By Jennifer Dubose
Josh McKain’s Data-Driven Framework to Align Goals and Accountability, Ep #7
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
On this episode of Buy the Numbers, I sit down with Josh McKain to talk about his 3.5-step framework—the process he uses to help companies turn their goals into results.
Josh shares how he starts every project by aligning teams, often uncovering surprising gaps in understanding. From there, his framework guides teams through assessing their capacity, building a strategic roadmap, and staying on track with regular check-ins—the “half-step” that keeps everyone aligned.
We also explore the importance of tracking the right KPIs. Overloading your team with metrics can create confusion and dilute focus. Instead, Josh recommends identifying 3–5 key metrics that truly drive success and making sure every team member understands how their work impacts those goals.
Whether it’s coaching your team with data, staying agile in the face of challenges, or gamifying progress to boost performance, Josh’s insights are packed with actionable advice. Tune in to learn how you can set your team up for measurable success.
You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in…
- Learn more about Josh McKain and Henry Rose Consulting [1:23]
- Josh’s three-and-a-half-step framework [4:42]
- Breaking down goals into KPIs [8:28]
- Why you need to review KPIs as a team [19:31]
- How Josh measures accountability [23:03]
- The importance of machine monitoring and data [25:43]
- The key to setting good goals [34:40]
Connect with Josh McKain
- Connect on LinkedIn
- Henry Rose Consulting
Read the Full Episode Transcript
[0:00] Speaker 1: All right, Metalworking Nation, so thanks for coming back today. Today I talk with Josh McCain. Josh has a really great mindset on just getting stuff done and how to set goals, how to, the accountability to those goals and helps a lot of businesses in our world.
So he works with manufacturers. I think he said typically in size 10 to maybe 100 employees or something like that. So I think that probably matches pretty well with a lot of us in that range.
It kind of almost kind of turned into a little bit of more of a consulting session for me where I was talking a lot about some of our struggles. But Josh has a great mind on how to help you align your goals with your strategy and then the accountability to go along with that. So hope you enjoy this episode.
As always, please like, review, rate the show. And with that, let’s go.
[0:55] Speaker 3: Welcome to By the Numbers. Each week, we’ll explore the numbers that drive your business. From accounting and finance to operations and the exciting realm of mergers and acquisitions.
Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, our discussions will equip you with the insights and strategies you need to rein in the power of data to elevate your manufacturing company. Let’s crunch some numbers.
[1:23] Speaker 1: Josh, thanks for joining me today.
[1:24] Speaker 2: Absolutely, thanks for having me, Mike. I’ve been really looking forward to it and glad we got connected and it’s a busy time of year, but I’m glad we made it work.
[1:32] Speaker 1: So we got connected through LinkedIn, like so many relationships, I think, in our industry. You had me on to interview me, what, a month ago? Yep.
Something like that?
[1:40] Speaker 2: I think it’s been a little longer than that, but yeah, for the book that I’m working on, all about mistakes, specifically in the manufacturing industry. And I actually still remember what you said. Do you remember what you told me was?
I do remember, yes. So it’s actually very relevant to today’s conversation. It was putting off tough decisions or tough conversations.
And the problem never seems to get easier when you delay it.
[2:02] Speaker 1: Yeah, I’ve never seen one self-improve itself, right? Like just take care of itself. It’s not self-healing.
Unfortunately, that’d be really great if it was. That’d be great if they were, but they seldom are self-healing. Well, why don’t you tell the listeners a little bit about, you know, kind of what you do, what your background is and so forth?
[2:16] Speaker 2: Yeah, so I run a consulting firm called Henry Rose Consulting. And a lot of people ask if it’s, you know, if I’m like bought into a franchise or a licensee. My kids’ middle names are actually Henry and Rose.
So I wanted to try and incorporate their names, Henry Rose Consulting. I work exclusively with manufacturing leaders and executives to help them get their most important stuff done. So just like you said, we’re gonna talk about getting stuff done.
That’s what I do with all my clients all day, every day. Get your most important projects done. Things that might be hanging over your head, they’re stuck in the mud, maybe they’re unprofitable.
Get those projects back on track. So I kind of function as a, almost an outsourced project manager. I’m not turning the screw.
