By Jennifer Dubose

Legacy, Liquidity, and the Long Game: What Really Happens After the LOI (Part II), Ep #25

If you think selling your business is just about getting the highest number, think again. In Part II of my conversation with the all-star team at CLA—Erin Mickels, Mike Britten, and Mike Pohl—we dig into the fine print that can make or break your deal after the handshake. From LOIs to sales price allocations to working capital battles, this is where the real money is won or lost.

We start with what seems like a formality—signing the LOI—but as you’ll hear, that’s often the moment your leverage walks out the door. I’ve seen it firsthand: missed tax planning, bad rollovers, vague language that bites back later. This episode is all about what to watch for before you sign and how to avoid rookie mistakes that can cost you millions.

Then we dive deep into the deal mechanics that trip up even seasoned sellers—working capital disputes, earnout illusions, and how sales price allocations affect what actually ends up in your pocket. If you’ve never had a deal derailed over working capital, you’re lucky. But most sellers? They’re not ready for that fight—and it’s why deals fall apart at the 11th hour.

And once the wire hits your account? That’s not the end—it’s the start of a whole new challenge. What do you actually do with that liquidity? How do you avoid the tax bomb that comes a year later? How does your risk profile shift when you’re no longer a builder, but a steward of capital?

If you’re serious about getting full value for the company you’ve spent a lifetime building—this episode is essential listening.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:15) Grow your top and bottom-line with CLA
  • (1:54) Structuring employee retention bonuses after a sale
  • (2:55) Why you shouldn’t sign an LOI without legal and tax review
  • (11:02) What buyers scrutinize during financial due diligence
  • (11:45) Working capital and earn-out frameworks
  • (14:18) The challenge of valuing work-in-progress (WIP) in deals
  • (16:51) The importance of post-close working capital adjustments
  • (17:57) How sales price allocation impacts your tax bill
  • (21:44) How ProShop ERP can help you achieve on-time delivery
  • (24:12) Understanding which assets are taxed at ordinary income vs. capital gains
  • (25:40) How earnouts tied to employment can trigger wage tax
  • (27:15) What to do (and not do) after receiving your payout
  • (29:40) How selling changes your risk profile and investment approach
  • (32:08) How to value fully depreciated assets in a business sale
  • (34:40) What determines your company’s EBITDA multiple
  • (36:06) Mike’s “psycho spreadsheet” for modeling post-acquisition performance
  • (38:12) Valuation as both art and science in the lower middle market
  • (42:08) How Qualifying Small Business Stock (QSBS) can help you avoid federal taxes
  • (44:18) Why complex tax strategies require early planning and good advisors
  • (45:44) Stay tuned for Top Shops 2025 registration!

Resources & People Mentioned

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] Mike Payne: You can sell your company for whatever you want, but at the end of the day, the buyers can expect a certain something in response to that, right? I think from a tax perspective, you know, when you look at the net value of a transaction, where I see people probably get hurt the most is in that sales price allocation.

[0:20] Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring, improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation? Maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business ready to sell. At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more every day.

[0:40] CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings, like one manufacturer that boosted capacity and revenues by 15 to 20%. Visit c connect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line.

[1:00] Narrator: Welcome to buy the numbers. Each week we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or juststarting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to re in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.

[1:20] Let’s crunch some numbers.

[1:30] Mike Payne: Welcome back to By the Numbers. This is gonna be part two of the episode I recorded with a great team from Clifton Larson, Allen in their beautiful connection center in Minneapolis, Minnesota, talking about how to prepare your business for sale and like kind of all the steps you should go through to do that.

[1:50] So there was a lot of information there. So we took a break last week. We’re gonna come back this week, talk about this next part of the process. And, uh, I think you’re gonna learn a lot of good stuff. So let’s go. Can I drop in a recommendation as a buyer, if you wanna take care of your employees, offer ’em a retention bonus after the transaction.

[2:10] And I say that because, you know, most companies have those people that you’re telling the buyer, oh yeah, these people are really important. I’ve seen more than one situation where the seller wanted to make sure to take care of those 2, 3, 10 people, whatever it was, and they took care of ’em so well, they left the buyer.

[2:20] Right, so make it a retention bonus six months from now or something like that, because that helps ensure the success of the buyer. That, that generally, as you talked about, there’s, there’s things that you care about beyond the money, right? You care about your employees, you care about your customers, you care about the legacy that you’ve built, and that’s one of those things that can help keep that legacy exactly.

[2:40] Mike 2: And then also right in the agreement that if that employee doesn’t stay, buyer doesn’t get that cash, it’s coming to you as additional. Oh, for sure. Yeah. A hundred percent.

[2:50] Mike Payne: No, that’s your money. It’s just if you want to do it, you know, maybe, maybe trickle it out to ’em. I think that that’s a really good point.

[3:00] So I’m gonna carry right on with you. So let’s, let’s build down into like now maybe we have a LOI on the table and let’s start talking about that process. So I’m gonna pick up kind of where you led us. Which is, okay, so I’ve got this offer. What do I need to start looking at from a tax perspective? Yeah.

First, don’t sign it.

Mike 3: Call

[3:20] Mike 2: your attorney. Call your tax person. Call your financial accountant. At that point in time, don’t sign it and say, Hey, I signed it. Now what? Right. And there’s a lot in those Lois, and I think from a tax side it’s, you know, what is the structure of this transaction? So we were talking about structure.

