By Jennifer Dubose

Owning the Problem: Why Accountability, Communication, and Culture Drive Throughput, Ep #38

One of the patterns I keep seeing in manufacturing has nothing to do with machines, software, or technology. It shows up in how teams respond when something goes wrong. In this episode of Buy the Numbers, I sat down again with Josh McKain from Throughput Mastery to talk about the habits that actually drive throughput, especially accountability, communication, and culture.

Josh has now hosted more than a dozen live conversations with manufacturing owners and leaders, and what stood out to me is how often completely different topics circle back to the same root issue. Whether the discussion starts with cash flow, sales, hiring, or quality, it almost always ends up at communication. The shops that move forward aren’t the ones avoiding hard conversations, they’re the ones willing to own problems and work through them together.

We talked through real, practical examples from the shop floor. Scrapped parts, heat treat failures, non-conformances, and rework are going to happen. The difference is how leaders respond. Even when something isn’t technically your fault, it’s still your responsibility to solve if you want to deliver for customers and keep improving.

This conversation also pushed into leadership and culture. Delegation matters, but abdication is dangerous. Some things, like cash flow, culture, and accountability, are too important to fully hand off. If you’re trying to build a shop that consistently improves and doesn’t rely on blame as a coping mechanism, this episode will resonate.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:57) Welcoming Josh McKain back to Buy the Numbers
  • (1:41) Josh explains Throughput Mastery and the structure of his leadership groups
  • (4:10) Why small, trusted groups unlock vulnerability and honest discussion
  • (5:43) The most consistent takeaway across episodes: communication
  • (7:51) How trust, not technology, becomes a true sales differentiator
  • (9:10) Showing customers systems, not just machines, to build confidence
  • (11:52) Using data to prove on-time delivery and reliability
  • (12:33) Overcoming manufacturing stereotypes in hiring
  • (14:51) Why authenticity matters more than polished marketing
  • (17:36) Taking responsibility for workforce challenges instead of assigning blame
  • (19:15) Scrap, rework, and why problem-solving is cultural, not procedural
  • (21:22) We detail how Factur can generate new opportunities for your business
  • (23:09) Using non-conformance reports to drive continuous improvement
  • (24:55) Applying AI tools to uncover overlooked process improvements
  • (27:24) Identifying trends through NCR data and KPI reviews
  • (31:18) Why cash flow is too important to fully delegate
  • (32:26) Delegation vs abdication and what leaders must always own
  • (36:24) Can culture be measured? Using simple scoring to track trends
  • (40:39) Combining “gut feel” with turnover and HR data
  • (41:59) How to connect with Josh and participate in Throughput Mastery

Resources & People Mentioned

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] Mike Payne: It may or may not have been your problem. Maybe your part got scrapped at Heat Treat. Right?

I mean, like, you know, let’s put it into that practical of an instance. You’ve machined a part, sent to Heat Treat, and it’s scrapped. Well, you’re still not, you’re just gonna not deliver a part to your customer?

[0:16] Josh McKain: Yeah, yeah, just tell them, sorry, I didn’t do it.

[0:18] Mike Payne: Yeah, not my problem. No, you’re gonna, you’re gonna regroup, you’re gonna, you’re gonna get this right, and you’re gonna solve your problem.

[0:29] Narrator: Welcome to By the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business, from accounting and finance to operations, and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.

Let’s crunch some numbers.

[0:57] Mike Payne: Josh, welcome back to By the Numbers.

[1:00] Josh McKain: Thanks for having me. Great to be back. Two-time guest, can’t believe it.

[1:04] Mike Payne: Yeah, you’re in a rare crowd. I, you know, I’m just a year in, a little over a year in, so there’s only been a few people have made several, and you’re one of them. I guess, I don’t know if there’s, like, I need to have an award made up for that or anything like that, but.

[1:17] Josh McKain: Well, we were just talking about John Hughes. I know he’s been on here several times.

[1:21] Mike Payne: Yeah, John.

[1:21] Josh McKain: I’m gonna have to, I’m gonna have to somehow get on here more than him. Yeah, there you go.

[1:27] Mike Payne: Well, for the people that maybe didn’t listen, I think it was right about a year ago your episode came out. For the people that didn’t hear that and maybe don’t know who you are, why don’t you just give a quick little introduction of who you are, what you do, and why we’re talking today.

[1:41] Josh McKain: Yeah, so my name is Josh McCain. I run a company called Throughput Mastery, and that’s been a three-year evolutionary process of the business that I run, going from one-on-one consulting to manufacturers on strategic planning and strategic development, to doing some seminars and then some mastermind groups, and they’ve been in person, they’ve been virtual, sales reps only, owners only, all sorts of iterations on those groups, and the group that I’m having the most success with getting the best feedback from members is the current Throughput Mastery program, which is virtual mastermind groups for manufacturing owners and top-level leadership, people who are managing people and teams of people.

That’s usually who’s on the calls. We meet a couple of times a month, and it’s just a place to share what you’ve learned recently, experiences, the hard knocks, the successes, the failures, all of that.

