By Jennifer Dubose
Why You’re Never too Small for an ERP, Ep. 52
Almost every shop owner I talk to has told themselves the same story at some point: we are too small for a real ERP, so we will keep running the business on the old system and a pile of Excel spreadsheets. On this episode, I wanted to kill that myth, because the cost of believing it shows up in underpriced jobs, broken handoffs, and a value chain that quietly leaks money from quote to cash.
To dig in, I brought in Jon Hughes, a CFO consultant and principal at CLA, and Brian Schoonover, corporate controller and acting CFO at Turfco, a third-generation manufacturer in Minneapolis. Brian is right in the middle of replacing a system that was implemented back in 1989, so he is living this decision in real time, and Jon sees the pattern across dozens of shops.
We get into the question I hear constantly: am I too small for an ERP? Both of them land on fiction. The point is not that a two-spindle side hustle needs enterprise software tomorrow, it is that the moment you decide to scale, a system built around getting product out the door becomes one of the best investments you can make. Accounting should be the non-event at the end, not the thing the whole system was designed around.
We also spend real time on build versus buy in the age of AI. Everybody has a story about vibe coding an ERP or an instant quoting tool over a weekend. It is impressive, but you give up industry best practices, and you take on security and vulnerability risk you can’t even see. My take is simple: keep your core data secure and built on best practices, then point AI at that data to do the heavy lifting. I used it to crunch a thousand work orders down to the twelve that actually needed my attention.
Then we walk through the part that scares people most, selection and implementation. Brian shares how he built his own RFP, made vendors sell themselves to every department, and started the demo at the back of the building instead of the accounting office. And we both get honest about change management, the ROI math, and the surprise that the real resistance often comes from the front office, not the shop floor.
What’s Covered in this Episode
- (1:00) Meet the guests: Jon Hughes of CLA and Brian Schoonover of Turfco
- (4:08) Buying Hill Manufacturing in 2018 and inheriting a homegrown Access and Excel system
- (5:55) Turfco’s system from 1989 and the transition to an ERP
- (8:21) ERP is not an accounting system: the QuickBooks misconception
- (10:34) How CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings
- (11:12) Selling an ERP change to ownership when they are happy with what they have
- (15:11) Mike’s broken Excel quoting template and the underpriced jobs it caused
- (17:29) Fact or fiction: I am too small to have an ERP, and why both guests say fiction
- (20:33) Acumatica, NetSuite, and Intacct: strip the labels and they are the same class of software
- (22:14) ProShop ERP paid for itself in weeks with per-user pricing. Book a demo at ProShopERP.com
- (23:50) Vibe coding and the security considerations of a homegrown, AI-built system
- (30:38) Using AI on top of a secure ERP to crunch a thousand work orders down to the twelve that matter
- (32:57) Brian’s selection process: building an RFP, starting at the back of the building, and narrowing to four
- (39:49) Check out the Job Shops Workshop and Networking Reception at IMTS
- (42:15) Implementation at the halfway point, and mapping what each department actually does
- (45:43) The ROI math: save an hour per person per month and the SaaS pays for itself
- (51:03) The biggest surprise: the real resistance came from the front office, not the shop floor
Resources Mentioned
- CLAConnect
- ProShopERP
- IMTS
- Acumatica
- Learn more about Brian’s company, Turfco, at Turfco.com
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] Call it what you want, vibe coding is nothing new, right? I mean, I can remember coming in on a Monday and telling people, Oh, look at this kick-ass Excel spreadsheet I created. It’s the same thing, right? It is. Or, I mean, go back a generation before and go, Hey, look at this new filing system I created in the file room, right? Like it’s, in all cases, we’ve been vibe coding systems for a hundred years, right? Or longer. We’re just putting systems and processes in place to control our business. Welcome to Buy the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business from accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company. Let’s crunch some numbers. John, welcome back to Buy the Numbers. Hey, Mike, it’s a pleasure to be here. Great to see you again. Yeah. And what, a month ago, we actually, or maybe a month and a half ago, we actually got to finally see each other in person. Yeah, we, we met in person, right? It’s always so strange, Mike, when you’ve known someone online and you actually get a chance to meet face to face, but that was a really good, that was a good experience, Mike. It was great, great hanging out with you.
[1:22] Yeah, that was fun. So I know a lot of listeners were there too, but yeah, so John and I got to meet in person at the, at Toolpath Summit on the Summit out in Mammoth, California. Yeah. Great event. Good, tons of people there. And, and yeah, I got to finally meet John and Jennifer in, in person. So that was good. Mike, in my mind, we’re, we’re sitting there still in the living room, having this conversation with the mountain in the background. And it’s going to have a good, a good conversation here. Well, that would, that would be ideal, but this time it’s on video. So it was just, I have a mountain in the picture behind me. You can stare at that. So John, for the, for the listeners that you might just remind them real quick, you know, kind of who you are, what you do, a little bit about CLA real quick. Yeah. So I’m John Hughes. You may know me from my movies, 16 Candles and Pretty in Pink. Just kidding. I’m John Hughes, the accountant. I’m with CLA. I’m a CFO consultant and a principal with the firm. Have the privilege of working with shop owners and helping them build profitable businesses. And listeners I’ve connected some of you and several of your peers with John and or with CLA. Yeah, boy, do not hesitate to reach out because John’s got a wealth of knowledge and is absolutely willing to share it. So when we get to the end of this and you have a bunch of questions, feel free to reach out.