[3:40] Five to 10 years out thinking about how I’m gonna sell. And you’re gonna get the LOI it’s gonna get in front of you and they’re gonna have a lot of nice words, mumbo jumbo in there. I call that nice word. Yeah. And it’s gonna go through and most of the time they’re gonna say, we’re gonna buy your business, or they’re gonna say, we’re gonna buy your equity or business.

[4:00] But then down a little bit further in the, the, the. I dunno paragraphs about the details or somewhere about the PR conditions precedent. They’re gonna have this clause or statement saying, we are gonna assume that we are getting a amortizable step up for the business, a part of this transaction. Well, what that means is they’re gonna structure this as an asset sale.

[4:20] So however it is that they’re buying the stock and you can buy stock. Of an entity, make certain elections or do what you may have heard of or you’re gonna hear of when you go sell an F reorg such that they wind up buying equity, but for tax purposes and asset sale. So in that instance, that’s where we go back to, you know, what does that mean to me?

[4:40] Is there a gross up due to me? Is that gonna cost me more on money and get that into the LOI saying if that’s the case and I’m out based on my stock sale that I think this was, and I owe no more money. Put that in there. The other thing with these lois, in terms of, you know, just taxes is looking at it and saying, is there a rollover?

[5:00] And I don’t, we haven’t spoken about roles yet, but if you, a lot of companies say, Hey, we want you to stay on just a minority a little bit. ’cause you were the key folks to this business. You ran it for, you built it, you know all the customers. You are so valuable. We still want you and we want you to have a second bite of the apple.

[5:10] So we want you to stay. Maybe three to five years and have a rollover. You wanna take a look at how they’re actually structuring that rollover? Are you what they call Perry pursue even with the buyer, or are they putting you down such a level in the role that you may never get any of that? They make it sound great.

[5:30] You’re gonna get in a million dollar roll, but by the time you go through the calculation three years, you’re still. Only, only if it winds up being a publicly traded company in three to five years. Do you get anything? So kind of understanding where you’re at and what that means and under being able to negotiate those terms and the, and yes, that’s in the LOI and I think it’s very important to get these types of things in the LOI to set that level.

[6:00] You don’t have to, you know, draft the purchase agreement detail there, but at least the level set of what the basic. Deal is, and I tell you what, there’s a lot of people that go, yeah, well it says non-binding in there in these lois, but you are steadying the basis to the bargain at this point in time. And so you’re negotiating from there.

[6:10] And, and, and they ev a virus will always come back to it going, well, that my offer was based on this in the lo I not, oh yeah, you can get some, a little extra because you thought it was. Non-binding,

[6:20] Erin Mickels: your leverage really flips, right? The second you sign on that dotted line, you’ve, you’ve basically agreed, right?

[6:30] Maybe you feel like it’s softly and there might, you might feel like there’s room for negotiations, but you’ve largely agreed to the terms that are within this document, right? It’s, it’s not the purchase agreement, it is non-binding technically. Right. But the foundation, the terms that are noted in there, whether it’s financial structure or otherwise employment, right.

[6:50] You are largely agreeing. To that between parties, and that’s really kind of what kicks off the rest of the process. So from a buyer perspective, you know, if you’re trying to go back to the drawing board, you know, every, every month, you know, as you work through diligence, it’s probably gonna be pretty hard to get a transaction done, right?

[7:10] If you’re continuing to go back and, and renegotiate. So I just wanted to, to share that. Maybe just share a quick story too. You’d be surprised at the number of clients that I say we connect with. Even that share that, Hey, I signed an LOI, let me know what you think. Right? And it becomes really hard to, uh, put some power back in their hands to, to, to renegotiate the deal at that point in time.

[7:30] I think oftentimes there’s a lot of hidden complexity. And these Lois too. I’ll share maybe just one quick story. We had this happen a couple weeks ago. You know, the, kinda the standard terms that you would expect in an LOI structure price, employment. You know, there was lease, they had some related party lease arrangement, which I feel like is all fairly common stuff to be included.

[7:50] But they also had, and hold me honest here, but they also had a clause in there that talked about profits, interests and in this case it actually disclosed a number and said, you know, you are gonna get. I’ll just, I think it was 1.5 million of, of shares. And so I think the inherent nature of this individual, and maybe other people too, would say, well, maybe that’s equivalent to $1.5 million of value.

[8:20] Right. I think that’s what this individual took a step back and, and thought when we had a chance to dig in and ask a couple quick questions. It, it turns out that the value of of these units was virtually zero. Right. I mean it just based on the structure of the plan and you know how that value assigned to the broader pool and, and it, it was.

[8:40] It was only gonna be awarded based on any sort of appreciation of that plan. Right. And so I, I share that for context just because it does get, you know, the terms within these agreements can be fairly complex and sometimes folks just maybe haven’t fully vetted or understood what that truly means. Uh,

[8:50] Mike Payne: those are, those are great points.

Is there anything at the LOI point that, that you’re needing to see, Mike? You know, really as we get close to

[9:00] Mike 3: that. Actual transaction occurring. What we really start to turn our attention and focus towards is, you know, keeping that eye on the, on the horizon and saying, okay, we’ve now kind of got our number locked in.

[9:20] Let’s. Let’s rerun everything. Let’s revisit everything from a personal standpoint, make sure it still is meeting everything that you were hoping this number would meet from a financial perspective, and then start thinking about. What’s next? I get this big check for, pick a number. How, how do we wanna start thinking about deploying that, uh, in a way that will continue to meet your needs for the rest of your life?