[2:39] Mike Payne: Yeah, so to put that in reference for, you know, I see I recorded with you what, a couple months ago now, something like that?

[2:46] Josh McKain: Yeah, I think so.

[2:47] Mike Payne: Yeah, I say recorded, and we did record, but one of the things I loved about what you’re doing is just kind of the live Zoom call, basically, right, of a group of people that have a interest in whatever that subject was. We talked about cash flow on the episode I did, and it was really great, and you know, one of the things we don’t get today, right, like recording, just recording a podcast that’s going to come out in a few weeks, is we don’t get those real in, you know, questions on time, in live time about something you just said, someone has a follow-up question, or maybe a question that you didn’t cover, and what was, what I enjoyed about it so much was just kind of the, you know, I mean, I remember some of the questions were very vulnerable too, right? They were like, hey, I’ve messed up.

How do I, how should I fix this, right? And that’s great, I mean, because we’ve all messed up, and lots of times that doesn’t get talked about as, you know, whether it’s on these platforms, or social media, or whatever. We talk about our wins, we always talk about our losses, but we learn our lessons in our losses, right?

So yeah, I love what you’re doing. I’ve caught most, if not all, I don’t know that I’ve caught any live myself, other than the one I was on, but I have followed up and listened to, I think, maybe all of them, and it’s good stuff. You’ve had some great guests on there.

[4:10] Josh McKain: Yeah, yeah, it’s, I like the structure, because I do a little two-minute introduction, and then I can pretty much mute myself the rest of the conversation. I don’t have to do anything. I’ve got these guest speakers coming in, and they’re sharing great ideas, and like you said, the audience is driving a portion of that conversation as well with their questions, and speaking to the vulnerability, I think the people on the show are usually a little bit more willing to speak, because we are, we’re 13 episodes in, so I mean, there’s, it’s a small number of people on the call, and they know that it’s not going out to 2,000 listeners every week, so it is still a little bit more intimate feel, and all of my groups, that’s, they’re limited to how many people can join.

They’re capped, because I think you get, you obviously miss out on the people who aren’t in the room, but you also get that vulnerability, and you can interact a little bit more intimately, is probably the right word.

[5:10] Mike Payne: Yeah, no, I certainly experienced that. I mean, it was really good. So, so you’re 13 episodes in.

You’ve had some great guests. You’ve had some really great conversations. I’m curious now, you know, if you were to look back on the, you know, those first dozen episodes or whatever, what are, you know, we’re all interested in throughput.

We’re all interested in the topics that you’re covering. What are some of the just kind of golden nuggets of information that have kind of come out of it that you just, like maybe you weren’t even thinking that direction when you had that guest on, or, you know, whatever. What’s some of the stuff we can share with others?

[5:43] Josh McKain: Yeah, well, one theme that I would say, it’s been present in probably at least half of the episodes, and this is not going to be news to anyone listening to this. You all already know this, but it’s, it’s always good to have a reminder. It’s that no matter what the topic is, every speaker, it seems like, is stressing that communication is the key to this.

Whether they’re talking about cashflow or problem solving or securing a new line of credit with your bank, everyone is saying communication is the key here. That’s what everyone is saying. And it really just has driven home.

Again, I knew this already, but it just drives it home to just hear, yeah, I mean, just being up front with people, sharing the good, the bad and the ugly, asking for what you need, actually truly telling people, this is what you need, admitting your failures, sharing your successes. That’s, and no matter what the topic, communication has come up as a key piece of it.

[6:37] Mike Payne: Yeah, I think, I mean, that’s, you’re right. It’s not shocking, right? But it’s, it’s affirming, right?

Like you know it, and it’s just good to hear that theme. You know, one of the things we see across a lot, if not every single Making Chips episode we do, is culture also. That’s, that is a reoccurring theme every time you talk to any sort of business owner about, you know, where their success lies is in the culture they’ve built around their company.

So yeah, culture, communication, you know, I mean, obviously in the world we all live in, quality and those things matter, but those aren’t necessarily the differentiators. Yeah, right. That’s the low bar.

You got to, you got to have just a, it’s barrier entry there. It’s just, yeah, that’s the entropy, quality, safety, you know, those types of things. But yeah, the differentiators, certainly, I know like with my customers, you know, the communication piece.

That’s, I mean, internally and externally, but one of the things our customers tell us differentiate the us in their supply chain is we have good communication. We have good communication because we have good culture. It’s expected.

That’s just part of who we are, how we do things. Yeah. Any, yeah, so okay, so that was your number one there was communication.

What’s some other, what’s some other stuff you’ve learned?

[7:51] Josh McKain: Well, maybe that’s sort of top of mind. I don’t know that’s necessarily the best, you know, the number one takeaway, maybe a big surprise. So this is sort of a different way of framing it, a big surprise that I didn’t expect.

