whole podcast in and of itself, but.

[13:00] Everything else. I mean, we have not had trouble. Now, the only thing I would tell you there is if, if there’s a high amount of customer concentration mm-hmm. So like any, any one customer makes up, I mean, pick your number, but def I would say definitely if they, if, if a customer starts pushing 20% of revenue, something like that

Speaker 3: mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: I would almost require, and I typically have required during the due diligence stage that we go together and talk to the customer.

Speaker 3: Hmm.

Mike Payne: And, and we find out what hurdles is this gonna cause?

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Is this gonna be a problem that I’m, you know, I current owner am selling to this person, buyer, and we need to maintain this customer relationship for the.

For the deal to make sense.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Those can be delicate conversations, right? Like as a seller, you’d be feel fearful that your customer would be like, oh man, we gotta find a new supplier. Like, what’s going on?

Jeff Lee: Yeah,

Mike Payne: right. But in, again, in my case, since I’m typically buying a shop that I can bring value to, when I’m able to sit down with their customer and say, Hey, I know they’ve done a great job for you.

[14:00] Here’s how we do things. Here’s my ERP system and how I’ve. You know, guarantee my quality and you know, I’ve got these certifications and all that type of stuff. Typically we walk outta that meeting with the customer very excited

Speaker 3: that

Mike Payne: things are not, they will only improve. Yeah. Right. They, they, they will not get worse.

They may or may not get better, but they will not get worse, and we’re bringing more capability to the table.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. On the question of customer concentration, because there are a few machine shops we looked at. Some of them are way more concentrated than what you mentioned, 20, 25%. Some are over 50%. Yeah.

Some even pushing 60, 70%. And I’m wondering, because a lot of people, they’re fearful of that. But if you have a portfolio of machine shops like yourself, couldn’t you actually absorb that risk? Because this machine shop might be 60, 70%, but then you have other machine shops to kind of balance it out. Rather than breaking up the concentration of this one machine shop, you kind of spread it out across your other shops.

[15:00] Mike Payne: Yeah, so two of the shops I bought, one shop I bought had about 90% customer concentration in one client. Uhhuh, another one had about 90% in two. And of course, again, that’s an instance where you have to go talk to that customer, right? Yeah. Like there’s, because if that customer’s going away, there’s no value in that shop, right?

So yeah. So you have to go talk to them. And you know, I mean, quite frankly in both business, in both of those conversations, I distinctly remember that the customers was scared to do more with that company because they knew they were 90% of their business.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Right. And I mean, that you’re, I found, I mean, you’re sophisticated customers, they don’t want to be your 90%.

Yeah. I mean that’s because if anything glitches. You’re gone. Yeah. Right. And um, so I think your point is excellent. Most of those have been thrilled that Oh, okay, great. You know, the, we’re gonna come in, we’re still gonna be a, a, a big customer to this new vendor, but we’re not gonna be the only customer that mean that really puts a lot of risk on their supply chain.

[16:00] Jeff Lee: Yeah. So I guess building on that, some of these machine shops, they might have very high customer concentration. Other ones that I’ve looked at, they’re, they seem to have dec, they have stagnant, if not declining revenue and also declining margins. Yep. And how do you evaluate if this is purely from owner neglect?

Like the owner’s just kind of checked out, there’s just saying cruise control, or is it. Broader existential issues or market forces or competition that’s affecting the shot? How do you navigate that? That’s

Mike Payne: a great question and I would encourage anybody that really kind of wants to take a little bit deeper dive in that.

If you’ll go back and we and editors, let’s try to get this in the show notes, but Paul Vanier and I recorded an episode maybe back in January, February this year where we talk about this $2 million cap, you know, and why can’t shops break through that?

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: And part of that, and I, and, and, and we cover some of this in there, but I think a lot of that, this industry, I think is very ripe for that declining revenue.

[17:00] You know, if you look at a lot of shops across the industry, a lot of them can get grouped into a category that you could call like a lifestyle business, right? Like yeah. I’ve grown it up to a point where like, I’m happy, I’m making plenty of money. I’ve got these great employees that are making plenty of money.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: And you just start coasting. I think that’s very, very common across this industry. Matter of fact, I think every shop I have bought falls into that category, including Hill Manufacturing when I first bought it.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: I think one of the things that you can, you can look at to have clear evidence of that or not, is if you look at their capital expenditures over the last five to 10 years as that revenue has declined, whatever that is, however, whatever that time period is.

