By Jennifer Dubose

The PEO Playbook: How Small Shops Compete Like Big Employers, Ep #45

If you’re like most shop owners, HR, payroll, and benefits are necessary evils—important, but far from the reason you got into manufacturing in the first place. Yet those “back-office” functions can quietly drain your time, introduce risk, and even limit your ability to attract and retain great people.

In this episode of Buy the Numbers, Mike sits down with Jon from Thrive PEO to unpack one of the most misunderstood tools available to small and mid-sized manufacturers: the Professional Employer Organization (PEO). What starts as a conversation about payroll quickly expands into a broader discussion about risk management, employee benefits, compliance, and how to build a business that can punch above its weight class.

They break down common myths—like “we’re too small” or “it’s just outsourced payroll”—and reveal how PEOs actually create leverage. From accessing Fortune 500-level benefits to removing administrative burdens and reducing liability, this episode reframes HR from a cost center into a strategic advantage.

But beyond the numbers, this conversation is really about focus. What happens when you reclaim hours every week? What could you do if you stopped worrying about compliance, payroll taxes, and benefits administration—and started reinvesting that time into growth, people, and profitability?

If you’ve ever felt stretched thin trying to manage everything yourself, this episode might just introduce the “easy button” your business didn’t know it needed.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…

  • (0:00) How PEOs give small businesses access to large-company benefits and pricing
  • (2:52) What a PEO is and how it consolidates HR, payroll, and benefits
  • (6:00) Real-world example of fragmented HR functions vs. a unified PEO solution
  • (8:07) Myth: “We’re too small for a PEO” and why size doesn’t matter
  • (11:33) Leveraging pooled buying power to offer better, more affordable benefits
  • (14:57) Breaking down the “too expensive” myth with real financial logic
  • (17:14) Grow your top and bottom line with CliftonLarsonAllen (CLA)
  • (18:11) The three pillars of HR within a PEO: compliance, support, and technology
  • (19:55) Using PEOs as a resource for handling sensitive employee situations
  • (22:31) Enhancing employee experience through onboarding and HR tech
  • (23:39) Real example: outdated employee policies and the risk of non-compliance
  • (25:39) Constantly evolving employment laws and the challenge of staying compliant
  • (27:11) Integrating HR systems with quality management and compliance requirements
  • (29:38) Get a free report of sales opportunities in your area from FacturMFG.com/chips
  • (30:46) Opportunity cost: what business owners could do with time saved
  • (34:04) Hidden costs: liability, lawsuits, and compliance risks
  • (36:20) Expanding into retirement benefits and 401(k) access through PEOs
  • (39:16) Quality of life improvements for owners and leadership teams
  • (41:02) Why you need to have a conversation with Verdant Commercial Capital
  • (41:41) How to evaluate and choose the right PEO provider
  • (44:34) Payroll tax risks and real-world horror stories for small businesses
  • (46:56) Cash flow challenges and how PEOs stabilize payroll-related expenses
  • (49:53) Key criteria: people, processes, and platform when selecting a PEO
  • (53:21) How to connect with Jon to explore Thrive PEO for your business
  • (55:16) Final takeaway: using a PEO to “punch above your weight” in talent and growth

Resources & People Mentioned

Read the Full Episode Transcript

[0:00] A PEO environment, not necessarily having to play by the same rules that you would in the open market. You know, for smaller employers, getting access to disability insurance products, as an example, require a certain level of employer contribution and participation that make it not palatable for a lot of small employers. Getting access to expanded life insurance options as a small employer is challenging. PEOs put you in a place that you look like a large employer from a benefits perspective and don’t necessarily have to follow those same rules. And on the major medical side, you know, you’ll never meet anyone anywhere in any company says, you know, our benefits are really cheap and affordable. There’s no such thing as a good deal in benefits. But PEOs put you in a better spot. You know, for smaller employers that are playing in the exchange, you know, through Obamacare, so these groups under 50 with age-banded rates in the open marketplace, PEOs move you to the large group market. So true, it’s called composite rating, you know, that you see in larger employers, true employee rate, a true family rate, not something that’s blended based on your demographics. And so for a lot of employers, most of them, I would say 80% of the time, you know, you have richer benefits, you know, expanded offerings, the things that wouldn’t make sense to put in place before, and usually a little bit more economical. Yeah. Welcome to Buy the Numbers.

[1:30] Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business, from accounting and finance to operations, and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company. Let’s crunch some numbers. John, welcome to Buy the Numbers. Thanks, Mike. Thanks for joining me. Yeah, thank you for having me. So we were just trying to figure this out. Roughly three years ago, two and a half, three years ago, probably, you were on making chips. Probably three years ago, in this building. In this building. With your friends from Illinois, if I remember correctly. Yeah, it was Nick and Jason. Yeah. And I think we, if I remember correctly, we might have been drinking Prisoner’s Release High West bourbon. In the HR business, I don’t know that I’m going to admit that. It was a morning meeting. Yeah. No, I know it wasn’t because I know that bottle got finished over like three episodes. And actually the same day, we had a mutual friend of ours on the show, Steve Burkett from Auto-Turn. Steve’s funniest guy I’ve ever met, maybe. Which was a, it was more of a comedy episode than anything else. But yeah, so we’ll drop that in the show notes. It’s definitely worth going to listen to both of those.

[2:52] You know, full disclosure, you are my PEO, but let’s give the listeners a little bit of context. So what is a PEO and what’s your, what is Thrive? Sure. What do you do? Yeah, so in its simplest terms, you know, PEOs take every, in theory, take every non-revenue generating employee-related administrative function that a small business has. Small to me is probably anything under about 500 employees and give you a single source solution to manage those things. Most PEOs touch things that we all have to manage at any size of any employer. You have a payroll piece of your business. You got to pay your people. There’s an HR component that comes into play. Usually there’s employee benefits, workers’ compensation insurance. Most people manage those things with a group of different vendors. We’re just bringing those together under one roof and giving employers a single source solution to handle. And PEO stands for? Professional Employer Organization. Industry itself has been around since the late 80s. You know, I think initially doctors in particular were using it as a way to discriminate. For benefits purposes, give themselves access to better, more affordable benefits.

