By Jennifer Dubose
The Cost of Quality — Why Getting It Right Is the Fastest Way to Get Paid, Ep #39
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Quality is often treated like a cost center in manufacturing. Something we have to do to satisfy customers, auditors, or certifications. But in my experience, quality is much more than that. It’s one of the biggest drivers of cash flow, reputation, and long-term profitability in a shop. In this episode of Buy the Numbers, I sat down with Mehul from Ground Control to talk through the real, often hidden, cost of quality.
Our conversation starts with a simple but critical idea: parts don’t get paid for unless the paperwork is right. You can machine a perfect part, ship it on time, and still watch payment get delayed weeks or months because an inspection report or FAI is missing or incorrect. That reality reframes quality documentation from “extra work” into a core financial process.
We walk through the full value chain of quality, from inspection planning and bubbled prints to in-process checks, scrap, rework, and external escapes. Along the way, we talk about where shops lose the most time and money, how better systems can prevent problems before they happen, and why catching issues internally is always cheaper than letting them reach the customer.
This episode is a practical look at quality as prevention, protection, and leverage. If you’ve ever dealt with late payments, chargebacks, rejected paperwork, or rework that quietly eats margin, this conversation will change how you think about the true cost of quality.
You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…
- (0:00) A real-world quality failure and why documentation mistakes are so costly
- (1:30) Meeting Mehul and the origin story behind Ground Control
- (5:01) Grow your top and bottom-line with CliftonLarsonAllen (CLA)
- (6:12) Why quality documentation is directly tied to getting paid
- (12:00) Why bubbled prints are the essential first step of quality planning
- (14:16) Using automation and AI in quality without removing human judgment
- (15:15) How Factur can help you fill a qualified sales pipeline
- (16:21) The time and labor cost of manual quality processes
- (19:07) Prevention vs correction: how better planning reduces scrap and rework
- (20:31) The importance of in-process checks and smarter inspection strategies
- (23:26) Why quality education must extend beyond the quality department
- (24:07) Mark your calendars and come see us at IMTS 2026
- (25:07) Reporting quality data with or without a fully integrated QMS
- (26:54) Internal vs external failures and why external escapes are far more expensive
- (28:55) Supplier scorecards, penalties, and long-term reputation risk
- (31:40) How paperwork errors can erase margins and delay cash flow
- (35:56) Reframing quality as a revenue generator, not just a cost center
- (39:56) When quality failures become safety, legal, and life-or-death issues
- (41:48) Quick hits: key KPIs, common myths, and no-cost improvements
- (44:10) How to connect with Mehul and learn more about Ground Control
Resources & People Mentioned
- Grow your top and bottom-line with CliftonLarsonAllen (CLA)
- Get a free report of opportunities in your industry from facturmfg.com/chips
- Mark your calendars and come see us at IMTS 2026
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[Speaker 1]
What are some of the nightmares there and the cost of quality of not getting the right documentation at the right time in the right place?
[Speaker 2]
I mean, we have seen some egregious things, like I can just tell you one off the top of my head. We saw a hundred page, not even a hundred, it must have been 150 page FAI report, you know, tons of material certs, tons of dimensions, characteristics, balloon drawings, the whole works and it got rejected because of they misspelled the word the. What they spell it, the instead of the or what?
I don’t even, it must have been TEH or something. And the problem was they, the source inspector didn’t tell him specifically what the issue was, as they say, rejected due to, you know, FAI rejection, not bought off, fix, fix it and then resubmit it.
[Speaker 4]
Welcome to buy the numbers each week. We’ll explore the numbers that drive your business from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company.
Let’s crunch some numbers.
[Speaker 1]
Mahul thanks for coming to the show. Thanks for having me, Mike. So we met, um, what back in like late summer, early fall.
Yeah. I guess it was in summer in Indianapolis at the automated shop conference. That’s right.
I met you, Paul Van Meter, a few others. Yeah. Yeah.
And, um, you were telling us about ground control at the time and, and, uh, one of my shops is actually now using ground control, but why don’t you tell the listeners a little bit about who you are and what ground control does so they’ll understand what we’re going to talk about today?
[Speaker 2]
Absolutely. And it’s funny because that show was an interesting show because my dad was actually there. He had the title chief dad.
[Speaker 1]
Your dad was awesome, by the way.
[Speaker 2]
Like we all loved your dad. He’s so proud of you.
[Speaker 1]
I know.
[Speaker 2]
I’m very lucky. He, he helps us all the time in like the story, the whole really origin comes from him. So he has always been an entrepreneur.
He, um, owned several PCB manufacturing businesses. So a little different from machining, but the same end customers. And he was building PCBs for everyone from, you know, SpaceX and Tesla to Apple and Google to Lockheed and Northrop.