[9:50] And, and then, you know, knowing that we. Have to execute, but there are some pieces, you know, especially if there’s charitable intentions. What, what mechanisms do we need to potentially set up and get ready to go so that when that transaction is consummated, we’ve got. All the logistical and operational pieces in place to make that

Mike Payne: go

Mike 3: smoothly.

[10:20] Mike Payne: As you say that, like one thing I think of, I like to put this in a practical sense that I think maybe Mike and Mike would have to work together on this, but let’s say that, you know, a third of my transaction value is the real estate. Right? Well, I might want to swap that out for another piece of real estate.

[10:40] Right in my portfolio on what is, what is the 10 31? 10 31. Yeah. So part of the wealth management that you’re doing is saying, okay, like you just got paid $5 million for this piece of real estate. Let’s go, let’s go do a, the exchange on the real estate here and buy and create that passive income off the real estate or, or whatever that might be.

Is that, yeah. That, that’s kind of the, the types of things you’d be looking at?

Mike 3: Absolutely. Yeah.

[11:00] Mike Payne: Which can have a serious tax implication.

Mike 3: Mm-hmm.

[11:10] Mike Payne: Okay. So we’ve, we’ve got the LOI, we we’re executed, we’re, you know, the, the, the buyers in due diligence where they’re gonna be working real closely with you, Aaron, right?

[11:20] Because you’ve done this quality of earnings. You’ve got these financials in front of ’em, all those types of things, what are the things you’re seeing there from buyers that sellers need to be aware of, like kind of during that due diligence phase?

Erin Mickels: Yeah, maybe I’ll just comment. I think one of the topics that hasn’t gotten brought up yet is working capital and a working capital mechanism.

That was

[11:30] Mike Payne: my next thing. You jumped,

[11:40] Erin Mickels: I, I jumped the gun. Um, you know, I, I would say just a flag in, in even that letter of intent stage is to be reviewing that for clarity. And, and details, and maybe it’s lack thereof, right, of, of how the framework of this working capital mechanism will be put in place. I think that’s a very common dark hole sometimes, right?

I’ve,

Mike Payne: so I’ve had more deals not closed at closing because of working capital than. Any other topic.

[12:00] Erin Mickels: It’s a very misunderstood topic, and what we always like to say is, look, you know, at, at the LOI stage, it’s not such that you’re setting any sort of target at that point in time, but the methodology of how this working capital framework will come together is, is critically important.

[12:20] The same could be true in in an LOI around any sort of earnout structure. And sometimes you might see that too as part of, you know. It’s probably the most common way to bridge a value gap between buyer and seller is to have an earnout structure in place. And you know, both of those frameworks long before you even get to the target setting, right?

[12:40] What a normalized level should be, or, you know, achieving X threshold for, say, an earnout, to make sure that we’re super crisp and clear as far as what the components. Of the working capital and the Earnout framework are going to be, so oftentimes what we see, if I just fast forward to like a purchase agreement phase of this, is it’s mapped out at the chart of account level, so we know exactly which accounts, you know, from a working capital perspective, is it, you know, the enterprise value oftentimes is, is assuming that it’s a cash free, debt free deal, but it includes an ordinary course level of working capital to be left in the business to just to sustain ordinary course operations post-close for the buyer.

[13:20] So. Working capital will most likely include accounts receivable, inventory prepaids, accounts payable, accruals. Seems pretty vanilla, right? You get into the world of complexity when you have things like deferred revenue. It’s a very, very common one. Um, where again, in a cash free, debt free deal, sellers keeping their cash.

[13:40] The buyer is now taking this deferred revenue liability and has a performance obligation that needs to be satisfied post-close. So how do you handle that? Right? On the accrual side, you’ll oftentimes see maybe accrued bonuses, PTO, you know, just some common accruals that become more disputed topics in this, this world.

[14:00] So just flagging that is another area to be aware of as you’re. You know, embarking on even that letter of intent stage, and I think there’s definitely some prep and planning that can go into that framework too, to just understand even answering that question, right? Like what is a normalized level of working capital that any business needs without question is more of an art than a science

Mike Payne: in the manufacturing sector.

[14:20] I think one of the, the, the harder ones to put a finger on is, which I always include in working capital, is whip. I mean, how, what is the value of something that yesterday was a. A piece of raw material and today is a third of the way through a finished product, right? That third of the way might be the most valuable piece of that process, or it may have only just may be the least valuable part of that process.

[14:50] So what is the, that whip calculation is can be really tough in the manufacturing space. But I think, you know, all the topics you brought up. I mean, working capital, again, I’ve, I’ve seen more deals fall apart over working capital calculations probably than anything. I, I think, I mean, I, there’s other topics, but I, but I would have to say working capital is probably the most difficult, especially if, you know, go back all the way when I was talking about this is the first time maybe you’ve been through this, the only time you’ll ever go through it.

[15:20] It’s a real, it, it can be a really difficult concept to grasp and understand that. I mean, there, there’s an element there and you gotta put a calculation on it. Receivables is easy, inventory is pretty easy. You know, those types of things are easy, but it’s, it’s those interim ones that can get really tough and they can get, it can turn a deal upside down just overnight.

[15:40] I mean, I, I was closing three years ago. I was closing on a deal and the guy walks into closing. He goes, I don’t think I can do this. I’m like. What, you know, we’re, we’re three or four months into the deal, like we’re we’re at closing. And he, I said, what’s going on? And, and it was all over the working capital.