[4:08] Gotcha. It’s expanded, you know, as the industry and as regulations have come out that, you know, more adversely impact how we employ people and where we employ people. It gets a little bit more difficult every single year. This industry has evolved into this big thing. Well, and, you know, one of the reasons, I mean, we’ve talked about recording again for a while. But one of the reasons I reached out to you is because, you know, talking to a lot of our listeners and stuff, you know, it’s, I mean, this is obviously an important topic, right? I mean, people are our most valuable asset. Absolutely. You know, we need to take care of them. We need to manage that process. There’s a lot to it. A lot of people I talk to, let’s touch real briefly. They’re like, oh, my accountant does my payroll. Or I use Paycom or Paychex or something like that. Explain, go a little bit beyond that. I mean, I know that’s a function of what you guys do for us. But what else does a PEO do versus like a payroll company? Yeah, so I think anybody in my company would get mad at me to hear me say that payroll’s the easiest thing that we do. Payroll’s payroll’s payroll’s payroll. Sure. You know, there are parts… Probably even better when everybody’s on salary. Yeah, for sure. It’s even easier. It’s probably the one part of our business. There’s not a lot of room for forgiveness. You don’t screw up someone’s payroll.

[5:27] So payroll’s the easiest thing that we do. And it’s really, with technology anymore, it’s not a super complicated function. In a manufacturing environment, it can be. If you have ERP systems and you’re doing, you know, detailed job costing things, it can get a little bit more complicated. But for the most part, it’s pretty easy. PEOs are just giving you kind of a, you’re getting a system. You’re not, it’s not just a payroll solution. You’ve got a payroll solution that’s attached to a comprehensive HR offering that’s attached to a Fortune 500 benefits offering. It’s an overall infrastructure that a lot of smaller employers don’t have. Right. So, you know, to put that in perspective for listeners, you know, from my perspective, being a shop owner like a lot of the listeners, when I bought Hill, our accountant did our payroll. Yeah. So every Thursday or whatever it was, the, you know, someone, someone at Hill would send over to the accountant, like, Hey, here’s everybody’s hours. And then those person, the firm would cut checks and bring them over and they’d be signed. And, you know, of course we’ve come a long way from there, even just with doing direct deposits and those types of things. But, but that was it. And then separately from that, we would manage health insurance renewals every year. Separate from that, we would worry about our employee manual and different policies.

[6:42] And are we, are we staying legal with, you know, some new state law change or whatever? I mean, you know, one of the, one of the, one of the things I’m sure we’ll talk about at some point, you know, like even just the change here recently of no tax on overtime. Right. Like I’m assuming that added a layer, some layer of complexity. If you’re doing your own payroll. Yeah, absolutely. I don’t know because I use you, but I’m sure for a lot of people that became like, Oh crap, what do I do now? Again, a lot of that was just removed from the table, right? So, so the, the person that we used to call our HR person, you know, still deals with pieces of that puzzle for us, but was able to be kind of like reallocated. Now actually handles a lot of our ARAP type stuff, just kind of firmed up internally. It’s like, well, we don’t need somebody full-time worrying about those things anymore. We’ve got a firm handling those things now. Yeah. The reality of any business, whether it’s a manufacturing business or a whatever. Whatever. Whatever is no matter how efficiently or effectively you’re handling the functions that a PEO takes off the table, they have nothing to do with your core competency. Right. And in today’s world, you got to focus on those things that ultimately drive revenue throughput in your, in your case.

[7:57] And any time spent on those things that aren’t contributing is, is time wasted. Yeah. Which, yeah. And, and I, and I want to dive into that a little bit later. So one of the things I wanted to do in this episode is I want to kind of do a little bit of myth busting. Sure. Right. So we kind of set the stage for- Lots of myths about our business. Right. And, you know, as, as a lot of my listeners know, I spend a lot of time talking with listeners. They reach out to me with, you know, maybe something they heard on an episode or just some question about, you know, whether it’s some finance and accounting questions or KPI type stuff, anything we’ve talked about on episodes. And, you know, I mean, payroll is all of our biggest expenses. Yeah. And so it generally comes up in conversation of how are you handling payroll? And, and we hear lots of different answers. When I’ll say, oh gosh, why are you doing that yourself? Like just outsource that. Like it’s, you know, one of the most common things I hear is, oh, I’m, I mean, I’m way too small to do that. I don’t, that’s too expensive. You know, lots of things, but, but generally it kind of starts with, I’m too small. So let’s talk a little bit about that. And, you know, what is, what is the right size to, to be looking at outsourcing this function? That’s a, that’s a great question. And, and that question alone, we could spend an hour talking about.

[9:19] Right. I don’t know that there’s an ideal size. And if you talk to PEOs, you’ll see, you’ll hear, you know, a lot of them say, well, we have a, you have to have at least five employees. That’s not true. I mean, if you look at our company specifically, our smallest clients have two or three employees and our largest clients have several hundred employees and we have everything in between. If you’re looking at this the right way, you know, how do I create efficiencies in process? How do I focus on my core competencies? How do I reduce employer liabilities and business risks? The bigger one, which we could spend some more time talking about, how do I provide benefits that help me punch above my weight class and attract and retain the best possible talent for my business? You know, all of those things hold true of any company of any size, you know, so we have these smaller employers where it doesn’t make sense to allocate the resources necessary to hire full-time HR. And then we have clients that have full HR departments where they want them focused on strategic HR instead of the things that we’re doing, maybe. How do we attract and retain better talent? How do we communicate with our internal staff better than we are? Right. You know, how do we build, how do we make culture something other than a buzzword? Yeah. Everybody says culture is important. It’s not just a poster on the wall, right? It’s not. It’s not a ping pong table in the break room, right? And so it works for companies of all sizes.