So Paul’s episode, number eight, your tech stack is your best sales tool. I was just expecting him to have some sort of CRM functionality built into ProShop or to, I guess, impress customers with the technology that you’ve got, which are both real things, but he really tied it back to trust. Can you prove to your prospects and your customers that you’re going to deliver quality parts on time in the right way?

You’re going to package it the way they want and deliver it to the address they wanted at. Can you build that trust? Because again, this is not new, but everyone has always heard people buy from people they know, like, and trust, and having good tech capabilities that almost ensure you’re going to make good parts and deliver them on time, that develops that trust.

And so the sales tool is not, in Paul’s case, the sales tool is not the software. It’s what the software provides, which is trust. So that was, I thought I knew what topic he was going to cover.

And he came on, he, I was learning along the same time with everyone else.

[9:10] Mike Payne: Yeah. And that is such a, and I would encourage people to go listen to that episode. We, there’s also a making chips episode from maybe back in the spring about tech stack.

And I would encourage people to listen to both of those. The, you know, that foundation there is really so critical, right? So as we’ve developed out our tech stack and, you know, I mean, pro shop’s part of that tech stack for us, but we have a lot of other stuff.

And I can tell you now, like when I’ve got a new prospect or even the existing customer in the shop, you know, five, six, seven years ago when they came by our meeting was almost exclusively on the shop floor showing them my cool lathe or my cool mill or some new part we’re making. And that stuff still matters, right? They do need to see that capability on the floor.

The, but what I have found now, if they’re here for an hour, we spent 50 minutes in the conference room, really going more through the systems that we have in place to deliver on our promise to them. Right. So, so whether that’s on the front end, you know, managing a quote process, an RFQ process through managing the job through making sure they get what they need at the end.

Right. So they don’t just need the parts, right. They need the quality docs and the certs and all that go with it.

And you know, so us showing them, well, here’s how we solve for that. Right. And so it’s, you know, so when they’re here now, they’ve met my people, we’ve explained our processes and we’ve shown them our systems.

Right. And the peoples and the people, the processes and the systems are the foundation of what we do and how we do it. So yeah, that, that was a great episode.

Like I said, there’s also another one a little bit earlier in the year on the making chips channel that if you want to learn more about tech stack, go listen to those. Cause they’re just foundational, I think, to establishing a good customer front.

[11:09] Josh McKain: Yep. Yep. And like you just said, everything, the example you just gave, bringing the customer in, taking them into the conference room, showing them what you can do.

That’s all building trust. Exactly. Like Paul said, you’re showing them, Hey, we’re going to consistently get you good parts and we’re going to get it to you on time.

It’s just establishing that trust.

[11:27] Mike Payne: Yeah. Yeah. Because every shop you walk, they walk into as a potential new vendor to them is going to tell them that they make good parts and they deliver them on time.

[11:38] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[11:38] Mike Payne: Right. And they all have the same mill. They all have the same way.

They all have the same saw. Their tool room looks the same. Right.

[11:48] Speaker 5: Yep.

[11:48] Mike Payne: Yep. What’s the differentiator.

[11:52] Josh McKain: Yeah. And can you prove, look at our on time, look at our time delivery performance over the last eight months. The number’s right here.

Another episode that came up that I was thinking through back at, I think it was episode five, was Arthur Field. And he was talking about the stereotypes in manufacturing and how they prevent us really from hiring. They make hiring more difficult because people expect.

So he said, dark, dirty, and dangerous. Those are the stereotypes in manufacturing. And the idea that he shared that this was really new to me, I’d never thought about this before.

So not only is it our idea to paint, or is it our responsibility to paint a true picture of what manufacturing truly is now. There’s robots and it’s pretty clean and it’s pretty safe. And there’s, you know, it’s a high tech space.

Not only is it our job to paint that, but it’s also our job to, to overcome these stereotypes that have, Arthur specifically said, you know, kids are learning about manufacturing through movies they see in Hollywood where these two bad guys are fighting in a warehouse that’s dark and dirty and dangerous. And subliminally, it’s telling them, oh yeah, that’s what all plants are like. They’ve never consciously thought that, but that’s what they’re thinking.

So we can’t just expect them to know, well, this is what a plant looks like today. We’ve got to show them and overcome those stereotypes. Yeah.

[13:18] Mike Payne: I think that’s such a great point because that’s, I know, I mean, for 15 years running or something like that, I saw a study recently, I think it was Gardner media, but 15 years running, the biggest issue facing manufacturers is people. The next five vary as we’ve run through cycles, right? Automation, AI is on their list now.

Like, how do I incorporate that? Lots of things, but the one consistent over this 15 year period is people. And I hear, we all talk about it.

We’ve got to expose people more. We’ve got to, we got to get to the parents and explain to them that this is not a, this isn’t a, my kid wasn’t smart enough to do something else.

[14:02] Speaker 5: Yeah. Yeah.

[14:03] Mike Payne: You know, and we talk about it and we talk about it and we talk about it. And one of the things that I just, and I don’t disagree with it at all. Right.