[16:00] So we had to kind of like go, we had to start over from explaining how we got to that number and, and what it means to him. And, and then we did close, but it was, I didn’t think we were going to halfway through that conversation. It’s, it’s a tough one. It’s a really tough one.

Erin Mickels: I think from a seller perspective, I think it’s.

[16:20] Creates a little confusion to say, wait, you’re gonna, you’re gonna keep my receivables. Right, right. I thought I was gonna be able to keep those, but I think maybe not appreciating the other side of the equation that they’re also gonna take your payables and certain accruals. Right. I mean, it, it comes in the form of, you know, current assets and current liabilities and, you know, there’s a lot of ways to structure the deal and value the deal, but at the end of the day, I think the working capital mechanism is a very common piece to the puzzle.

[16:40] Just getting in front of it, you know, having some positions and basis of understanding that normalized level that would be left in the business and assumed by that buyer day one post close. Yeah,

Mike Payne: and something else that, I mean, sellers, I mean, again, if you don’t have someone advising you, you might not know to ask for this, but I think it’s generally pretty normal.

[17:00] But you know, you should have a, like a six month settle up too, right? So in almost every business I’ve ever bought, you know, we had a working capital target and they overdelivered. So, you know, three to six months out is, is generally a decent number in my opinion. I, I think, you know, everybody has probably different opinions on that.

[17:20] But, you know, I’ve written some really large checks six months out because they over, you know, they, they were supposed to deliver $500,000 in working capital and they delivered 1,000,002. Right. I mean, like there was, and, and if you don’t ask for that, they’re keeping the million too. If that’s not in the deal, that’s their money now.

[17:40] But, you know, we always work it in that we generally go with six months. We’re, we’re going to, we’ll calculate what did you deliver in working capital And, and we’ll settle that up with you. But I have seen deals that. That didn’t happen and they still over delivered, you know, by a lot of money and no one ever benefited from that.

[18:00] Well, the buyer benefited from it. Okay, so the next kind of hairy topic that I want to talk about, and I think Mike too, I think you’ll probably address this the best. So I’ve got this purchase agreement and it’s got this thing in there called a sales price allocation. What in the world

[18:10] Mike 2: is that? Yeah, so for tax purposes it could have the financial.

[18:20] Purchase price allocation and you can have a tax purchase price allocation. The first thing on that is they do not have to agree. And so if they’re talking about we need it for one that doesn’t have to agree to the to the other. So you wind up in a, in the agreement, in the purchase agreement, and you’re doing an asset sale or a deemed deficit sale on the stock sale, who cares what they wanna do there?

[18:40] You’re getting paid X dollars for your stock. Sure. But now we’re in an asset type scenario and now that purchase price allocations in there, they’ve said, okay. Within so many days after the final balance sheet, which is where your networking capital true up is going, you’re gonna provide buyers gonna provide a seller, seller’s gonna provide buyer the allocation purchase price based on hopefully a methodology that you guys agreed to in that purchase agreement before the transaction closes.

[19:00] And I think that’s the biggest thing at this point in time to just emphasize, is agree to the methodology. In the agreement before it closes. Do not let it be silent in there that says, buyer gets to tell you after the transaction what, how they want to allocate purchase price. ’cause if I’m the buyer, I’m gonna put it the most short term assets that I can because I’m gonna get bonus depreciation and instant deduction.

[19:30] Well, that’s great for them, but for you, that’s recapturing all those fixed assets that you’ve depreciated over time. So with that, you want to take a look at that and put a methodology. In the agreement that says, all right, AR is gonna be based on book value. Or if you think the AR is, you know, even more devalued, something different.

[19:50] Inventory, maybe book value or tax bases, fixed assets, and this is where the big thing comes to work. You wanna be as close to tax base as you can, but you don’t wanna be egregious because if you’re egregious, an IRS agent is allowed to upset the apple cart. But the regs are in the indicate that if by and seller agrees, that is the best.

[20:10] Indication of fair market value. So as long as it’s not egregious, the agent is bound to stick to that. So we want to have something in there, the methodology, so you can have tax basis plus 10% tax basis plus 20%, but something close to tax basis if a buyer, you know, goes back, you know, sometimes people get valuations for that, which you can do.

[20:30] And then just general knowledge, usually 80% of the deals that we get involved in are smaller deals where you don’t get a valuation, you can’t agree. Most people then say book value, net book value based on gap financials as of close, and then allocate the rest goes automatically to goodwill. So whereas, you know, buyers you might see on financials all these.

[20:50] I, I, from the tax side, we kinda like these fake assets, right? These right of use assets, they call ’em for leaseholds. You know, what the heck is that? Um, that goes on the balance sheet. You’ll want to exclude those for tax. They don’t exist, so you won’t be paying that. Another item in the purchase price allocation, I’m kind of.

[21:10] D, you know, veering off a little bit, but deferred revenue. Yeah. As much you see, Aaron already knows this as much of a pain as it is for financial purposes. For tax purposes, it can be even more of a nightmare because deferred revenue, depending on the transaction structure. All that deferred revenue might be picked up by the seller in an asset transaction, and that’s gonna be ordinary rates to you.

[21:30] You may be able to get an offset based on the cost to fulfill it may be able to, but you want to make sure you know what that is and identify it prior to the transaction and be able to negotiate that in there so that way you can get the net. Otherwise, you. Potentially wind up with picking it all up as ordinary, and it’s a big aha moment after the fact.

So that’s another big item in the purchase agreement.