[10:40] We have a pool table in the break room, not a ping pong table. We have a ping pong table. That’s different. We have a Pac-Man too in our office. Nice. I have one that doesn’t work. So for that smaller employer that says we’re too small, I guess it depends on where you want to go as a company. You still got to compete. And in the absence of size, your value proposition has to be strong externally in what’s presented to the marketplace and internally to keep those people, to keep a skilled employee from going across the street to a larger competitor for another nickel an hour or for better benefits, you have to be able to compete. And what PEOs do for that smaller company is it levels the playing field some. If you’re a five employee shop or a 10 employee shop, your benefits, if you choose the right PEO, should stack up nicely with the largest providers in your industry. Right. That’s one of the main topics I want to address. So we’re all fighting for people. I mean, there’s not a shop out there that won’t tell you that, well, I mean, maybe some are right sized, but you know, everybody’s looking for the right people. Yeah. And in a lot of cases, we’re competing with the shop across the street. We’re competing with our customers for those people. A lot of our customers are massive global organizations that have every benefit known to man, you know, they have advanced pay scales. They have, they have a lot of things that, that if I’m a eight person, 10 person, 20 person, 30 person shop, whatever it might be, two person shop, I’m just not going to compete with. Yeah.

[12:14] Right. I mean, I, yeah, I can, I can maybe pay you the same. My benefit package is going to be $200 a month more. And, you know, so net net at the end of the day, coming to work for me is going to cost you $200 a month, right? That’s right. Over going to work for somebody else. In my, I mean, I know in my specific instance, you know, like working with you guys, that’s just not the case. You know, I’m buying benefits on a larger scale. I’m offering benefits that are, that are competitive or, and, or directly comparable to that of my customers. Should be, should be anyone with the right provider. Right. Probably important to say, PEOs aren’t selling insurance. We’re consumers, just like you would be in the open market. We’re just aggregating employers together to achieve some purchasing power. And what it does. Yeah. So you’re buying on the scale of thousands of employees and I’m buying on the scale of dozens of employees. It’s a, it’s a kind of a Walmart principle. And, but what that does is it allows me to compete with the, the, the shop across town. You know, maybe it’s my customer that has, that does have 1200 employees locally. Right. A hundred thousand globally. Sure. But now all of a sudden I’m offering a very, very similar and or highly competitive, and it’s maybe in some cases even better benefits package. Yeah.

[13:31] A lot of cases better and a PEO environment, not necessarily having to play by the same rules that you would in the open market. You know, for smaller employers getting access to disability insurance products, as an example, require a certain level of employer contribution and participation that make it not palatable for a lot of small employers. Getting access to expanded life insurance options as a small employer is challenging. PEOs put you in a place that you look like a large employer from a benefits perspective and, and don’t necessarily have to follow those same rules. And on the major medical side, you know, you’ll never meet anyone anywhere in any company says, you know, our benefits are really cheap and affordable. There’s no such thing. Doesn’t exist. As a good deal and benefits, but PEOs put you in a better spot, you know, for smaller employers that are playing in the exchange, you know, through Obamacare group. So these groups under 50 with age banded rates in the open marketplace, PEOs move you to the large group market. So true, it’s called composite rating, you know, that you see in larger employers, true employee rate, a true family rate, not something that’s blended based on your demographics. And for, so for a lot of employers, most of them, I would say 80% of the time, you know, you have richer benefits, you know, expanded offerings, the things that wouldn’t make sense to put in place before, and usually a little bit more economical. Yeah.

[14:57] So I, I can put that in perspective. I haven’t, I haven’t done this math. I mean, I don’t know. We’ve been with you guys almost kind of since the beginning. Almost five years. I do remember at one point kind of in that first year, you know, again, our show is called By the Numbers. So we do like to talk about numbers and, you know, my payroll processing, so we were using our accountant before and the cost of processing payroll had gone up. By the way, no accountant wants to process your payroll. That’s, that is true. Yeah. I don’t know very many that want to do that. They do it as a value add. But my cost of benefits the same year had gone down. If I remember correctly, it was like $23,000. I mean, it was significant. So, and my cost of payroll processing had only gone up thousands of dollars. Right. So, I mean, the net, net effect for me was better than neutral. Yeah. I don’t remember the exact numbers, but it was. Yeah. I think we were a good 20% or better below your existing rates, which weren’t bad in the first place. You know, ideally when this works out and it works out well, you know, we talk about, I can’t afford this. First of all, I’m a small employer and a PEO, any PEO, I have five employees.

[16:13] They’ll charge you $1,000 per employee per year just to administer the HR function. Right. The benefit administration. Sure. And all these different things. Tell me what kind of employee you could get full time for $5,000 a year that you’d want to have in your business. Yeah. So, the numbers work, but when you start applying the economics behind saving money and benefits, potentially saving some money on taxes, potentially saving money on workers compensation insurance, more often than not, it is a budget neutral or better decision. Right. The numbers always work. When PEOs aren’t engaged by someone, it’s something else. You know, hey, my brother-in-law processes my payroll at our accounting firm. Sure, sure. And he really wants to continue to do that. It’s something else. Right. I’ve been in the industry for about 30 years, and I’ve always said if someone says no, it’s more a not yet or not right now. Yeah. And we have customers all over the country that have come back. Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation, maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business ready to sell? At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more. Every day, CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings, like one manufacturer that boosted capacity and revenues by 15 to 20 percent.