And I was software engineer. I, you know, did my undergrad, got my master’s in AI and went to go work at, you know, big tech, like Amazon quickly found that it wasn’t for me and joined the family business and got a very, very intimate look at, you know, how can technology transform manufacturing business? Sure.
Because up until that time, things were fairly, you know, paper-based antiquated. I mean, it was still running. The business was doing great, but there was a lot of room for scale with technology.
Sure. And so I got to build software things like, you know, enhancing the customer experience, operational efficiencies, automating data entry, all sorts of things. And one specific thing that was really interesting was quality documentation.
Quality at our businesses and probably several other ended up being a little bit of an underserved department, even though it was one of the most critical departments. And it’s interesting because, you know, the way some people look at it is like, well, quality’s main job is to stop me from shipping things, which is true, but, you know, for a much more important reason. Stop you from shipping bad things.
Exactly. Right. And so we were, you know, getting parts.
We were a quick turn shop. We would do 24 hour turns, 48 hours all the time. And what would happen is we would actually get parts that were sitting on the shipping dock, just waiting to ship, but they couldn’t because of the paperwork.
And that paperwork was, you know, all your CFCs, your FAI report, all that kind of stuff. And the way we were doing it was either at some facilities manual or at other facilities with, you know, legacy software. Things that were not bad, but they were a little bit, weren’t seeing the time savings we expected.
And so me and two friends, we kind of locked ourselves, you know, in a room for six weeks and said, let’s see if we can come up with something better. Yeah. And so we were all software engineers.
We wrote the code and we gave it to them literally six and a half weeks later and they did something. And then the first week they were doing them twice as fast. Oh, wow.
Yeah. So that was like, okay, this is kind of interesting. Yeah.
So we looked at, you know, talk to other shops we knew and said, you know, do you guys also face this problem? And turns out a lot of people are doing quality documentation more manually than they need to.
[Speaker 1]
Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring improving profitability? Gaining efficiencies with AI automation?
Tightening up your cybersecurity? Getting your business ready to sell? There’s so many things.
At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more. Every day, CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings. Imagine cutting scrap by 75% and saving millions or boosting capacity and revenues by up to 20%.
Picture achieving four and a half million in accelerated tax deductions, doubling your business’s sales price or slashing order intake time by 75% with automation. And how about increasing inventory turns by 50% with key operational changes? All of these are real CLA success stories with one thing in common, a deep understanding of the client’s business.
So what’s your biggest challenge and how can CLA help you? Visit claconnect.com to learn more about how you can grow your top and bottom line. Yeah.
So, you know, I talk about with my team. So sometime a couple of years ago, we went through and did kind of a whole, you know, process mapping of everything we do. Right.
And, you know, naturally you kind of start the process and you go, well, we quote a job and then we get an order and, you know, and it, you know, we found we were found pretty quickly. I mean, that, you know, I mean, that’s, there’s nothing wrong with that value mapping, but, but we real quickly kind of ditched that plan and started at the back end. Right.
So, I mean, ultimately what do we want out of everything we do? We want to get paid. Right.
I mean, it’s, I mean, we need money coming into the bank. How do we get money coming into the bank? Well, we send an invoice.
How’s the invoice get paid? They’ve received parts. They’ve received more importantly, all the proper documentation that goes along with those parts, because, you know, when we started breaking down, like, when do we get paid late by some of maybe our biggest customers that generally pay us great, you know, on their terms, whether I like the terms or not.
You know, we, I think that a scenario probably most people in this industry can relate to is, you know, you’re expecting to get paid in net 60. 60 comes and goes, you know, net on 65th day, you’re going, why haven’t they paid this invoice? And you call them up and they say, oh, we didn’t, you know, we didn’t get a copy of the inspection report.
So we haven’t received those items yet. So now you’ve got to wait. Now you’ve got to get the paperwork.
Hopefully you still have paperwork. I mean, if you have good systems in place, you do, and it’s just a matter of emailing them over. But now you, you know, sometimes you might even be restarting a 60 day payment cycle at that point.
Right now, I have found typically the customers are like, oh, gosh, yes, we have had the parts. Thanks for getting this paperwork. We’ll get you paid next week.
But point being, you know, just the paperwork side of quality, I mean, is really your trigger to even get paid on a job much. I mean, parts are no parts. If you don’t have all the quality documentation in place, you’re not getting paid.
So, you know, I love that, you know, you’re answering a real problem there. And that’s, that’s just the first piece of it. Right.
That didn’t even get into like the, you know, prevention of errors, catching errors, all those types of things. So if people haven’t guessed by now, today, we’re going to talk a little bit about kind of the cost of quality. And there’s a there’s a lot of things there that that can go in into that.
I mean, beyond the fact of just making good parts, but we’re going to kind of take this more from the angle of the systems that you can have in place to, you know, lower the cost of quality. And, you know, you talked about speed of quality already. That’s obviously going to be a big factor, getting the paperwork there.