[21:50] Mike Payne: Hey everybody, what do you think of when I say OTD? Well, in making chips, we’ve got lots of acronyms to deal with, but OTD is on time delivery. On time delivery is part of Hill’s Mission. Deliver quality parts on time. Every time when I was shopping for an ERP system, I was looking for something that would ensure that we do that.

[22:10] On a regular basis, delivering jobs on time was something we struggled with, and I know that most shops struggle with. I think I saw recently that 70% of shops struggle with delivering parts on time. So the best decision I made in that Enter pro shop. Did you know that many of Pros shop’s customers quickly experienced 95% or better on time delivery rates with their customers, and now ProShop has a guide to help all shops, whether you’re using ProShop or not.

[22:40] Visit ProShop erp.com/ 95. Again, that’s ProShop erp slash 95 to get your copy today. You know, I, I, I think what people, sellers need to hear based on those, just those last two topics we talked about, I think those are the things that, uh, one. Yeah, they might be the most complicated parts of the deal. Two, they also have the, the two biggest effects on what you net out of the transaction.

[23:10] Is that, I mean, is that a fair statement? Yes. Yeah. So like I’ve, you know, I’ve joked with, I mean, sort of joked with people before, like, you know, okay, I’ll buy your company for $2 million, and they say, well, I really want three. It’s like, okay, well I, I mean I can pay you three. But our working capital and our, and our sales price allocation is gonna be drastically different, right?

[23:30] So, I mean, I can pay you three if you’re gonna deliver me an extra million dollars in working capital, right? Like, I mean, and, and that’s, it’s joking, but it’s not. I mean, you can sell your company for whatever you want, but at the end of the day, the buyers can expect a certain. You know, something in response to that.

[23:40] Right. So, and, and I, I think from a tax perspective, you know, when you look at the net value of a transaction, where I see people probably get hurt the most is in that sales price allocation. You know, the, the buyer offers it all in asset value. ’cause that’s great for them and you’ve. Section 1 79 to all of your assets over the last 10 years.

[24:00] And there’s, so it’s all gain, right? There’s no, there’s nothing there you can do with that or whatever. So yeah, I think paying particular attention to those two things are, are really important. And that’s where talking to Aaron and Mike would be very valuable to you. Would it, would it be

Mike 3: helpful to.

[24:20] Almost lay out just a few different assets in terms of, you know, what gets taxed at ordinary rates versus capital gains. Yeah. Mike,

Mike Payne: why you want to kind of cover some of that, like in a typical transaction with those, what those different tax brackets might look like?

[24:30] Mike 2: Ordinary, but different categories.

Yeah.

Mike Payne: Not the bracket.

[24:40] Mike 2: So in terms of different categories, it’s really, you know, the, the, your, what they call hot assets, and that’s more of a partnership context, but hot. You don’t wanna touch ’em because it’s ordinary. It’s, it’s gonna be appreciated inventory. So a buyer could actually allocate more than your tax bases and your inventory.

[24:50] And I’ve seen that done where a buyer says, okay, I believe ending inventory is worth $5 million. But you’re recording that just because what you have in it at, you know, four, four and a half. Now that’s ordinary income to you. Ar if you’re on a cash basis and not an accrual basis, that’s all gonna be ordinary to you.

[25:10] Deferred revenue, we kind of covered that as as ordinary there. Fixed assets, the recapture on fixed assets, that’s ordinary and then. If you had bought other businesses on asset deals, you went out and said, yep, I’m doing the asset transaction. I’m getting the step up and the write off, and I had that intangibles for which I’ve got tax basis and amortizing.

[25:30] That amortization then is gonna be recaptured at ordinary rates. There’s a little stuff you might be able to do with that, but a lot of times you’ve had goodwill. It’s gonna be recaptured. But just to be aware that that’s a, that an ordinary, I think one other item I wanna mention, kind of, it’s ordinary, but this is a little bit different just based on transaction structure.

[25:50] You commented about earnouts before, and so if you’re doing an earnout, this is a great thing. You get extra value, especially if you believe it’s there and you’re gonna be able to provide that. And it’s just not want someone, a buyer wants to give right now, but if the buyer puts in there that the earnout is subject to you.

[26:10] Being employed at the time to get it. Now that has wages to you, that’s not purchase price, that’s wages. So be very careful on that. Make sure that that’s not written in agreement anywhere. Highlight that and just say, no. That doesn’t need to be at, at this point. Yeah.

[26:20] Mike Payne: And, and you know, back on the purchase price allocation, you know, in, in my experience, you know, that’s where the buyer and seller both have the most opportunity to gain.

[26:30] Right. So that’s, that’s where, you know, it’s, there’s an art and a science to it. I mean, I, I, I know when we go into a deal, you know, we’re typically looking to structure a deal that nets the seller as much as we can net them without too much damage to ourselves. There’s things in that structure. There’s things in the purchase price agreement that maybe don’t matter to us, that matter to the seller and vice versa.

[27:00] Right. So we can give there, but you know, I mean, I, yeah, I want as much of it in fixed assets, right As po I want a whole lot more fixed assets than I want Goodwill as the buyer. But don’t ignore that page, I guess is the point of bringing that up. It’s important, you know, talk to your advisors, you know, and, and work through.

[27:10] What does that mean to. To you as the seller, and, and if you’re the buyer, you know, work, work through that too. As we start to kind of wrap up, Mike one. Okay. Let’s, let’s assume we worked all that stuff out. It went to closing and they’re sitting at lunch with you afterwards with a big old check. That would be nice.