[17:44] Visit claconnect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line. I’m looking at the kind of list of myths that I’ve heard. You know, first is too small. We’ve kind of covered that. We’ve kind of covered the next one. But maybe more specifically, you hear one or two things when I talk to people about a PEO. Well, that’s just outsourced payroll. We kind of covered that. It’s much more than payroll. What is it beyond just like even basic HR, though? Right? So… Yeah, that’s a great question. HR is a very broad topic. If you mention HR, most small employers, they bring up payroll. So we’ve talked about payroll. You can take that off the table. You know, so PEOs do a lot of things. I think the HR function in most professional employer organizations is really three-pronged. The first part is just looking for things that could expose the assets of your organization if it were challenged by a regulatory body, like a Department of Labor, as an example. Or the more likely scenario is an exiting employee that’s attached themselves to an attorney on the way out the door. Right. So they look for those things that could create issues down the path. Internal policies and procedures, handbooks, job descriptions, hiring practices, any kind of written employer-employee communications, down to little things like the break room wall postings, you know, and say, okay, Mike, on a scale of 1 to 10, we think you’re an 8 to get you to a 10 and keep you there.

[19:13] We need to put in these processes. So that’s part of it. So there’s a compliance piece. Compliance in this country is a moving target. Every year it becomes a little bit more difficult to be an employer in this country. There are different rules for employers over 50 than there are under 50. Right. Once you hit 15 employees, the rules change a little bit for different reasons. Sure. So PEOs look from a compliance perspective for those things that expose your business where you are today and then scale with you as you grow to kind of check all those boxes moving forward. So if you find yourself on the other side of a table at some point in the future, eyes are dotted, T’s are crossed. The second piece of it, our company Thrive, we’re giving you access to credentialed HR people. So not to displace what you currently have. HR in most small businesses, you’ve got a leadership team that owns a little bit of it. Sure. You know, if you don’t have dedicated support. It’s just, it’s a sounding board. Another set of eyes and ears. Here’s a sticky situation we’ve got going on within our company. Termination issues. How should I handle this? How do I handle this? Here’s what we’re thinking. What am I missing? Kind of thing. Yeah. And, you know, so again, to put that in the day-to-day life of a shop owner perspective, I mean, there’s, there’s two or three of those instances a year that there’s something going on with an employee and, you know, I know my gut, how I want to handle it, but I fire off an email, make a phone call, whatever, and say, Hey, here’s the situation.

[20:45] How should I handle this? And sometimes you guys, you guys tell me you’re fine. Like go with, go with your gut. And other times you’re like, let’s do this. Let me send you a form. Right. And, you know, and, and, and beyond just me, I mean, I think maybe one of the better values is even just for my team. Yeah. Right. Because I mean, I’ve, I have been around a lot of business. I’ve been in a lot of situations. Maybe I, maybe I do know how to handle something, but my shop floor manager doesn’t. Right. And he has access to that as well. Yeah. And, and on the bigger side of it, a lot of times in a PEO and, you know, in a, any company absent of a PEO or absent of a true resource for human resources is a lot of times when you have an employee that has an issue that’s brewing, it’s with an immediate supervisor or someone in a managerial capacity. And there’s a fear of, if I bring this to them, they’re going to fire me. Right. And so they, it stews and it becomes a bigger, bigger issue, becomes a cultural issue because you’ve got people, you know, communicating on a shop floor about something that’s going on and it never gets addressed until it becomes a problem. And so PEOs, a lot of times that HR component, we’ve got the compliance piece, that HR component also gives employees a sounding board. Sure. Where they can call this kind of a neutral person in the mix and say, hey, here’s what’s going on.

[22:09] And we can communicate that up the chain. In a way that benefits you instead of hurts you down the line. So it’s pretty robust. They do lots of things. You know, they can handle unemployment hearings. They can, if you have these sticky issues, they can come and sit on site with you and participate as another set of eyes and ears or communicate and collaborate with you through the process. And then the last piece of it, most PEOs, I would say 95% of them put smaller employers in a better position from an HR technology perspective. Yes. To enhance the overall experience of your employees and then make the business run more efficiently. You know, anything, you know, complete employee lifecycle from recruiting new hires to the onboarding experience. Yeah. I mean, golly, speaking to that, you know, the fact that when we do make a hire decision, we’re able to send someone a link, right? Where they go in. Welcome to Hill. Right. And they fill out all that paperwork that everybody hates doing on their first day. Nine times out of 10 now, I mean, when they show up on their first day, they’ve already filled all that out. And we’re not losing a day there. We’re able to go immediately into, you know, the training that we need to get them on the floor, get them on a machine, whatever.

[23:28] Yeah. And that’s nice. And it’s more in line with what they would see with whoever your largest competitor is. Yeah. Again, we’re punching above our weight, right? You are. There’s not a lot, you know, and talking a little bit on the HR thing too, again, I’ll give a couple examples as a, you know, daily shop owner for my listeners. Two instances that kind of still stick out in my brain of working with a PEO. When I, I’ve told this story before, so some have heard it, but, you know, I bought Hill in 2018. And, you know, sometime in that first few months, I asked somebody for a copy of our employee manual so I could know what rules we’re operating by. And, you know, I, I read through it over, you know, an evening or something. And I still distinctly remember one of the things that stuck out to me. And one of the sections, this was in 2018, was that we were not allowed to have Sony Walkmans on the floor. That had been dead for 30 years. Right. And so that was the age of our employee manual. Yeah. Which, you know, as soon as we engaged with you guys a few years later, I was like, Hey, we need a new employee manual. And you went through and you updated it and you, you made it current and relevant and you do that every year.

[24:46] Right. And, and which brings me to the next example. In that same time period, Oklahoma passed medical marijuana laws. That was a big one. And so that needed to be updated in how we handle marijuana and… Safety sensitive position. Safety and all those types of things. And, you know, I, I mean, I can tell you just knowing how I am, had I not had somebody to lean on, my manual wouldn’t have been updated for those things. And the good news is, Mike, I don’t know that very many companies out there reference employee Sony Walkmans in their handbooks, but most of them are outdated. It’s something someone paid a labor attorney to, to pull together for them three years ago or 10 years ago. Or in our case, 30. Yeah. 30 years ago. And they don’t update what, you know, that information as frequently as they should. Those regulations that impact how we employ people and where we employ people. And it varies if you’re a multi-state employer, like a lot of manufacturing companies are. The rules and regulations vary widely from state to state to state. Yeah. There’s federal laws or state laws. In some cases, there’s local laws. And they’re, and they’re always adjusting those things. There’s a big push this year across the country in many states for adjusting, you know, family leave laws, you know, to these paid leave environments.