I mean, as everybody knows, this industry is incredibly capital intensive.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

[18:00] Mike Payne: And to stay on top and to continue to grow and get better, you have to invest, right? You, I mean, you’ve gotta invest in automation, you’ve gotta invest in tooling and work holding, I mean, all sorts of things to continue to grow and, and be efficient and profitable and so forth.

And mm-hmm. So I think if you see a declining revenue stream, say over the last five or six years. That’s a very, I think a five to six year window is just about right for that, because that’s usually, in my experience, in that three to five year window when owners start to shut down and just be content.

Mm-hmm. It’s three to five years in that they start to go, maybe I’m just ready to be done. Yeah. You know, and another clear sign will be the age of the owner. You know, I mean, if if they’re in that latter part of their career, then then that’s more likely that’s the case. I mean, if, if I met a 55-year-old owner or a 60 or you know, whatever, and I saw that versus a 30-year-old, right?

I mean, I can make some assumptions that, okay, this person has just started shutting down.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

[19:00] Mike Payne: I think another clear indication is do they have a strong team around them? So if, if the owner’s been doing everything themselves. Right. They’re doing the quoting, they’re doing the invoicing. Like they’re, that’s more likely that it’s just burnout.

Mm-hmm. Versus if they’re 64 and they’ve got a, an amazing team and it’s burning down. Mm. That might be more indicative of a bigger problem. I see. But like for pure empirical evidence, I think if you look at CapEx spend

Speaker 3: mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Over the previous three to five years, whatever that window looks like, I think you’ll see that they had just quit reinvesting in themselves and, and trying to stay ahead.

Jeff Lee: Okay. On the topic of like looking at capital expenditure, looking at financial statements, are there any specific things that you look out for? So say whether it’s like free cash flow, depreciation, the payables, receivables, inventory, et cetera, anything that you look at where it’s like an immediate red flag or something that looks really good to you that just pops out within these, these financial statements.

All

[20:00] Mike Payne: of the above. I mean, it’s, I mean, I wish I could pinpoint you like this certain ratio, you know, divide this by this and times it, times this. There’s not one because everybody’s a little bit different. I will tell you one of the things I’ve, I’ve had really good success with is, you know, I just kind of compare ’em to myself.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Right? So I take a lot of those metrics that you’re about plus others. Uh, matter of fact, a lot of the KPIs I’ll judge against actually come out of like the modern machine shop, top shop survey.

Jeff Lee: Oh, the top shop benchmarks.

Mike Payne: Yeah. Yeah. You know, like where do they rank in revenue per machine or per FTE, what is their CapEx spend?

What is their profit margins? And, and like I mentioned earlier on, you know, to some degree I’m looking for ones that aren’t performing perfectly.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm. You

Mike Payne: know, again, that those KPIs give me an idea of, okay. If I can improve these numbers, what does the business look like?

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Right. If I can get them running the way I run, that’s my indication of am I bringing value to this business?

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[21:00] Mike Payne: So it’s all important, you know, I mean, you, you, you mentioned like receivables and so forth. I mean, yeah, absolutely. You need to look at what, what’s the turn on receivable? I mean, are other customers paying ’em in 30, 60, 90, or 150 days? Right. I mean, there’s, there’s a lot of aspects of the financials you have to.

Really look at and understand, but I, I tend to look at ’em and get a better picture of what I’ll be able to do with those more so than what they’ve been able to do with them. Okay. If that makes sense. I hope that makes

Jeff Lee: sense. Yeah, that makes sense. I think you mentioned earlier, and also in your other episode, you have a very specific tech stack that you’d like to implement, and I think some of the tools you mentioned, if I recall, are like pro shop datas.

I think there are a few others you like to implement

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Jeff Lee: Of once you acquire a machine shop. Who actually goes in and implements this tech stack? Is it yourself? Do you have an IT guy? Is it the GM that you install? And like, what’s the timeline in which you want to do this?

Mike Payne: That’s another great question.

[22:00] It varies kind of by technology. You know, like we’re very proficient internally, like with our pro shop ERP system. Mm-hmm. So from a implementation of the software, it’s really. It’s, it’s more of a training issue than it is the actual putting it in there. Right? It’s not really a big deal.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: So, again, I’ve got people, processes, and systems that I need to onboard this new company to our people, processes and systems.