You know, when I when I look at the cost of quality, I and I’d love to hear if you feel differently. But, you know, I think a good inspection plan helps you prevent a lot of quality issues. Right.
And then there’s the oh, I don’t know what you would call it, but the actual time of doing it all. Right. So whether that’s first articles in process, all that type of stuff and doing the reporting and then catching stuff internally, scrap, rework, so forth, and then worst case, catching stuff externally.
Right now, you still have the scrap and the rework and maybe a little damage to your scorecard with your client or your reputation or anything like that, chargebacks. And and then, yeah, the payable cycle. Right.
Like just having the correct documentation along with everything. So how do you feel about those buckets and maybe you have more or maybe you like to drill those down differently?
[Speaker 2]
No, I think you’re absolutely right. I mean, just looking at a lot of these regulated industries, you can’t even do work for them unless you have the proper QMS in place. Right.
Right. I think, you know, of course, ISO 9001, I think that’s kind of fairly table stakes now these days. But looking at aerospace as an example, if you don’t have your AS9100 QMS, you’re not even going to get any work for them.
They won’t even quote jobs to you. Right. And so I actually I completely agree that I think it’s often looked at as a chore, like, oh, I’m forced to do all these things.
But you can also look at it as, oh, wow, I’m like putting the proper systems in place that are going to help me build quality product all the time and, build a preventable kind of proactive landscape instead of being reactive. And after the scrap happens or after you get the RMA, you’re like, well, shoot, now what do we do?
[Speaker 1]
Yeah, I mean, in my experience, when I bought Hill and when I bought the subsequent shops I’ve bought, typically everything related to, well, the work orders just in general, I mean, all the processing was paper based. But on the quality front, you know, that it leaves a lot up for interpretation, you know, in my experience. And, you know, I can remember seeing like in process check paperwork that’s just, I mean, it wasn’t even really thorough enough.
Certainly based on the way we do things now, I would say that the way we were doing it was so prone for error, you know, and it didn’t set you up to have a, you know, have a quality process that’s going to save you time and money. But I feel like now, and it starts with, you know, an area that you start with, you know, even just bubbling a print right to me is kind of that essential first step of your quality planning that you can really start to affect the outcome of a job. I mean, and, you know, I know in some cases just like the bubble prints just required.
But I mean, what have you seen like impact? So maybe explain a little bit about what ground control does as it relates to like, maybe we start with like the bubbling the prints. And then what impact have you seen on that with some of your customers that were doing it differently before?
[Speaker 2]
Oh, absolutely. Yeah. So I mean, you know, when you’re looking at bubbling a print, really what you’re doing is kind of mapping out the entire, like you said, the entire process and building the part and taking stock of, Hey, what are the dimensions that we care about?
Of course, you know, we care about all the dimensions, but what are the critical dimensions? What are the major dimensions? What do we need to really make sure we take into account so that we build this product or this part correctly.
And I think from our experience, and we’ve talked to hundreds and hundreds of shops, I want to say over 50, 60% of them are still doing this on pen and paper by hand. And I mean, there’s obvious drawbacks to that there’s, there’s less obvious drawbacks to that the obvious ones being that, you know, it takes a lot of time. And it’s very, very error prone kind of process, right?
Because if you, you know, when you’re looking at really, really tight precision work, like, I don’t know, half a thou, a single typo can destroy you. Exactly. Destroy.
And then you’re dealing with scrap and rework and that whole mess. And so what we do, our software, uh, ground control is really meant to kind of, yes, speed up, but I think more importantly, make sure that you’re accurately kind of settings things in place, right? So make sure you’re, you’re accurately bubbling a print and you’re catching all the dimensions.
And so what we do is we automate that process by essentially letting you look at a drawing, whatever structure it is, and automatically identify all the characteristics on the page, but with the still human in the loop element, you know, I think there’s a lot of buzz about AI to get on my soapbox for a second. There’s a lot of marketing hype about AI and how it’s going to, you know, take away everyone’s jobs in the next six months or 12 months or two years or whatever. And I think there’s certainly some truth to how good AI is getting, but I think that there is still kind of, we’re not at a place yet.
We’re still at a place where humans need to be in control. So what we try to do is help you use the AI to identify things and then let the human make the final decision. So at the end of the day, you know, you’re the one in charge of making sure what characteristics need to be bubbled, what part of which operation, things like that.
Yeah.
[Speaker 1]
My, my AI soapbox is just, you know, it’s, it’s at a trust, but verify stage, right? Like you can let it do a task, but you damn well better check it out. And then I also am a firm believer that AI is not going to take anybody’s job, but people that know how to use AI might take your job.
Yeah.