[26:08] And it’s, it’s challenging to keep up with it. It’s challenging for a PEO to keep up with it. And we have resources that are dedicated to looking at those things. It’s your daily job. That’s our, that’s our core competency. It’s understandable that people would have handbooks that need a little work. And that’s just, you know, that’s a very simple part of what PEOs do. But it’s an important part. I mean, it is an important part. Might be simple, but it’s, I mean, it’s the rules, it’s the agreement you’re both, you and the employer are agreeing to on a day-to-day basis. Yeah. And it’s one of the very first things that comes up when you get in one of those ugly scenarios down the road. If you’ve got someone that has brought you to the table for a wrongful termination or some sort of discriminatory action, one of the very first thing that opposing counsel asks is, let me see a copy of your handbook. Of course. And then show me, and then show me where my client acknowledged that information. Well, and, and let me, let me put this in perspective for you in the manufacturing environment that you may or may not even be aware of what’s going on right now. But so we actually had yesterday, we had our ISO internal review or management review. So we’re with our management team.

[27:23] We were with our external ISO auditor, not our auditor, but our consultant. And she brought up that in AS and IS environments, it’s becoming more and more important to, I think more specifically on the AS side of things, that employees have signed a code of ethics, right? So people are starting to put those in their quality management systems. How are you leveraging that the employee has read this and acknowledged it, right? In our case, we have a similar, when she showed me an example of, of what a lot of aerospace companies are requiring of their vendors to have in their QMS. I was like, you know what? I think we have something really close to that in our employee manual. So we pull our employee manual up. It’s really close. There was a couple of little clauses like, okay, well we could add those. So in our case, our solution to that, as it relates to our QMS and being able to pass an audit is let’s add that, let’s add those couple of clauses to our employee manual acknowledgement, right? In our code of ethics, right? So it’s, it’s not just HR in that case, right? Now we’re digging even into our QMS. It’s all connected.

[28:42] Yeah. It’s, it’s all there. And, you know, when, when we finalize the wording on that, we’ll send it to you, you’ll update our employee manual, everybody in our… Everybody will get an alert. Everybody will get an alert that, hey, you need to go acknowledge these changes to your QMS or to your employee manual, which then when I’m sitting through an AS audit in two months and they say, have your employees acknowledge their ethics manual or their, your ethics policy, we’ll be able to point directly to them in your system to say, yes, look, every employee has seen this, acknowledged it and accepted it. It’s nice. You know, there’s a lot that comes with running any business and it’s nice going home at night knowing that at least this part of a business is taken care of. And that’s what PEOs do. So there’s the compliance piece. There’s the people piece. There’s the technology piece that could be pretty extensive. In manufacturing, growth isn’t accidental. It’s engineered. But a lot of suppliers are still building their pipeline on outdated lists, inconsistent follow-up and hope-based marketing, hoping their website will somehow bring in leads. Gabe Draper, the founder of Factor, knows that struggle. Years ago, he ran a shop that went bankrupt, not because of quality, but because he didn’t have a steady way to generate new opportunities.

[30:03] That experience is what led him to build Factor. Factor helps suppliers create consistent sales opportunities by combining targeted outreach with marketing that puts you in front of the right buyers. Their team finds the right companies, starts real conversations and sets qualified meetings. So if your pipeline swings with referrals or seasonality, Factor brings a system that puts you back in control. And for listeners of this show, Factor is offering a free custom report that highlights the best opportunities in your industry, plus a list of real companies that match what you do. Request yours at factormfg.com slash chips. That’s F-A-C-T-U-R M-F-G dot com slash chips. We talked a little bit, John, about, you know, a PEO is too expensive. And we talked some practical numbers, right? So, you know, I’m spending more on payroll processing than I was. I’m spending less on benefits, right? So at worst case, in my opinion, I’m net neutral. I think in my specific case, I’m actually a little bit ahead. But let’s talk for a second about, like, the opportunity costs of what I could be doing instead of screwing around with all this HR stuff that really just frustrates me anyway.

[31:19] Yeah. So talked a little bit about it earlier. Any time that you’re not spending on growing your business, any time you’re spending on any business function that’s not generating revenue, you shouldn’t be… Shouldn’t be wasting time. Shouldn’t be doing those things. And so there is a significant lost opportunity cost, you know, that’s taken off the table when you engage a PEO. Yeah. You know, if I could give a small business owner 10 percent of their day back or… Hour a week. Yeah. You know, what could you do with that? Sure. Receivables, new customers, you know, processes and throughput, all these things. Sleep. Sleep’s good. I mean, I’m just being honest, right? A little extra time with your family or on the golf course, right? Well, and that, you know, so even that, right? I mean, it’s, you know, I talk a lot on By the Numbers and Making Chips Both about, you know, owners need to, they need to work where they bring the most value to the business. Right. So if your value in the business is in sales and quoting and stuff like that, that’s where you should spend your time. If your value in the business is, I’m the best setup machinist we have and automation expert, spend your time there. Don’t spend it on HR issues and payroll. Payroll, HR, benefits, worker’s comp.

[32:42] And even more specifically, again, when I talk about that typical shop out there, I can’t even begin to put, wrap my head around the numbers of shops that we, right, wrong, or indifferent. We often take the accounting HR function. We combine them, especially in a smaller shop, right? We combine those. And then if you take it one step further, how often that is the job of a spouse, a child. Yeah, for sure. A, a, a sibling, a cousin, something like that, that often doesn’t have training in that area, whether it’s HR, whether it’s accounting, whether it’s finance or anything, but it’s something they can do. Well, why, why do owners do that? Because they don’t want to mess with it. They, they want something for their spouse or it’s, it’s somebody taking that off their plate. So even just from a, my point of that is it’s also just even a quality of life thing. Oh, it absolutely is. It absolutely is. You can tell you’ve got an M&A in accounting background because you, yeah, because of the lost opportunity costs.