Right? So every part of our organization and our process is owned by somebody, right? So it really, the first step we’ll take is identifying who’s gonna own those processes in the new company. And it may be just ourselves, right? They may not have that. Infrastructure to, I mean, they don’t have a scheduler and they don’t have a purchasing person and all that type of stuff.

Um, or maybe they do right. But you still, every part of the process has to be owned. Right. So

Speaker 3: yeah,

Mike Payne: and that’s just issue of training. I mean, I think one of the beauties of the, kind of the tech world we’re in right now when we talk about a tech stack mm-hmm. So whether it’s our pro shop or data nos, whatever, you know, it’s all SaaS, right?

[23:00] It, and the, the support is offsite but available 24 hours a day almost. Right? So it’s, I don’t have an internal IT team that goes out and does all that stuff. I have an IT group that knows my tech stack and they know that we like this brand of. Routers and wifi and access points and all that type of stuff.

And they know this is how we configure our PCs and this is, you know, our, like our shop floor PCs and you know, we use this Microsoft 365 configuration. Mm-hmm. All those types of things. And you know, this is how we organize teams and OneDrive and all that. So, I mean, there is a hardware component to it and a software configuration component to it, but that part happens.

Remarkably fast with just having the right people around.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Right. And having the right, like I think that’s gotta be part of choosing your tech stack.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Is having people, and especially if you have growth through acquisition in mind, it’s choosing. Vendors and partners that can support that.

[24:00] Fellas? Hey, well I got you both real quick. So I’m really trying to drill in like our work holding options at Hill and all of our shops. Any advice,

Speaker 6: Mike? It’s as simple as Raz. Ramm

Mike Payne: as what?

Speaker 6: Raz Ramm. You’ve never heard of it?

Mike Payne: I have not,

Speaker 7: Paul. What Nick is referring to is the seven habits of highly effective work Holding

Mike Payne: that makes more sense,

Speaker 7: repeatability, accessibility, scalability, reliability, adaptability, and modularity.

Speaker 8: If you wanna find all of these principles in one catalog, check out the SMW Auto Block Catalog. You can find it at smw Auto Block. BLO k.com.

Jeff Lee: Thanks fellas. Yeah, like to implement the, I guess, the hill style of running a machine shop. Like how long, what’s the, the fastest you’ve done it and what’s the longest it’s taken?

[25:00] Mike Payne: Um, the real answer probably is it’s never ending, right? Because hopefully you’re always building and improving, but the reality is. You know, by the time we like, and I’m just trying to think with this most recent acquisition, you know, we, we were onboarding 35 people and, you know, 20 something machines. I mean, so, you know, it’s, there’s a lot going on there.

We had the employees onboarded within the first week. I think it was, might, you know, might have been 10 days. Mm-hmm. You know, and that’s, so that’s getting all the employees onboarded through our HR partner. We use a PEO that, you know, so they just kind of come in, they’re like, boom, sign up here. You know, and now boom, we switch over payroll, right?

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: And then we had pro shop install to be able to start collecting. You know, if nothing else, you gotta start collecting. Clock in, clock out data, right? So that you can pay people that takes all of a day to get that at least there. And all they, and all, all you’ve done at that point is train ’em on.

Here’s how to clock in, here’s how to clock out, right?

Speaker 3: Yeah.

[26:00] Mike Payne: Now, from there, in this most recent one, then our next step is to like get the IT infrastructure in place, right? So even the data of coming in out of the building, right? So we had to upgrade our internet connection. We had to put in our routers and our access points.

With that, we go ahead and we use, I think it’s called Unify. So they’ve got, you know, that, that now works with our camera systems and some access control and stuff like that.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: You know, that takes, you know, say a week to get in and get configured. All that poured over all your Microsoft stuff, your, you know, I mean, it, it, it probably can be done in a month, um, but it’s also never ending.

Yeah. It’s like

Jeff Lee: constant upgrades, constant tweaks you’re finding. Right? And I think you also mentioned you acquire shop and you learn new things from that shop too, right? And then you take it and apply it to other places,

Mike Payne: right? So some stuff you don’t change, right? Yeah. You, you learn something great from the shop you bought and now you’re trying, now you’re reverse engineering or that back into your existing portfolio, whether it’s, I mean, it could be as simple as a handbook policy.