I mean, it’s, you can’t. My, the thing I’ve yet to really hear is a how. Right.

So I’m curious, was there any, what were some of the discussions that came out of that? Cause there’s a lot of hows, right. But to answer all those things, did anybody have anything new there where you’re like, oh, you know, that’s a really good idea.

I hadn’t thought of that.

[14:35] Josh McKain: Really? No, nothing was a earth shattering new revelation of how to show people the shop. Arthur’s a video guy.

So he was talking about, get your phone out. Every one of us has 10 years ago, like Hollywood quality cameras in our pockets.

[14:51] Speaker 6: Right.

[14:51] Josh McKain: So get your phone out, walk out on the floor. I mean the big, his big push that is probably, I’m not super comfortable with it. And it’s a little bit new for me is be candid, be unprofessional, be unpolished, just pull it out.

And what’s on your mind, just show the shop floor and show what you’re working on. Of course, as long as you can show it and just be open and honest and vulnerable in a, just a real way people want real. And especially if you’re trying to appeal to younger generations, they can sniff out a lack of authenticity from a mile away.

They’re like sharks smelling blood in the ocean. They can smell if you’re not authentic. So that was probably my biggest takeaway with Arthur was, yeah, just be real and raw and show what you’re working on.

Yeah.

[15:40] Mike Payne: Yeah. And I think, I think that probably is kind of the right answer because the, you know, I think, I think we’ve, again, we’ve all been focused on this for 15 years and there hadn’t been noticeable movement, right. Or resolution to this problem.

But when you look at, you know, like you said, Arthur’s a video guy, he’s, he puts out some really good content. Obviously the, you know, kind of the giant in the industry for that is Titan, right? Like Titan and Titan recently filmed at my place.

And when you talk about just be real, be honest, grab the phone in your pocket. Two thirds of our video was done with his cell phone.

[16:17] Speaker 6: Hmm.

[16:18] Mike Payne: There was one other guy that had a camera, but most of he and I talking is he and I talking to his phone. So that’s cool. You know, you don’t have to have that full on video production.

And I think, you know, I think a young person watching that video about our shop, it should be received well, right? I mean, Titan brings a great energy. We have a nice shop.

I mean, I think you, I think a young person watching that video would be hard pressed to go. Well, that’s not the type of place I want to work. You know what I mean?

We do have a clean shop. It’s not dark, dirty, and dangerous. We have modern technology.

We’ve got robotics and AI and, you know, multi-axis turning and, you know, milling and the, those are cool things. And again, Titan is, you know, obviously this is what he does and he’s really good at telling that story, but I think everybody can do that too. Right.

I mean, you can grab that phone, like Arthur’s saying, just tell your story.

[17:17] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[17:17] Mike Payne: I know. I’ve done, I mean, I’ve done it a few times personally, like on social media and it’s always good feedback. Like I get good feedback from those.

So yeah, that’s a good idea because waiting on some organization to do it, waiting on them, right.

[17:36] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[17:36] Mike Payne: To solve this problem is not going to solve the problem.

[17:39] Josh McKain: Yep. Yep. And that sort of came up in Arthur’s episode and another one, Jim Mayer was our first episode all about the skills gap.

And so you had asked, what was, were there any like, not magic bullets, but like, were there any new techniques for showing your process and your facility, getting young people interested? And the technique, I don’t know if it was Arthur’s or Jim’s episode. This was maybe the only nugget of wisdom that I’ve shared on this show so far was that it doesn’t matter.

There is a best thing to do, but it doesn’t matter exactly what you do matters that you’re doing something. So there’s really only, there’s two buckets of owners in manufacturing. Everyone is one or the other bucket.

One bucket, they blame the young people for not wanting to work in manufacturing. The other bucket, they accept that, okay, maybe a lot of young people have been turned off to manufacturing, but what can I do about it? They’re asking the question behind the question, what this maybe wasn’t my problem that I created, but it is my problem that I’m facing.

What can I do about it? And so whether it’s a video or a tour through the local community college or internships, whatever you can do to get people in, as long as you’re doing something and you don’t even have to accept responsibility for the problem. But if you were taking responsibility for the solution that puts you ahead of half of the owners out there who would just rather blame the younger generation and act like their hands are tied, whatever they say may be true, but it’s not helpful.

It’s helpful to go out and pursue good young people who do want to work and get them into your shop working harder than they are anywhere else.

[19:15] Mike Payne: Well, I think one of the things you just said there is, you know, maybe more enlightening than just as it relates to this. I mean, again, we talk about how you differentiate yourself as a shop and, you know, with your tech stack or whatever. It’s the same thing.

You know, I mean, there are shops that blame everything. It’s manufacturing. It’s hard, right?

As Paul Van Meter talks about a lot, there’s one way to be successful and there’s a million ways to be unsuccessful on every job we run, right? And I’ve been in those shops. I’ve talked to those people that like of those million ways.

It’s never their fault.