You know, I’m not the one doing the work, but I’ll meet with the leadership team, the executive one-on-one or like a project team and help guide them. Okay, this is where we are. This is where we wanna be.
What are the exact steps we need to get here? What do we need to measure to make sure we stay on track? We can talk about that and help them get projects that are behind to being ahead and being, I think on my LinkedIn profile, I say keeping them enjoyable.
Fun things, they can go from being hanging over your head and a source of stress to something you’re proud of that you got done and it’s going very smoothly.
[3:34] Speaker 1: What is the typical size company you’re working with?
[3:37] Speaker 2: It tends to be small to medium, which I would say is 10 employees to less than 100 in my case. I’ve done a little bit of work with kind of an outlying company that’s like 3,000 or 4,000 employees, but that’s rare and I don’t know if it’s gonna continue.
[3:53] Speaker 1: Well, I think that’s great because that’s certainly the demographic of our listener base, right? When you look at the precision machining sector of the manufacturing space, I need to eventually find the right numbers, but they’re somewhere in the neighborhood of 30,000 shops in the United States. I think that’s the right number.
I mean, I’ve seen it as low as 17, I’ve seen it as high as 40, but I think the more reliable data I’ve seen puts it somewhere in the 30,000 neighborhood. But the average machine size is like 12 machines with 10 employees, something like that, right? So when you look at our listener base, I mean, I’m sure a lot of them are gonna fit right there in that demographic of shops you work with and can probably relate to a lot of what we’re talking about today.
I know I can.
[4:37] Speaker 2: Yeah, well, that’s great. That means what we say should be super valuable today, so that’s awesome.
[4:41] Speaker 1: I hope so. So what do you help a shop do?
[4:44] Speaker 2: Every client that I work with is gonna go through the same, we’ll call it three and a half step framework. So we go through the same process with everyone, but the nuts and bolts inside each of those steps changes depending on the challenges that they’re facing. So it always comes down to, first things first, we gotta get the team aligned on where we’re going.
And this is always one of my favorite parts of the process. There’s one example where I went in with a company and it was our very first meeting and I wanted to take them through my process. We started out and I said, okay, there’s 11 people in the room.
Okay, we need to get aligned, we need to make sure we all understand where we’re trying to take this project. What are we actually trying to accomplish here? And a couple of people raised their hands, thanks for coming in, we appreciate your time, but we don’t need to do that.
We all know where we’re headed, we’re aligned, we’re good to go. So I was like, great, that’s perfect. You’re gonna really speed this up.
If everybody could just write down where this project is headed and what our goals are, and then we’ll share them and we’ll just make sure, but you’ve already done the work, you guys are already aligned, I know you got it. So 11 people write down answers and then they all say it and we had 11 different answers. Yeah, okay, you’re right, so we need to get aligned.
So that’s step one, is getting the team aligned. Where are we and where are we trying to go? What are we actually trying to accomplish?
So then I’ve got a series of assessments that I’ve developed for their time. Do they actually have the time within the company to get this project done? Is it actually possible?
Because you know just as well as I do, lots of companies are just working on too many things that are all good ideas, they appear important, but they just can’t all be done. And that’s a very common problem. So we assess their time and their team.
Do they have the right people on board to actually get it done? Do they have the time and human resource capabilities to get the project done? And then once we do those assessments with that information in mind, okay, that’s where we wanna go, these are the capabilities that we have, let’s build out our strategic roadmap.
How are we going to get this project done? What are the step-by-step things we need to do to get it done? And so that’s part three.
And then three and a half is I stay on board through regular calls with their team. That’s basically providing accountability. And sometimes through those calls, we’ll find that we didn’t meet a milestone and so it requires a little bit more strategic planning to get back on track for where we’re trying to go.
So that’s the three and a half step framework.
[7:06] Speaker 1: Everything you just said, I can absolutely relate to in my shop, right? So I fit your demographic and we’ve got a great team of people. We run with a management team of about six people and then lots of, it’s a little bit support behind them and then of course the shop floor.
But we go through a strategic planning process annually, make sure we’re still in line. And then so where this fit is for me, to talk about on like by the numbers, one of the things that I have caught on to just really in the last year is, so I’ve always had KPIs to track towards my goals, right? But what I found this year too often was that they require too much manipulation by me.