[27:00] You know, I’ve, I’ve never bought a shop. We didn’t learn something from that. We took. Something that they did that was better than the way we were doing it and pull it back in across the entire portfolio.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. How do you think about centralization versus decentralization? Like how much of, and specifically a lot of these shops will have similar like roles across that, like for example, maintenance, it, purchasing.

Yeah. Uh, customer relationship. Like how much of that do you push it to each individual shop and how much of it do you push it up? On to the group level or, or to the, the upper level, and then have someone from HQ handling those things,

Mike Payne: right? Yeah. So again, I, I think this is one that clearly depends, right?

So, you know, I may acquire a shop that has a better purchasing person than what I currently have. Well, now I need to loop them in to that purchasing process. Differently than if they, you know, they just have someone that does it on the weekends. Right? So, and a lot of it’s also gonna depend on what needs to be site specific versus can be done from anywhere, right?

[28:00] So again, when we build out our systems, our processes, and our people, because of the options that we’ve chosen to go with, like. A pro shop or you know, whatever. A lot of those things could be done from a beach in Mexico.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: That’s gonna help determine what you have to do locally versus not now. I mean, obviously I don’t have work from home machinists.

Right. So at at that level, obviously they’re gonna be where they’re at. Yeah. To some degree that’s true of maintenance, but not entirely. I guess it depends on how spread out you are, you know? But as you work through that chain and each individual piece of the process, I just think you have to look at. Do I have the capability to do this remotely or not?

And mm-hmm. You know, so the one, the things you can’t do remotely, you gotta have people on site at everywhere. You’re at the other processes. I mean, ideally, I mean, kind of the, the more you get into the office, ideally that can be done from anywhere, right? I mean,

Speaker 3: yeah.

Mike Payne: Our accounting package is online.

[29:00] Right. And I handle our finance and accounting, since that’s my background. You know, I was in Europe for two weeks earlier this year. I still did my job every day. ’cause I can, yeah, just having a laptop, I’d spend 30 minutes every morning or, you know, whatever. A lot of it’s gonna depend on the technology you have in place and how much you’ve standardized that across everything.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: You know, again, it’s gonna, it is gonna depend on your current organization and the organization you’re buying, but I think the key thing, and, and this is whether it’s a process or even a part, we, what we look at when we, when we do these acquisitions is everybody will understand this. I wanna run every part we run, I wanna run.

On the machine and or machines or machinists that can be the most efficient. Right? So yeah. So when we make an acquisition, there’s oftentimes a shift in where things are made.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Right? So if I might be making a part at Hill that we’ve been making for 20 years, but I just made an acquisition that they can make it better because they have a different piece of equipment.

[30:00] Maybe I don’t have enough bar feeders to always run this part on a barfed lathe. And they’ve got five. Mm-hmm. Right? So there’s always capacity to run that on a bar fed, lay. That job’s now gonna be run there, right? So think about it from a part level. You’re gonna wanna run those parts wherever they run the best.

And I would say the same thing about purchasing or sales or like you want to, you wanna take your best resources and put ’em on that process.

Jeff Lee: Yeah, like taking that example, that customer relationship, would it move from that original shop to the the new shop? Or like how would that work? I

Mike Payne: don’t make my customer go through, like setting up new vendors and do stuff.

We just outsource it to the other shop. I see. So the PO would still come to me. I issue a PO through the other shop. We have like an intercompany shop rate that we charge each other.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: And then, you know, we just. Pay each other, and that way I still have a true financial picture of each shop.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: But yeah, you could also say, Hey, well we want to get this company set up with you, Mr.

Customer, and there’s nothing wrong with that. I just try to make it as seamless for the customer as possible.

[31:00] Jeff Lee: Yeah. Say you have one shop, another shop, and then they’re both serving the same customer. Do you have those two salespeople still talking to that customer, or do you. Concentrate the customer relationship to one person,

Mike Payne: it would be customer dependent, but I would, I would tend to want to consolidate that to who has the best relationship.

Speaker 3: Mm.

Mike Payne: But if I felt like I, it was advantageous to have both those relationships, I would have both those relationships.

Jeff Lee: Okay. Has there been anything like repeatedly where after you acquired a shop, you just got like bitten in the ass, or it’s like, okay, this has happened like two or three times. And like something you can just highlight to everyone where it’s like, this is something that has like come up and like bitten me a few times.

