By Jennifer Dubose
How to Hire Top Talent for Your Machine Shop When the Best People Aren’t Looking | Ep. 549
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
You need a machinist. You post the job, ask around, and start sorting through resumes. But here’s the question that’s harder to answer: Why would someone who already has a good job leave it to come work for you? “We have a great culture” probably isn’t enough—especially if you can’t explain what that actually means.
Recorded live at IMTS 2026, we sat down to talk about what it takes to connect good manufacturing companies with the right people. Through HireMFGLeaders, they combine recruiting expertise with the perspective of manufacturing leaders who have made—and learned from—their own hiring decisions.
Mike shares why one of the most valuable parts of working with the team happened before he ever saw a candidate. A two-hour intake call forced him to answer questions about Hill Manufacturing’s future, what made his best employees successful, and what he actually needed beyond someone to run a mill. Those questions matter whether you use a recruiter or handle hiring yourself.
We also get into finding talented people who aren’t actively looking, keeping relationships with former employees, getting honest feedback on compensation, and recognizing when you’re overselling an opportunity—or scaring a good candidate away. If hiring always feels like an emergency, this conversation gives you a few questions to answer before you post the next opening.
What’s Covered in this Episode
- (0:50) We’re at IMTS 2026 with billions in equipment, but who’s going to run it?
- (1:14) Meet Trevor and Myles with our recruiting firm, HireMFG Leaders
- (1:48) Onboarding: Moving past “I need a warm body” to the shop’s vision and roadmap
- (4:26) Why culture fit matters as much as talent
- (5:48) Brooke on finding the best fit instead of digging through resume stacks
- (6:53) Why good companies and good people often don’t find each other
- (8:16) Headhunting top talent that isn’t looking
- (10:10) Coaching employers on what an expert really costs
- (11:41) How the employer-employee dynamic has shifted for Mike over five years
- (13:11) Internal branding, Sparky, and employee pride
- (15:02) Get more out of every setup with Kennametal
- (15:51) Trevor’s path from engineering intern to leaving and coming back
- (19:38) Top intake questions, starting with where your business will be in five years
- (21:51) Who would you clone, and what do they have in common?
- (22:50) What you offer a candidate that others don’t
- (24:03) Add AI chat to your website with Navu
- (25:15) What sets Hire MFG Leaders apart from other recruiters
- (27:36) Knowing the language and delivering two or three top candidates
- (30:45) Why temp agency and LinkedIn resume floods waste your time
- (32:10) Increase spindle uptime with the Hennig Workflow Automation System
- (33:00) Why owners shouldn’t try to be their own recruiter
- (36:36) Anonymity, competitor conversations, and compensation negotiations
- (43:10) What it costs: 25% of base salary, contingency-based, with a 60-day guarantee
- (45:44) The reward and the pressure of shaping someone’s career
Resources Mentioned
Connect with Myles Rickerd and Trevor O’Malley
- Hire MFG Leaders
- Connect with Trevor on LinkedIn
- Connect with Myles on LinkedIn