[27:30] Yeah. What do I do with this? What’s, what is that last step? Kind of, of this part of the process? Yeah. Ho hopefully that’s not the first time that

[27:40] Mike 3: we’re, we’re sitting down and, and getting together. Good point. Um, but I think the, the first. I guess word of caution at that point is don’t do anything too quickly.

[28:00] Give yourself a time, uh, a period of time to just. Take a step back and maybe breathe. I mean, these are incredibly time consuming transactions and I think every single business owner that we’ve talked to that’s gone through this process, they are exhausted. And yeah, you might be really excited that you’ve gotta check with a really big number on it.

[28:20] Enough for Jet, hopefully. But we wanna make sure that the way that it gets distributed and, and ultimately, you know, invested perhaps over time is, you know, not forgetting about the tax piece that we’ve obviously talked about. You know, if you transact in February of this year. You might not end up ultimately writing the tax check until April of 2026 and if you get too aggressive with, you know, paying off the house and you know, buying a jet, then you know, all of a sudden fast forward a few months and we’re scrambling to try and make that that tax payment depending again how the.

[29:10] Company is structured. You know, sometimes it makes sense to leave money in the business to make, you know, state tax payments or things, things like that. Uh, you want to obviously leave some for any last minute payables or things that might come through. So my first conversation is always, Hey, let’s pause.

[29:30] And then the second piece of it is, let’s start thinking about the personal tax. Piece of this. How do we want to, you know, make sure we’ve got enough money set aside, enough liquidity set aside to take care of that. And then the last piece is you starting to talk about where, where and how do we want to invest this.

[29:50] So many business owners are. They know their business. They know the risk that they’re taking as they operate and grow that business. Most are not as familiar with. Market risk and hey, if I go and invest this, am I potentially gonna lose everything that I worked so hard at building and, and now see in front of me?

[30:20] And that’s where we do a lot of conversation around, Hey, here’s how markets work. And a lot of education right on that front. We don’t have time to get into all the. You know, nuanced tax things that you could do from an investment perspective. Opportunity zones is one that’s been talked about a lot, and there’s other things that you can do to continue to drive down your personal income tax.

You’ve essentially moved into an entire different part of the tax code, uh, going from a business to now a bunch of liquid assets.

[30:50] Mike Payne: Yeah. It’s interesting when you say that. Like, I, I never really thought about it till you were just talking about it, but I guess, you know, a lot of entrepreneur, founder, business owners, you know, I mean, a lot of ’em I know, anyway, we don’t have a lot of personal liquidity, right.

[31:10] Because we, we continue to invest in our, in our businesses. Mm-hmm. So we haven’t, I mean, I’ve got some money in the market, but. The majority of my money’s in my business. Yeah, right. So all of a sudden, a large liquidity event where I’ve got all this cash. I mean, you would have to think pretty differently about what you’re doing with that.

[31:20] Yeah. And, and what risk you’re willing to take. I mean, right now when I sit down with a wealth advisor and you do the little exercise of your risk assessment, like I’m off, I’m off the top right because everything I do is, you know, small private equity, you know, type deals, which are the riskiest you can do.

[31:40] But yeah. Now if I’m settling down and this is it. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. That risk profile is gonna change dramatically, I would assume. Yeah. Mm-hmm. I hadn’t thought about that, but that’s, yeah, that would, it would totally change your focus on what you wanna do with your money. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So,

Mike 3: so often they’re used to, what’s the highest ROI, right.

[32:00] How, how can I, you know, get 10%, 12%, 15%? Well, that looks a lot different in a business structure than it does in a personal wealth. Sure. Market structure.

[32:10] Mike Payne: Yeah. Okay. So. Wrapping up, I mean, so listeners, I, we never even really talked about this, so we’re, we’re sitting in front of an audience. Is there, anybody in the audience has any questions about what we’ve kind of covered so far?

[32:30] Right. Okay. So the question was, I’ve had capital assets for many, many years, and as a seller they’re on my book at zero. How do you assign the value of that as an asset to the seller or the buyer? Yeah, so I would tell you, and I, I’ll give you my experience and then you guys chime in here. So I don’t really care what that, that piece of equipment is worth, right?

[32:50] So I’m doing my valuation and I’m, ’cause I’m buying your earnings. Right. I’m buying a multiple of your earnings. I don’t care a ton about the value of the particular asset in the sales price allocation. I’m gonna assign some amount of that to the particular asset. It’ll be based in some sort of reality, right?

[33:10] So we might have an equipment valuation done, something like that. But it’s, you know, so that’s, again, back to that sales price allocation to me is a little bit of an art and a science, right? So it’s, it’s how do you. Because I’m not really buying your asset, even though I’m buying your assets. Right. That’s just the, that’s the structure of the deal.

[33:30] Yeah. So it’s a, it’s different than like, I’m gonna come buy this fixed asset from you, and the used market value of it is $25,000. Right. That’s not how I’m structuring that in that purchase agreement. It’s more what is the breakdown in the purchase price allocation. The sales price allocation of where I’m allocating asset value versus goodwill versus working capital versus, you know, that list can be three lines or 30.

How do you, how do you guys look at that question?

[34:00] Erin Mickels: Yeah, I think it’s just terminology a little bit, right? I think it gets confusing when you use the word an asset sale. It’s not really, you know, you’re not selling just your assets. I think generally speaking, the way that business would be valued would still be, like Mike said, evaluating the the adjusted earnings or the freak.