[2:49] And John, you brought along a guest today. You want to introduce Brian? I did. Yeah. So brought Brian from Turfco. Brian is not only a client of CLA, but he’s also an alumni of the firm. Brian, love to hear a little bit of your, your background here. Sure. Nice to meet both of you. Thank you for having me on. Brian Schoonover. I’m the corporate controller, acting CFO of a small manufacturing company here in the Minneapolis area called Turfco. We do a topside lawn care equipment, manufactured mostly by hand here. My background is really in the publicly traded sector for many years at the kind of, at that controller, small VP level. And as you mentioned, John, right before I came here, I actually was with CLA for about two and a half years in the cast consulting world, doing kind of a lot of what you do there too, whether it was, you know, from the controller to the CFO space. Worked with some great people there, worked with, of course, with Jennifer and a few others. And I’ve been here with Turfco for just over two years. I’ve come into a company that’s a third generation ownership. I know there’ll be some more introductions, but just a lot of cleanup that was a, we were able to happen, able to take care of. And as we move forward, you know, with technology being the way it is, it’s a, I think today is a, is a great opportunity. So Brian, when we were talking before we hit record, you talked and you mentioned you’ve been with Turfco for a few years. I got the impression kind of one of the first things you did when you came in was start to look at kind of the, some of the systems around the business, right? Yes.
[4:22] You know, I can relate that to my own journey in, in this space. When I bought Hill Manufacturing in 2018, I mean, really one of the first things I started doing was looking at that system as well. And, and like you, we had a, like actually your system might’ve been a little bit older, but we, you know, so we were coming from a homegrown, like access database, Excel, model, you know, I mean, it’s an ERP system, but it was, it was homegrown. Fun fact, uh, my sister actually wrote it, oddly enough, but the, you know, fast forward, I guess it had probably been, you know, 20, 25 years at that point, you know, late nineties, early to late nineties or mid to late nineties was when it started. It was highly inadequate. It ran the business okay, but it definitely was not scalable. Sure. Right. Yeah. Why don’t you talk a little bit about like when you came into Turfco, like kind of what, what you were looking at that prompted you to maybe start looking at some other options. Sure. When I came in, of course, I inherited quite the operation. I had replaced a gentleman who had been here for 12 years and he did a great job, but like a lot of family owned companies, a lot of systems always kind of been on the back burner because we’ve been doing what we’ve been doing for ages and it’s worked part of the reason I was brought in with my background is the company wants to grow and it became apparent early on. I was sharing what the, about the consultant, but even without the consultant looking at what the system does, we have a five-year growth path. We need everybody on the same page.
[5:55] And one of the things I realized quickly is we have a lot of different groups within the building that use our current system, but sometimes it doesn’t feel like we’re on the same system, you know, we typical old manufacturing shop, things are routed through our software, but Excel still rules the day. So it’s kind of depending on who has the, who has the latest and greatest version and, and, and all of that. Again, our, our system was implemented in 89. Uh, so as I was mentioning before we started, uh, my second day on the job, I got to meet the consultant who actually helped implement the software and he said, I’m retiring in two years. You guys better figure something out. So as we looked at the growth and we looked at what we needed, it became apparent quickly that we need something that, honestly, the front office here, we’re at literally at the front of the office, our building is just one long building, my thought was our software. What we have now has to start at the other end of the building. So by the time everything gets up to us, the accounting really is the non-event of everything. Yeah. I’m, you know, I’m glad you pointed that out too. So again, a little bit more about my background, late nineties, graduate college and, and started a software company that we did, uh, systems integrations into ERP systems. Um, large, you know, SAP style ERP systems.
[7:15] And, you know, from my experience back then, if you had your system since 89, the system I had at Hill from, you know, call it 95, whatever, you know, a lot of the, a lot of ERP systems at the time were built, I think in the CFO’s office. Yeah. Right. It was designed to get the, the data you want off the floor so that you could do certain reporting analysis, you know, whatever. And when I was, you know, fast forward to 2018 and for you, what, 23, 24, something like that, sounds like we both had a similar goal, which was, no, I need a, I need a system that helps get product out the door, right? In your case, equipment, in my case, parts for your equipment or whatever. Sure. Yeah. I want a system designed around that. And then I’ll give accounting what I can. Right. Right. Like, I mean, that’s, that’s kind of, that’s certainly how I took the approach. You know, I didn’t need a, in my case, I did not need a highly sophisticated financial package as much as I needed a, like a shop floor management, quality management system. And I think that’s a big shift in the ERP market probably over the last 20, 25, 30 years. Yeah. I’ve been, I’ve actually been involved in several implementations over my career. And I think what you said is, is absolutely true. People mistook ERPs as, you know, not to bash account softwares, but think like QuickBooks, right? Well, you can run a company on QuickBooks.
[8:46] Well, you can, if you’re the accounting side of things, but it was right. But ERP systems, accounting system, everybody equates that to an accounting system and really the inner, you know, ERP, enterprise resource, right? Uh, you don’t need, yeah, we’re small. We don’t need a full, full-blown system that we can’t use because it’s just too much, but when it’s the devil’s in the details, when you want to get it set up so that to your point, have everything go through the system. So when accounting gets it, it’s a lot of, it’s just plug and play, you’ve, you’ve put all the proper information in, you know, so that at the end of the day, when you make a machine, if everything’s run through the system, the way it’s supposed to run through, you know, accounting’s looking at it and saying, yep, that makes sense. Yeah. Yeah. And that’s, you know, that, that was, that was certainly our case. I mean, like I knew, I knew from an accounting package standpoint, I could run my business on QuickBooks or Sage or, I mean, go down the list. There’s plenty, plenty of accounting packages that would, would, uh, be powerful enough, but, but I needed something on the floor. I know a lot of times we’ll say things like, you know, manufacturing’s a team sport because it really is. And we’ve got, you know, finance is, is one of the players, but we’ve got, you know, sales and, and operations and engineering and, and quality. So, you know, just thinking about this as, as a team sport and to have a system that was, you know, designed just from the perspective of the accountant, right.