[Speaker 2]
And if anything, it’s going to create new jobs. I think there’s going to be a whole new set of jobs, just managing AI, controlling it, all that kind of stuff. Yeah.
[Speaker 3]
In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental. It’s engineered, but a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent follow-up, and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle.
Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities. That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers.
Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations, and sets qualified meetings. So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do.
Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R, M-F-G dot com slash chips.
[Speaker 1]
Yeah, I mean, I can speak for our experience. We’ve been auto-bubbling prints for, I don’t know, six or seven years now, I guess. Longer than that.
Well, at least seven years. You know, I mean, just so one of the costs, right, is time. And I remember very early on, as we were going digital with ProShop and, you know, needing bubbled prints and, you know, for the previous 25 years of the company, you know, the inspection manager gets the print, prints it out, sits down and bubbles it.
And then, well, at some point in there, they were doing it in Adobe, right, or whatever. And then translating those dimensions to a check sheet. And, but, you know, we were on some complex parts that might have, I mean, certainly dozens, if not maybe even a hundred or so dimensions.
And it took time, a lot of time. And then, like you said, a typo, right. So saving time, saving mistakes.
But I remember the first time we auto-bubbled a print and it took like six seconds and it caught everything. And it was like, it was shocking, you know, and I would say now in seven years, we’ve probably bubbled five, six, 7,000 prints, you know. So if that used to take you 30 minutes at a time and now it takes you 30 seconds, we’ll say, even to just load it, bubble it and load it into ProShop, maybe even a couple minutes, if you, I mean, really want to stretch it out there.
That’s game changer, right. I mean, that’s a huge cost of quality. And especially we, you know, I don’t know how most people do, but I mean, we certainly, it was, it was generally a, it was either a programmer or a inspection engineer, inspection manager doing that.
I mean, those aren’t cheap positions either, right. So to lose 30 minutes to an hour of their time bubbling a print versus doing it in seconds was a total game changer.
[Speaker 2]
Yeah, it certainly, it becomes a no brainer. And like, you know, a hundred dimensions is very complex. And we have some customers who regularly balloon five, 600, 700 characteristics.
I mean, these are huge parts, massively complex, but even at 25, 30, a hundred, it’s still important to kind of use automation where it makes sense, right. You actually want to spend your time focusing on inspecting the parts, you know, programming your CMM, making sure that things are working in process and not just bubbling prints all day.
[Speaker 1]
Yeah. So that, you know, that actually just even leads into that first bucket that I, what I call prevention as far as I like, that’s the first step of prevention. Right.
So, so now that I have this bubble print, you know, I can now create like an intelligent inspection plan and make sure I have the right tools and, you know, to inspect something. I mean, I I’m, I’m sure, I hope I’m not the only shop out there that’s ever gotten midway through a part and go, oh, we don’t even know how we’re going to measure this. You know, like it, it, I mean, it absolutely has happened.
Fortunately, it doesn’t happen much, but yeah. So that planning phase, you know, I mean, I certainly has, you know, led to the prevention and, you know, I, I can speak for myself. If I look at kind of our scrap rate pre and post a more diligent, you know, planning, inspection planning, I mean, we easily, easily, our scrap rate is decreased by two thirds.
I mean, our scrap and rework. Now there’s, that’s not just because we bubbled a print. I mean, that’s because it’s because of all the steps we’ve taken, but that, you know, saving that time that then allowed us to plan, that then allowed us to make sure we had the right inspection equipment, you know, down the line, adds up to a pretty drastic reduction in scrap and rework.
At least it has in our experience. Have you seen similar things in other places?
[Speaker 2]
Absolutely. And I mean, that goes to like one of the next things, which is probably the most manual, more than bubbling that we see is in process checks. I think, you know, you go into most, and again, this is not meant to be a slight anyone, but most machine shops you go into, there’s printed Excel workbooks at each station and folks are, you know, writing down the actual in-process measurements.
That’s what we had before, you know, that’s what we had eight years ago. Yeah. And now you see, you know, great systems like ProShop.
We have several customers who use ProShop and we tell them, you know, normally what folks will do with our software is they’ll export to an in-process check or they’ll use our software to do the in-process check. But if you’re using the ERP like ProShop and you have a great, like digital QMS, truly paperless QMS, that is a huge way to prevent things, again, in-process versus getting to the end of the line, you’re in shipping and then you realize, oh shoot, jacked this, you know, this dimension.
[Speaker 1]
Right. The other thing too, I mean, I guess it’s kind of the planning and in-process, but one of the things, again, you know, better systems led to better processes. I mean, one of the things that I noticed in our in-process checks before and after kind of this process switch was, you know, we used to just check everything, right?
Because it’s there, check it. And, you know, we can be a lot more intelligent now in what we check, right? So I don’t maybe need to check these three linears that are all done by the same tool on the same op and, you know, during the same process in the machine.