So just be careful.

Mike Payne: That’s such a great question. I’m trying to think if there’s any like commonalities. I, I, I will say, I think one thing I pride myself on is learning from my mistakes. Mm-hmm. So I don’t know that there’s been anything that’s got me multiple times.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: I think what I would probably say, that’s the most general statement that I can make.

[32:00] Across. Every time you do it is it comes down to people. And every time you’re talking to a seller, of course you wanna understand their people. Right. And what everybody’s roles are. And, and there’s always opinions from the seller of like, these people are gold. Right? Like, I couldn’t have, I couldn’t do it without ’em.

Oh yeah. And then the, then there’s always a group of people that are like, yeah, you know. They haven’t even been here a year. They just show up and they’re, they’re here for a paycheck. And I can tell you in every instance, like if I just took that as gospel, I would have a lot more stress. ’cause there’s always those people that are critically important to the seller that don’t float over to you.

And there’s a variety of reasons. They’re so loyal to the seller. They don’t like change. I mean, there’s a lot of reasons that those, there’s a few of those or some percentage of those. That, that just can’t make the leap. But then there’s also always some of those that are at the bottom that the seller tells you, you know, you could get rid of these people.

[33:00] There’s always a few of those too, that may be under new leadership, may be under seeing change. They like, they thrive with change. You trigger some sort of excitement with them where they become some of your best.

Speaker 3: Yeah,

Mike Payne: so most of the time I’ve been bitten in the ass. Has to do with people.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: More so than anything else.

So I guess my most general statement I would make is, you know, get that feedback from the seller, but don’t just bank on it and give people time to adjust to you. Don’t go in and just say, okay, well they said this person’s not any good, so I’m gonna lay off these two or three people ’cause we have too many.

Yeah, give them three months, six months, a year, you know, whatever. And see what they do with you. And then, and then, then vice versa on the good side because. I have been fought by the, you know, the people that were running the company have been some of my biggest hurdles to, to accept change and accept our people, processes and system.

That’s probably the most generalized advice I’d give there.

[34:00] Jeff Lee: Do you have like a specific return target or like an IRR or, I think in the private equity world, a lot of people, they use this term moic, MOIC. And IRR as well. Like do you have a target in mind or is it just no target? I just go out and take what’s good.

Mike Payne: So, I mean, you can go Google and get a whole list of IRRs and m and all sorts of stuff, and there’s value in all those calculations, especially to like bankers and, you know, financial executives and so forth. I tend to break it down a lot more practical. So remember when you asked me about, you know, are there some key metrics that I’m looking for?

[35:00] And, and I mentioned that there’s benchmarks I’m look looking for in a lot of ways. Some of it’s financial, some of it’s not. So when I do like a valuation, very typical. I mean, I’m no different. I look at generally three years history, right? And calculating EBITDA and apply a multiple to it. The other thing I do though, in my spreadsheet, so I’ve got the previous three years and then I’ve got another column sitting out here of what does the current year or the most previous year?

This is my first column. What does it look like if I operate it my way? Hmm. Right. So I, I usually assume no revenue bump, just so if I just do the exact same thing, but I operate it my way. So I have my efficiency numbers, I have my revenue per machine. FTE per machine, those types of things. Well, which does actually sometimes translate to a revenue bump.

But if I operate their existing business, the way I operate my existing business, what does it look like? And then I apply my, what I believe my multiple is not what I’m buying them for, but what I would sell for.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: Right. And if it’s not two and a half times the value, then I’m not all that interested.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[36:00] Mike Payne: And it, it doesn’t mean that I’m gonna, I mean, I know that it’s gonna take me time to operate their business the way I operate my business. Mm-hmm. So it doesn’t mean that. On the day of close, I’ve doubled the value, but what it means is that in, you know, a, a a 6, 12, 18 month window, I believe I can get it there, then I’m okay.

Yeah. And then you do have to look at, you know, like if you’re doing bank financing on an acquisition, you do have to start then looking at, you know, the more detailed, like you asked about. Does it start to break any bank covenants? Does it, Hmm, if, if I do this and I’m getting bank financing, that does, does now my combined balance sheet and income statement.

Am I, am I covering my fixed cover charge? Like the, the things like you’re bringing up? Am I still in good parameters? But typically you will be. If what I said is true, I don’t know if that helped, but that’s how I do it.