And when I say manipulation, I really mean calculation, right? So I’m not manipulating the information, but I’ve got to go gather it. So I got to go gather production efficiency and total revenue, hours worked and all these things to hit these goals that we’ve set.
And they could even just be our highest level goals related to our on-time percentage and our shop utilization and stuff like that. I’m pulling data from, in some cases, two or three different systems to end up at a number, right? Well, that’s incredibly hard for, if I’m the only one that knows the formula, right?
For people to know how they’re doing on a day-to-day, week-to-week, month-to-month, quarter-to-quarter basis. So one of my strategic goals this year for my entire operations is breaking down each of our goals to a set of KPIs that whether you’re in my accounting department, my production scheduling department, estimating department, or you’re a welder, you have your piece of that puzzle available to you. And where do I find it?
What’s a good result, a bad result? And how can I change it? Because that’s, I think for us lots of times, that’s the missing piece.
People don’t know, they maybe can see, okay, I’m not doing a good job. Maybe I’m not doing a bad job, I’m not doing a good job, but I’d like to be doing better. What can I do to do better?
So that’s a big goal of mine next year is to get all my goals aligned to KPIs. Is that done in the past? I mean, I have in the past, in different environments and so forth.
But like I said, it just kind of dawned on me this year that I don’t really have that here. I have a lot of those tools available. And I think part of it is that last piece for us is helping people understand how that number fluctuates and how their performance can change that number.
So there’s a training element there that we’ve got to build in.
[9:41] Speaker 2: Are you the only person who has access to all of this data?
[9:45] Speaker 1: No, not the only, but I’m the only one. I only taught myself how to pull it all and get the results I need. So again, part of it’s a training element.
I mean, there’s definitely some of the financial aspects or financial data that I guess not everybody has 100% access to, but collectively they do.
[10:05] Speaker 2: Yeah, what time period are you normally measuring on these KPIs? Is it daily or per shift or is it weekly, monthly?
[10:13] Speaker 1: It depends on the KPI really, right? I mean, I guess probably at the simplest form, the most I really try to break it down is at the job level, which could be a day, could be a week, right? Depending on the job and the difficulty of that job.
I mean, we look at stuff even down to the hour, right? I mean, some stuff, you know, parts per hour, right? I mean, that matters.
And this one hour could have thrown off a complete production schedule. But really, I guess the most minute we break it down to would generally be at the job level. You know, my floor has access through machine monitoring and our ERP system to know how they’re doing hour by hour, shift by shift and job by job, right?
But I don’t know what I do. Well, I do know that they don’t understand. And again, this is back to my responsibility to teach them how that all piles up into this big number that we look at as a company, monthly, quarterly, annually, right, and that affects their bonuses and affects everything, the entire company.
[11:14] Speaker 2: Are they aware of the big number? Oh, yeah. So they know where the company is headed.
Right. They know the goal is and they see the KPIs, but it’s the link between the two that they won’t always see where the tie is.
[11:28] Speaker 1: Yeah, they maybe don’t know the significance of a KPI, right, or an individual KPI and how their hour by hour, day by day, week by week performance might affect that. I’m a huge believer that certainly in my case, I don’t have anybody here that’s not trying to do their best every day.
[11:45] Speaker 4: Yeah, good.
[11:46] Speaker 1: Right, and I think that’s probably true for most everybody. Everybody wants to win, right? The numbers can show you if you’re winning or not.
[11:55] Speaker 2: Yeah, so your goal with these KPIs in 2025 is just to let your team know if they’re winning or not on a daily job to job basis.
[12:05] Speaker 1: Yeah.
[12:05] Speaker 2: They’re putting in the effort to win, but is it going in the direction to help the team?
[12:09] Speaker 1: So some people it’s gonna matter at the job level, right? And other people it’s gonna matter at the shift level and other people it’s gonna matter at the shop level and other people, you know, I mean, as you move through the organization, those numbers affect you differently, right? And your goals, you know, the KPIs you’re looking at.
[12:25] Speaker 5: Yeah.
[12:25] Speaker 1: This is all my opinion, at least.
[12:27] Speaker 2: Yeah, I think most people would agree with that. Something I’ve seen with KPIs and you’ve probably seen it too, and I’ve been guilty of it, is over-measuring. So you’ve got your big goal of where you’re headed, what maybe it’s your sales numbers for 2025.