[34:20] Free cash flow of the business times, some sort of multiple. That would be the, you know, what we define as maybe the enterprise value of the business, but it’s structured for tax purposes as an asset deal. Yeah.

[34:30] Mike Payne: So, so your entity is gonna survive. And I mean, you might shut it down, but that entity’s gonna go on.

[34:40] I’m just buying everything you have in it. So Any other questions? Yeah. Yep. Good question. Okay, so the question is how do you, how is the multiple determined? Again, I’ll take a cut at it. You guys fill in the blanks where I’m wrong. So again, I, I know that, you know, generally in my space of manufacturing, it’s around a four to 4.2, like you referenced.

[35:00] From there, it’s what does the rest of the company look like, right? And to me, I kind of call it like a health meter, right? So I need good equipment, right? If the equipment’s. Yeah, really, really good stuff. It’s been maintained. It’s got preventative maintenance, like that’s gonna help boost the valuation.

[35:20] If it’s all 30 years old and I’m gonna have to replace it over the next five years, that’s gonna pull it down. Same way with like the management team, right? So has the owner decoupled themselves from the company? So is this gonna survive? Yeah. Without them, that’s gonna change the multiple from a, from a two to a seven.

[35:40] Right? Is it, you know, so a lot of the, again, I’m, I’m, we’re, we’re talking a lot about, on my show, we talk a lot, a lot about how to grow your value as a buyer. I’m looking for comp, I mean, really a lot of my buying strategy is to buy what I call kind of just old tired shops that need my people, processes and systems.

[36:00] To, to survive. Right. So, so in a lot of ways I’m looking for shops that don’t have the people, the processes and the systems to, to perform like I do. Right? So I actually, you know, like I have this psycho spreadsheet I use that, you know, I, I put in the three year financials I put in. What the, what the current or, or trailing 12 months would look like if I was running it right.

[36:30] So we were just talking about this at lunch and you know, one of the things like I look at, like there’s things I know I do well, there’s things I know I don’t do well, so I can recast your 12 months if I’m running it. Right. I have maybe more buying power than you have, but maybe I’m really bad at something else.

[36:40] So like you might be kicking my butt at that. That’s great. So I’ll kind of recast what it looks like if I’m running it. And then from there I have a bunch of benchmarks I track in my business. Right? And that could be revenue per ft. E or or, or maybe margin contribution per FTE. And then I’ll compare you to me, right?

[37:00] If you’re already hitting some of those. Then your multiple’s checking up every time. And I do have like, it, it is a psycho spreadsheet. It kind of calculates all this for us, for me. But you know, if, if you’re hitting a lot of the benchmarks that I’m already trying to hit, your multiple is ticking up with every one of those.

[37:20] If you aren’t hitting any of ’em, your multiple’s ticking down with every one of those, right? So for me, you know, I know that in my space. You know, somewhere between three really on the low end, although there are times they drop below that, three to five is very normal and it’s just gonna be what is the performance of your company.

[37:40] If I literally can just buy it and bolt it on, it’s gonna be worth more to me. Now I’m a strategic buyer, right? But that’s gonna be worth more to me than if I’m gonna buy it and I’m gonna have to like redo everything. Right, and I’m gonna have to replace all the equipment and people and everything else over the next couple years, then it’s worth a whole lot less.

[38:00] ’cause I’m gonna have to invest that much more in making it part of my portfolio.

[38:10] Erin Mickels: It’s such a great question and I think we could probably spend a whole nother hour we could spend talking about that high level. What I would say is it’s, it’s qualitative and quantitative and it, it’s gonna. Be widely different depending on the industry that you operate in, focusing on maybe the financial aspects of it.

[38:30] I would say industry and size matter, uh, type of buyer matters, whether it’s strategic or some sort of financial buyer, private equity. Then you get into, you know, the finer details of, you know, customer concentration growth, right? You get back into the story of what are the three years, or five years or whatever of historical financial statements, what does that tell us?

[38:50] But probably equally as important, what does, you know, the budget or the forecasted period look like? We haven’t really spent a lot of time talking about that today either. But I think, you know, it’s, it’s equally weighted, I would say, in both the qualitative and quantitative factors. Coupled with, I mean, look, at the end of the day, somebody’s paying you a multiple of your earnings.

[39:10] In theory A, a big piece of that is for the growth of the business or the expected growth of the business. And so, you know, there’s a lot of different levers to that. Excellent question. And I think a lot of work goes into that to just giving. You know, a seller, a range right? Of, of what do we think the business is worth to kind of tee off a lot of the processes that we’ve been talking about here today.

[39:30] But again, probably the most important piece of that puzzle is understanding if, if at the end of the day, the business is gonna be valued based on some multiple of of EBITDA adjusted EBITDA seller discretionary earnings. That we have a really clear understanding of what that number is and, and probably, you know, kicked down a couple of their doors on the financial side of the house to really give a crisp range.

[39:50] The other piece I would say is, you know, valuation as we see it is what somebody’s willing to pay. Right? Right. So, you know, that’s, that’s the value I think in, in using, you know, an, an investment banker. A broker who’s actively then marketing the business and, you know, discussing with. Different types of buyers and perhaps a broader pool of buyers trying to, to draw that competitive tension to maximize value.

[40:20] Mike Payne: So everything she just said is in my psycho spreadsheet, right? I mean, that’s, I

Erin Mickels: wanna see your spreadsheets. It’s,

[40:30] Mike Payne: it’s pretty darn good. It’s been developed over 20 years. It’s pretty good. Um, the, you know, I, but I think the other thing people lose sight of. As Aaron said, like it’s, it’s what someone’s willing to pay for it, right?