[19:57] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[19:58] Mike Payne: Right. Yeah. So, so there’s kind of this throw your hands up like, well, there’s nothing I can do about it.

I’ve been in the shops and I’d like to think we’re one of them like, okay, something went wrong. That’s fine. Set it aside.

How do we fix this? Right. So, you know, the same thing, it’s, it may or may not have been your problem.

Maybe your part got scrapped at heat treat. Right. I mean, like, you know, let’s put it into that practical of an instance.

You’ve machined a part, sent to heat treatment, scrapped. Well, you still not, are you just going to not deliver a part to your customer?

[20:31] Josh McKain: Yeah. Yeah. I’m sorry.

I didn’t do it. Yeah.

[20:33] Mike Payne: Not my problem. No, you’re going to, you’re going to regroup. You’re going to, you’re going to get this right and you’re going to solve your problem.

Right. Well, so it’s kind of the same thing with, I mean, again, that might even go back to, it’s just a cultural thing. Right.

Are you a problem solver or are you a, or do you just accept the defeat? Well, young people don’t want to work in the industry. So I guess I’ll just auction my equipment off.

[20:56] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[20:57] Mike Payne: I mean, that’s your alternative is as my team retires, I’m just going to auction my equipment off and go out of business.

[21:03] Josh McKain: Yeah. And I mean, it’s, it’s definitely easier to just blame someone else and sometimes it feels good, but it’s not super effective if you actually have goals you want to achieve.

[21:14] Mike Payne: Yeah. And it very well may be their fault, that other person’s fault, but you still got to solve the problem though.

[21:22] Speaker 3: In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental. It’s engineered, but a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent follow-up and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle.

Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities. That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers.

Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations, and sets qualified meetings. So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do.

Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R M-F-G dot com slash chips.

[22:26] Josh McKain: I’ll give a plug for, that’s John Miller’s book, the QBQ. I’m looking over on my bookshelf. QBQ, asking the question behind the question.

I reread it every year. I’m due in about a week to reread it. It’s like a hundred pages.

And it just encourages you in every situation, good, bad, whatever, ask the question, what could I have done to have fixed this or made it better? Or what was my role in, in achieving this outcome? Cause it’s always good to learn that and to see, well, this is what I could have done better and I’ll do it better next time.

And instead of passing blame, even if it’s not your fault, you can still ask, well, how could I have prevented this? How could I have helped this to go more smoothly? So great book, highly recommend it.

[23:09] Mike Payne: Yeah. No, I want to look at that. I, it reminds me of, so this is a conversation we’ve been having internal of our shop lately.

So if we have a scrap part or rework or something like that, we ever, you know, everybody’s got to fill out or whoever touched that part that where it went, where there was a failure has to fill out a non-conformance report. Right. And the last part of the non-conformance report is process improvement suggestion, right?

Again, this is, I’m, this is, that part is not revolutionary. I’m just setting the baseline. And I know we used to let them not fill out the process improvement.

And I’ve been in a lot of shops that don’t require you to feel like if you don’t know, just like leave it blank. Right. Well, my, my new approach, I say new, I’ve expected it for a couple of years, but now I send it back to them.

If it’s, if it’s not filled out, there’s gotta be something like, yeah, I don’t care if it’s ridiculous almost. Right. I mean, you can say, well, the only way we can solve this problem is with a wire EDM machine that we don’t have.

Okay. That’s fine. Right.

Doesn’t mean I’m gonna go out and buy a wire EDM machine, but if I got a hundred of those this year that would have been solved with a wire EDM machine, I might start thinking about it. So what I’m trying to do is just prompt people to say, to really have more of that problem solving mentality where it’s like, well, I could, this could have been prevented if this other step would have happened, or if we had this other tool, or if we had this other capability, or if, you know, whatever. I mean, there can be a million answers, and I’ve actually even, you know, we have machines all over, we have computers all over our shop floor because we run ProShop, and so this is all done on the floor.

I’ve even rolled out like ChatGPT to all those and say, hey, if you don’t know, like if you really don’t know an answer, like what you could have done different, put the, put, put what happened into ChatGPT and say, what might have prevented this?

[25:24] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[25:25] Mike Payne: And I’ll tell you, it’s pretty incredible the answers that it can come back with.

[25:30] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[25:31] Mike Payne: I would say nine times out of ten that we’ve done that, there’s been at least one or two ideas that nobody in the room considered, and once they read it go, you know, that’s actually not a bad idea.

[25:46] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[25:46] Mike Payne: And so again, it’s just, I guess it goes back to culture, right? Like we’re trying to create a culture of, we want people thinking, we want people looking for solutions, not problems, right? Like, so that’s, I love that we got on that topic because I mean, that’s like one little trick we’re doing to try to promote that as part of who we are and then back to the biggest thing you said, then communicate it, right?

Don’t know what could be done better and not communicate it back to the team, right? Tell everybody.

[26:16] Josh McKain: Well, speaking of the communicating, what do you do with those forms once they’re filled out? Is there a regular review where everyone gets to see them?