[10:21] And not, you know, all the other stakeholders that are needed to really, you know, be able to run an efficient shop and, and accomplish our goals. Manufacturers, what is your biggest headache? Is it measuring improving profitability, gaining efficiencies with AI and automation, maybe tightening up your cybersecurity, maybe getting your business ready to sell? At CLA, their goal is to know you and help you with challenges like these and more. Every day, CLA helps manufacturers tap into millions in revenue and cost savings, like one manufacturer that boosted capacity and revenues by 15 to 20%. Visit claconnect.com to hear real success stories and learn how you can grow your top and bottom line. Brian, I’m curious, you know, so, so I’ve, I’ve talked to a number of shops over the years that like, kind of in the same boat, I was an 18 that you were two years ago, you know, they have some sort of system in place, right? Whether it’s a homegrown, whether it’s an old system, it’s, it’s been shocking to me how many times I’ve talked to people that they like, leadership wants to make a change to a new system. Ownership does not, right? They, they’re perfectly happy.
[11:44] So, so I’m curious, you know, you as, you as a coming in as a, in a CFO role, you know, presumably as a leader, having to kind of maybe sell this a little bit to owners, like, where did you start that process? And like, how did you, what was the case that, you know, the business case that you made for it? Well, I think the simple start was that second day when the consultant, because the two, the two brothers that own it were also in the room and they heard him say, yeah, I’m retiring in two years, but on top, but yeah, but on top of that too, as we started talking five, 10 year plans, I just shared with them for us, the biggest piece that we need to solve or resolve, however you want to say it, you know, our lifeblood is the production management, right? We have a production manager who’s, he’s been here 27, 28 years. He’s, he’s great at what he does and he knows how to do it. Hands on, he could do it on a, on the, on the back of an envelope. The problem is how do we make it more efficient for him? Because to John’s point, you know, ERP is not an accounting software. We have all those parts, but you know, one of the pieces is, okay, if my, if the production manager is going to put out the shop order so we can get products made, well, that’s got to trigger something in purchasing. That’s got to trigger something in, in the, you know, as the material handlers in the back start to try to find these products, it’s like, well, do we have it? Do we not have it, you know, working with vendors? And so for me, when I, when I looked at all that and understanding where our current system sits, just in total usage and everything else, one of the things I mentioned to the owners early on, and we’ve just kind of mapped it out, as I said, at the five-year percentage we want, and it’s very achievable.
[13:31] We need to find a way to create some more scalability for the different departments so that people can pick up and put down where they need to, if there’s assistance needed, you know, for, for example, right now, if, if, if purchasing needed me to do something, they’d have to contact me, they’d have to tell me where their spreadsheet is, and then I’d have to understand how does that tie into our system versus what’s in the shop order versus, you know, where being able to put everything into one system to say, okay, you know, again, soup to nuts, we want to start it. Ironically, our building is set up that the receiving is really at the back end of the building and it pushes all the way up towards the front of the building where our shipping goes. And then the front end is our engineers, our front office, et cetera. So, you know, when I said earlier about wanting to start it from the back of the building to the front, I mean, that’s really what it is. How do we, how do we go from order to cash? How do we go from all this? And I, and the, the, my biggest concern to them was, we were joking earlier, but the age of the server, it’s on the, the age of the system with, with everything we’ve all heard of catastrophic, you know, stories where something, one bad thing happened and it just wiped, wiped everything out. And we knew going in that we were going to have to do something that was going to create scalability, not only of production, but of efficiencies, you know, again, a lot of manufacturing companies I’ve worked with other ones, they have a system, but they run it in Excel.
[15:01] And, and we all know Excel is a great tool, but it’s only as good as the information in there. So as soon as you have one bad data cell, you’re, you’re hosed. Yeah. I’ll give you my real life example of what you just said. So I, I have this kind of homegrown system. It’s, there’s a, there’s a core system and then it’s supported by tons of Excel spreadsheets, right? And as any good, you know, capitalist entrepreneur would do, one of the first things I wanted to do was understand how we price our jobs that we do. Like, oh, we’ve got this Excel template that we use to quote in, right? And it’s, it’s, it, it’s detailed. I mean, you, you really should be able to capture all of your estimated costs and, and come up with, you know, good pricing. But I, you know, so I start kind of testing it out against some jobs we’ve recently run and things like that. I’m, I’m just like not getting the price. Like I’m, things are not matching up. Well, like any good Excel spreadsheet that’s been used for years and years and years, there’s tons of broken formulas, right? So there were cells that we were not capturing, you know, and, and I think everybody knows how simple that happens, right? Like you’re using it one time and instead of saving it as new, as a finished file, right, you saved over the template.
[16:24] Yeah. And, and, you know, like you’re not summing up everything correctly. And, you know, so we had been under quoting jobs for some period of time. I don’t know how long, you know, at least, at least the version I saw was wrong. Right. You know, so then now, and that was at the very start of the process, right? That was, that was just at the quoting phase. Now turn that into an order, turn that into, you know, I mean, how many broken processes are there along the way that you end up just with an entire broken value chain inside your business? Oh, absolutely. And you know, there’s that. And then of course, in today’s day and age with, you know, the increase of tariffs and, and oil and everything else and, and, and product costs, Excel only tells you the basics of the story. And then, you know, we’re, we’re doing a lot of cost comparisons like you were doing a lot of cost comparisons right now that we’re scratching our head because it’s, a lot of it sits in Excel and some of it’s in our system. And so trying to understand to your point that the source of truth of what’s really happening and how do we get to that final number that makes sense. I kind of jumped ahead there. Let’s, let’s back up in the process of, so, so I want to ask a question to both of you first. John, let’s start with you because this is another one I hear up all the time. I hear quite a bit, you know, fact or fiction, I’m too small to have an ERP system.
[17:44] Oh, I would, I would say that is, that’s fiction because I think that, you know, if we’re going to manufacture, we’re going to have production planning materials that we have to order and we need to be able to pull all of these pieces together. And I think that, you know, in today’s day, there are ERPs out there that are affordable options. So I wouldn’t say that, you know, I wouldn’t say that someone’s too small for, for an ERP, perhaps as your first getting started, but I think as soon as the business starts to scale, that’s one of the more important investments that you can make, that’s really gonna, gonna play a role in the long-term success of that business for all the reasons that we we’ve discussed and all the coordination that’s involved and also really to get, you know, accurate visibility into what’s happening in the business. So I think as soon as you’re, you know, starting to scale that business and you’re moving out of the, you know, the garage with a couple of spindles, I think you should be thinking about systems and that’s one of the better investments that you can make in your business. Brian, how about you? I agree. I think that’s fiction, you know, back in my dark ages, if you will, a job, I was a small business consultant a couple of decades ago.