You’ve got your big goal. And so you start to think, well, we probably need to measure, you know, new orders and jobs completed. And we probably need to know about sales calls made and we need to know about inbound calls that we received.
And then it’s like, well, and our system can also measure this and this and this and this. And before you know it, without a lot of thought, you’ve got 12 or 13 KPIs, which in my opinion is over-measuring. And what I’ve seen is that people are, they’re going to default to the KPIs that they like.
And it’s probably gonna be three to five because those are pretty natural. That’s a natural range for us. But you’re leaving it up to each individual within the company to choose which KPIs they like.
And they’re all grading with different biases and desires. So some of them want to find the KPI that’s tied most closely to that end goal. And that’s what we would hope for.
But for other people, you know, it’s, well, this impacts my department the most, or this number changes every day. And so it gives me the quickest feedback or this number I always win at. And so, you know, I wanna focus on that one.
So before you know it, you’ve established 12, 13, 14 KPIs for the company and every person in the company is operating with a slightly different set of three to five KPIs.
[13:53] Speaker 1: So that’s probably not even new information for you. I mean, that makes sense. So we’ve talked a lot on making chips episodes, especially over the past year, I’d say.
And I think it’s only gonna get worse. There’s an influx of data in today’s world, right? I can get data from my ERP system.
I get data from my machine monitoring that I have in place on the shop floor. I get data from my customers. I get data from my vendors.
I get data from my accounting package. There’s a lot of data. I mean, there’s more than you could possibly consume.
And again, back to where I think my failure has been is I’ve been taking all that data and maybe I’ve been pulling this piece out of this system, this piece out of this system, pulling them all together to get a metric that means something to me, right? But without the context of these three systems I’m pulling it out of, it doesn’t mean anything to Johnny, right? He doesn’t know how he affected that number.
He just knows that I’m not happy with it or I’m extremely happy with it. You know, whatever the case might be. So I think you bring up a great point of just identifying those, the ones that truly matter because you can get bogged down in worthless data.
[14:56] Speaker 2: Yeah, it’s not necessarily a bad thing for some people in the company to operate with different KPIs at a really detailed level with a department. Sure. So your controller is going to be measuring AR compared to AP, and that’s a really valuable KPI to them, but not for anyone on the shop floor.
Right, they don’t care. You know, they need specific KPIs for their department, but then overarching company-wide, there should be clear agreement. These three, four, five things are what is going to move our needle with the most impact towards our goal that we all are aware of and we all agreed upon at year end.
[15:34] Speaker 1: Yeah, so in our case, the three kind of overarching KPIs that we talk about every month had to do with our overall shop efficiency, our scrap rate, and our on-time percentage. Those are the three things that affect my customer the most, so those are the three things that affect our shop the most. And I have, I believe to be, really good systems in place to track those three things and get a very accurate number that is actionable at my level, right?
But what I found I don’t have is how does Johnny on the floor, how does he know if he’s affecting our on-time day-to-day, week-to-week, job-to-job, right? And we have things in place to do that, but have we properly trained them in how to use that number that he is personally touching versus me looking at it from a entire organization standpoint? And the answer for us was really kind of no.
So that’s probably the most simple example of where we’re really digging in. But to be on time, that touches the entire organization, right? From the time we got a PO from a customer to the time we shipped it, it touched the entire organization, right?
Purchasing, planning, programming, the shop, the shipping department, the receiving department, it touched vendors, it touched accounting. I mean, it touched everything. So for me to achieve that goal at the shop level, there’s how many people need to have a goal underneath that?
Everybody, right? And they can all affect that number differently, right? If my inspection department waited too long to get an inspection plan in place, then we didn’t get the job started on time, right?
So even just in the case of on-time delivery, maybe my inspection department needs a metric of how long from receipt of order to approved inspection plan in place. But what’s that gap, right? Is it 24 hours or is it a week?
That can change my on-time delivery percentage from a shop perspective. That’s very granular, but I can track that. So I need to teach them how to find that.
How do I find that dashboard in our, we use ProShop ERP system. How do I use this dashboard of my work queue to go from an average of 1.7 days to one day for that inspection plan, right? Whatever that might be.
I’m making up numbers now, but.