[26:26] Mike Payne: So they go into, so they all get reviewed kind of through the chain, right? So your quality department sees every one of them. My quality department and my ops manager see every one of them.

I tend to look at every one of them. I miss, you know, if I’m out for two or three days, I don’t catch them all or whatever. The, so everybody has access to all of them.

They do go through a review process. There are ones that are like, okay, yeah, that’s just bad luck, right? Like tap broke, you know?

The, but there are many based on some different criteria, you know, whether it’s value of the part or, you know, just different stuff that do go into like an NC, like a regularly scheduled, like NCR review meeting where we just sit down and we talk about that one. What could have been done different? What do we need to do next time?

You know, we don’t want this to be a reoccurring theme, right? And then the next time we run something, I mean, part of our process is to go look at the previous times we ran it also.

[27:28] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[27:28] Mike Payne: So, so we do go look at the history of NCRs on this part, even if it didn’t get to that, like that formal NCR review, my manufacturing engineering team should have looked and gone, you know, cause at some point you start to spot a trends like, like, you know, I use broke a tap as an example. Like, I mean, it happens. You can start to see a trend though, that we break it every nine parts, right?

Yeah. So let’s, you know, maybe we could prevent this by just replacing the tap at number eight, right? So, so there are lots of times when you start to see those trends from the reviews or from the process improvement suggestions that it changes the way we do things next time.

[28:14] Speaker 5: Yep.

[28:15] Mike Payne: So that’s how we handle it.

[28:18] Josh McKain: Yeah, no, it makes sense. I was thinking also, what was the, you said maybe we need a wire EDM machine and you had said, well, I probably won’t get it for one report, but if a hundred people said that. And so when you review those, you get other people chiming in saying, you know, I didn’t think about that, but actually that could have helped me last week too.

And then you do, it turns into more reports because it’s being shared and it’s being communicated and people are remembering, yeah, that’s actually something that could have helped me too.

[28:48] Mike Payne: Yeah, we do. And in addition to what I described, we also do in our monthly shop meeting, we review our kind of our top. So we look at the overarching data and we do look at, cause that’s KPI we track, right?

Scrap and rework. So we do look at like, what’s, what are our top reasons and causes of NCRs. And we look at, you know, we talk about ways we can reduce those.

Sometimes we’ll review one of these. We’re like, Hey, you know, here was a big failure, but here’s what we learned from it. And here’s how we’re going to start doing things going forward.

Right. So, yeah, I mean, a lot of that goes back to like, I mean, you’ve heard me talk before about like, I’m all about kind of data driven decisions, right? So collecting all that type of stuff, we have the data, we can look at it, we can make judgment calls on, you know, is this worth making a change?

So, so like in the EDM example, yeah, as you talk about stuff, that, that could be the type of thing that just, you know what, this is a reoccurring, you know, several times a year, we realize that if we had this additional capability and I mean, through EDM out just for fun, but I mean, it could be as simple as, well, we really need an insert, you know, an inserted drill with, through coolant, through spindle coolant, right?

I mean, like we need to run this type of part with this type of feature on the machine that has through spindle coolant, high pressure coolant delivered through the tool, blah, blah. Okay, well, now we’re saying, okay, do we need to go invest in some more tooling or something like that?

[30:23] Josh McKain: Yeah, and I think you, oh, sorry, go ahead.

[30:25] Mike Payne: No, I was just saying, you know, so again, buy a new machine, I used as an example of, I don’t care if it’s that out there, but what, but to your point, what it does, it creates communication, it creates conversation, which creates ideas that then lead to, okay, this could solve for a lot of problems. This one decision can solve for several.

[30:51] Josh McKain: Yeah, and I think that ties in, I think it was on your KPI episode with John where you said, once you realize what your scrap rate is on a certain part, you build that into your quote or you turn it down and so you can see, well, I know for this part because of our non-conformance, we’re going to have to run it with these tools and it’s going to cost us as much money, so either we need to not quote this or we need to build that in. So it’s just more data.

And that also reminds me too, you just said you’re very data driven on your cashflow episode. You said something, this is a provocative way of saying something. I had a marketing professor say at one time, you had said the cashflow is too important, something along these lines, it’s too important to just let the accounting people look at it.

That doesn’t mean that you don’t think the accountants are not smart enough to do it, but it means the minute something is off with your cashflow, you want to know. It’s so important that it has to go all the way to the top. And that was a good takeaway of that episode for me is just some of these things you think, well, that’s a finance and accounting function.

I don’t need to mess with that as the owner, but if it’s mission critical like that, it’s too important to just leave in a single department’s hands. It needs to be spread out.

[32:06] Mike Payne: Yeah. And I think that’s one of them for me. I think it probably should be one for most people, but it goes back to, if you listen to shows, you listen to consultants, you listen to all the common sense in the world, you read books about business ownership and leadership and stuff.

I mean, everything’s about decoupling from your business and delegating. And I agree with that a thousand percent. You have to, otherwise you are the bottleneck to your business.