Jeff Lee: Okay. I think doubling in in value. Right. 12, 18 months. That’s crazy.

Mike Payne: Well, it is, and I think it was, I’m assuming it was episode 80, whatever you said, of machine shot mastery where, you know, we talked about, you know, how does Mike four X’s money in a couple years?

[37:00] And, and that’s how, right. Because the typical scenario is I know that if I just operate their existing business

Speaker 3: mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: The way I operate my business. I’ve doubled the value now, if I can grow it at all, right? If I can then grow that revenue with the existing customers, or my existing customers or new customers, I’m gonna start, you know, three times, four times x my valuation.

Cool.

Jeff Lee: So. Those are all the questions that I had. I think, I know it was a very long list, so, but I’m glad we made it through.

Mike Payne: Well, I loved this. I think this was so good. ’cause I think it covers, you know, again, I’m sure a lot of people sit out there and listen. It’s like go all the way back to what we talked about at the very beginning where.

I, and I know I can be guilty of this. I’ll talk about some of this, like, it’s super simple.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Because I’ve done it a lot of times and I really have, and I’ve done it across multiple industries. I’ve done it, I’ve just done it a lot of times, and it’s super easy to sometimes talk about it, like it’s just no big deal.

[38:00] Like surely everybody understands what I’m talking about. It’s no different if I’m talking to, you know, I, I’m not a machinist. I didn’t grow up on the shop floor. I don’t know how to set up and run the machines. Hmm. And when I sit in a meeting, you know, a planning session with, on a new part or something like that, everybody in the room talks about stuff that sounds super simple to them, and I don’t know what the hell they’re talking about.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: And I know when I get on these type of topics, you know, it just in your head, you just know it and you kind of lots of times skip over stuff and, and don’t dive into the details like the stuff you’ve asked about. So hopefully this is. Valuable information for a lot of people.

Jeff Lee: Yeah, and I think especially in machining, a lot of people are really good operators and like you mentioned, a lot of these, the founders and the owners, the people who are looking to acquire, they came from machining background, so they’re really good at machining.

Their technical knowledge is very strong, but not necessarily, they don’t have the investment banking, the investor, the private equity background. Right,

Mike Payne: right.

Jeff Lee: And a lot of this financial stuff in initially can be very intimidating, but. I think it’s like for myself, ’cause I don’t have that background either.

[39:00] It’s, I found it just getting the reps in, so just looking at machine shops, just talking to them and doing it over and over and over again. Yep. You just get more and more comfortable. Right.

Mike Payne: And that’s such a great way of putting it is, I mean, yeah, just putting the reps in and, and I mentioned this early on too, where you know, if I’ve closed 150, I’ve been in due diligence and not closed probably that many again.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

Mike Payne: But to even get to due diligence, that means, I mean, you’ve looked at probably 10 for every one.

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: Right. So if I’ve been in due diligence a couple hundred times and it means I’ve talked to thousands, right. And, uh, so yeah, it’s getting the reps in and it’s, it’s seeing red flags. It’s mm-hmm.

[40:00] Seeing green flags and, and just, you know, as you practice that, you know, I mean, no different than my machinist can hear a drill going dull. Right. Yeah. I can hear a deal going bad. Right? It’s, you just mentioned, uh, one thing that, that made me think of this too, when we were talking about things you look for that, that I kind of left out.

So I would also encourage people to draw on their strengths, right? So if your strength is that you were a machinist and now you’re running a business and now you’re looking to acquire, what do you know best? Well, you probably know the shop floor piece a hell of a lot better than I know it, right?

Speaker 3: Yeah.

Mike Payne: So. Spend your time out there looking for that red flag. You know where, where I can hear a deal going bad and you can hear a drill going bad, you know, you know, listen for the drills going bad. One of the things I always do in due diligence on a shop is I’ll, I’ll pull 10 to 15 of their best jobs. And that can be defined by a lot of things, right?

Things that run all the time. That can be. What they consider to be the most profitable. I mean, there could be a lot of things that call it their best, but I want a, I want a representative cross section of the parts they run, and then I, I don’t tell my internal team that we’re quoting this like we might be running it.

[41:00] Hmm. I generally get it to ’em like, Hey, I was talking to a shop. They’re looking to outsource some parts, quote this. Right. So if they just look at it just like any other customer, and then you can start comparing, okay, how do I price jobs? How versus how do they price jobs? And a, again, every shop does things a little bit differently.