[17:45] Speaker 2: Yeah, and your inspection department and the time required for them, is that built in to the quoting process of this is how long it’ll take us to get the part and your sales team or whoever’s doing the quoting is going to have conversations where they’re like, it’ll probably take around two days for inspection. But sometimes it varies. Whereas if you really dial in this KPI, they can say, yeah, we have everything done within 24 hours.
Right. And they can know with confidence, they probably wouldn’t convey this to the customer unless they’re really analytical, but they can know in their heads. And then we hit that 24 hour period 97% of the time because they’ve got the dashboard and now they’ve got the number.
Right. Feel confident saying it. So it does have that specific metric has trickle down effects throughout the whole process, which is just an added bonus of measuring it and dialing it in and making everyone aware of it.
[18:38] Speaker 1: And then, from my perspective, all of those metrics to also help you decide, are you providing your team the adequate resources to meet the goals that you’ve agreed to meet? Right. I mean, if you find out that you’re not getting it done in two days and you want to get it done in one day and the biggest problem is manpower, well, it sounds like we need to hire somebody.
Right. Because we have double the workload that we have the capacity. And again, there’s too much data available and you can overanalyze it.
Just like you were saying, if I’m measuring 15 different things to track kind of one goal, it’s probably too much. Right. But I think the more, in my case, I think the more I can break down everybody’s role towards our three overarching KPIs, right, then that will be helpful.
And then kind of back to what you do on the accountability piece, are we making progress? Well, now I’ve got a way to track that.
[19:31] Speaker 2: Yeah. That was actually something I jotted down here to make sure we brought up later. So I’m glad you did is that these KPIs have to be reviewed as a team.
So everyone sees them on a daily or weekly basis and they can self-assess, did I hit my target or not? And some people that’s going to be extremely motivating and if they see, yes, I’ve hit it three weeks in a row, I’m hitting it next week too, because I’m not losing my streak, then they’re going to buckle down and get it done. But other people, they can still, you know, want what’s best for the company and work hard, but they would just like some external feedback and accountability.
So if you’re reviewing these KPIs regularly, now you’ve got it, it’s carved in stone, it’s right there, it’s indisputable. It’s not my opinion of your performance, this is just, this is exactly what the numbers say. We needed this many parts done by this date and you got it all done, so way to go.
Right. Let’s do it again next week. That regular review, everyone is expecting it and they know what’s going to be reviewed.
So it’s not like there will be any surprises, which are really detrimental to any one-to-one kind of performance review is a surprise. Something they didn’t know they were being evaluated on. That’s a great way to really discourage your people.
[20:41] Speaker 1: I mean, I think one thing you’re speaking to that I know has been a really popular topic, I think throughout kind of industry 4.0 type stuff, but just in the last six months, I’ve been involved in industry discussions about it, gamification, right? If I know what wins and I know what my score is, I want to win, right? I mean, I want to level up, I want to get to that next score, I want to beat something.
I think that’s one of the big things we saw. So we run data nomics machine monitoring here. So we’ve got TV monitors all over the shop.
So every machine has a little data collection device on it and it’s collecting all sorts of data. Like I said, more than you could possibly review on a regular basis. But in its most simplest form at any given time, really anybody can look up at a TV screen and it’s giving them a grade from an A plus, A, I think an A minus, I don’t remember, B plus all the way down to a C, right?
And I don’t think I have anybody here that doesn’t want to run at an A, right? I mean, so if they’re looking up there at that screen and it’s doing all sorts of algorithms in the back to know if I’m running an A or a C, right? But if my typical person, if they’re looking at that screen and they’re at a B plus, I mean, they want to finish at an A.
So maybe they’re speeding up their touch time, whatever they’re doing, just the fact that it’s monitored and it’s displayed, people are stepping up their game a little bit, right? That is hour by hour, minute by minute data, cycle by cycle, right, on a part that is working its way up the chain to our overall shop efficiency number, right? But yeah, I mean, I think the more you can gamify, like these are our goals and maybe it’s a range, right?
And again, maybe if you go back to more of an A, B, C, like we’ve got to be here, we want to be here. People will drive for that. Nobody wants to fail, in my experience.
There are people that don’t care, but nobody wants to fail, right?
[22:32] Speaker 2: Yeah, I think that’s probably an important distinction that, yeah, you may not have people really driving to win in every case, but yeah, most people aren’t trying to fail. You know, they’d rather not.