But I also am a big believer of, you can’t delegate everything, right? You can’t be so delegated and outsourced that you don’t have a touch on those things that are the heartbeat. So for me, cashflow is definitely one of those.

The one I think that probably gets most overlooked is your culture. Your culture is going to follow you as the leader, as the owner, whatever role, whatever that role is. And if you outsource your culture, you’re going to have a poster on the wall that tells everybody what your culture is, that nobody’s living.

[33:16] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[33:17] Mike Payne: Right. So there’s, I think there’s so many things in our business that we have to, again, you do have to decouple, you do have to delegate. But there’s so many, I think sometimes that gets said so much to such an extreme that we look at delegating everything.

And I just, I don’t think that’s real, right? Yeah. You know, there’s strategic customer relationships that I still own.

The day-to-day customer relationship, same customer, but the day-to-day aspects of that customer relationship I don’t own. But the strategic aspects of it do, right? Same way with things in our culture, same way with things in our finance and accounting, same way with things in our operations.

I think sometimes we talk too much about delegation and not focused enough on like, but what do you have to own?

[34:12] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[34:12] Mike Payne: Right. Yeah. And yeah, so cashflow for me is one of those.

And part of that too, and I think this is going to vary for everybody. You know, I mean, I grew up in a finance world, right? So that’s, that is my background.

That’s what I’m strong at. So I’m going to own that piece. If I came into this world and have the manufacturing facility I have because I was a really good machinist and I was really good at manufacturing engineering, there’s a certain part of that I’m going to own.

And I am going to delegate off the finance, right? Yeah. But you got to stick to what you’re best at.

[34:49] Josh McKain: Yeah.

[34:50] Mike Payne: And own part of that.

[34:52] Josh McKain: Yeah. What’s your most valuable contribution to the business? You can’t, obviously you can’t delegate that.

And I’ve heard, it’s interesting. I’ve not really heard the perspective that you’re sharing that, you know, we’ve talked about it so much that like delegation is kind of running away, maybe out of control. And I think there’s some truth to that.

And I have heard people say, delegation is not abdication of duties. So you can’t just delegate and forget about it. And I think that’s a lot of times delegation instead of a tool to grow the business.

And instead of a tool to push it forward, it’s just a way to get the things you don’t like off of your desk. And I mean, there’s an element of that to it. That’s true.

But really it’s, you should be delegating intentionally to strengthen the business and not just to, I want this off my desk and I never want to think about it again. That’s not delegation. That’s passing the buck, which would have a negative connotation to it.

[35:51] Mike Payne: Yeah. Yeah. Maybe, you know, using the cashflow example, I mean, okay, it’s not your strength and you have a team that is good at it, but it’s still your cashflow.

[35:59] Josh McKain: Yeah. Still got to know.

[36:01] Mike Payne: And you may hate it and you may even want to avoid it because you’re in a cashflow crunch right now. Right. Like, but that’s when it’s time to double down and really understand it.

Right. I mean, I know I’m great at avoidance. I mean, I can avoid things I don’t want to do better than most, but sometimes you just can’t.

You got to dig in deep and take care of it.

[36:24] Josh McKain: You mentioned culture a few minutes ago and tying back to the show, on Jim’s episode one, he talked a lot about culture and he always asks this question that I think he’ll just ask people, what’s your definition of culture, which is you get a lot of great viewpoints. And he said, culture is the worst behavior tolerated. That’s what’s going to form your culture.

And I thought that was a great nugget of wisdom. I don’t have much more to add to that, but it reminded me of your KPIs. You had talked about measuring culture and that I think you had said maybe you didn’t have a great way of measuring it or it’s difficult to measure.

Do you have KPIs measuring your culture?

[37:02] Mike Payne: I don’t. So I kind of do, but it’s not a good answer. And I actually learned this from my great friend, Matthew Nix, Nix Industries, fifth generation business owner.

And this can apply beyond culture. This can apply to anything that there’s not a hard number for. It’s easy to track scrap as a percentage of parts we’ve made.

It’s how many did we make and how many were bad.

[37:34] Josh McKain: Put it into a spreadsheet and you’re done.

[37:36] Mike Payne: Culture. How the hell do you measure culture? And we’ve all heard all the cultures, how you feel on Sunday night.

Are you looking forward to going to work tomorrow? All great analogies, but how the hell do you track it? Matthew has a great way as far as I’m concerned, and I’ve started to do this because a lot of it’s gut.

So his team, as you layer through the organization, they are asked that. How is the culture? Green, yellow, red.

I mean, you can put any parameters on it. Rank it on a scale of one to five. And your view of my culture and my view of my culture can be totally different.

But it’s not going to be different day to day, week to week, month to month.

[38:29] Josh McKain: There will be consistent differences in how people are.

[38:32] Mike Payne: Yeah, there’s a consistency to what you think is great and what I think is great. Yeah. And so I might measure to three and you measure to four every day, every week, every month.