[19:11] We were really at the, the QuickBooks smaller version level, and we actually ran a Mac platform software that’s, it was called a CountEdge and we had a lot of like small mom and pop manufacturers, people that had their own little design firms or whatever, but even at that level, you know, those softwares can do what you need to do, but what I’ve learned over the years and what someone who I was working with made a really good point way back then, and it’s the old adage of act how you want to be and who you want to be, not where you are today, you know, so if you’re running a company and you’re, even if you’re a startup, but you have something like, I know this is to John’s point, I know this is going to scale, make that investment, right? You know, that doesn’t mean you have to go to the top end. There’s a lot of good, a lot of good softwares at several levels and platforms that can take you from point A to point B, and especially in today’s society with AI and with everything else, a lot of these softwares, you know, you can take the tier, the lower tier ones, the tier twos, the tier threes, and they’re almost designed to semi plug and play into each other so that when you hit the top end of maybe a tier one software where they’re really designed for that lower revenue, a lot of what you need really plugs in well into the next software, because at certain levels, you know, at the level we’re looking at, and I’ve said this several times, you take a Acumatic, a NetSuite, Intact, you take all of those where they’re kind of all on that same platform. If you remove all the labels, they’re the same software, right? Sure.
[20:50] The interfaces are different. Some of the other features, some of the ways you get information in and out might be different, but at the end of the day, you know, go back to the old argument of Excel versus Lotus one, two, three, right? Right. It’s a software, it’s a software, but I think to say, well, we’re too small to have that, I, you have, in my mind, unless you’re truly wanting to just be, I just, you know, I only want a couple of spindles a month, this is a side hobby. I think that that’s the wrong mindset. Yeah. So I, I agree wholeheartedly with both of you. I’ve, I’ve said many times on many of our podcasts, if I were starting a machine shop today, for example, I would buy my first machine with a PO issued from my ERP system. I would back it up a little bit further than both of you said, even probably and say, no, I’m, I’m just going to start right from the beginning. And, and Brian, you probably can feel that pain too, like going through the transition to me is it’s, it’s, it’s almost just worth starting correct. Oh, absolutely. From the beginning, you know, cause we were importing data from Excel spreadsheets and access databases and all those types of things. And then we, you know, it probably took us a year to really get it all cleaned up and, and operating for us. And, you know, it would just feel like a dream to just start fresh, right. And just do it right from the beginning. No, absolutely.
[22:15] All right. Shop owners, listen up here. I think all of us know we are in one of the most in capital intensive businesses there is. And margins are tight and we’re, we’re always fighting issues. And then when we make money, what do we do with it? Stock markets up and down all over the place. Well, I get asked a lot about where can I invest my money? I’m a firm believer as business owners, you’ve got to invest in yourself first. You need to reinvest capital into yourself. So the number one thing that I’ve done in this industry and investing was ProShop ERP. We’ve been using ProShop since 2018 and my payback literally was within weeks. With their per user based pricing, I knew when I made the decision, I only needed to save my workers roughly one hour per month, we saw within the first week, we were saving multiple hours per day. That type of ROI just doesn’t come along very often. Outside of that, the real value has been able to quickly implement best practices across my entire shop from the time we get an order to the time we ship it. Scaling my business with confidence, being able to go out and know that I can deliver on my promise to deliver quality parts to my customer, and then gaining insights into every job, employee, machine, and every process in our business to really drive efficiency and look for opportunities for improvement. That’s where the real value in your business drives. So visit ProShopERP.com, book a demo and start realizing ROI today.
[23:45] That’s ProShopERP.com. Brian, you brought up something that this will probably end up being a little bit of a rabbit trail and I, and I have some strong opinions on it, but you know, you brought up AI and, and, you know, some of the options that are out there. I’d love to hear both of yours take on, there’s a lot of, oh, I vibe coded this this weekend, right? I vibe coded an ERP system. I vibe coded a instant quoting package. I, and you know, I mean, AI is amazing. I mean, it does things that it allows me to do things. I didn’t, that would, would take me days, weeks, months, years, and, you know, sometimes minutes, right? Again, I have my own opinions. Let’s, let’s start with you guys off the shelf, you know, like industry package, ERP system, or vibe code your own and AI. With this question, Mike, where my mind goes is to the security considerations. You know, coming at it from the perspective of working at an accounting firm, certainly lots of financial information that, you know, hackers, fraudsters would love to get their hands on. And so we’re talking about it’s operational information, it’s designs, and it’s also financial information. It’s information that that’s sensitive. So I think, you know, and I hear about different, you know, applications that owners, entrepreneurs have vibe coded it and the utility that they’re able to get from those and the ability to build something that’s specific and customized, but I also really pause there on the security considerations.
[25:32] You know, so I think one it’s, you know, is our, is our data secure? And I think the other piece, which I probably don’t have, you know, a good enough understanding of is what are the vulnerabilities in those systems or, you know, what are the things where they’re kind of the, you know, we don’t know what we don’t know as far as the, the weaknesses in, you know, some, something that we vibe coded versus, you know, buying a system that has been tested. That’s gone through quality control, you know, protocol and somebody who’s really, you know, standing behind that and supporting that system. Yeah. I think that’s a, I think that’s an excellent take on it. Brian, how about you? Yeah. So I kind of to John’s point, I mean, and again, you know, software today, a lot of it’s cloud-based, right? So the security, there’s always going to be a risk no matter what you do. But I like to go back to the adage of don’t work harder, work smarter. So if something’s already there, I don’t want to recreate the wheel. And I, and we’re finding here in our company that AI is a great assistant to what we have. For a couple of reasons, you know, one, we can take data, for example, speaking AI, we’re, we’re creating our own AI policy and, you know, let’s go back five years, you’re going to Google AI policy. You’re going to try to find things. You’re going to find templates.