[22:43] Speaker 1: Then you have the people that it absolutely motivates. I mean, I remember when we first put the machine monitoring data on the floor, there was a third of the people that were like, oh, I want an A plus every day, right? So they’re looking up at the monitor every half hour and going, okay, I’m on track or I’m not, you know?
I think you can do that in all aspects of your business. Would you agree with that? I mean, it’s just a matter of finding the data, reporting the data and teaching people how to change the result.
[23:14] Speaker 4: Yeah.
[23:14] Speaker 1: I mean, you work with all these shops on accountability. What are some of your tactics to measure accountability?
[23:20] Speaker 2: I would agree that it’s possible to measure and improve anything. You can find a way to measure, you can find a way to gather the data, but sometimes it’s a little bit more manual. And I like it too much data or measuring like really hard to find pieces of information.
I liken it to shoplifting prevention at like a Walmart. Though they could get shoplifting to zero and they could make it to where you can’t ever steal from them. But it’s gonna take metal detectors throughout the store and, you know, like video surveillance and they’re gonna have to strip search every customer that leaves the store.
Obviously no one’s gonna continue shopping there. The honest people are not gonna continue shopping there. So there’s marginal returns to like shoplifting prevention where it’s like, yeah, every additional percentage of prevention was really detrimental to overall sales.
And so with data, you should put in the effort, you should put in time and attention to measure the data and get the data that you want. But it also has to be easily or readily available in the time period that it’s needed. So if you’re looking for on a job by job basis, the specific thing that we need to measure and it takes us 48 hours to gather and compile the data and put it out, that’s probably not very useful.
You’re on to the next job already and you don’t even remember what happened back then. So anything is measurable and it shouldn’t be, you shouldn’t avoid data based on, well, this is gonna be a little bit of a headache and it’s gonna slow my day down. You shouldn’t avoid it from that.
Like if it’s your job to gather the data, then that’s your job. And even if it’s a headache, that’s okay. But the juice is often not worth the squeeze where you’ve gotta ask, am I still able to get this data accurately and timely where it can actually influence behavior and decisions?
Well, that’s the key that I try to stress with clients and I hope this is answering your question. That’s the key that I try to stress is we’ve gotta make sure that whatever we’re measuring can actually influence the behavior that is going to make a dent in our goal. So it’s those three steps, the data influences the behavior, which pushes you towards that ultimate goal.
And if it’s not going to do that, then yes, we could get the data, but it’s not really gonna be worth it.
[25:43] Speaker 1: No, I like that. I hadn’t really thought of it that way. If I look at the evolution of kind of where my shop has been from when I bought it in 2018 with a sort of an ERP process, I wouldn’t call it an ERP system, but there was a series of access databases, Excel spreadsheets, and printed out pieces of paper that ultimately got jobs through the shop and successfully for 30, 40 years.
But I would, every day, they’d bring me in a stack of file folders of things that had been all the way through shipped and invoiced. So from some time in the previous three or four days, of job folders to look at job costing on. So how many hours did we have in the job?
How much material did we have in the job? And it was usually written in pencil on the front of the folder. Someone had already said, okay, we had 47.2 hours in this, we had this much in material, this much in shipping costs, maybe there was an outside process, whatever it is, here’s how much we sold it for, here’s this margin. Three or four days after it shipped, there’s not a damn thing I can do about it, right? I can’t save that job, right? So then as we transitioned to, again, in our case, ProShop ERP, that brought visibility into a job today.
I could see how it ran on the saw today versus how we had estimated it. So the very first operation of the job, if we estimated it was gonna take two minutes apart to cut, but it took five, I’m already off, right? Now I can get engaged in that job now to maybe save that six hours extra that that job took, and we can start looking at it today for the rest of the job, it’s like, okay, can we pick up time at the lathe, the mill, whatever?
Throughout the process. So I saw the lathe process, the mill process, everything. Then to the point where now two and a half years ago or more we installed machine monitoring, right?
And now I literally can look part by part how we’re doing against our expectations. And one of the things we found there, again, by having more data and knowing how to read it and having history of running parts and being able to compare the last three times we ran this, why are we behind this time? And I’ll give you a simple example.