I can check one of them. If one of them is right, they all three should be right, right? You know, maybe an OD, an ID, a groove depth, you know, whatever.
Where you’re using a common tool for common features, you can feel pretty good by checking one instead of four.
[Speaker 2]
Yeah, that’s a great point. I think there’s like the other side of the coin is just over process, you know, over documenting everything for the sake of it, which like you said, isn’t the most efficient. There’s probably a good sweet spot where, you know, you’re checking the key things that matter, but you’re not just doing process for the sake of doing process.
[Speaker 1]
Right. Yeah. You want to, yeah, you don’t want to not check enough, but you don’t need to overcheck it.
Right. So again, cost of quality. I mean, if you’ve got people spending too much time checking apart or checking a plus or minus 20 dimension, when you know you can hold that and, you know, and maybe skipping over a plus or minus one or so, I mean, that’s probably that’s pretty extreme, but, you know, it could happen again, if you don’t have time to process it and plan it, then yeah, I mean, I could foresee that happening for sure.
[Speaker 2]
Yeah, that, that’s a, that kind of led my mind to another interesting point, which was like education, you know, it’s not just the quality team that needs to know quality processes. It’s kind of everyone on the floor of the machinists planning team, everyone, frankly, right. Cause they’re the ones that need to know why am I doing this?
What could be considered as extra work? Why am I even doing this? Right.
And so making it clear, like educating down the line, and that goes back to having a good QMS, like a software. Sure. Or it doesn’t have to be a software, but I suppose some sort of system.
Sure. Yeah. To educate folks, keep folks up to date on processes, keeping everyone in line, probably very underrated, but hugely important.
Yeah.
[Speaker 3]
What is up metalworking nation making chips family. It is an even year, which means IMTS is coming September 14th through 19th at McCormick place in beautiful Chicago. It is the largest manufacturing trade show in North America, bringing together thousands of manufacturers, OEMs and solution providers every two years to explore how new technologies are being applied to real shop floors.
So whether you’re planning future capital investments, benchmarking operations, or simply trying to cut through the noise around emerging technologies, IMTS is designed to help manufacturers make better, more informed decisions. Whether you’ve been going for years, or this might be your first time, put it on your calendar right now, schedule your time away from the shop. It’s good to get out and see new things.
It’s going to be a big party. I hope to see you there. Go to IMTS.com and register today.
[Speaker 1]
So we’ve talked a few times about the reporting. We’ve, we’ve started kind of talking about the reporting side of it, right? So we’re, we’re capturing this in process data.
Obviously there’s first article data that we have hopefully caught before that. Maybe, um, what if I don’t, I mean, like as we’ve said a few times, I’m on ProShop. You mentioned many of your customers are on ProShop, but what if I don’t have that?
How do you help there? What’s best practice there? I think you can help, but what do you see as best practice?
What do you see work or not work? Like if you don’t have a digital, if I don’t have a integrated QMS system, I do need to still, I still got to report my quality data.
[Speaker 2]
Yep. Yep. I mean, the, the obvious answer is, you know, there are times to think about, are we at the scale to invest in technology?
But if not, I think it just comes down to kind of what we’ve been saying this whole time, right? Having a good process in place and having a very strong culture of following that process and not cutting corners for the sake of speed or whatever. So as an example, um, something that we can help do there is, you know, we’ll help you bubble your print, generate your inspection plan, kind of highlight based on the profile of this customer, you know, what are the key tolerances that we actually should think about.
And then once you’re actually doing your, you know, like building the part, taking it through op 10, op 20, et cetera, you can actually use a system like ours to enter that data and get instant validation that says, Hey, you know, you should maybe look into this. You’re using up all your tolerance or, Hey, you’re good. You’re well within tolerance, things like that.
And, you know, not to be a dead horse, but just being proactive, doing the stuff at the beginning instead of building the whole part and then say, all right, let’s do our FAI now and measure everything and hope that we made it. Right.
[Speaker 1]
Okay. So we’ve, we’ve planned the job, you know, we’ve bubbled the print, we’ve planned the job, we’ve done some first articles, we’ve, you know, we’ve done some in-process checks and then now you bring up, okay, we find a problem. It’s a delicate balance there.
So as we started really driving our initiative to, you know, we have internal KPIs we’re targeting for scrap and rework, just like everybody else. I’m sure internally and externally. Right.
And externally, those targets are based on what our clients find acceptable. Right. I mean, our big OEM customers, they track everything we send them and they have a parts per million goal.
And, you know, I would say, I think our tightest is 0.4%, like they consider no big deal. Right. So whatever that translates to in, I mean, what, what is that couple parts per thousand or whatever?
Yeah. So that’s, we established that as our goals, right? So we take our tightest tolerance, our tightest allowance from our customer.