[26:59] You’re going to start typing. I, I’m in a CFO round table group on a monthly basis. I emailed my group and I said, does anybody have current AI? Cause you know, why recreate the wheel? I got three or four different policies from them. I was able to put it into our co-pilot and I said, take this, put it in my language, put it on my letterhead, use my tone, tell me what my best AI policy is. Right. So it, it did all that work behind the scenes for me. I’m not typing, but then to the point, you know, that is so critical. I think people lose sight of this too, is AI is great, but it still requires human verification. Sure. Because it’s constantly learning. Yeah. It’s hallucinating still, right? Yeah. You can put stuff in there, but like, even with that AI policy, I had to go through several iterations because it, it did things and then I said, well, I want it to say this and I put it out there and it’s like, that’s not really what I’m looking for and get the final result. And I’m still typing a little bit, but it’s the same thing if, you know, our owner put some stuff into the copilot, cause he wanted to kind of create a little mini dashboard that he was working on and it took several iterations, right? Because your stuff, your language is unique to you, even if it’s depreciation. Well, everybody knows what depreciation is, but a lot of companies treat it differently, right? So the AI is going to see the word depreciation.
[28:18] Well, that’s part of this. Well, maybe it is, maybe it isn’t. So I would say, you know, if you have a lot of time and patience and, and money anyway, because it’s, you know, you’re going to, you’re going to do it and you’re still going to keep building on it and fixing it working, it’s a great hobby. But for me with a company, with everything that we need to do, I would rather go with something that’s already proven. Yeah. So love both those takes. I’ll get, I’ll give you my additional take just, you know, for the audience to hear my opinion on it. First of all, you know, call it what you want. Vibe coding is nothing new, right? I mean, I can remember coming in on a Monday and telling people, Oh, look at this kick-ass Excel spreadsheet I created. It’s the same thing, right? It is. Or, I mean, go back a generation before and go, Hey, look at this new filing system I created in the file room, right? Like it’s, it, in all cases, we’ve been vibe coding systems for a hundred years, right? Or longer. We’re just putting systems and processes in place to control our business. My bigger take, and, and, and this will start to getting into like how we, how you might want to go through an ERP selection, my bigger take on it is, you know, ERPs have evolved a long way from like Brian, what you had in 89, what I was dealing with and, you know, from the mid nineties, mid late nineties, back then they were very generic, like one size fits all, right? And you adopted your business to match your ERP system. You know, fast forward 30, 40 years and, you know, you can get an ERP system for anything, right? Like, I mean, I have a friend that just bought three car washes and he implemented a cloud-based ERP system for the car washes, right? I’m in precision manufacturing, same thing. I, you know, I can get, I can get one focused on my industry.
[30:08] And I think what you lose when you vibe code, and again, I did vibe code, right? I created Excel spreadsheets and all this back 30 years ago. You know, if you build your own, you build it to match your business and how you do things. You don’t necessarily get industry best practices, right? Right. And, and that’s one thing, you know, in my case, as my listeners know, like we use ProShop ERP. And it is, it is based on industry best practices, right? Now, Brian, to your point, I today used AI to go into my ERP system and look at hundreds of jobs and identify it. I asked it a series of questions of things I wanted it to look for. And it crunched, you know, gosh, probably a thousand work orders and narrowed down to the 12 I needed to go pay some attention to, right? So for me, like I want the industry standards, industry best practice. I want my core data to be on a sound, secure environment to John’s point. But now I can use AI to access that and analyze that and crunch data.
[31:24] It would have taken me weeks to do what I did today and, you know, writing a good prompt and five, maybe 10 minutes later having back data that then I, that was actionable, right? But yeah, so for me, a lot of it’s just that, like, I want my core data secure, sound, I want it to help me develop processes based on best practices. And, you know, from there I can use other tools to break that down. Mike, one of the things you mentioned there is it sounds like, you know, you’re, you’ve got sort of your AI configured within your kind of operating system there. It has the ability to access your ERP and you’ve got that set up within your environment. I think that’s an interesting point because I think that’s the same for you, Brian, as well. That’s not always the case, right? Where we’ve got the AI configured to our systems and, you know, a lot of times, right, we’re just kind of going out to the chat bot or whatnot, you know, with our information. And I think that’s probably, you know, it’s probably an opportunity for a lot of shops is to, you know, hey, we’re using AI, how do we configure this to our environment? How do we create some of those guardrails or security around that? You know, I think it kind of gets back to some of that security consideration, but also just, you know, how do we, how do we make this as effective as possible? And there could be opportunities out there for shops to kind of elevate the way they’re using AI. I’m glad we kind of started there because I do want to talk about, Brian, your experience selecting an ERP system. And I think that’s one of the first questions people do need to ask, right? It’s like, you know, as you pointed out, what do I need if I’m still in my garage with, you know, one piece of equipment versus, you know, you’re an operating business, maybe, you know, responsible to different quality standards and security standards and so forth.
[33:23] But, um, you know, one of the, I do think one of the first questions you can ask, like, you know, do I just build something myself or, or do I need to buy something? And I think the three of us all agree that, you know, probably a off the shelf, if you will, is, it definitely has its advantages as you scale and become a real business. Okay. So Brian, you came into a real business, had an old system and you said, okay, this isn’t going to work. How did you start that kind of selection process of saying, okay, well, cause there’s a ton of systems out there. Sure. So again, I’ve been through a couple of these, so I’ve, I’ve implemented a few. I did some research just to see who’s the, who’s the big players at our level and where we want to go. And I’d already kind of had the names. I had some contacts, of course, with CLA and with a few others. So what I did is I really narrowed it down. You know, honestly, I use my history on which systems I’ve used, but then I also went back through my CLA work and I said, all right, I’ve worked with several manufacturing organizations and what did they use? Yeah. And I was able to kind of compile a list and I wanted to keep it simple. So I did my pros and cons and I brought it down to four. And then having done this before, my approach really was at the end of the day, I want whoever we go with to sell themselves to everybody else. Cause I don’t care.