They have different equipment, they have different capabilities, and you’ll get a picture of, is this company making money on the jobs or not? Yeah. You know, are they, I mean, ’cause you know, so I didn’t know that when I bought Hill and you know, I quickly found out on two of our three biggest customers, you know, we had not job costed.

We just knew they were good customers and we were, and, and those two of the three probably made up 50% of the revenue at the time. And I would venture to say 75% of the work we did for them was pretty close to break even, because some of the pricing at that point was, you know, pushing 10 years old. It was that bread and butter work that you just know you’re good at.

[42:00] And no one ever looked at it again. Right. But you didn’t look at the fact that you’ve had labor increases and material change. You know, a lot of stuff. And again, go back to that. Is this a, is this a natural decline in the owner stepping away, or is it, well, those things happen, right? They quit job costing.

They quit re quoting jobs. They quit looking for ways to run something better. And eventually you, you know, your, your, your margin just starts getting closer and closer and closer or tighter and tighter. You know, that first year to two that I owned Hill, I mean. You know, you’re taking 50% of your revenue and you’re going, uh, Hey Mr.

Customer, I need to increase the price on this. And they aren’t loving you. Like, they’re right. They’re like,

Jeff Lee: like, who are you?

Mike Payne: Yeah. They’re like, you just bought this company and came in and raised all my prices 20%. Like this is not a good relationship. Yeah. We worked through that and, and you know, through a lot of transparency, you know, just showing them our job costs.

[43:00] Well, I can’t keep making it for 2% margin. Right? Like, where are you comfortable? Right? Yeah. And we’d get it to 10, we’d get it to 12 and you know, finally start getting back towards shop rates that, that were sustainable. But again, the reason I bring that up is if, if, if that’s where your strength is, lean on it.

Right? Like my strengths on the financials. So I, I certainly can dig into financials and I can measure against KPIs, and I can reforecast performance. Yeah, that’s where my strength is, but, but there’s a lot to be said for just knowing how to run parts and how a shop runs, and also being able to just look at what they do and know if you can do it better or not.

So I mean, everybody needs to take their own angle. Yeah. And decide, you know, what’s important to ’em. But yeah, at the end of the day, I mean, if you combine all those things together and everything still feels good, it’s probably gonna be a good acquisition.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. I guess one bonus question, and this is just my curiosity, is.

[44:00] Where do you see machining or the, uh, the industry going over the next 10, 20 years? Because you see a lot of these older folks starting to retire. And it’s quite alarming, right? Because there’s a lot of knowledge and know-how that’s just retiring.

Mike Payne: Yeah.

Jeff Lee: And if, if young people or people like yourself also go acquire these shops, they’re just gonna disappear.

So, and the capacity disappears.

Mike Payne: First of all, I have to point out, I love how you said young people or people as such as yourself.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. I take that back. You, you’re also, you’re also young.

Mike Payne: No, I’m not

Jeff Lee: young people. Like all of us.

Mike Payne: No, just kidding aside, you, you just addressed. Like all the issues we’re facing.

Right. Um, as an industry, I think you’re gonna see a lot of consolidation. There’s gonna be less shops 10 years from now than there are today, but I bet the average size goes up. Right. I think there will be a fair amount of consolidation because of people that want to acquire and try to keep some shops alive.

[45:00] But I I, I think the bigger thing is, you know, with advancements in automation and AI and. All those types of things and, and, and a and a good tech stack. You know, I think, I think those things can improve productivity and efficiency to a point where not only will shops be larger and have more spindles and more employees than the current average.

There also I think will be much more efficient.

Speaker 3: Mm.

Mike Payne: I think the advancements you’re seeing in those things and, and the investments in work holding and tooling technologies and all those types of things are gonna make everybody have to be a lot more productive to be competitive. So I think the average size of your machine shop, if you base it off, like number of spindles, could nearly double.

And then I think with the efficiency gains that those types of people that are acquiring shops and looking to grow such as yourself, I think you’ll also be making a lot of CapEx investment. In productivity tools, whether that’s in the front office or on the shop floor. So I think the average shop spindle size will grow.

[46:00] Employee size will shrink and output will double. Mm. Triple maybe. Yeah, because I think the market demands greater and greater efficiency. And I also think you’re gonna see more and more turnkey type shops that you know are, are doing everything from raw material to install ready parts. Yeah.