[33:57] That’s a, that’s a very real concept and one people should consider and quality of life falls into play there. Another thing that comes in line with PEOs is there’s a liability cost removed. Sure. It is treacherous being an employer in today’s world. We live in a very litigious society. There’s lots of rules that are, that are changing on an annual basis. Sometimes on a quarterly basis, you know, what’s it worth as a small employer to say, Hey, take those sticks of dynamite and slide them to my side of the table. Right. You know, so when people say a PEO is too expensive, well, what’s your business worth? Right. You know, the wrong lawsuit or the, there’s lots of moving parts to being an employer that can be costly if they’re not managed properly. And so there’s, there’s several moving parts outside of more soft costs things that come into play. Then, you know, you compare a PEO fee structure to the standard payroll company that, you know, these 800 pound gorilla pay comp, pay core, pay velocity companies that are out in the marketplace. PEOs are going to look a little heavier, but when you start weighing everything else, that lost opportunity costs, the liability costs removed, better, more affordable benefits, maybe some tax benefit that comes into play. Maybe I saved a little bit of money on administration of my 401k, workers’ compensation insurance. There’s lots of different things that come into play to make the financial value proposition of a PEO, usually a, an easy decision.

[35:27] You know, our company has been pretty fortunate. 80% of the companies that we do a proposal for become a customer, which is a pretty good hit rate. Yeah. So we don’t do a lot of proposals. You might need to charge more to everybody else except me. And if you’re winning 80%. We’re winning. Yeah. We are, we, we have year over year consistently won 80% because the, the, if you understand the messaging. The value props there. Value props there. If, if, if someone comes to me and says, Hey, look, I want access to a PEO to get better, more affordable benefits. That’s probably by itself, not a good enough reason. Sure. But if you look at it, the overall picture and what it accomplishes, the numbers, numbers always work. I have never met a business owner in any industry that said, you know, I started Hill manufacturing because I really love to do HR and payroll benefits. I don’t know very many of those people. Yeah. The, um, you brought up a few things there in, in, in that statement. I, I wanted to make sure to address. So again, punching above your weight, um, from day one, after I bought Hill and talking to employees, like what’s, what’s something that the Hill does not offer you want retirement’s always retirement funding is, is always a topic. And I mean, I’m, I’m ashamed to say that I still have not put something in place to really address that, but you know, it’s expensive to offer, you know, 401k plans. And, um, I mean, you can do IRAs. There’s so many options out there, but you know, that’s one of the things you guys are bringing to the table for me right now is, is a 401k option that, that quite frankly, without you, I couldn’t offer.

[37:09] Yeah. 401k is a challenging thing. You know, you start looking at the fee structure, you start looking at the compliance, you start looking at fiduciary liability, and then you turn the other direction. It’s expensive. Yeah. It, it gets expensive. And any PEO, not just our company, any PEO, most PEOs are operating under a different structure for 401k. Usually it’s markedly more economical. The fee structure is considerably less than it would be if you were engaging a similar provider in the open market. You know, structurally, you can still set up a 401k just like you would, if you were having a direct conversation with whoever, lots of 401k vendors. So fees are less. The bigger thing though, is in a PEO setting, as long as you remain a customer of a PEO, that fiduciary liability, that one piece of, you know, installing a 401k that nobody wants. You know, we talked about moving things from your side of the table to ours. That slides over to the other side of the table. So you’re getting a big box, big brand retirement vehicle at a less, lesser price point without the liability that you would have. And I think this is a fair statement to say, probably across our industry, you know, I think one of the hurdles for independently trying to do a retirement plan, especially a 401k, is the tests that you have to go through. Is it, you know, is only the owner benefiting, right? Or is everybody benefiting? And it’s usually the other. It’s usually the owners can’t participate.

[38:42] Right. But there are even ways structurally. People say they can’t afford a 401k. Well, there are structures to 401ks. And you guys bring those to the table that I don’t have access to. Yeah, we do. And that holds true of any PEO, but we do. There are ways to make PEOs or 401ks in a PEO environment very affordable and where everyone benefits. Yeah, I think, you know, I think one of the, I really do, and I’m glad we covered that myth because I really do think one of the biggest benefits that I’ve seen is not having to mess with it. Right. So, so again, whether, whether that means it gives me an extra couple of hours a week to spend on something else that benefits my business, or it gives me an extra couple hours a week, you know, I jokingly said to sleep, right? But just quality of life. Yeah, for sure. I mean, I, I don’t have to worry about payroll on Friday because you guys have it under control. So I can not worry about that. I can, I can either work on something that is benefiting my business or I can just relax. Work on something that benefits mine. I can spend time with my family. I can, you know, it’s, it’s more off my plate that I don’t bring value to, like I do not bring value to the HR process and that’s important.

[40:03] And the, we, I think so often, I mean, as entrepreneurs and small business owners, you know, we just take everything on. Right. And, and I think in my experience in this industry, specifically as manufacturers, we very much just generally have a, well, I can do that myself attitude. Right. Cause we can make anything. Oh, sure. So like, why would I buy that? Right. I’m going to make it. Well, it’s, it’s kind of the same case in this. Why would I, you know, I think that attitude flows over to so many other aspects of our business of, well, I can just do it myself. Sure. And that’s what most do. But at what cost? Yeah. You know, HR, people become an issue at some point. You’re absolutely right. You said earlier, you know, your people are your biggest asset. They’re also your biggest liability that comes into play at some point. And it’s, it’s usually a reactionary thing. HR there. It’s something that people add later. Hey guys, it’s Mike. Are you thinking about upgrading some old equipment or expanding your business? You need to talk to my friends at Vernant Commercial Capital. When we needed some new equipment, they made the financing process fast, smooth, and actually very enjoyable. What impressed me the most was how well they understood our industry.