And we say, okay, that’s, that’s the most escapes we want to allow out of here. Right. Which then turns into your internal rate, hopefully skyrocketing.
Right. Because you’re catching them because I would always rather catch it internally and have a chance to rework, rerun, you know, whatever. There’s obviously a high cost there of catching your internal, but it’s just a fraction of the cost of getting caught external hard and soft cost externally.
Right.
[Speaker 2]
Yeah. And the second order effects, right? Like, yeah, the, the obvious first order effect is okay.
They ask you for, you know, send an RMA, you have to scrap the work, do it again, extra labor, extra material costs, et cetera. But the second order effect is, you know, over time that does affect your supplier scorecard. And that actually does affect you getting more work.
Right. Because at the end of the day, the OEMs care about two things, right? They want things on time and they want it good quality.
Uh, or maybe three things if you add having the paperwork, but at the end of the day, they care about.
[Speaker 1]
Well, and I would even, I’ll, I’m going to flip what you said a little bit. First and foremost, they care about quality. Right.
They’ll take a late part that’s good over a good, a bad part on time. Right. So, so yeah, I’m going to flip that around just a little bit and say, no, they care about quality first.
Then they care about on time. And then I mean, yeah, I guess they want to pay you. But yeah, I mean, the reputation piece, you know, not to mention the, you know, just the, God, the administrative costs of an external failure.
Right. So you got an issue in RMA, you got to, I mean, maybe they, maybe they have you do a, a root cause analysis on this, right. Or, you know, maybe, I mean, God forbid it was customer supplied material and you’ve got to, you got to pay them for the material or the casting or whatever that might be.
And so now you’ve involved like your accounting department and having to do work, you’ve involved the shipping department and there’s, you know, the administrative costs of an escape are huge. Not to mention you still need to re rework or remake the part. Right.
And then that leads us all the way down to what we first started talking about, which is you also need this to get paid. Right. So, so yeah, let’s just talk briefly about that.
I mean, as you’ve worked now with, you know, hundreds of different people, I mean, what do you, what do you see? What are the, what are some of the nightmares there and the cost of quality of not getting the right documentation at the right time and the right place?
[Speaker 2]
I mean, we have seen some egregious things, like I can just tell you one off the top of my head. We saw a hundred page, not even a hundred, it must’ve been 150 page FAI report, you know, tons of material certs, tons of dimensions, characteristics, balloon drawings, the whole works. And it got rejected because of, they misspelled the word, the.
What they spell it D instead of the, or what? I don’t even, it must’ve been T E H or something. And the problem was they, the source inspector didn’t tell them specifically what the issue was as they, they just say rejected due to, you know, FAI rejection, not bought off, fix, fix it and then resubmit it.
And now you got to go look through this whole report, figure out what the typo even was. You’ll probably find two others that they didn’t even spot. They finally get it accepted.
And, and this is like notorious and that’s pretty brutal. It’s brutal. And the issue with this, I won’t say any names, but the issue with OEM is they actually charge you money if you fail in FAI.
[Speaker 1]
Yeah, no, I, you know, so I have a, one of, used to be my largest customer and now one of my largest customers, you know, any given year top three, you know, and they’ve, I will say they’ve loosened up on this greatly. But when I first bought Hill, there was a $300 charge if anything was wrong. And I don’t mean like the part was bad.
I mean that, yes, that was $300 too, but, but yeah, paperwork error, $300. I don’t remember what they called it. But some feet, basically they’re saying, Hey, we’re going to have to spend time fixing your mistakes.
So we’re charging you $300, which, I mean, I guess I get to some degree, right. I mean, I wish I could pull that off. Matter of fact, I used to, I used to kid with my buyer when she would call with a, like rev change after we’d gotten the PO or, you know, a date pushback or date pull in or any quantity change, anything like that.
I’d always kid with her. I’m like, okay, I’m charging you $300 for that change. Right.
Well, you can’t do that. I’m like, well, I am. And of course I wasn’t, but you know, the same thing, right.
But what was good for the goose was not good for the gander in that case. But no, I mean, there can, I mean, to your point, there can be some significant, you know, penalties. And in addition to your scorecard and your ongoing reputation with them.
But I mean, there were definitely jobs where we would get it, we’d get hit with $300 charge over something stupid. You know, I mean, if it was a small job, we were, we didn’t even make $300 on the job.
[Speaker 2]
Well, that’s the, that’s the kind of ironic thing is, you know, it’s a $300 charge, which sucks. And it feels very visceral cause you, you know, you get it, but then you think about the cost of the actual product and the invoice that you’re late on that, you know, manufacturing businesses, unfortunately, like unlike software businesses are not as high margin. And so being able to get your invoices paid on time is worth its weight in gold.
Yeah. And that’s what we often tell people is, you know, we had a customer who I think their first pass yield, it went up from like 30% to 80% after using our software. And, you know, wow.