Jeff Lee: End to end.

Yeah.

Mike Payne: Yeah. Versus just cut it and send it back to the customer and they send it off for coatings and everything else and they’re buying o-rings and bolts from, yeah. Somebody else, I think, I think you’re gonna see more and more just like I can, I can provide you the entire value chain. Yeah, that’s just the one PO solution right here.

The one invoice solution, that’s certainly where we’re trying to build our company. What we’re calling it internally is just install ready parts. So we deliver our customer apart, I mean, with the bolts that they need to bolt it to the other thing, right, or whatever. I, I do think there’s gonna be a major disruption to, with the, you know, what you could call manufacturing as a service market that’s growing.

So I think you, I think you’re also gonna have these. Absolute mega shops, you know, these a hundred million dollar shops.

Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.

[47:00] Mike Payne: You know, like a send cut sends doing, you know, something like that. I think that’s going to commoditize a part of the market. I think it’s also gonna increase the value of everybody else because there’s, there are, there is a family of work out there that, that, that model fits really, really well for, which is just gonna make the stuff that doesn’t fit that model like the super high complex.

You know, working with the engineering team, DFM services much more valuable. So I think, yeah, I mean, I, I, I think you have to invest to sort of compete with some of that and like have the automation and the, and the services and the technology to provide a customer a better experience. But I, I think the customers will also value that more than they currently do.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. Cool. Anything else you wanna add on, Mike?

Mike Payne: The only thing I want to add is like, I’m super excited that you know, someone such as yourself is exploring all this, and, uh, I hope that there’s thousands and thousands more of you because our industry needs it.

Speaker 3: Mm.

[48:00] Mike Payne: I’ll I’ll say the same thing that caused you to reach out to me.

I’ll say it again, which is, seriously reach out to me. I mean, I, I love these conversations. They give me energy, they gimme excitement about where the industry’s going. And if I, you know, if, if there’s anything I can do to help, I want to help. Mm-hmm. You know, I’m happy to talk valuation models, I’m happy to talk, you know, those KPIs I look at, I’m, I’m, I’m happy to go through those things and share any of that information that someone might find valuable.

Jeff Lee: Yeah. And, uh, how can people find you, Mike? What’s the best place?

Mike Payne: Well, right here on the podcast. Yeah. Um, for one, but yeah, LinkedIn and yeah, I, I, I, I tend, LinkedIn’s probably the easiest thing. I tend to be there the most, but, but I’m gonna reverse that question ’cause I, I, I suspect there’s gonna be a bunch of people that want to talk to you after this.

So,

Jeff Lee: yeah.

Mike Payne: How do people get in touch with

Jeff Lee: Jeff? Uh, LinkedIn is probably best, but if you search on LinkedIn search Jeff J. Lee, ’cause they’re, it’s gonna be 10,000. Jeff Lees. So

[49:00] Mike Payne: there’s a couple, Jeff Lees, you know, and, and I’ve got your contact information. So. You know, assuming it’s okay with you, if any of the listeners wanna reach out and talk about any things that, that you heard Jeff say today or reach out to me, I’ll connect you.

Jeff Lee: Yeah,

Mike Payne: absolutely. But yeah, Jeff, this was great. Thanks so much for, for coming on and, and, you know, being willing to share where you’re at in the journey and, and ask your questions. And I think this will be a really, really valuable for a lot of people and, uh, yeah,

Jeff Lee: it’s awesome. Yeah. And thanks so much for inviting me on.

Definitely learned a lot. And I think I’ll def I’ll have another set of follow on I’ll probably be sending you, uh, in the near future.

Mike Payne: Yeah. Who knows? Maybe we’ll need to do a part two. A part two. Yeah. Yeah. That’d be fun. Definitely. So, yeah, with that, uh, listeners, thanks for sticking through this and uh, yeah, reach out to me.

[50:00] Reach out to. If you have any questions, and um, we’ll, we’ll talk to you next time. Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring, improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation, maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business rate to sell at CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more.

Every day CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings, like one manufacturer that boosted capacity and revenues by 15 to 20%. Visit c connect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.

Connect with Jeff Lee

Connect With Buy the Numbers

Subscribe to Buy the Numbers

on Apple + Spotify

Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.