[41:18] Vernant offers flexible terms, quick approval, and they were just great to work with. If you want a true partner in your corner, check out Vernant Commercial Capital. Go to VernantCC.com slash numbers. V-E-R-N-T-C-C dot com slash numbers or find them on LinkedIn. Okay. So John, as we kind of wrap up. So if, if someone’s listening to this and they’re like, okay, maybe I really should look into this. Where do they start? That’s an awesome question. There are some great resources available for people that are considering PEOs. One of the best places to start is our National Trade Association. It’s NAPEO, N-A-P-E-O. You can go to NAPEO.org and search for PEOs that are licensed to do business in your marketplace. You’ll find that there are likely hundreds. Lots of them. Yeah. There are hundreds. And PEO organizations that are members of NAPEO are probably good places to start. Sure. Like a lot of industries, there are good providers and bad providers. So I would start with NAPEO and then just sort through the process. You know, you’ll see that, you know, we talked about the 800 pound grills in the payroll space. Most of those own PEOs too. ADP has a PEO. Paychex has a PEO.

[42:38] If your experience with ADP or Paychex from a payroll perspective has not been great, adding other services probably won’t contribute to a better customer experience. So, you know, I would look for companies that have some experience in the industry. I would look for companies that preferably have a local presence beyond a salesperson from a boots on the ground perspective since we’re, you know, we’re working with people. Having a company that has dedicated HR support or payroll support that’s not based six states away can sometimes be helpful. NAPEO. So the people. You got to like the people. You’re going to be working with them very intimately. You know, they’re processing your payroll. They’re helping with HR. They’re helping with benefits. They’re having some really challenging conversations. Really challenging conversations. Make sure their processes don’t interfere with how you run your business. So you’ve got the people piece that’s super important. Make sure you like them and they’re accessible. Make sure their processes are in line with where you want to go, that they can scale with you as your business grows. I would always recommend doing a technology demo. So whatever platform that they’re using, PEO industry is a pretty challenging one. I would say good 90% of PEOs use the same technology platform. We went in a little bit different direction, but look at it to make sure you’re not taking steps backwards.

[44:02] You won’t be, but just make sure you understand how that works. And then the price structure. I think the numbers will always work regardless of what PEO you choose, but you’ll know, you know, trust your gut. It’s a very important decision to make, but I always tell people, people will rank it within the top business decisions that they’ve ever made because it makes life so much easier. It is absolutely the easy button for small employers. You actually just reminded me of a point I wanted to make too. This is just going to be kind of a real statement and it might hit people a little bit in the gut. It might sound controversial. I don’t know. We’ll see. I’ve dealt with a lot of businesses over a 30-year career. I mean, hundreds. There’s been several that have gotten themselves. I mean, I can point to a good handful or two that have gotten themselves in a lot of trouble as it relates to payroll taxes. And one of the reasons I tell people as small as one, two, three employees to outsource this function is payroll taxes. Absolutely. You know, it’s interesting that you even bring this up. Banks have started referring their small business clients to PEOs because it insulates their loan portfolio against payroll tax liens because of how PEOs are capturing taxes.

[45:25] You know, we’re not in a position where we can hold on to taxes for a quarter and then remit them, which is what gets companies in trouble. That’s because of the size of our payroll tax deposits. We’re funding them every 24 hours. So we don’t have the luxury of holding on, which is actually a good thing. And so it insulates that bank’s loan portfolio. And yeah, just to put that in real life perspective for people. And, you know, again, I run a small manufacturing business. I understand what we’re all going through, which is, you know, one of the biggest hurdles we have in this industry is cash flow. Yeah. I can give you horror stories of small businesses that I’ve worked with that, you know, it came time to make that quarterly tax payment and it’s $20,000, $10,000, $100,000, whatever the number is, it doesn’t matter. And you don’t have it in the bank account because you’re waiting on that customer to pay you next week. For sure. Or two weeks from now, whatever it is, you don’t have it. You can’t write the check if you don’t have it, right? And you skip, you miss that one quarterly payment. That starts to snowball. Oh, sure. Because that $20,000 still do. Yeah. And you get penalties and you get interest. And then the next quarterly comes around. And that client is still slow paying you.

[46:44] Yeah. And the client is still slow paying you. And now you owe $60,000 to the IRS and the state and, you know, all the… And I have horror stories of what I would say otherwise successful businesses being demolished because of payroll taxes. For sure. And if this isn’t your strong suit, this isn’t where you play around because they will shut you down. Like you will be out of business. Yeah. And I know there’s a listener or two right now that has dealt with this. And is maybe currently losing sleep over it. And the best answer I could give to any small business owner, manufacturing or not, is just get that out of your… Like just eliminate that problem. Take it off the table. Yeah. By using a PEO that when every week, every two weeks, every month, however often you make payroll, that’s out of your hands. Just becomes part of the system. Yeah. It’s gone. It’s nice. And if done correctly, it annualizes all of your labor burden expenses, apart from taxes, all those things. Sure. Where you’re seeing right now, any small business, these giant spikes. You hit a month, you get a blip.

[48:00] You hit a quarter, you get a bigger blip. You’re annualizing your tax expenses, your insurance expenses, all the workers’ comp, all these things. And paying them right alongside payroll. So if your workers’ comp is an example, you’re funding workers’ comp premiums on a monthly basis. You have these 10 to 12 installments. Your weekly payroll, now you get 52 smaller ones. Yeah. And I think we all know we can’t miss payroll, right? Because our guys won’t show up on Monday. It doesn’t work out usually very well when you don’t pay them. But that’s everything related to payroll is the same, right? So don’t make your benefit payment this month. And that works out great. And when everybody gets a letter that says your benefits have been cut off. And that doctor bill, you now own 100% of. Your team’s still not going to show up on Monday. Or your 401k. I mean, don’t mess with this. And if you have any vulnerability at all in a cash flow cycle of missing something, what you don’t want to miss is anything to do with your people. Because I don’t blame them if they don’t show up on Monday when they didn’t get paid. Or their benefits got dropped or whatever. Certain industries, I think manufacturing industry is one where you’ve got skilled labor, right? Word spreads quickly when you miss a payroll. Word spreads quickly when you have a tax problem.