Right. Every year. But that establishes a pattern.

And if you’re collecting that data from enough people. Right. Throughout your organization from the top all the way throughout, you’re going to have a composite score of your culture.

[39:01] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[39:02] Mike Payne: It’s just a whole bunch of people’s gut feeling. Right. Yeah.

[39:06] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[39:07] Mike Payne: But you’re going to have you’re going to have a number. You’re going to have a yellow. You’re going to have some baseline standard.

Well, now you can track a trend. Right. So you can see if it’s getting better or worse.

You’ll see like right after the Christmas party, it goes up a you know, but and you’re going to see that time when we’re crunched and everybody’s getting hammered and everything cultures down a little bit. But if you establish a baseline based on anything, it can be a gut. It can be an actual number.

Now you can establish trends.

[39:44] Speaker 5: Yeah.

[39:44] Mike Payne: And so so that’s how I think that’s how I’m attempting to measure culture, like in a quantitative way that that I know if we’re on track. But the reality is I can walk around the shop at any given hour and tell you how our culture is right now. Right.

I can see it in people’s body language and faces and like, you know, but so does everybody else on your team. Right. So that’s why I think, you know, again, the more you can capture that data from more people, you can start to establish what yours is.

And are you trending in the direction you want to or not?

[40:17] Josh McKain: Yeah. And even if your baseline is wrong, so you come out and you say, well, I think we’re a yellowish green. I think that’s where our culture is at, even if you start in the wrong place.

But you say, yeah, our surveys are coming back. Great culture is high, but turnover is also way up. So there’s something we’re measuring it in the wrong way somehow.

But now you have some form of data.

[40:39] Mike Payne: Yeah. And I’m actually glad you pointed it out, because Matthew actually does then combine that with like his turnover data, which is hard data.

[40:48] Speaker 5: Yeah, that’s a fact.

[40:49] Mike Payne: And he’s got a couple other little HR things he tracks. So kind of all that, he feels very confident that he has a picture of what our culture is, you know, on a monthly, quarterly basis, whatever that is. I don’t remember how often he tracks it.

Actually, it’s everything I just said. If listeners want to hear it, if you go back and find the by the numbers episode I did with Matthew Nix in the spring, I think, we actually took a pretty good deep dive into some of that, because that was the first time I’d heard that.

[41:19] Josh McKain: Yeah. Put some data to those soft metrics. You got to.

[41:25] Mike Payne: Sorry, editors. Hold on. Okay.

All right. So I’m going to wrap this up now. Okay.

Because I actually have a call at 1130. I could get on. All right.

So I’m back, editors. So Josh, man, this was great. I always love when we can talk, because I like that we’re just talking, right?

Like we didn’t sit down with some crazy agenda that we’re trying to, we just, let’s talk about what you’ve learned through your show. It sounds like a lot of good stuff. Like I said, I know you’ve had a lot of great guests.

So tell the listeners how they can join in the fun and go find your shows and reach out to you and stuff.

[41:59] Josh McKain: Yeah. So the best starting point is to just join us on one of these live episodes. I post about it on LinkedIn.

There’s always a link at the top of my page to the next episode coming up. It’s called the throughput show, listening on Apple or Spotify or anywhere. And my website is throughput mastery.com.

And there’s a link on there also to register for the next show. And yeah, that’s the best place. I’m Josh McCain on LinkedIn.

It’s spelled MCK, which is unique. I’ve learned. Yeah.

That’s the best place to get involved is just join one of those shows and chime in and find one that interests you. If the, if this week’s topic is no good, next one might be different.

[42:38] Mike Payne: And all the other ones you said are like on Spotify, Apple, et cetera. So they go back and they can listen to the ones we’ve been talking about.

[42:44] Josh McKain: Yeah. And episode nine is Mike Payne. Cashflow is king with a couple of guests on there.

[42:49] Mike Payne: So that was a fun one that we, yeah, I would encourage people to go listen to that one. And matter of fact, there’s some tools that we talked about in there, like with the 13 week cashflow and stuff. I’ve actually sent out to several people that have listened to the episode that have reached out and said, you mentioned on there, you’ve got a template.

Do you mind sending that to me? So yeah, listen to that. And if you want to copy that template, holler at me.

I’m happy to get it to you. Well, Josh, again, thank you. I, like I said, I always enjoy our conversations.

They’re always great. I love what you’re doing in the industry. I love, I mean, we have so many people, great people in the industry that are out there just sharing, trying to lift the entire industry up and share all this stuff.

And I appreciate you being one of those. And the listeners go listen to Josh’s show. Start with my show.

I mean, if you listen to my show, you already like to talk about cash. So go start on number nine. If that one piqued your interest, go listen to those others.

And yeah, with that, Josh, again, thank you listeners. I will talk to you next time.

[43:46] Josh McKain: Awesome. Thanks again for having me, Mike.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.


Connect with Josh McKain

Connect With Buy the Numbers

Subscribe to Buy the Numbers

on Apple + Spotify

Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.