[34:52] Right. I’m sure I’m kind of that end user. I’ll touch it some, but there’s going to be people who have never really touched a software like this before, and they’ve got to be able to use it. It’s got to be easy for them to use. It’s got to be simple. And so I, I started kind of just going department by department through our building and saying, what is it this group needs? What is it this group needs? I kind of put my own RFP when I reached out to the groups and we were going through our initial conversation and I kind of gave everybody, you know, to keep everything on a level playing field. I said, here’s my script. You’ve got to answer these questions and you’ve got to prove to me you can handle it. And again, I’ve said it before, but I told every one of them, don’t tell me you can do accounting or you won’t even get my front door. I want you to start at the back of the building and come to the front. And so there was a, there was one or two that just kind of disqualified themselves because they couldn’t follow that simple process. They kind of had their own way in mind of how they wanted to do it, but I was very specific in how I wanted it done. Because again, I think, and this is to your point of, we know our business, right? I knew even early on, I knew how our company operated. And so I knew how I wanted it presented because again, it’s kind of a order to cash or purchase to production, kind of a, kind of a mindset. So that’s really how I wanted them to present not at, well, here’s your accounting on by here’s this piece, but our people here, when they saw it, they’re like, Oh, this makes sense.
[36:21] Cause that’s how the receiving works. That’s how the material handling works. That’s how it gets to this department, how it gets to that department, how it ultimately gets built and out the door, you know, whatever. And so I, I went with four higher names and just kind of put them through the ringer on that. They came in, they had to do, they had to present to the groups. That was kind of the initial steps. Yeah. And in, and in your case, you consulted with CLA on this, correct? Yeah, obviously we’ve used them on a couple of different projects here to having been, having being an alumni, but honestly, we’re in the process of implementing Acumatica right now. And I laugh because I had actually never heard of Acumatica until about a year in at CLA and cause people were talking about the software that was out there and it is newer in comparison to some of the other ones, but I actually reached out to a few of my people that I had worked with out there that had worked on a couple of different systems. And I said, what would you guys recommend? And they, they helped kind of, it was interesting that the people I talked to when they would get back to me, their list really kind of matched my list of who to talk to. Having the, the in with CLA really did help from that aspect as well. Of course, when you look at the ERP world, it’s just, like I said earlier, it’s massive, right? I mean, you’ve got the, you’ve got the really big companies that like all of my customers use, right? I mean, I have customers on SAP and all those types of things.
[37:44] And then, and then you’ve got kind of this mid tier. And then I think, you know, you really get down to some niche. You know, again, going back to mine, like their ideal client profile is machine shops that are either ISO or AS9100, right? Because they have integrated QMS in their systems. Or I mentioned the car wash. I thought about after I had said that, I have a friend that’s a sole practitioner attorney, and he has a legal office ERP system, right? You know, how scalable are they? How broad are they? How best practiced are they? Like, and Brian, it sounds like you and I had a very similar approach, which was, I need a system to help me get parts out the door. At the end of the day, I got to ship parts. I love how you talk about, you know, order to cash, right? And, you know, like I talk about with my team, like, what do we make? Well, our end goal is to create payable invoices. And in our case, that involves shipping some parts. Yes. But we also have to ship like material certifications and, you know, correct paperwork around all that and quality data and all those types of things to get the invoice paid, right? So, so when I look at my complete value chain, again, it starts at, I need to create an estimate that’s not on a broken Excel spreadsheet that will then, you know, ideally turn into a quote that ideally turns into a PO that ideally turns into a production cycle that creates parts, that creates an invoice that is payable, correct, right? Yeah. And, and from there, my accounting package can handle it in my case. At that point, I hand that invoice off to the accounting package.
[39:31] It takes care of everything else and, and, and I’m good. Right. Yeah. As I said earlier, I kind of want accounting to almost be the non-event of all of this. Yeah. Yeah. And it should be. Yeah. If you run a job shop, manage a job shop or spend your day trying to squeeze more output out of the same people, machines and hours, this one’s for you. During IMTS week, the job shops workshop and networking reception takes place on Tuesday, September 15th. This half day program is built specifically for shop professionals like us who want practical ideas that they can actually take back to the floor. You’ll hear how other shops are reducing operational costs, improving output, applying AI and shop ready ways and implementing automation where it makes sense, plus you’ll get a detailed industry outlook and the chance to connect with other job shop leaders who are solving the same problems you are. If you’re going to IMTS to find ideas that can move the needle in your shop, don’t just walk the aisles, get in the room, learn more and register at IMTS.com. Okay. So your case, so now you worked with CLA, you know, you, you obviously you, you made a decision on Acumatica. CLA is an integrator of that and they were able to help you kind of tie that whole big picture together.
[40:57] Yep. Yeah. So when we got down to it, it was between Acumatica and one other software. And honestly, at the end of the day, you know, the two owners of the company, the final decision, if you will, because they’re the ones signing the bottom line of the check and everything was on them, but they leaned heavily on me. Acumatica came in very economical. We knew it was going to be an outlay and that what, that didn’t scare us, but through the whole process, they really listened well, they delivered how we needed them to deliver what we needed them to deliver. And it does help that if coming from CLA here in Minneapolis with a big manufacturing presence here, and I know pretty much everybody all the way up to the whole market director here, um, that she came out and Samantha came out and visited at one of the meetings and her comment to the owners was, you know, if we go with you guys, it’s going to be great and scary because Brian knows who to contact, which, and honestly, there’s nothing, you know, there is nothing wrong with leveraging your resources, right? I mean, why wouldn’t you? Well, I think you speak to something that everybody can consider though, right? It’s, it’s, it’s what’s that relationship I’m going to have, whether it’s directly with the ERP company or an integrator, you know, because it is going to be a process, which actually is a perfect lead into the other thing I want to talk about is that implementation process. It can be scary. It can be daunting.