[49:22] Absolutely. See how that impacts your customer base. Right. That, you know, that client that you’re trying to get a contract with when the market is squawking that you’ve had an issue covering your financial obligations. You won’t recover from that. That’ll still be your reputation 20 years from now is you missed a payroll period or you missed. Oh, for sure. My benefits got dropped or, you know, whatever it is. Yeah. You might find it right there in your Google reviews. I almost would guarantee you you’ll find it in your Google reviews. Okay. So again, we kind of side subject from what should we be looking at? I remembered I wanted to make that point is that that alone to me is probably worth the time. People, processes, platform. Make sure you like the people. Make sure you trust their processes and what they’re bringing to the table. Make sure the platform is what they say it is. Yeah. Where do people make mistakes? Where do they end up getting hurt in this? You know, so people ask me that all the time. What I love about this business is there’s not really a downside to it. You can make poor PEO decisions like any industry. There are good providers and bad providers, but it’s still, I’ve done a lot of different things over the course of my career. It’s the coolest business concept I’ve ever encountered. When I first heard about it, I was working in the golf industry.

[50:40] I think my first reaction was, is this legal? Once we covered that it was. Those are usually the best solutions. Yeah. Right. It still made all the sense in the world to me. Here I am almost 32 years later and my belief system around the industry is still very much the same. If you’re making an educated purchasing decision, if you’re really evaluating who you’re engaging as a PEO, you won’t regret it. And that holds true of our company and any of the, there’s roughly 900 providers across the country. Wow. That’s a lot. Yeah, it’s a lot. It is a lot. I didn’t realize there were that many. Well, John, this has been great. I’m very hopeful that my listeners are paying attention to this and we’ll really give it a serious look. I know you’ve always been like super generous with your time and so forth. And you even talked about like regionally, you know, looking at regional providers and stuff. So that’s not going to be my entire audience. But if some of them just want some extra advice on maybe their situation and so forth and want to reach out to you, maybe ask some follow-up questions, what’s the best way to get ahold of you, find you, ask those questions? Yeah. So you can find us online at thrivepeo.com. Although we have had an Oklahoma-centric focus, we do have clients now in 46 states, Puerto Rico and Hawaii. That’s a lot.

[52:00] So we can work almost anywhere in the country. And even if any of your listeners are evaluating PEOs or in a PEO relationship that they’d like to take a closer look at, have questions about a PEO provider that they’re considering installing, I’m happy to help. Well, I know everybody appreciates that. I would give you my utmost recommendation to anybody listening that… We appreciate that. We couldn’t be happier. Would we say five years ago or so we switched over? Yeah, five years. And it’s honestly, it’s probably the thing that keeps me up least at night now. Good. HR issues, I don’t even think about them now, right? I mean, things happen. I mean, we’ve certainly had HR issues to deal with in those five years, but I don’t have to think about them. I literally can just, whether myself or someone on my management team, like, oh, just call Thrive and just ask them how to handle it. And I don’t have to think about it again. In my case, and I know some of my listeners are in the same boat too, gosh, in that five years, I guess we’ve probably done five acquisitions. And you guys are, you’re double what you were when you onboarded with us in size. But it’s, you know, like even, you know, like our most recent acquisition last summer, you know, we’re bringing on 20 something employees.

[53:17] You know, that’s a lot of work, unless all I have to do is say, hey, John, I just brought on 20 employees, can you go onboard them? I think the conversation was something exactly like that. I mean, you guys showed up, you onboarded them. And, you know, benefits are done, payroll’s done, workers comp’s done, you know. A week later, they’re on my payroll. And it’s, yeah, it’s, it’s easier for sure. You know, so, yeah, I would just encourage everybody to explore this option, reach out to John. Again, for me, they’ve done a great job. Thank you. I think if, I think it’s probably, I think I’m safe in saying too, if you called John and he said, hey, I’m not your best option, he would point you to somebody that is. Yeah, for sure. We have those conversations on a weekly basis. You don’t want to lose sleep over somebody you can’t serve well, right? Oh no. Yeah. Again, quality of life. You don’t want customers that don’t fit you well either. So anyway, again, thank you so much. Thanks for having me. I appreciate it, as always. I don’t know if we answered the best way to find you. How can people find you? So thrivepeo.com is the best way to get us. There are several methods of contact on our website, whether an online form or our telephone number. We’re a 918 number. I’ve heard too many people complain about calling payroll companies via these 800 number phone trees. So we’ve never done that.

[54:34] We can be reached at area code 918-794-2200 also. But I would start at our website. Lots of great information there. Lots of ways to reach us there. But happy to help in any way I can. And we appreciate being here for sure. If you don’t find him that way, reach out to me and I’ll just give you a cell phone number. You can bug him on the weekend if you need to. That’s okay too. Well, John, thanks again. Listeners, thank you. Please like, share, review. That always helps us a lot. Share this with your team. Share this with maybe some other shop that you know is kind of going through some HR issues, maybe some growth. It really does help a lot as you’re expanding and growing. I think maybe the biggest soft value of using a PEO is that punch above your weight thing. And when you can look and feel like a big shop because you have these systems and these processes and these benefits, it’s going to make a difference. And when you’re out there fighting for the few people in your market that fill your needs. Gives you a little extra swagger out there. Absolutely. A hundred percent. So again, thank you. Thank you. And yeah, listeners, we’ll talk to you next time.

This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.


Connect with Jon Scoggins

Connect With Buy the Numbers

Subscribe to Buy the Numbers

on Apple + Spotify

Subscribe

For the latest episode straight to your inbox, business-building tips and other exclusive content, Subscribe to #MetalworkingNation today.