So there was a job, this was probably a year and a half ago or so, that we generally run really well, right? We hit our cycle times, we hit our change outs, everything. Well, you notice a day or two in, like we’re behind on this.
And so you’re looking for problems, right? Did we have some tool breakage? Do we have, what was going on?
And I go look at the history and see, so-and-so ran it these couple of times, so-and-so ran it these couple of times, now this guy’s running it and he’s running behind. And you go find out, well, this is a bigger part that probably 90% of the guys in my shop, it’s big, but it’s not too big to lift the part and put it in the machine, right? And we had somebody running it that couldn’t do that and needed to use the crane.
Well, that was adding a minute or two apart, right? To load and unload, it was adding time to that job, right? So not necessarily the decision that, I mean, I know the decision we made, but you learn something about that part though, that this person can’t run parts that are over X number of pounds because they can’t load and unload this machine efficiently.
It’s not that even that it was, I mean, I wanna say it was like maybe a 15, 20 pound part, right, it’s not that it was too large for someone to lift, it was just too large for him to do it all day, right? So it just wasn’t a good part for that person. He was running it as best as he possibly could, right?
So, I mean, the granularity of that data allowed us to make an operator switch, right? And get that job back on track for it to be profitable.
[29:50] Speaker 2: Instead of finding out four days later and then trying to go back and figure out who ran this part, hey, what’d you do on Tuesday? What images did you have?
[29:59] Speaker 1: Right, yeah, and if you’d have talked to him four days later, he’d be like, I don’t know, I mean, I just load the part, ran it, unloaded the part, load new, you know, like, I mean, again, he wasn’t doing anything wrong, right? It’s just that part was a bad fit for that person, right? So now that could be too granular of data, you could argue, you know, that you’re, but if you have it and you use it properly.
And it’s available on time. And it’s available on time, then it can really make a different impact on a job profitability, which then climbs up to a shop profitability, which then climbs up to the utilization of the, and efficiency of the entire shop. That we’re all, hopefully all on the same page to reach that higher arching.
[30:38] Speaker 2: Yeah, that’s a really perfect example of the secondary benefits of KPIs. So for continuous improvement throughout your operation, you can’t improve what you don’t measure. You can’t guess and think, we want to improve this in some way, but we don’t know how or by how much, but because that data has become available.
So like you said, when you first came to Hill, that data wasn’t available to even see that the part was taking longer. It became available and it became available on time. So now you can see this part is taking longer.
And so not only are you going to fix the KPI for that one part and get back on track, but you’re also fixing the process for all future parts because you’ve measured it. And just like you said, whoever that person was, 15, 20 pound parts, we either need to quote in extra time for a crane if this person does need to run it, or we need to run it. You’ve made a major improvement to future production just by that piece of data that was on time and relevant to what your goals are.
[31:40] Speaker 1: Yeah, and to this day, I mean, when we’re scheduling jobs, I mean, that is a consideration, right? It’s like, who can and can’t run this? Because I mean, there’s some stuff we run that nobody can lift and load and unload without a crane, right?
So in that case, it doesn’t matter. But if it is borderline, I mean, we do take that into consideration.
[31:57] Speaker 2: I mean, the benefits just keep going. You’ve got interview questions or if you put out a job posting, are you able to lift over 20 pounds?
[32:06] Speaker 1: Repeatedly all day, yeah.
[32:07] Speaker 2: If they say no, it doesn’t disqualify them from working with you, but you know, okay, this person’s availability in the shop is going to be more limited. Sure. And so if you’ve got two completely equal candidates, except one can lift the 20 pounds and one cannot, then there’s pretty much a hiring decision.
Yeah, the benefits just continue even further.
[32:27] Speaker 1: I believe in data. I don’t believe you can let data make all your decisions for you, but I do think you need data to make decisions. So even if you’re going to go against what the numbers might be telling you, at least you know what you’re giving up, right?
So whether that’s a money number, a performance, you know, whatever that number might be, you know, I believe knowing the data is incredibly valuable when you’re making decisions because it can either, it can point you in the right direction, or at least, well, like I said, just let you know what you’re giving up if you don’t use those. And then the accountability piece, for sure. I mean, that’s, I don’t, I think, I think sometimes I might rely too much on data, you know, for accountability, because there’s always reasons for the data being off, right?