[42:27] You know, again, both of us coming off some existing systems, we’ve got old data. We want to, we want to try to pull forward what’s relevant. We don’t want to pull forward what’s not relevant or maybe wrong, right? I don’t, I didn’t want those broken Excel spreadsheet templates, but I did want like production data I wanted, you know, historical pricing. I wanted some stuff like that. So talk a little bit about like this big, scary monster of implementation. Like how was that process for you guys? Right. So we are where I would say we’re at the 50 actually at the halfway point, but honestly, I lean back on my, both my small business implementation from years ago, as well as recently implementing some software at this level and thinking about what went right, what went wrong and where were my headache points and so I kind of pulled together, I’ve got some, the project manager of this, but I’ve got two administrators and they’re, they’re the ones, you know, one’s kind of on the front office side and then my production managers on kind of the backside of things. So between the two of them, we cover the whole group. And as we’ve been going through, I told Acumetic and the other company, when we get to it, you are going to sit down with each department and fully understand what they do and what they need, right? A lot of it is the scary part is, well, what if I have to change my process? And when we talked about that internally, Hey, there’s going to be changed.
[43:52] There’s no way around that. Uh, if the system can do it, that’s what we want. Right. You know, ideally we want the system to handle 85, 90% of what we do versus 50% and that other 10%, whether it’s another piece that we can plug in or, you know, ideally, you know, the use of Excel becomes much, much smaller. Sure. And so a lot of it, you know, the front office accounting side, that’s, that’s pretty straightforward, but a lot of our production processes right now that are so manual, and even though we use our system, there’s still a lot of the Excel, it’s been having those individuals spend more time, uh, on these we’re kind of through the discovery training calls now, if you will, of what’s going on to get a more hands-on with some of our information so they can go, you know, sandbox it and try to break it and understand that is also kind of the nice thing about these ERPs today, you know, we call them off the shelf, but they’re still very customizable. Oh, a hundred percent. So the beauty of it is, is yeah, they have their standard functions, but, oh, you want it to go that way? Well, here’s what we’re going to do. We’re going to create the process for it. And now you go forward and you do that, or yeah, we can do that. That’s just a different setting here that we need to do. So that’s, you know, once we get through that, now it’s where I’m kind of pushing them to say, well, now we need to start, and we’re not at the train, you know, the user, obviously they accepted some testing, but we are now at the part where I want them to start turning it around.
[45:23] So instead of talking to us, having people in our office driving the screen, will they tell them what to do so that they get that? And I think that’s, you know, that’s a big piece when it comes to an implementation is giving people the time to play and break it. Yeah. You brought up a few thoughts there. One, in my case, one of, one of my decision criteria. So, so my system is a SaaS system. I mean, obviously any, any investment like this, you make, you need to think about your ROI and, you know, in my case, when I was able to sit back and look at it, it’s okay, well, if I save everybody in my company one hour per month, I’ll pay the SaaS price, it’s kind of how it broke down for me. And, you know, honestly, within days of implementation, we were finding that we were saving multiple hours per day per person, right? So my payback period was just, it was non-existent, right? Like it, it just didn’t, it was so fast. And it’s funny, you know, fast forward eight years now, you ask anybody on my team, they’re like, they, we don’t know how to run our company without our system, if it’s correct. Right, right. But, but one of the things, you know, when you’re talking about, again, our system is also very customizable. However, I did have to challenge our, our internal team quite a bit during the implementation process to say, wait a second. I mean, we may want to change the way we’re doing things though.
[46:51] Again, back to my best practice example, right? It’s like, just cause it’s not gonna allow us to do things the way we’ve always done them, we need to revisit, like, are we doing things the right way though? Right. And, and there were definitely processes that, that we changed the way we were doing things. Oh, absolutely. It was because the default system way was better, right? I mean, I can say for certain, I mean, we’re a bigger, better, faster, stronger company today than we were doing it the way we had always done it for the 40 years prior to. Oh, absolutely. Our current system. I think Mike, that’s a really important point around, you know, going through this process, we may change the way that we’re doing things. And I think it’s important to look at those processes as part of the implementation. We certainly see that a lot on the cost accounting side, right? We don’t have the right hygiene and practices for cost accounting, and we’re bringing those bad, you know, broken processes over to the new system. We’re going to get similar results. And you mentioned earlier, Mike, one of the, you know, we’re talking about vibe coding versus off the shelf. And, you know, one of the points you raised there is that buying that off the shelf system, you’re also getting, you know, it’s been configured to industry best practices.
[48:12] So, you know, versus doing the way, you know, setting something up to do things the way we’ve always done them. This may be a time where we say, hey, there might be a better way to approach this, and we need to change our process. And I think it’s a really important point to be considering that as you’re going through the implementation. I mean, it certainly was true for us. I mean, one of the things we liked about the system when we looked at it, and I think this is important for anybody to consider is, I mean, I’ll use the 80-20, but it was probably more like 90-10, you know, 80% of the system off the shelf matched our operations really, really well. And then there was definitely 20%. It’s like, okay, do we adapt the system to our process or do we adapt our process to the system? And it was probably a mix. You know, there were some things we adapted the system and customized it to maybe use our language or use some of our processes and stuff. But I would say there’s also a lot of things we do today that we adopted because the system pointed you in that direction. And that’s a lot of the vernacular we use today. That’s, you know, those types of things. And I think we’re better for it for sure. No, absolutely. Okay. So as we start to kind of wrap up here, Brian, I know you’re kind of in the middle of implementation right now, but you’ve been involved in some other stuff.