[40:40] So I think the smaller you go down the scale in enterprise value, it’s more art than science, right? So if it’s a $500,000 company versus a $500 million company, there’s a totally different valuation model that’s gonna go into that. Some buyers will not sell for what their reasonable enterprise value is, right?

[41:00] I, I always joke, I’ve never met a business owner whose company wasn’t worth a million dollars, right? Like that is like a floor. It seems like that they’re not selling my business for less than that. It might only be worth. 300,000, but I’m not selling it for less than a million. So, so there’s, you know, at that level you’re in a lot more of an, it’s a lot more art right.

[41:10] As you go up. It’s, and it’s certainly like, if, if you get into, like, so a couple years ago we bought a division of a public company. Well, that was really easy to determine the valuation, right? There’s a mm-hmm. There’s an earnings per share price out there and, and they have a con, they have a contributed margin to that.

[41:30] There’s, there’s not a whole lot of. There’s not a whole lot of guesswork in that. Right. So it’s a lot of art and science. There’s absolutely, I mean, her point of it’s worth what someone’s willing to sell it is a hundred percent, but it’s also worth what someone’s willing to buy it. And, and also don’t get hung up on the price.

[41:50] Get hung up on the net price. Right? So that’s where we get back to the conversations of the, the tax implications and everything of your sales structure. Again, I’ll buy your bus. I’ll buy your million dollar business for 2 million, but it’s gonna be structured totally different and, and you’re still gonna net the same amount.

Anybody else have a comment on that? Well,

[42:10] Mike 2: not, not quite there, but yeah. Yes. So normally about this time, we get a question going. I’ve heard that there’s a scheme out there that you can sell your business and not pay any tax. Oh well. Yeah. Will you teach that to us? Well, yeah, I’m about, I’m about to. I was gonna say, there isn’t such that you can’t pay no tax.

[42:30] There’s gonna be some taxes, state taxes, local taxes, but there is something called qualifying small business stock. And that is something that’s actually accurate and it is out there, it’s in the code and it’s kind gotten more life in the last since. Since 2018 where they made this as a hundred percent exclusion depending on when you purchased it.

[42:50] There’s some stock when it was issued and 50% it when it was issued, not purchased 50% and 75%, and now it’s a hundred percent. And what this is, is if you were doing business as a C corporation, this goes back maybe to the five 10 year out planning. Sure. If you’ve got originally issued stock and you’re doing business as a C corporation and you sell that stock and you’ve done all sorts of things to qualify throughout the time, and we don’t have.

[43:10] The time to go through all that. When you sell it, you can exclude from your gain on your schedule D, $10 million or 10 times your basis, whichever is greater. So, you know, you have some of these folks that are, you know, maybe they put $3 million into the business, contributed in capital, got the stock back, they had the cash to, to put it in or put it in over time.

[43:40] Now they have, when they sell it for $30 million, they get to exclude that $27 million gain, 30 less. The three that you put in it and don’t, isn’t able to pay, have to pay federal taxes on it. So just be aware. There is a provision out there. There’s, if you’re not in a C Corp right now, can you convert to a C corp?

[43:50] Yes, you can get into C corp structure. It’s a little bit more complex and if there’s a gain from when you convert to today, the built in gain, you still pay tax on. But again, complexity to that. But there’s something to think about for planning. And if you are currently a C corp, I would say a C corp that just came into existence since, you know, in the last decade.

[44:10] This is something to think about when you go to exit, assuming 1202 is still around the code section 1202 qualifying stall, business stock is still around.

[44:20] Mike Payne: That was a perfect way to wrap up because if you look back at the beginning, we talked about so many sellers sit there and go, oh my God, I’m so stupid.

[44:30] Like, I don’t understand this and I don’t understand what you just said. Like, that was so tech. I mean, I do, but that was, that was so technical. Yeah. They, they always

[44:40] Mike 2: tell me not to. No, no, no. Quote code section.

Mike Payne: And I, and I, I say that jokingly because that’s, that’s the, that what you did is you drive home, you drove home the point of like, you need advisors in this process, right?

[44:50] Like, I mean, that is something that most people would not know. They would not think about. And that’s where professionals such as. Those of us, you know, those of these guys sitting up here at the table or at in these chairs, um, can bring value to this transaction for you 10 years out. Right? I mean, like you just talked about, like, I mean, what you just talked about needs to happen in the five to 10 year range, not the zero to one year range.

[45:20] Right. So I, I think I, I was joking that like. It went over everybody’s head, but I mean, it’s a great point of that’s a super technical planning thing that you can do that will have a massive impact on the net value of what you get out of a transaction. So all of you. Thank you so much. I think this was good.

[45:40] I hope everybody got some value out of it, so yeah, thank you guys. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thanks for having us. Thanks.

[45:50] Speaker 6: I am fired up for Top Shops 2025, and you should be too. It’s happening November 11th and 12th in Charlotte, North Carolina, and it’s one of the most impactful events in manufacturing. Nick, Mike and I will all be there connecting with shop owners, sharing what’s working and learning right alongside you.

[46:10] You can’t register yet, but head over to top shops event.com and sign up for updates so you don’t miss out.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.

Connect with CLA

Connect With Buy the Numbers

Subscribe to Buy the Numbers

on Apple + Spotify

Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.