So, you know, I think you have to be real intelligent about that and not just, this is running too slow, or this is, you know, we’re not getting enough wins on our quotes, and, you know, just go to blaming, right? Like- Exactly, yeah. I try to use it as coaching tool, more so than anything.
You know, it doesn’t have to change what you’re doing, you just maybe change how you’re doing it.
[33:34] Speaker 2: Yeah, the way that I see it, to sort of build on that, the way that I see taking, if you’ve got an underperformer or an underperforming machine or a metric that’s down from where you want it, like you said, it’s not just, hey, this is too low, figure it out and get it higher where it needs to be. But as the type of leader that I strive to be and that I can tell through all of our conversations that you are, the way you approach that piece of data, you know, that underperformer is, hey, this number isn’t where you want it or where the company needs it or where I would like to see it. What do we need to do as a company to support you in reaching this goal?
Because we know that you are out here doing your best. You want to make an A plus on every shift. We know that you’re trying to do that.
What needs to change about the process? And then you might hear someone say, honestly, these parts are just super heavy and I have a hard time loading them manually, so I have to slow down. And you get an answer instead of, you know, maybe an excuse or defensiveness, they’re just, they’re trying to look for solutions when it’s approached that way.
[34:39] Speaker 1: Yeah, well, as we kind of wrap up, do you have any kind of closing thoughts on, I love this conversation, it’s so timely for me because again, I’m, you know, kind of in this year-end phase where I’m told you my goals next year is to really get kind of accountability tied to our goals. And in my case, a lot of that’s data-driven, but any kind of thing to wrap up to tell shop owners, like, you know, maybe your top tips on setting goals and tracking them and achieving them?
[35:03] Speaker 2: Yeah, so I think the key to setting good goals for 2025 and even just next week, the key is that you’ve got to know you’re overarching number one, this is the most important metric for us, this is the most important thing we need to get done. That’s gotta be step number one. And if you don’t know what it is, that’s good, because now you know that you don’t know, and so you need to figure it out and you need to put in the time to figure it out.
[35:27] Speaker 1: You made a post sometime last few weeks on LinkedIn, you had two trains hit each other and one was my top priority and my other one was my other top priority, right?
[35:35] Speaker 2: Yeah, it’s just not gonna work.
[35:37] Speaker 1: Right.
[35:37] Speaker 2: You gotta have that number one top priority, and then you gotta make sure that all of your goals need to contribute, because you can have multiple smaller goals in the achievement of this, in pursuit of this large opportunity. All of your goals have to be related to that and making progress towards that number one overarching goal. And then everything you measure needs to be directly related to that goal.
So it’s kind of like a family tree going down, your overarching goal, and then, you know, your sub goals, and then your KPIs, everything needs to funnel up to that number one goal, that number one opportunity. And then those KPIs, trying to avoid over measuring, but making sure that you are measuring and that once you do measure, you’re reviewing. Yeah.
That to me, that sums it all up. That’s goal setting and measurement and accountability in 45 seconds. To me, that’s what needs to happen.
[36:30] Speaker 1: Yeah, I love it. I love it. I think that’s what we all need to hear as we’re going into a new year and setting goals.
Josh, how do people find you?
[36:37] Speaker 2: I’m on LinkedIn. Josh McCain, it’s M-C-K-A-I-N. I’m on LinkedIn, HenryRoseConsulting.com, but LinkedIn is probably the best place.
[36:46] Speaker 1: Perfect, yeah. And if anybody wants to reach out to Josh, I can certainly connect you as well.
[36:51] Speaker 2: Awesome.
[36:51] Speaker 1: Thank you, Mike. Listeners, I hope you enjoyed that. I think Josh, you know, gave us a lot of insight on how to just get more done.
And I don’t think I’m alone and feeling overwhelmed most of the time on all the stuff that needs to get done. I probably distract myself a little bit too much, right? I probably have too many trains on the track, using Josh’s analogy, but yeah, use some of this, reach out, have questions, reach out to Josh, me.
Yeah, we’d both be happy to make connections there and talk through anything. Yeah, with that, please rate, review, like, subscribe, all that fun stuff. And I just appreciate everybody’s support.
Thank you.
This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
Connect With Buy the Numbers
Subscribe to Buy the Numbers
Audio Production and Show Notes by – PODCAST FAST TRACK