Yeah. And the investment in technology is, is greatly worth it. Just if not alone, just for getting your invoices paid on time.
Right.
[Speaker 1]
Yeah. I mean, a hundred percent. I mean, all your systems, I mean, all your systems need to work together to help accomplish that.
Right. I mean, I, I would argue to anybody that no one system is going to solve that problem, but, but, but if you have all those systems working together correctly and you have the right processes in place, then you can fix all the, you can fix most of those issues. This is manufacturing, you’re still going to have things happen, but, you know, just even using the $300 example, I mean, people might go, well, yeah, okay.
But, you know, I mean, there’s, there’s more than one shop in our space, you know, with a net margin at the end of the year around 10%, right. So, so to cover a $300 extra expense on that job, it needs to be at least a $3,000 order. Right.
To, to now break even. Yeah. You know, depending on your shop, depending on your volumes, I mean, I’ve got plenty of $3,000 orders flow through here.
Right. Two parts here, four, you know, 10 parts there, whatever.
[Speaker 2]
And, and one thing I’d recommend to people is, is like, don’t be afraid to, you know, reach out to your OEM for understanding for specific requirements. As an example, we’ve noticed PPAPs getting flown down a lot more in the aerospace industry and folks who maybe aren’t used to things like automotive industry may not know how to do them because their PPAPs are pretty, pretty complex compared to FAIs. But most OEMs actually have pretty good training material and we’ll take the time and won’t be like, well, why don’t you know this already?
Right. Because I think there’s a new standard of AS9100 coming out in September. They’re actually changing it to IA9100.
Oh. And I expect a lot of changes to happen specifically around PPAP and APQP, at least in that industry.
[Speaker 1]
I didn’t, yeah, I guess I haven’t followed along with that. So, so yeah, back to like, you know, we, we kind of opened with, you know, delivering the right document set with the parts or wherever, I mean, whether it’s physically with the parts or emailed to the right email address or whatever, you know, to me, that’s probably been the biggest factor in, despite all the time savings and everything else that we get, you know, better planning and all that, probably the, the biggest thing I’ve seen is just even really that speed of getting paid. Because when we were completely paper-based and all that stuff, just, you had to make sure you had it right. And, you know, I mean, good Lord, if it didn’t go with that packing slip, you know, it was a shot in the dark if we still had a copy, if, I mean, there was, and then you got into all sorts of issues, you know, and you’ve got two or three people chasing things down for half a day.
Right. So again, if you go back to the cost of time, you know, if you have two people spend four hours, you just lost eight hours that you’re never going to recoup. Right.
So what’s the cost of that? You know, it’s either $400 at your cost or it’s $800 at what they could have been charging for. Right.
I mean, there’s, however you want to do that math, it doesn’t matter. But I think a lot of the cost of quality just gets lost in, you know, it feels like a sunk cost. Like it’s just a something we have to do.
So it’s just, it doesn’t matter. You know, the other thing we’ve found with having better controls around our quality, and again, having the right kind of tech stack in place to track things, we’re also able to charge better for our parts. Right.
So if something’s super complicated to do a first article or requires a lot of in-process check, that’s going to keep the machine from running because they’ve got to check every 10th part and the machine’s not going to run while they’re doing it or whatever. You know, we’re able to capture that, see that and work that into our bid. Right.
So if it’s a 10 minute cycle time, but the machine’s not running, you know, for 10 minutes an hour because of a first article or because of an in-process check, it’s not 10 minutes cycle time. Right. It’s a 12 or whatever it is.
But yeah, the speed of getting paid, I think is probably a, that’s probably something that you don’t notice until it gets better. You know, and you quit getting, you quit finding those invoices that aren’t paid and calling and they’re going, oh, we haven’t received your paperwork.
[Speaker 2]
Yep. Yep. Classic net 180 payments.
We’ve seen those a couple of times.
[Speaker 1]
Well, I mean, I’ve got some of that, you know, and, and you don’t, you know, as the shop, you don’t have any reason to start asking questions until 181 days or 91 days or 62, whatever it is, because you weren’t expecting to get paid until then. And then when you don’t, and then lots of times that’s when the clock starts, right? So now you could have just turned 60 into 120 just because you didn’t send the right paperwork.
[Speaker 2]
Yeah. Maybe a good way to look at it is, you know, think about quality as not necessarily a cost center, but like a revenue generator, right? Like good quality can, yes, it’ll cost money.
Absolutely. Good quality, you know, CMM operators, QMS software, you name it, but it can actually generate, generate you a lot of money when you think about what the customers will think because at the end of the day, to be fair to them, you know, they have their own regulators who are on top of them, making sure that they have their paperwork for their end products.
[Speaker 1]
So, Oh, sure. Yeah. They’re not doing it to make our lives difficult.