[49:29] What do you think some of the biggest surprises maybe people would see, you know, kind of coming from some homegrown systems and so forth to working with like an integrator to really put something in place that you have seen or you expect to see? Well, I think I expect to see here, but I have seen, and it goes back to what John said, right? You’ve got a system that’s got industry best practice. And my last implementation that I did, we get a small company, the company made it work, but we found out really fast. Some people were doing things to try to justify their job. Right. Such a great point. That’s the fear, right? Because I’ve even heard people, well, if we do this, do I lose my job? Because like, for example, our system is so old that our invoices are sent through a different server. It’s a whole batch process. It’s antiquated, right? So one of the things with our ARAP group is, well, if we do this with the system, as soon as we hit record, it sends the invoice off and it’s constantly, it’s no, we’re not replacing you. We’re, to what you said earlier, we’re going to give you more time to actually get some of the other things that we’d love to do, right? I mean, it’s the antiquated system. So I think a lot of it is, it’s that and finding out that on the backend, almost the remorse of why didn’t we do this sooner? You know, that’s probably what I hear most from people that I’ve talked to about ERP systems, like, Oh my God, like I’ve been banging my head against the wall for years, should have done this years ago. Yeah. And I love your point about the people too, you know? So it’s interesting in my implementation.
[51:07] So I’ll talk about my struggle. I expected, so I, so I was going from, again, this homegrown system that had very, very little visibility on the shop floor, right? To PCs at every machine that, you know, you’re clocking into work for the day, you’re jobbing into the job, you’re recording how many parts you made, like, I mean, pretty drastic change on the shop floor, right? I expected that to be my biggest hurdle, right? And you know, for the shop floor to maybe revolt even, right? Like we’re not doing this, it’s big brother and you know, like whatever. I kid you not within days, they were so accepting of it. Like they, they immediately saw it as making their job easier, right? They had work instructions right in front of them. They had quality data right in front of them. They had the print right in front. They had everything they needed to do their job and to do it well in front of them at their workstation. Yeah. Where I saw the biggest revolt was actually in my front office. So the purchasing, the accounting, some of those functions, it was seen as in fairness, that’s where the biggest changes happened, right? And it was, I mean, there were, there were months of like circumventing the system because they didn’t want to learn the new way to issue a vendor PO. They wanted to just do what they’d always done, right? Well, now it’s not in the system. Now we don’t know if we have the material.
[52:34] Now we don’t know if we have the material so we can start the job, all those types of things. And I mean, in all fairness to most of the people that struggled with that are not with me anymore. They were not ready to make that change. But to your point, you know, where I used to have, I mean, at the time my company was a third of the quarter of the size it was, and I had two people doing purchasing. And today it’s someone’s part-time job. Right. Because the system does it that much better. Almost kind of the same way with accounting. It was a full-time job. ARAP is pretty full-time. And then I handle kind of the CFO role myself. You know, the, the administration side of the implementation probably had the bigger impact on us than on the floor. And I can see that cause I’ve seen that in the past too. And honestly, I think back to not my last one, but one of the first ones I was in, I was on that first nervous Nelly side where it’s like, what is it going to do to me? And, uh, the controller I was working for at the time said, all it’s going to do is allow you all those things that I dump on your desk that I need, I want you to research. It’s going to give you time to do that. And it actually, you know, and that was the beauty of it is to your point, something that would have taken me four hours, the system does in 20 minutes. Now I’ve actually got time to dig deeper, to actually answer more intelligently, to do, yeah, use your brain and to do more fun projects than just process. Right.
[53:59] I mean, a lot of the older systems, that’s what the people did is it’s punch, go punch, go where now you’re able to be involved in more things. And I think it’s, it’s freeing in a way. Once, once people accept the fact that it’s not a replacement, it’s like anything else, like AI, I’ve heard people, AI is going to take away all the accounts. Well, okay. That’s all fine and good until then they have to call us, you know, John at CLA and all the, you know, all the other ones, because, well, we’ve got all this, these numbers, but we don’t know if they’re right. Right, right. Exactly. Or we don’t know what they mean. We just spit out numbers. Yeah. Yeah. Gentlemen, this was great. I think it gives people a good primer of, you know, kind of how to, how to go down this road of, do I, am I too small for an ERP all the way to, you know, kind of through implementation? Yeah. I appreciate both of your input. Once you give everybody real quick, if they have some questions for you, you know, maybe kind of how to reach out to you and we’ll include that in some show notes too. Yeah, absolutely. I’d encourage folks to visit us at claconnect.com. There’s a lot of good insight on there in regards to system implementations and, and other relevant topics. And you can find me either on LinkedIn, John Hughes, a three letter John, my parents knew I wasn’t smart enough to spell a four letter word or it’s john.hughes at claconnect.com. And I appreciate the opportunity to be on here with you today, Mike and Brian.
[55:25] Oh, absolutely. And Brian, how about you? Sure. And I appreciate it as well. I’m also on LinkedIn at Brian Schoonover and I will, it is ironic. There’s actually three Brian Schoonovers in the Twin Cities. Really? Get out. And there’s another one. He’s actually very high up in the tech world here. So I, I get a lot of his ads and the vendors, Hey, if you listen to this, and I, we’re connected and I’ve joked with them several times. I’m just going to start answering as you, because your giveaways from your vent, your perspective vendors are much nicer than mine. Let me tell you that. But that’s a Brian Schoonover on LinkedIn or bschoonover at turfco.com. You can definitely reach out and ask questions. Be glad to answer. Yeah. And as always, if, if you have trouble finding them, reach out to me. I have John’s cell phone number, so I’ll just let you text him. Brian, I’ll at least connect you via email. Yeah. Listeners as always, thank you for sticking around and listen to this. Hopefully, you know, if you’re kind of in that, on that ERP journey, you learn something here that you can, you can take with you. Yeah. Reach out if you have any questions and all of us would be happy to help you. Absolutely. Again, gentlemen, thank you so much. We’ll talk to everybody next time. Well, thank you. Thank you, sir.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect with Jon Hughes and Brian Schoonover
- Connect with Jon Hughes by email at Jon.hughes@claconnect.com or find him on LinkedIn
- Connect with Brian Schoonover by email at bschoonover@turfco.com or find him on LinkedIn
- Explore manufacturing resources from CLA at CLAConnect.com