I don’t think no, I mean, there’s, there’s a real reason for it, right? I mean, we want, we, for a lot of the things I do, I will hope our parts are right. Cause it’s going to affect me or somebody else.
If it’s not right. And you think about, gosh, think about the aerospace automobile medical. I mean, we don’t want to be sending out bad parts, right?
I mean, that’s, those could be life altering events if they’re not good parts.
[Speaker 2]
I read a terrible, terrible story, maybe a year, year and a half ago about a bell helicopter that had a crash mid flight. And they looked at the quality paperwork and it turned out that one of the suppliers had used the wrong, they were looking at the traceability basically. And one of the suppliers had used the wrong type of steel or aluminum that wasn’t able to handle the vibration frequency of the helicopter.
And that’s what caused the crash. These things are maybe not the only thing, but certainly is extremely important.
[Speaker 1]
Well, yeah. I mean, now, now there’s the hidden cost of quality, right? I mean, what is, what does that cost?
You know, I, it seems like once a year I run across a story similar to what you’re talking about. And there was, there was a famous one kind of before I got in the industry here locally in the oil and gas industry, something similar like that. It was a wrong material thing.
And, you know, nobody, nobody checked it, nobody, you know, whatever. Right. And somebody signed off on the wrong thing and, you know, the part exploded on an oil well, killed three people, you know, type thing.
You know, when they started tracing everything back, it went back to, you know, shop XYZ, whatever it was. And because everything had been signed off, I mean, like there was the owner of that shop actually spent some time in prison because he had signed off on the certificate of conformance or whatever, you know, and there was lawsuits and then the shop was gone. And yeah, so, I mean, you don’t really talk about cost of quality, right?
I mean, we’re kind of joking about NCR fees and all that. I mean, those are all annoying. I mean, there’s people’s lives literally on the line, right?
In a lot of cases. Well, hey, so I think I love how we’ve kind of covered the whole value chain of quality and certainly ground control can play a big role in that. A couple little questions for you based on everybody you’ve talked to, all the research you’ve done, all the development you’ve done around quality.
Let’s just get, let’s give, let’s give listeners just a like kind of little quick hits on a couple of things here. So what is like one quality KPI that you think everybody should be tracking?
[Speaker 2]
Probably an obvious answer, but certainly your, you know, rework rate. Rework. Yep.
[Speaker 1]
I would agree. That’s, I think that one gets lost, right? Cause we just go, oh yeah, just throw it back on the lathe and fix it.
You just lost six hours of that lathe or something like that. How about what’s, what’s one kind of myth around quality that you think maybe costs shops money? They don’t even realize it’s happening.
[Speaker 2]
I said this one earlier, but I think the myth is that quality is a cost center only. I think it’s actually a huge driver of revenue and even profit, right? Revenue from the sense of your customer is going to give you more work proper from the sense of higher yield, higher, less rework, more money.
Yep.
[Speaker 1]
I think that’s a good, good answer. Do you have a thought on like one process change that shops could take that will increase quality without spending a dime?
[Speaker 2]
If you could do one thing instead of, you know, let’s say you don’t have a QMS built in like pro shop, just use Google sheets on a computer instead of the writing down the in process notes. Cause the ability to have it digitally, it’s all free. You can use it.
Anyone can use it. Everyone’s got computers. Most people have computers at some workstation.
Sure. Having digital data will do you wonders. Yep.
[Speaker 1]
I like that. I would, I would add the one thing I would say, just plan your inspection process too, right? Like don’t just, don’t just shoot from the hip, actually plan it, plan out a process that will work and do it.
Well, that I really enjoyed this conversation. This was good. I think, you know, quality, we all talk about quality is the absolute heart of what we do.
It’s the most important thing we do. I don’t always see great processes and procedures and systems around quality. I know you guys are trying to solve that problem.
Just real quickly for the listeners, like how can they get in touch with you? How can they see what ground control does? If they have questions about their own processes, what’s the best way to do that?
[Speaker 2]
Yeah, absolutely. You can head to our website, run ground control.com. You can find us on LinkedIn or Google, maybe even Chats TV these days.
You can, you know, book time directly there. You can email me my phone number and email are both on the website. Yeah.
Thanks for having me on Mike. This is a blast.
[Speaker 1]
Yeah, this was good. I, and I certainly appreciate your time doing it. It’s like I said, it’s an important topic.
Listeners as always, thank you for listening and would love it if you would rate, review and share this, subscribe, all those fun things. It really does make a difference and we certainly appreciate it. So until next time yeah, just go make good parts so that you don’t have to deal with this cost quality.
Talk to you soon.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect with Mehul Shah
- Ground Control
- Connect on LinkedIn
Connect With Buy the Numbers
Subscribe to Buy the Numbers
Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK